Questions about Hyperinsulinemia/Diabetes

Kumar said:
As far as I can think, I still feel that excess glucose in blood aided by some "predisposition" causes hyper insulin secretion. Upto some limit of glucose metabolism & body's capacity to take that glucose, everything remains normal. But when this limit exceeds, IR come into picture.
No. The excess glucose in the blood is caused by the insulin resistance, which makes it more difficult for the cells to take up glucose from the blood.
 
Kumar said:
Mr. Hans,

Thanks. This is from your one link provided. Does it relate hyper insuln secretion With IR?

No, it obviously does not. The first sentence says: "In nondiabetic, normotensive obese subjects". The idea of the exercise is that you actually READ the texts.

As far as I can think, I still feel that excess glucose in blood aided by some "predisposition" causes hyper insulin secretion.

I would congratulate you on thinking right for a chance, except for the fact that we have been hammering this into your head for over a year, now, so congratulating you for finally understanding it would only be sarcastic. And anyay you only got it half right.

Yes, the predisposition for insulin resistance causes (not aids) excess glucose in the blood, and the pancreas reacts by increasing insulin secretion to counter this. ... As we have told you a zillion times :rolleyes:.


Upto some limit of glucose metabolism & body's capacity to take that glucose, everything remains normal. But when this limit exceeds, IR come into picture.

No, IR is into it all the time as several of the links I gave you explain. IR can be detected long before it results in high BG (clamp test).

Reducing carbs & fats intake OR reducing obesity by diet control & excercise should mean, you are empitying the capacity of body to take glucose & use insulin. So both BG level & insulin level can be normalised.

No, it works because it reduces insulin resistance. There is no reservoir or capacity limit mechanism, that is pure fantasy.

But due to presence of "perdisposition"/Constitutional defect, this can be a visious circle and patient can again be initiated/forced to incraese his glucose levels occasionally.

No, it is not a predispodition for overeating, it is a predisposition for getting IR. That is what the link you just quoted shows. In obese persons that are NOT predisposed for IR, another mechanism comes into play.


Excess glucose + excess fats or obesity may mean that body's capacity/cell's limit to take glucose & fats is over till insulin presence is normal.

No.

All these may be possible by adopting some mechanism by cells to discourage sugar intake by doing some changes in lipid layer of cell membrane or other mean.

No.

Kumar, those links I gave you were not just something I googled uncritically; they were carefully selected to cover the issue we have been debating. I will actually grant you that you are not capable of identifying which sources to read, so I did it for you. Now, read them and understand them.

If you understand them, you will not need to ask more questions on this subject (or the questions you ask will attain a totally different level of sophistication and relevance).

If you don't understand them, we must conclude that this subject is too complicated for you, and any more effort is wasted.

Finally, if you do understand them but prefer to trust your own hunches and ideas more, then so be it, but then we can't help you.

Hans
 
Mr. Hans, Mojo,

Thanks for you suggestions. I shall study those links. But I have one doubt:-

If excess glucose in the blood is caused by the insulin resistance & the predisposition for insulin resistance causes excess glucose in the blood, how IR can be reversable by weight contol?
 
Kumar said:
Mr. Hans, Mojo,

Thanks for you suggestions. I shall study those links. But I have one doubt:-

If excess glucose in the blood is caused by the insulin resistance & the predisposition for insulin resistance causes excess glucose in the blood, how IR can be reversable by weight contol?
In other words, you have not understood ANYTHING up to now? I have explained this care fully to you a few pages back in this thread.

Predisposition has nothing to do with lifestyle or eating habits, it is inherited.

Whether or not your genetic predisposition will actually leads to diabetes is depending on lifestyle, and eating habits.

You have a remarkable habit of consistenly putting things upside down. Let me try to explain it in common words:

Suppose your ability to have a bad lifestyle without getting sick depends on how much resistance money you have in the bank. Every time you sit the whole week-end in front of your computer and eat chips, you are drawing resistance money from your account. For every pouns you gain in weight, you draw money.

Every time you exercise, eat good food, and loose weight, you put money INTO the bank.

If your account gets overdrawn, you get diabetes (here the analogy stops; once you have overdrawn, you may pay down on your dept, but you cannot get back in positive).

Are you with me so far?

Now, of course, the "resistance money" is someting inside your body, and so is the bank.

So where is the genetic part? Well, we are each born with a different amount in the bank. Some have only a very slim account, so as soon as they start "spending" they go into debet. Others have some more and will only hit red after decades of overweight and sedentary lifestyle. And some have a big sum that they are virtually unable to spend during their lifetime.
Read it again, it answers your question.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
Mr. Hans, Mojo,

Thanks for you suggestions. I shall study those links.
Shall study?? Kumar, you SHOULD HAVE STUDIED them BEFORE you asked more questions.

It is very insulting that you ignore the answers we give you. You are asking us to do a lot of work for you, work you should really have done yourself. The LEAST you can do is read the answers and make a serious effeort to understand them.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Shall study?? Kumar, you SHOULD HAVE STUDIED them BEFORE you asked more questions.

It is very insulting that you ignore the answers we give you. You are asking us to do a lot of work for you, work you should really have done yourself. The LEAST you can do is read the answers and make a serious effeort to understand them.

Hans

Mr.Hans,

Sorry, you have taken my reply like it. I have no such intention of insulting anybody here esp. you & some other. Since, I study such serious aspects with many links, only when I am free & relaxed. I get good concentration at that time. You can understand it, as I mentioned "shall study" not "will read".:)
Moreover it is a topic of my interest & requirement, why I shall not study or why I will keep other intentions? So nothing like that as you thought. Anyway sorry again. Best.
 
Intentionally or not, your behaviour is insulting. I don't care when you study or how long you take, but FINISH studying the answers you get before you ask new questions, not to mention questions already answered. I realize this would mean you won't be posting for the next few months, of course ;).

There is another possibility: Realize that all this is over your head (something that has been painfully obvious to the rest of us for a long time now), and either give it up or learn some basic skills, like English, primary school chemistry, simple logical reasoning, basic pathology, etc.

Hans
 
Mr.Hans,

I do understand, what is needed to be understood by me. But all aspects which are yet unclear in modern understanding remain unclear to me, but you intend to mention those as clear Eg.IR. So contradictions & misunderstanding starts. It is just egoistic superiority thinking that "modern understasndings are complete/absolute understanding" but reality can be just opposite im many understandings. Real realities may not be alike you take them. So pls face as per reality & post accordingly. Sorry, if it hurts your egoistic superiority feelings.

Goshawk,

Welcome again after long time. Be contributing here. Best.
 
Kumar said:
I do understand, what is needed to be understood by me.

You certainly do not. Worst of all, you don't even realize how little you understand.

But all aspects which are yet unclear in modern understanding remain unclear to me,

Since you don't understand the aspects which ARE clear, you have no way to find out which are unclear. To you everything is unclear.

but you intend to mention those as clear Eg.IR. So contradictions & misunderstanding starts.

No, just lack of understanding on your part.

It is just egoistic superiority thinking that "modern understasndings are complete/absolute understanding" but reality can be just opposite im many understandings.

You are a liar an an idiot. A liar because you keep claiming that we hold things absolute when we have repeatedly told you nothing is absolute, and an idiot because you think you can get away with such a blatant lie.

Real realities may not be alike you take them. So pls face as per reality & post accordingly. Sorry, if it hurts your egoistic superiority feelings.

The one having egoistic superiour feelings is you. You keep thinking that you can point out errors in science when you cannot even understand the carefully simplified explanations you are given. And who are you to talk about realities? You believe in all kinds of nonsense.

I could say more, but you are not worthy of my anger.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
I could say more, but you are not worthy of my anger.

Hans

"Truth sometimes can be bitter", but we should respect it in reality.

Are true causes of getting IR clear & known to modren understandings?

"Although there is no complete agreement yet on the components of the metabolic syndrome or the individual risk levels for each component, we know the syndrome poses a significant health risk to individuals and is a growing health crisis for our country. "
ADA LINK.

If so, how anyone can say anything for sure?
 
Kumar said:
"Truth sometimes can be bitter", but we should respect it in reality.

Yes. When do you start?

Are true causes of getting IR clear & known to modren understandings?

No. Do you think you have contributed to that knowledge?


If so, how anyone can say anything for sure?

So, because we don't know everything, we know nothing? Well it seems to fit YOU, that's for sure.

Have fun in your little foggy world, Kumar.

Hans
 
What did the researchers find?

This is the first study linking low magnesium levels to insulin resistance in obese children. Researchers found that 55% of obese children did not get enough magnesium from the foods they ate, compared with only 27% of lean children. Obese children had much lower magnesium levels in their blood than lean children. Children with lower magnesium levels had a higher insulin resistance.

http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-research/summaries/huerta-magnesium.jsp

What did the researchers find?

People that ate a lot of refined carbohydrates and little fiber had a higher chance of getting type 2 diabetes. The more refined carbohydrates a person eats, the more likely it is that they will be obese and get diabetes.

According to the study, today’s carbohydrates are very different from those in the early 1900s. For example, turning whole grains into white flour increases calories, reduces the amount of fiber (by 80%), and reduces protein. More foods include white flour now than in the early 1900s.

http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-research/summaries/gross-refinedcarbs.jsp

Mr. Hans,
The above links tells something different about IR. I want to be absolutely clear otherwise it can be fatal or with many adversities, if we take it lightly & as it is. Can't it be alike it?

More you can check at these ADA links.

Most people suggest weight loss and overcoming the obstacles to losing weight, eating right, and burn calories by exercising. If one will not eat more or will eat less and burn calories by excecising, what medicines will then do?:D The problem is in excess & unnatural eatings & unhealthy lifestyle/environment. If one is asked to eat healthy, live in healthful environment & excecise for health, what more medicines are meant? Can medicines treat a person who is still continuing as per modern lifestyle?
 
Kumar said:
Mr. Hans,
The above links tells something different about IR.

Two different things, in fact. Magnesium and fine carbohydrates. So what is your conclusion?

I want to be absolutely clear

If you want to be absolutely clear, I think the best solution is to have a window installed.

otherwise it can be fatal or with many adversities, if we take it lightly & as it is. Can't it be alike it?

However, we don't take it lightly. As you can see, a lot of research is ongoing.

Most people suggest weight loss and overcoming the obstacles to losing weight, eating right, and burn calories by exercising.

Yes, because that has been proved to work. So whatever the reason, it works. That argument sound familiar? Well, in this case, we can document the effect.


If one will not eat more or will eat less and burn calories by excecising, what medicines will then do?

If you don't follow these recommendations there is a risk that medicine is not enough to help you. At least, yo uwill need more medicine, and thus run more risk of side-effects.

The problem is in excess & unnatural eatings & unhealthy lifestyle/environment.

Duh, yes. That is what we have told you all along.

If one is asked to eat healthy, live in healthful environment & excecise for health, what more medicines are meant?

It means you may be able to do with less medicine, sometimes even no medicine, at least for some time.

Can medicines treat a person who is still continuing as per modern lifestyle?

Medicines can help such a person, but greater doses are needed, and the disease will progress faster.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
As you can see, a lot of research is ongoing.
Yes, indeed. The following is excerpted from a meeting report which arrived on my desk this morning.
Super-Size Me and the Fats of Life: The Obesity Epidemic

..... Dr John Gregory [gave] a fascinating talk into exaggerated adrenarche, and the links with child growth. He presented an overview of the adrenarche (unique to humans), stressing that although it leads to pubarche, no genital maturity is seen, and although there is an increase in growth velocity between the ages of 6-8 years there is very little effect on adult height.

Dr Gregory then presented work on the links between intra-uterine growth retardation, the "thrifty phenotype" hypothesis, resulting in high levels of DHEAS, and a greater risk of premature adrenarche and metabolic syndrome in later life. Post menarche patients who developed premature adrenarche were more likely to have been born with low birth weight, were more likely to have a higher concentration of insulin and triglycerides in later life, suggesting that it may be a forerunner for metabolic syndrome.

Earlybird Stategies

Insulin resistance in children was also discussed in Professor Terry Wilkin's review of the interesting findings from the on going EarlyBird study. In 2000 they enrolled 300 children aged 5 years and will study them annually until 16 years of age, primarily looking into factors that cause NIDDM in the young. Presently they measure a plethora of different blood analytes (with all samples stored for retrospective analysis) alongside other factors such as physical activity, measured by the rather excitingly named accelerometer, which cleverly measures intensity and duration of any movements made by the child throughout the day. Even in the first five years the EarlyBird study is producing a variety of interesting observations, linked with the development of Type 2 DM in young adults. By the age of five, girls show more evidence of insulin resistance than boys, but as children approach puberty insulin resistance falls but glucose levels increase, due to a reduction in β-cells.

.....

HOMA Explained

The EarlyBird study uses the HOmeostasis Model Assessment (HOMA) to calculate percentage β-cell function and insulin sensitivity. Dr Sue Manley from Selly Oak Hospital explained how the mathematical HOMA model works and its clinical uses.

....

Dr Robert Semple from the University of Cambridge gave us a comprehensive insight into clinical signs and the molecular biology seen in syndromes of severe insulin resistance. Clinically these patients often present with fasting or reactive hypoglycaemia, PCOS, impaired linear growth and acanthosis nigricans. They can also present with lipodystrophy, dyslipidaemias, and steatohepatitis.

Studying potential candidate genes involved in these rare inherited syndromes of insulin resistance, may give its a broader insight into the more common Type 2 diabetes.

He left us with. a short appeal that, if as biochemists we came across results that may be suggestive of a severe insulin receptor defects, as defined by the criteria:

- Fasting plasma insulin >150pmol/L
- Peak plasma insulin >1500pmol/L
- Insulin requirement >250 IU a day
- But a BMI <30

to contact him for further discussion.

.....

Dr Pinkney gave an eye opening talk on the different methods of bariatric surgery, and gave quite a convincing argument for it being used in the treatment of diabetes. He pointed out the remarkable reduction in insulin resistance on patients that lose weight due to bariatric surgery compared to diet and exercise, and argued that treatment of Type 2 diabetes is "too HbA1c orientated", and the option of bariatric surgery should be considered in cases where BMI is >35-40 and the patient is at high risk due to diabetic complications.

Dr Pinkney's argument was emphasized even further by Dr Carel le Roux from Hammersmith, whose talk expressed how gut hormones, particularly PYY (peptide YY) regulate appetite and satiety. Levels of PYY have been shown to be lower in obese patients, hence meaning levels of satiety are reached after a greater calorific load. Dr le Roux showed data from patients who had undergone a Roux-en Y gastric by-pass; PYY concentrations increased post surgery, and patients reached satiety after a smaller calorific load, hence aiding their weight loss, and reducing their insulin resistance.

Obesity Throughout the Ages

The whole day was brought to a close by an entertaining and thought provoking summary by Dr Ruth Ayling, who also arranged the programme meeting. Dr Ayling discussed obesity throughout the ages and its economic cost, at both laboratory and social level.....

ACB News Issue 507, July 2005
I hope I haven't included too much of this, but these sections were just so relevant to Kumar's obsessions that I really wanted him to see where it's really at.

You see, this is what real scientists are doing, people whose professional life revolves round the further elucidation of this common and widely-studied disease. The idea that Kumar, or even the participants on this forum, could possibly understand the cutting edge of this work sufficiently to make a contribution from the peanut gallery is just silly.

Rolfe.
 
Kumar said:
That is ok but can it be known in advance and if it is indicated that any medicine will work or not due to gastric acid levels? I don't think if doctors take care this aspect in advance.

Omeprazole!
 
Kumar said:
That is ok but can it be known in advance and if it is indicated that any medicine will work or not due to gastric acid levels? I don't think if doctors take care this aspect in advance.
Mmm, needs more comment. For example, one of Kumar's own obsessions, metformin.
Metformin hydrochloride is combined with a drug release controlling polymer to form an "inner" phase, which is then incorporated as discrete particles into an "external" phase of a second polymer. After administration, fluid from the gastrointestinal (GI) tract enters the tablet, causing the polymers to hydrate and swell. Drug is released slowly from the dosage form by a process of diffusion through the gel matrix that is essentially independent of pH.
Not only known whether it will work or not, but incorporating some quite nifty materials science here to ensure that it WILL. Pharmaceutical manufacturers take very great care of this aspect in advance, Kumar.

Now, it occurs to me to ask what homoeopathy and Tissue Salts are doing about this. Does anyone have the faintest idea how variables such as the pH of the gastrointestinal tract might affect the workings of these remedies? Why do you demand of real medicine standards it doesn't even occur to you to enquire about in your pet alternative fields?

And a related cross-post from the thread (now in Community) which appears to be talking about how it is that lactic acidosis doesn't cause myocardial infarction, also in relation to metformin. Kumar is very exercised about the ability of metformin to cause a dangerous lactic acidosis in patients taking that medicine. However, how real is this danger in fact? See here.
The reported incidence of lactic acidosis in patients receiving metformin hydrochloride is very low (approximately 0.03 cases/1000 patient-years, with approximately 0.015 fatal cases/1000 patient-years). In more than 20,000 patient-years exposure to metformin in clinical trials, there were no reports of lactic acidosis.
And since even this tiny incidence mainly involves people with significant renal dysfunction, just how worried should anyone be?

Not a lot.

However, there is the information if you need it, and if you want it. 0.03 cases/1000 patient-years. And half of these patients died. Terrible, dreadful, appaling side-effects of "allopathy". Shout it from the rooftops, these doctors are giving us dangerous drugs!

Now, supposing some Tissue Remedy were to be causing 0.03 cases/1000 patient-years of some serious complication, including 0.015 deaths/1000 patient-years, how would you know?

Kumar, why do you demand standards of conduct from real medicine which it doesn't even occur to you to apply to your alternative preoccupations?

Rolfe.
 
However, there is the information if you need it, and if you want it. 0.03 cases/1000 patient-years. And half of these patients died.
As opposed to the several hundred, per 1000 patient years, who would have died from diabetes complications without the drug. And the many more who would have serious morbidity. Yeah, allopathy is truely evil :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Originally posted by Kumar
Two different things, in fact. Magnesium and fine carbohydrates. So what is your conclusion?


Nothing is yet conclusive or persistant about IR, so we can think differently.:D

However, we don't take it lightly. As you can see, a lot of research is ongoing.

How you take seriously about possibilty of metformin LA effect? Do you regularily check LA level in blood?

Yes, because that has been proved to work. So whatever the reason, it works. That argument sound familiar? Well, in this case, we can document the effect.


But you don't accept silmilar style (mass observations & experiances) in case of Homeipathic remedies.

If you don't follow these recommendations there is a risk that medicine is not enough to help you. At least, yo uwill need more medicine, and thus run more risk of side-effects.

Are medicines just meant for "to eat some more"? When a patient can control diet & do exercise, he can also do some more.

The problem is in excess & unnatural eatings & unhealthy lifestyle/environment.

Duh, yes. That is what we have told you all along.
It means you may be able to do with less medicine, sometimes even no medicine, at least for some time.Medicines can help such a person, but greater doses are needed, and the disease will progress faster.


It means that the basis of IR lies in diet & excercise imbalance.:)
 
Rolfe said:
Yes, indeed. The following is excerpted from a meeting report which arrived on my desk this morning.I hope I haven't included too much of this, but these sections were just so relevant to Kumar's obsessions that I really wanted him to see where it's really at.

You see, this is what real scientists are doing, people whose professional life revolves round the further elucidation of this common and widely-studied disease. The idea that Kumar, or even the participants on this forum, could possibly understand the cutting edge of this work sufficiently to make a contribution from the peanut gallery is just silly.

Rolfe.

Sorry, I don't feel/find anything relevant to my thought i.e. basic cause for getting IR.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom