Proof of no demolition

That amounts to 8% of the perimeter columns, and 12% of the core columns were examined in the impact areas. In other words, 90% of the columns in the impact area were not physically examined.

<Giggle>. You think they should've tested ALL of the WTC's steel ?

Really ?

No telling what these black budget beam weapons can do.

Of course, there's no telling what they can do. Like other imaginary things, it's up to the guy writing the script.
 
While I will agree that the US could have provided a bit more aid at that time, I have to wonder what prevented any other country from doing so? If everyone all over the world saw that it was necessary why didn't they take the initiative? It seems no one else wanted to either and were content to simply point out that the US wasn't doing it.

Hang on a moment.... The US (and okay admittedly Iran, Pakistan and China but mostly the US) supported the Rebels in such a way that they could go from small isolated pockets of resistance to a well trained army capable of taking on and forcing the Soviets to withdraw, trained then in how to disable and destroy the infrastructure of the country and got them to do their dirty work, but then everyone else should have sent in aid afterwards? Surely the onus on helping clean up a mess is on the people that made it in the first place.

The US used this war to further their own agenda, in doing so helped reduced Afghanistan from one of the most progressive and modern Islamic countries in the world, to nothing more than a dirt-poor dustbowl. Why was it then up to the rest of the world to fix it? Are you going to expect all the rest of the world that objected to the invasion of Iraq to send in aid and fix up that mess there when the Democrats pull the US troops out and leave it in the same sort of disarray? Is that the sort of Legacy Americans want their country known for? Or is it only Islamic countries that you feel can be shredded to pieces and then left with nothing by shards of poverty?

The US, and Israel, keep playing into the extremists hands time and time again. The War on Terror can't be won with bullets and bombs, yet that seems to be the only language you know, too many John Wayne movies. About the only thing that Bush has gotten right is that this is a war for the hearts and minds of people, and quite simply, the West is losing that battle big time. Beating and shooting civilians, torturing prisoners, violating people's rights, knocking down their houses, dropping bombs on them. These things don't win hearts and minds. Every time a child is shot, every time a father is killed, every time a brother is arrested and beaten, that is what makes a new extremist. It has nothing to do with religion, nothing to do with jealousy, nothing to do with freedoms for the people in the US. It has everything to do with the freedom of people in their own countries. Freedom to no be bombed, shot or beaten by US and British soldiers. Freedom to make their own decisions and not be told what to do by the US, freedom to do things their way, even if you don't like their way of doing things.

Am I saying that all US soldiers do these things, no, but it only takes one to do them. It only takes one soldier to fire on civilians, one soldier to beat up a teenager for throwing stones, one pilot to drop a bomb on an innocent household, and the resentment and hate grows. Think about it a bit. Who is going to be loved more? The ones that beat your kids, blow up your homes and torture you, or the ones that pay you money to rebuild your home, build new schools and educate your kids, run a hospital to heal your hurts, ensure you have fuel to run your car, power to run your home and customers to buy your products. That is how to win the hearts and minds, but rebuilding what has been destroyed, not by tearing it down, and whether you like it or not, as it is now, the ones out there that are seen as helping people are the extremists while the soldiers are too often portrayed as the aggressors.

This is the image that has to be broken through, and until it is, there is no way that the west will ever win against the extremists. It's a strategy thing. The west doesn't understand the game that they are playing, and as long as the US continue to use the same old bully boy brute force tactics, it's going to be seen in the same light it is now, a aggressive imperialist evil force bent on world domination. Whether that is true or not doesn't matter, it is perception that matters and right now, that is how it is seen by most of the world's population.

Now I know I have drifted from the original topic here a little, but what I see the US doing today is so much a parallel of what they did in Afghanistan in the late 1980's. You haven't learned anything in the past 20 years. What you did back then, which eventually lead to 9/11, is being mirrored today in Iraq. What happens in another 20 years when the kids that are growing up disaffected in Iraq today, growing up hating the US for the chaos that is their home right now, have reached adulthood and decide to act on their anger, hurt and hate? What will you blame that on? Or will you just keep blaming religion?
 
The world dislikes Americans because they're jealous, and because their media tells them to.

Not true at all. It's this belief that stops the US from actually dealing with the problem. As long as they think "it's just jealousy" and get to "have perhaps the way we are treating the rest of the world isn't right" then nothing is going to change, except that the anger and hatred of the US will increase.

Now okay, I admit that I am anti-americanism (not anti americans, individually I find most of them are nice people, but I am very anti the pushing of American society onto everyone else) but I will still stand up and defend America when it's unfairly attacked. The trouble is that Americans see any attack as unfair and bury their heads in the sand too much. They are so isolated and inward looking they forget that there is a wide world out here and in their blindness they keep riding roughshod over it. As long as they do that, 9/11's are going to keep happening. Until USA'er wake up and see what is really going on outside the borders of their cossy little cul-de-sac and what their Government is acting like towards the outside world, people outside are going to keep targeting them, unfairly or not.
 
Most of the trouble in the Middle East... wait... scratch that... ALL of the trouble in the Middle East has been because of the three Abrahamic religions spawned there, that have succeeded in bringing more misery to mankind than anything else before or since.

Hence why I blame Abraham.

Muslims, Jews, and Christians have been taking turns exterminating everyone in sight for four thousand years.

-Gumboot

So I guess under that idea, the Babylonians, the Persians, the Greeks, and the Romans didn't actually cause any problems in the Middle East region? Nor have there been large periods of time when their has been relative peace between the different faiths there, like, oh from about AD700-1000 and from about AD1500-1900. No just blame it on religion because that's a great scapegoat. Easier than really looking into the actual problems. Nope easy way is to poke your head in the sand and believe that it's all the fault of a verse or two and that if everyone was an atheist we'd all be fine. Sorry but the world doesn't work like that. Try going and reading up on the real histories of the Middle East. Find out why the Crusades happened. Find out about the periods between the wars that happened there. Find out why the Allies attacked the Ottoman Empire during WWI. Power, land and in more modern time Oil have been far larger factors in what has started wars in that region than religion ever has been. Religion is merely a great rallying call and something you can use to con people into dying for while they do your dirty work for you, but the real wars and outside meddling have been over who controls the bit of dirt that makes up the ME and as such, controls its resources.
 
Not true at all. It's this belief that stops the US from actually dealing with the problem. As long as they think "it's just jealousy" and get to "have perhaps the way we are treating the rest of the world isn't right" then nothing is going to change, except that the anger and hatred of the US will increase.

Now okay, I admit that I am anti-americanism (not anti americans, individually I find most of them are nice people, but I am very anti the pushing of American society onto everyone else) but I will still stand up and defend America when it's unfairly attacked. The trouble is that Americans see any attack as unfair and bury their heads in the sand too much. They are so isolated and inward looking they forget that there is a wide world out here and in their blindness they keep riding roughshod over it. As long as they do that, 9/11's are going to keep happening. Until USA'er wake up and see what is really going on outside the borders of their cossy little cul-de-sac and what their Government is acting like towards the outside world, people outside are going to keep targeting them, unfairly or not.



It is true. Americans are aware of what's happening outside their corner of the world. The world is jealous of the USA.

New Zealanders are especially bad at it (our dislike and jealously dates back to WW2 when they saved the ANZAC bacon in the Pacific).

The world expects the USA to solve every single problem, yet complains bitterly any time the problem isn't solved to their liking (both in result and methodology).

Look at Somalia as a prime example.

Why did the USA go into Somalia? Oil? Land? No. They went into Somalia because the American people saw starving Somalis on CNN and wanted to help. They went into Somalia because the combined brilliance of the rest of the world utterly failed to solve the situation.

And then when the US came in and restored order, and started addressing the problem, the world complained that they were being too heavy handed. So the USA left, and the world complained about that too. And when Rwanda happened the US declined to get involved, and the world complained about that. So then with the Balkans the US decided to get involved again. And guess what. The world complained.

Did Europe learn nothing from World War Two? Their hand waving BS does not work. Talking, and making proclamations does not work. You would think tens of millions of dead would be a clear enough message, but these [rule8]s just do not get it |(yes, and those [rule8]s includes us Kiwis).

The only way to deal with scum is to hit them - hard and early.

It seems the USA is the only nation on the planet that has any long term memory. Sure, the USA's efforts haven't always been successful. Sure, the USA has focused its efforts on places that offer specific benefits to it, while sometimes neglecting places that don't offer a specific benefit. But if the rest of the [rule8]s at the UN actually got off their diplomatic backside and DID WHAT THE UN WAS DESIGNED TO DO it wouldn't be just the US trying to sort things out, so it wouldn't only be the USA's interests being protected.

The five permanent members of the UN Security council, on their own, have about 9,500,000 military personnel. The two largest - Russia and China - have not only NEVER contributed substantial forces to a UN mission, but both have actively fought AGAINST UN missions. Does no one except me see a problem with this?

The toothless UN is to blame for the current messes in the world, just as the toothless League of Nations is to blame for WW2. The UN could stop every single conflict on this planet within six months if they chose to.

They don't. Because with the exception of the USA and UK, the west are gutless cowards with useless memories. I almost hope western civilisation is destroyed to teach us a lesson.

You want freedom and peace? Pay for it. It's very expensive.

-Gumboot
 
So I guess under that idea, the Babylonians, the Persians, the Greeks, and the Romans didn't actually cause any problems in the Middle East region? Nor have there been large periods of time when their has been relative peace between the different faiths there, like, oh from about AD700-1000 and from about AD1500-1900. No just blame it on religion because that's a great scapegoat. Easier than really looking into the actual problems. Nope easy way is to poke your head in the sand and believe that it's all the fault of a verse or two and that if everyone was an atheist we'd all be fine. Sorry but the world doesn't work like that. Try going and reading up on the real histories of the Middle East. Find out why the Crusades happened. Find out about the periods between the wars that happened there. Find out why the Allies attacked the Ottoman Empire during WWI. Power, land and in more modern time Oil have been far larger factors in what has started wars in that region than religion ever has been. Religion is merely a great rallying call and something you can use to con people into dying for while they do your dirty work for you, but the real wars and outside meddling have been over who controls the bit of dirt that makes up the ME and as such, controls its resources.



Religion is to blame... and here's why...

There will always be war. I'm in agreement with Plato on that. If everyone became an atheist tomorrow, it wouldn't stop war. War's are primarily about resources, and they're primarily about perceived weaknesses and strengths of different states (no one starts a war unless they think they can win quickly and easily).

But.

Wars tend to be limited things. Long, protracted wars are rare. Wars don't tend to involve many people.

What changes that?

Religion.

Certainly, the Crusades weren't about religion. They were about resources. For the rich. But the rich didn't fight the wars. The poor did. The loyal did. The religious did.

Most people who went on the crusades did so for religious reasons. Religion ENABLED those few who wanted resources to mobilise enormous armies, over and over again.

Nothing but religion can do that.

Religion enables normal people to commit atrocious acts, and to feel right in doing it. It enables massive populations to blindly march forward into bloodshed.

I mean for Ed's sake, they event sent their frikken children on the crusades! Just like Islamic Terrorists train their children to be suicide bombers. That's religion for you.

You're right, there was peace between Jews, Christians and Muslims in the middle east before the Crusades and after them. There's a reason. The entire area was ruled by Muslims. The Romans kicked the Jews out centuries before, and Christianity had re-centred itself in Rome.

Meanwhile in the Middle East first you had the Caliphate (which extended into Spain and Southern France (Christian nations) let's not forget), then you had the Ottoman Empire.

Meanwhile, outside the Muslim Empire, during that time these three religions were happily brutalising each other.

When the three religions didn't have each other to fight with, they splintered and fought with themselves. They seem obsessed with fighting.

-Gumboot
 
Hang on a moment.... The US (and okay admittedly Iran, Pakistan and China but mostly the US) supported the Rebels


The biggest supporter of the Mujahideen was Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, by far.

The US's role in Afghanistan was actually very minor. All they did was give money and weapons to Pakistan.



The US used this war to further their own agenda, in doing so helped reduced Afghanistan from one of the most progressive and modern Islamic countries in the world, to nothing more than a dirt-poor dustbowl.


You're joking right? Afghanistan was not, by any sense of the word, progressive or modern in the 1970's. It was already a dustbowl, as it always has been, and given that the famine and economic failure was what caused the internal upheaval that brought the Soviets into the country... well...

Afghanistan was a disaster.




Think about it a bit. Who is going to be loved more? The ones that beat your kids, blow up your homes and torture you, or the ones that pay you money to rebuild your home, build new schools and educate your kids, run a hospital to heal your hurts, ensure you have fuel to run your car, power to run your home and customers to buy your products. That is how to win the hearts and minds, but rebuilding what has been destroyed, not by tearing it down, and whether you like it or not, as it is now, the ones out there that are seen as helping people are the extremists while the soldiers are too often portrayed as the aggressors.


It's a shame so many people so blindly swallow the media's crap from Iraq. The Coalition are rebuilding. The insurgents are killing FAR more civilians than the coalition ever has, and unlike the coalition, insurgents are doing so intentionally. Some Iraqis don't like the Americans, and some do. But far more of them dislike the insurgents, and they dislike them with a passion.



What you did back then, which eventually lead to 9/11,


September 11 had nothing to do with the Soviet-Afghanistan War. Your comparison of Afghanistan is also grossly flawed. It is your contention that heavy-handed tactics is the problem. The US did not fight in the Soviet-Afghanistan War. They did not fire any rifles or drop any bombs. No US combat forces operated in the entire country. What they did was HELP the Muslims fight to defend their country. And it was successful. In fact the US's role in Iraq and Afghanistan are totally reversed. The US is the Soviets. Iran and Syria (amongst others) are the USA, Pakistan, and Saudi Arabia.

You have it all backwards. And it's revealing your bias - you just want to blame the US, facts be damned. If the US is to blame for Afghanistan, Syria, Al Qaeda and Iran are to blame for Iraq.

If the US is to blame for Iraq, the Soviets are to blame for Afghanistan. You cannot have it both ways.

-Gumboot
 
It is true.

Rubbish, it's nothing but an excuse to avoid the real issues like how their foreign policies affect other people.

Americans are aware of what's happening outside their corner of the world.

HA! Without looking it up on Google, I bet 80% of them couldn't find East Timor on a map, let alone tell you why it is significant, most of them seem to have trouble locating Iraq and Afghanistan! Unless it happens in America, or involves America, trying to find out anything happening else where in the world from inside the US requires a lot of effort. Yes it is better with the Internet, but it involves active searching on the part of the person looking, and most don't bother. (I'd note here that forums such as this are a major exception because the people on it generally are wanting to know what happening, but they are, unfortunately, the exceptions.)

The world is jealous of the USA.

Hogwash. And apart from restating it, you haven't shown any evidence that such Jealousy exists, even the commentary below doesn't show it. You merely claim it as if that proves it.

New Zealanders are especially bad at it (our dislike and jealously dates back to WW2 when they saved the ANZAC bacon in the Pacific).

Again a bunch of Baloney. Most people in NZ weren't even born in WW2. Most dislike for the US in NZ is from the eroding of our culture and the pushing of US culture onto us via TV and commerce. Much of the rest that I have seen tends to stem from contact with US tourists who often seem to be loud, obnoxious, condescending and rude, something that really doesn't create a good representation of their country. In my own experience, while I find that most Americans are great individually, when in groups they would rank right below the French in "getting up my nose" (an slightly above Australians.) Strangely some of the best groups I have known were Japanese and Germans!

The world expects the USA to solve every single problem, yet complains bitterly any time the problem isn't solved to their liking (both in result and methodology).

Fair enough, and yes the rest of the world does need to step up to the crease and bat for a while, but unfortunately the US has gotten themselves into a place where as a superpower the rest of the world does look to them to do something, or at least back it. However at the same time, the US has fostered this by building up their military to one of the largest in the world and taking on the role of protector of the West since WWII instead of making others stand up and take equal responsibility.

Look at Somalia as a prime example.

Why did the USA go into Somalia? Oil? Land? No. They went into Somalia because the American people saw starving Somalis on CNN and wanted to help. They went into Somalia because the combined brilliance of the rest of the world utterly failed to solve the situation.

And then when the US came in and restored order, and started addressing the problem, the world complained that they were being too heavy handed. So the USA left, and the world complained about that too. And when Rwanda happened the US declined to get involved, and the world complained about that. So then with the Balkans the US decided to get involved again. And guess what. The world complained.

Firstly, fair enough that the US should have to be the world police, however, at the same time, when they do go in, they need to do so carefully. Blowing up civilians and foreign Embassies is not the way to win friends and influence people. I don't think that all that many countries actually complained about Somalia, or Kosovo, except when the US continued to bomb the wrong targets. (I'd also note that Kosovo was a NATO mission and involved many countries, not just the US.)

Did Europe learn nothing from World War Two? Their hand waving BS does not work. Talking, and making proclamations does not work. You would think tens of millions of dead would be a clear enough message, but these [rule8]s just do not get it |(yes, and those [rule8]s includes us Kiwis).

Yes and No. They learnt that disarming just leads to those that desire power being able to grab it unopposed. Talking and proclamations do work, if they are backed up with a united and determined front. That is the problem, since WWII there has never been a united front, backed up with the big stick if required, to deal with issues that arise. However I'll leave that until later since you mention the UN below. Had Germany known that France and Britain were armed and ready for war, Hitler would never have attacked Poland. He only did it because he thought that unarmed they'd never carry out their threats. Yes 10 of millions dead were a clear enough message they learned from, that's why today France is a nuclear power!

The only way to deal with scum is to hit them - hard and early.

Violence only begets violence. Look at Iraq. So much of the current troubles there could have been prevented by using less heavy handed tactics. Has Star Wars taught us nothing? The more you tighten your grip, the more people will slip through your fingers. Its even worse when fighting a group like Al Qaeda. They aren't a country. They don't respect borders, they have no fixed base of operations. They don't have supply lines. They can strike from the darkness and then fade back into the dust. There is no front line. Wars don't work against that type of enemy. And worse.. Every time you kill the wrong person, every time a child ends up in the cross fire, every martyr to the cause, you strengthen your enemy. Bomb and bullets will never work again terrorists, there isn't anyway to hit them hard, or early, and when you try, you just end up making more of them.

It seems the USA is the only nation on the planet that has any long term memory. Sure, the USA's efforts haven't always been successful. Sure, the USA has focused its efforts on places that offer specific benefits to it, while sometimes neglecting places that don't offer a specific benefit. But if the rest of the [rule8]s at the UN actually got off their diplomatic backside and DID WHAT THE UN WAS DESIGNED TO DO it wouldn't be just the US trying to sort things out, so it wouldn't only be the USA's interests being protected.

First off, I have no problem with the US ignoring somewhere that they have no interest in, I do have a problem with them meddling in that places affairs and then dumping and ignoring them when they lose interest. Second I do agree that the UN is a useless waste of space and with its current set-up it's never going to be of any use. Russia and China are never going to agree about anything with the US and Britain, and France will vote which ever way will mean they benefit from it. This is the problem, they will never show a united face and as such they are useless, in fact worse than useless. They get played like a divorced couple fighting over who spoils the kids more. However, just because they couldn't agree on the best way to get out of a soggy paper bag doesn't mean that the US and Britain have the right to interfere willy-nilly in the affairs of other countries, especially when it involves starting wars, not ending them. Let me get this straight right now. I applaud the US and NATO for their actions in Kosovo. They went in and stopped the fighting, but they also have a long track record of starting and perpetuating conflicts and wars for their own gain. Israel/Egypt, Israel/Palestine, Iran/Iraq, Afghanistan, Columbia, El Salvador, Cuba, Panama, and who knows how many other countries have all had conflicts that were attempted to be created, or sustained, by the US and/or Britain for their own purposes. That is not on, and that is why a lot of people about the world are highly anti-US.

The five permanent members of the UN Security council, on their own, have about 9,500,000 military personnel. The two largest - Russia and China - have not only NEVER contributed substantial forces to a UN mission, but both have actively fought AGAINST UN missions. Does no one except me see a problem with this?

No, you're not, they make the UN as useless and a papier-mâché crocodile, and Russia (as the Soviets) and the Chinese are as guilty as the US and Britain as far as meddling goes. The Russians are reaping the reward for that in places like Chechnya, whereas the Chinese are probably lucky that Tibetans are Buddhists.

The toothless UN is to blame for the current messes in the world, just as the toothless League of Nations is to blame for WW2. The UN could stop every single conflict on this planet within six months if they chose to.

Sorry I don't entirely agree. Yes they could stop a lot of things, and should, but some things they can't, and other things have been created due to countries already meddling. Blaming the UN for a mess created by the US meddling is not fair to the UN and ignores the complicity of the US, just as blaming the UN for the messes caused by the Russians meddling would be unfair.

They don't. Because with the exception of the USA and UK, the west are gutless cowards with useless memories. I almost hope western civilisation is destroyed to teach us a lesson.

No they don't because the UN's structure will never allow them to do so. It doesn't matter what the West want to do, even if even western country was in total agreement, because Russia and China still have a veto. Regardless, the impotence of the UN is no excuse for the US and UK to meddle with other countries with no regard for anyone other then themselves.

You want freedom and peace? Pay for it. It's very expensive.

Oh, we are going to pay for it, but not the way you think. The current situation has done more harm than good, and unless something is done soon to stop the heavy-handedness and actually get back to the drawing board to nut out a peaceful solution that will remove their support and cripple the terror organisations instead of continuing to strengthen them, then we'll all be paying the ultimate price.
 
I had composed a rather lengthy reply and then saw that Gumboot pretty beat me to it and expounded on the same points I was going to bring up. I will only add this.

After 9/11 there were a lot of things the US could have done that given the context and history of similar things would have been accepted. These include just bombing the country indiscriminately to it's hearts content. Invading and detaining the entire country's population. Arming a neighbor to do the same.

However the US decided against short, quick and sweet retribution and decided to actually try and build the country into a modern state. There are few historical precedents for a country to do such a thing to those that had just killed so many of its civilians.
 
Religion is to blame... and here's why...

Okay, let's have a look...

There will always be war. I'm in agreement with Plato on that. If everyone became an atheist tomorrow, it wouldn't stop war. War's are primarily about resources, and they're primarily about perceived weaknesses and strengths of different states (no one starts a war unless they think they can win quickly and easily).

Totally agree.

But.

Wars tend to be limited things. Long, protracted wars are rare. Wars don't tend to involve many people.

What changes that?

Religion.

Hmmm, tell that to the millions that died in WW1 and 2, the thousands that died in Vietnam and Korea. How about those that died in the 116 years that England and France fought over who got to sit on the throne! No religion need there, just a healthy dose of patriotism.

Certainly, the Crusades weren't about religion. They were about resources. For the rich. But the rich didn't fight the wars. The poor did. The loyal did. The religious did.

So what you are saying is that those that lead the thing used certain rallying cries, such as patriotism as well. (By the way a lot of the rich went on the Crusades, including at least one King of England. Perhaps you've heard of Richard the Lionhearted?)

Most people who went on the crusades did so for religious reasons. Religion ENABLED those few who wanted resources to mobilise enormous armies, over and over again.

A lot went because their country/lord demanded it too.

Nothing but religion can do that.

Except perhaps patriotism and politics....

Religion enables normal people to commit atrocious acts, and to feel right in doing it. It enables massive populations to blindly march forward into bloodshed.

And I guess it was the religiousness that allowed the Nazi's to slaughter millions of Jews, Gypsies, Homosexuals and anyone else that was racial pure...

I mean for Ed's sake, they event sent their frikken children on the crusades! Just like Islamic Terrorists train their children to be suicide bombers. That's religion for you.

And children didn't fight in WW1, 2 and The French, Russian, and the American Revolutions as well as the American Civil War? How about in Sierra Leone, Liberia, Congo, Sudan, Sri Lanka, and Burma? All because of religion right?

You're right, there was peace between Jews, Christians and Muslims in the middle east before the Crusades and after them. There's a reason. The entire area was ruled by Muslims. The Romans kicked the Jews out centuries before, and Christianity had re-centred itself in Rome.

It might have been ruled by Muslims at the times I mentioned, but there were others living there, including Jews, right the way through those period. If they were so determined to destroy each other, why no wipe them out, why let pilgrims travel to the holy sites? Why allow the many churches and monasteries to remain? Many of these places that are still there today!

Meanwhile in the Middle East first you had the Caliphate (which extended into Spain and Southern France (Christian nations) let's not forget), then you had the Ottoman Empire.

Meanwhile, outside the Muslim Empire, during that time these three religions were happily brutalising each other.

Oh? Where were the Jews brutalising anyone? In fact show me any incident that was actually over religion and not really Politics hiding behind religion.

When the three religions didn't have each other to fight with, they splintered and fought with themselves. They seem obsessed with fighting.

Again it is politics. When the Church split the Catholic Church, which had become nothing more than a political organisation, felt it would lose its power. In England when the King split from the Papacy, he believed that the Catholics would attempt a rebellion and so set out to exterminate them. Politics is far more dangerous and ugly than religion ever has been.

In fact show me any incident in the last 400 years where people have fought each other for no other reason than the other's religion.
 
I had composed a rather lengthy reply and then saw that Gumboot pretty beat me to it and expounded on the same points I was going to bring up. I will only add this.

After 9/11 there were a lot of things the US could have done that given the context and history of similar things would have been accepted. These include just bombing the country indiscriminately to it's hearts content. Invading and detaining the entire country's population. Arming a neighbor to do the same.

However the US decided against short, quick and sweet retribution and decided to actually try and build the country into a modern state. There are few historical precedents for a country to do such a thing to those that had just killed so many of its civilians.

Um which country was that? I thought 9/11 was perpetrated by Al Qaeda. Last time I checked AQ wasn't a country.
 
The biggest supporter of the Mujahideen was Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, by far.

The US's role in Afghanistan was actually very minor. All they did was give money and weapons to Pakistan.

Incorrect, they gave money that was to be supplied directly to the Mujahideen, but that was after they had already funded and helped the Mujahideen become the Mujahideen. They didn't start out as the Mujahideen, but rather small groups about the country that were just resistance groups. The US supplied and helped those groups form an organised resistance, as well as training their leaders and fighters right the way through the war, all because they were fighting Maxism, and then the Soviets.

You're joking right? Afghanistan was not, by any sense of the word, progressive or modern in the 1970's. It was already a dustbowl, as it always has been, and given that the famine and economic failure was what caused the internal upheaval that brought the Soviets into the country... well...

Afghanistan was a disaster.

No I'm not, perhaps you need to go and check it out. Under its monarchy Afghanistan was progressive and modern, far more than any of the other Islamic countries. The monarchy had good relations with the US and UK. Things started to change throughout the seventies, first with the Coup in 1973 which lead to a dictatorship, and then disastrously with the second coup and the civil war that followed.

It's a shame so many people so blindly swallow the media's crap from Iraq. The Coalition are rebuilding. The insurgents are killing FAR more civilians than the coalition ever has, and unlike the coalition, insurgents are doing so intentionally. Some Iraqis don't like the Americans, and some do. But far more of them dislike the insurgents, and they dislike them with a passion.

Unfortunately, as I noted, it is all about perspective. If all people are being told is about the bad things, that's what they come to believe. It's a propaganda war that needs to be fought, not one with bombs and bullets, and that is what most people seem to be missing, because currently it's being lost. (I'd also note here that I wasn't just think Iraq here, but South Lebanon sort of come into focus during my writing about which side is often seen as doing things. Israel destroyed, Hezbollah rebuilt, which side do you think the Southern Lebanese like better?)

September 11 had nothing to do with the Soviet-Afghanistan War. Your comparison of Afghanistan is also grossly flawed. It is your contention that heavy-handed tactics is the problem. The US did not fight in the Soviet-Afghanistan War. They did not fire any rifles or drop any bombs. No US combat forces operated in the entire country. What they did was HELP the Muslims fight to defend their country. And it was successful. In fact the US's role in Iraq and Afghanistan are totally reversed. The US is the Soviets. Iran and Syria (amongst others) are the USA, Pakistan, and Saudi Arabia.

I think you missed my target here. I said that if the US pulls out of Iraq leaving it in a mess, then it would be like what they did in Afghanistan. I never suggested that they had troops in Afghanistan in the 1980's (they had CIA in there as info gatherers and in Pakistan doing training, but never had any forces in there.)

What I was getting at was that with Afghanistan they taught the rebels to destroy the country to make it hard for the Soviets to remain, then when the Soviets withdrew they left the Afghanis with the mess, totally broke and with no-one to lead the country out of the mire the US had help get them into. This lead to chaos, civil war and eventually the Taliban taking over, creating a safe haven for Al Quaeda to train and draw the disaffected to.

In the same way, if the US and UK withdraw from Iraq now (which seems to be the way the Democrats want to go), they will leave the country in a mess that will deteriorate further into full scale civil war. This is exactly the same sort of mess that the Extremists have used in Afghanistan, Somalia and other countries to get into power and take control. With extremists in charge of Iraq they will have a further base of operations and a new supply of disaffected ready to brainwash and strike the US.

This is why I was comparing it to the way they treated Afghanistan.
 
It is true. Americans are aware of what's happening outside their corner of the world. The world is jealous of the USA.

New Zealanders are especially bad at it (our dislike and jealously dates back to WW2 when they saved the ANZAC bacon in the Pacific).

The world expects the USA to solve every single problem, yet complains bitterly any time the problem isn't solved to their liking (both in result and methodology).

Look at Somalia as a prime example.

Why did the USA go into Somalia? Oil? Land? No. They went into Somalia because the American people saw starving Somalis on CNN and wanted to help. They went into Somalia because the combined brilliance of the rest of the world utterly failed to solve the situation.

And then when the US came in and restored order, and started addressing the problem, the world complained that they were being too heavy handed. So the USA left, and the world complained about that too. And when Rwanda happened the US declined to get involved, and the world complained about that. So then with the Balkans the US decided to get involved again. And guess what. The world complained.

Did Europe learn nothing from World War Two? Their hand waving BS does not work. Talking, and making proclamations does not work. You would think tens of millions of dead would be a clear enough message, but these [rule8]s just do not get it |(yes, and those [rule8]s includes us Kiwis).

The only way to deal with scum is to hit them - hard and early.

It seems the USA is the only nation on the planet that has any long term memory. Sure, the USA's efforts haven't always been successful. Sure, the USA has focused its efforts on places that offer specific benefits to it, while sometimes neglecting places that don't offer a specific benefit. But if the rest of the [rule8]s at the UN actually got off their diplomatic backside and DID WHAT THE UN WAS DESIGNED TO DO it wouldn't be just the US trying to sort things out, so it wouldn't only be the USA's interests being protected.

The five permanent members of the UN Security council, on their own, have about 9,500,000 military personnel. The two largest - Russia and China - have not only NEVER contributed substantial forces to a UN mission, but both have actively fought AGAINST UN missions. Does no one except me see a problem with this?

The toothless UN is to blame for the current messes in the world, just as the toothless League of Nations is to blame for WW2. The UN could stop every single conflict on this planet within six months if they chose to.

They don't. Because with the exception of the USA and UK, the west are gutless cowards with useless memories.


I almost hope western civilisation is destroyed to teach us a lesson.



This sentence prevents this post from being an all-time great. It is still quite superb, however.



You want freedom and peace? Pay for it. It's very expensive.

-Gumboot


Let's see how those European welfare states function if they try shouldering their own defense burdens.
 
I had composed a rather lengthy reply and then saw that Gumboot pretty beat me to it and expounded on the same points I was going to bring up. I will only add this.

Well then hopefully my answers to him will have answered you.

After 9/11 there were a lot of things the US could have done that given the context and history of similar things would have been accepted. These include just bombing the country indiscriminately to it's hearts content. Invading and detaining the entire country's population. Arming a neighbor to do the same.

What similar things? And which country would be a target? No country attacked the US, how would bombing a country to bedrock and killing millions of innocent people have been acceptable? What they have done is seen by many as unacceptable as it is.

However the US decided against short, quick and sweet retribution and decided to actually try and build the country into a modern state. There are few historical precedents for a country to do such a thing to those that had just killed so many of its civilians.

Those that killed it's citizens? Which Afghani's or Iraqis killed any US Citizens without being attacked first?

As to there being few historical precendents... How about Japan? Germany? Seems to me that all the countries that have attacked the US have been rebuilt by them. Name one that hasn't.
 
nevermind.

Apologies for derailing the thread. I won't pursue this topic. I hate it when people derail a thread with politics, and now look at me...:o

Pomeroo: That comment was a bit tongue and cheek. I have no desire so see my civilisation destroyed. But like the Ancient Romans, I can't help but think many of us will continue to believe we are invincible, and will last for ever, even as the Goths sack our houses.

-Gumboot
 
Let's see how those European welfare states function if they try shouldering their own defense burdens.
Defence from what? Fighting terrorism doesn't require vast conventional militaries such as would have been needed to fight the Soviets if the Cold War had gotten hot.
 
Um which country was that? I thought 9/11 was perpetrated by Al Qaeda. Last time I checked AQ wasn't a country.

Of course it wasn't Al Qaeda, haven't you heard the Truthers? :D

No, but with Taliban supporting them it was essentially a war against the Afghan government.
 
Well then hopefully my answers to him will have answered you.

What similar things? And which country would be a target? No country attacked the US, how would bombing a country to bedrock and killing millions of innocent people have been acceptable? What they have done is seen by many as unacceptable as it is.

I don't feel random bombing is acceptable now as a response. But in the past it was. Britain firebombed German cities in retaliation for the Blitz. While I've encountered many people who call the United States' part in the bombing of Germany a "war crime" I've never encountered anybody who said the same about the UK doing so.

Those that killed it's citizens? Which Afghani's or Iraqis killed any US Citizens without being attacked first?

The Taliban, by harboring and refusing to give up those that committed the act are as complicit in it as the masterminds and financiers. Last I checked the Taliban were Afghani's.

And I never said anything about Iraq.

As to there being few historical precendents... How about Japan? Germany? Seems to me that all the countries that have attacked the US have been rebuilt by them. Name one that hasn't.

Well, as you can see the US isn't such a horrible monster after all. The US does have a precedent for rebuilding those it attacks, be it Japan, Afghanistan or Iraq. But internationally this has, historically, not been the case. There are exceptions, but usually defeat is followed with abject ruin. The world is littered with the remains of cities and cultures destroyed though war. This is kinda beside the point because the US did not destroy Afghanistan during the Soviet invasion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom