Questions about Hyperinsulinemia/Diabetes

Kumar said:
Nothing is yet conclusive or persistant about IR, so we can think differently.

Binary thinking, Kumar. Lots of things are conclusive, but not everything. So we can indeed think differently, but not all ideas are valid, only ideas that are consitent with what we already know.

How you take seriously about possibilty of metformin LA effect? Do you regularily check LA level in blood?

Rolfe answered that one.

Yes, because that has been proved to work. So whatever the reason, it works. That argument sound familiar? Well, in this case, we can document the effect.


But you don't accept silmilar style (mass observations & experiances) in case of Homeipathic remedies.

They are not similar style. That is the point. Homeopaths cannot document te effect of homeopathy.

If you don't follow these recommendations there is a risk that medicine is not enough to help you. At least, yo uwill need more medicine, and thus run more risk of side-effects.

Are medicines just meant for "to eat some more"? When a patient can control diet & do exercise, he can also do some more.

No. I said the opposite: Medicine is meant to do whatever better lifestyle does not accomplish.

It means that the basis of IR lies in diet & excercise imbalance.:)


That and genetic predisposition, yes. And not "imbalance"; it lies in too many calories and too little exercise.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
But you don't accept silmilar style (mass observations & experiances) in case of Homeipathic remedies.
You still don't get it, do you? You still don't understand why medical trials are blinded and controlled? Just wondering, do you still believe in part excitations?
 
Rolfe,

I think the LA related adverse effect can be dependent of "how much modern lifestyle & polluted environment is exposed to any person" In other words stresses, exertions, infections, O2 intake, pH effecting foods etc. may increase EXERTIONS so the LA levels. Figures may be different in many big cities who are effected & exposed to such conditions. So studies of people effected/exposed to such conditions is necessary & may give different picture. Peobably, it may also be a progressive/increasing condition.

Anyway, do doctors insist on daily lactic acid test on taking metformin. Lactic acidosis can be an emergency condition, so is it not necessary to do daily LA test with metformic esp. on initial prescription of this?

Btw, how metformin works? Does it just reduce absorption of carbs & reduce availability of glucose in blood just alike taking less food?

Metformin is used to regulate blood glucose (sugar) levels. Metformin works in three ways: first, it reduces the amount of glucose produced by your liver; second, it reduces the amount of glucose absorbed from food through your stomach; and third, it makes the insulin that your body produces work better to reduce the amount of glucose already in your blood.

• Do not take metformin without first talking to your doctor if you
· have kidney disease;
· have liver disease;
· have congestive heart failure;
· have acute or chronic metabolic acidosis, including diabetic ketoacidosis;
· have had a heart attack or a stroke;
· have a serious infection, illness, or injury;
· need to have surgery;
· need to have x-rays or other procedures using injectable contrast agents;
· are dehydrated (have lost water from your body) due to diarrhea, vomiting, fever, heat stroke, decreased fluid intake, or any other cause;
· drink alcohol; or
· are 80 years of age or older and have not had your kidney function tested.
http://www.drugs.com/metformin.html

Btw, Anyone is still left from these?:D A patient is need to be previously trained for all the things as mentioned on above link to avoid any possible fatal effect.
 
Kumar said:
Rolfe,

I think the LA related adverse effect can be dependent of "how much modern lifestyle & polluted environment is exposed to any person" In other words stresses, exertions, infections, O2 intake, pH effecting foods etc. may increase EXERTIONS so the LA levels. Figures may be different in many big cities who are effected & exposed to such conditions. So studies of people effected/exposed to such conditions is necessary & may give different picture. Peobably, it may also be a progressive/increasing condition.

What makes you think the studies do not already take that into account?

Anyway, do doctors insist on daily lactic acid test on taking metformin. Lactic acidosis can be an emergency condition, so is it not necessary to do daily LA test with metformic esp. on initial prescription of this?

No, because lactic acidosis is a very rare side effect. Read Rolfe's post again: 0.03 cases / 1000 patient years. This means that in 100,000 patients, there wil lbe 3 cases per year. Also, the condition has distinct symptoms, so it will be discovered.

Btw, how metformin works? Does it just reduce absorption of carbs or just alike taking less food?

It also reduces IR, and reduces the glucose production in ht liver.

Hans
 
Kumar - you are obviously concerned that the stresses of modern life will induce illness.

May I suggest you become a hermit? Failing that, at least remove yourself from the high-tech environment of electronic equipment such as computers. Reading things on the internet which you cannot understand must be very stressful for you.
 
Kumar said:
*snip*
Btw, Anyone is still left from these?:D A patient is need to be previously trained for all the things as mentioned on above link to avoid any possible fatal effect.
Kumar, these lists are "cover my ass" clauses. They list every conceivable condition that MIGHT increase the risk for adverse effects. This is to keep the company from being sued if somebody gets ill.

You should heed the advice of Mark Twain: "Never read medical books. You might die from a printing error."

But, as mentioned countless times: You can reduce your risk for adverse effects by needing less medicine, and you can reduce your need for medicine by loosing weight and excercising. As a bonus, you'll look better and feel better.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
Sorry, I don't feel/find anything relevant to my thought i.e. basic cause for getting IR.
In that case you either don't read, won't read, can't read, or don't understand what you read.

Rolfe.
 
Kumar said:
I think ....
As usual, anything following the words "I think" in a post of Kumar's is a pile of ridiculous, speculative nonsense.
Kumar said:
Anyway, do doctors insist on daily lactic acid test on taking metformin. Lactic acidosis can be an emergency condition, so is it not necessary to do daily LA test with metformic esp. on initial prescription of this?
As Hans mentioned, 0.03 cases per 1000 patient-years. A tiny incidence. Mostly in patients who had pre-existing kidney disease. Remember also "In more than 20,000 patient-years exposure to metformin in clinical trials, there were no reports of lactic acidosis." That's a lot of lactate assays (and a lot of inconvenience for patients) for absolutely nothing.

Kumar, if you feel well, you do not have lactic acidosis. If you feel well, your lactate will be normal. Therefore there is no need to test it.
Kumar said:
Btw, how metformin works? Does it just reduce absorption of carbs & reduce availability of glucose in blood just alike taking less food?
Why don't you read up on the subject (assuming you actually understand more than one word in three).
Kumar said:
Btw, Anyone is still left from these?:D A patient is need to be previously trained for all the things as mentioned on above link to avoid any possible fatal effect.
Now, how do homoeopaths and Tissue Remedies prescribers educate their patients to avoid adverse effects of their products? How do they find out about possible adverse effects? Where can we access the data on this?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
As usual, anything following the words "I think" in a post of Kumar's is a pile of ridiculous, speculative nonsense.As Hans mentioned, 0.03 cases per 1000 patient-years. A tiny incidence. Mostly in patients who had pre-existing kidney disease. Remember also "In more than 20,000 patient-years exposure to metformin in clinical trials, there were no reports of lactic acidosis." That's a lot of lactate assays (and a lot of inconvenience for patients) for absolutely nothing.

We may see something different in big crowded/polluted modern cities(due to more stresses, exertions, less O2 intake/usage, infections, modern foods, snacks, fast travels, less water intake etc.) now or in near future. Mass LA tests in healthful/natural & unhealthful/unnatural conditions can explain it. Can't all such unhealthful/unnatural factors cause more LA in body?

Kumar, if you feel well, you do not have lactic acidosis. If you feel well, your lactate will be normal. Therefore there is no need to test it.

Do You mean, living under healthful/natural conditions?

Why don't you read up on the subject (assuming you actually understand more than one word in three).

Is it not the effect alike taking less food & burning more calories by excercise. What will happen if it stop conversion of gycogen into sugar OR reducing glucose in blood by lesser absorption?

Now, how do homoeopaths and Tissue Remedies prescribers educate their patients to avoid adverse effects of their products? How do they find out about possible adverse effects? Where can we access the data on this?

A common thought: they need not to be much worried. But I (may be only I) feel/find it bit differently.:) A needle can remove deep seated things--good or bad but a sword may not.:D
 
Kumar said:
Posted by Rolfe
Now, how do homoeopaths and Tissue Remedies prescribers educate their patients to avoid adverse effects of their products? How do they find out about possible adverse effects? Where can we access the data on this?

A common thought: they need not to be much worried.
True, because their remedies have no effect whatsoever.
 
Kumar said:
We may see something different in big crowded/polluted modern cities(due to more stresses, exertions, less O2 intake/usage, infections, modern foods, snacks, fast travels, less water intake etc.) now or in near future. Mass LA tests in healthful/natural & unhealthful/unnatural conditions can explain it. Can't all such unhealthful/unnatural factors cause more LA in body?
Kumar, a group of us explained to you in great detail why this was not the case, more than a year ago. Why do you ask questions when you have no intention of paying any attention to the answers?

Where does it say that all the patients included in the statistics on the incidence of lactic acidosis were living in unpolluted rural districts and eating a healthy "natural" (whatever that means) diet? It doesn't, because patients would not be selected on that basis. (If you're including 20,000 patient-years, you can't afford to be that choosy!)
Kumar said:
Do You mean, living under healthful/natural conditions?
NO. <SUP>TM</SUP>

I said what I mean. If you feel well, you do not have lactic acidosis. Whether you are in the jungle, in the middle of Bombay, the Sahara desert or the far side of the moon.
Kumar said:
Is it not the effect alike taking less food & burning more calories by excercise. What will happen if it stop conversion of gycogen into sugar OR reducing glucose in blood by lesser absorption?
Read up about it, why don't you?
Kumar said:
[I said] Now, how do homoeopaths and Tissue Remedies prescribers educate their patients to avoid adverse effects of their products? How do they find out about possible adverse effects? Where can we access the data on this?

[Kumar replied] A common thought: they need not to be much worried. But I (may be only I) feel/find it bit differently.:) A needle can remove deep seated things--good or bad but a sword may not.:D
You're darn tootin' right there! When a so-called "remedy" has absolutely no effect on the body, there is probably no need to be "much worried" about adverse effects!

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
When a so-called "remedy" has absolutely no effect on the body, there is probably no need to be "much worried" about adverse effects!
Apart, of course from the sort of adverse outcome that can result if the patient is actually ill...
 
Mojo said:
A common thought: they need not to be much worried. True, because their remedies have no effect whatsoever.


Don't say with vested selfish interest.:) Many more things can be there which can be classified under "need not to be much worried" eg; Fruits, normal foods..etc.
 
Kumar said:
Don't say with vested selfish interest.
No need to have vested selfish interests to say that. One just needs to look at the evidence. And have the ability to think. Yes, that comes in handy sometimes.
 
Rolfe said:

Where does it say that all the patients included in the statistics on the incidence of lactic acidosis were living in unpolluted rural districts and eating a healthy "natural" (whatever that means) diet? It doesn't, because patients would not be selected on that basis. (If you're including 20,000 patient-years, you can't afford to be that choosy!)NO. <SUP>TM</SUP>


Lactic acid levels can be dependent on all such factors, so study should have been done by selecting proper groups. (just remember, you rejected one study on ground that patients were taking medicines also along with remedies). Unnatural/modern big citiy's & natural environment can effect. So study should have been done on people who are getting modern type diabetes the most, means people practicing modern lifestyles & living in big, polluted & crowded cities. I think, it may be surprising & helpful to check LA levels of city's bit aged & somewhat predisposed people.

I said what I mean. If you feel well, you do not have lactic acidosis. Whether you are in the jungle, in the middle of Bombay, the Sahara desert or the far side of the moon.Read up about it, why don't you?

I think, we can think that, a person adopting natural lifestyle can be more physically fit/feel-well than a person living in un-natural/ modern lifestyle in big, crowded & polluted cities.

Do modern lifestyles & modern livings causes various stresses/exertions resulting into more O2 need? More O2 need & less O2 intake/impairement & adopting modern lifestyle may lead to excess LA production. Can you tell differentiating effects of mental stresses, stresses due to modernizations or modern stresses and physical stresses/excercises ON lactic acid? What a healthy lifestyle & environment can do to LA levels?

You're darn tootin' right there! When a so-called "remedy" has absolutely no effect on the body, there is probably no need to be "much worried" about adverse effects!

As I said, many things can be there which can be classified under "need not to be much worried" fruits etc.. You can't say these don't contain anything.
 
Kumar said:
Don't say with vested selfish interest.
I'm not a doctor, and I don't have any connection with the pharmaceutical industry. How could I possibly have any vested interest?
 
Mojo said:
I'm not a doctor, and I don't have any connection with the pharmaceutical industry. How could I possibly have any vested interest?
BWEEEP! Invoking logic with Kumar error.

Vested interest is when you disagree with Kumar. He may not even understand the term, he just saw it used on some forum.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom