Proof of no demolition

No, but with Taliban supporting them it was essentially a war against the Afghan government.

Had the attacks been traced back to Columbians who were hiding in Brazil and the Brazillian government had pointed out that they weren't going to hand them over for various reasons (probably because they'd face the death penalty judging from recent cases) would you have supported the invasion of Brazil and overthrowing of the Government there?
 
No, but with Taliban supporting them it was essentially a war against the Afghan government.

Had the attacks been traced back to Columbians who were hiding in Brazil and the Brazillian government had pointed out that they weren't going to hand them over for various reasons (probably because they'd face the death penalty judging from recent cases) would you have supported the invasion of Brazil and overthrowing of the Government there?

In short. Yes.
 
I don't feel random bombing is acceptable now as a response. But in the past it was. Britain firebombed German cities in retaliation for the Blitz. While I've encountered many people who call the United States' part in the bombing of Germany a "war crime" I've never encountered anybody who said the same about the UK doing so.

I've always consider the firebombing of Dresden by the RAF a war crime, just one that was ignored because it was done by the side that won.

The Taliban, by harboring and refusing to give up those that committed the act are as complicit in it as the masterminds and financiers. Last I checked the Taliban were Afghani's.

See my post above.

This is kinda beside the point because the US did not destroy Afghanistan during the Soviet invasion.

No, they just helped to mastermind and financie it.....
 
In short. Yes.

And right there is exactly why the US has a bad reputation, because Americans feel they have the right to force their ways on other countries. How would you feel if the Chinese decided that they had the right to invade the US and remove the Goverment because the US is habouring "terrorists" involved in the Tiananmen Square protests or Falun gong?
 
And right there is exactly why the US has a bad reputation, because Americans feel they have the right to force their ways on other countries.


I think they feel they have the right to defend themselves from attacks, as per Chapter 7 of the UN Charter. And judging by the number of countries that sent combat forces into Afghanistan (including our own, let's not forget), a lot of nations agreed with them.

(For what it's worth the Taliban were not the recognised government of Afghanistan and had been recognised by the UN as a threat to peace and security)

-Gumboot
 
I think they feel they have the right to defend themselves from attacks, as per Chapter 7 of the UN Charter.

However Afghanistan didn't actually, nor were they planning to attack them, which is why the US mostly used the North Alliance to do the dirty work, again. The other countries have sent in troops since the Taliban ran away for peace keeping and rebuilding (something that would have been far more useful back in 1989.)

For what it's worth the Taliban were not the recognised government of Afghanistan

Perhaps, but then they hadn't had an offically recognised government since 1973.

and had been recognised by the UN as a threat to peace and security

Which is rather interesting considering they never showed any interests outside of Afghanistan, yet other countries that show similar disrespect for their peoples, though not because of religion just get given a book on slums. I guess that says it all about the UN.

eta: and having other countries support your actions doesn't always make it right either, plenty of countries were in the "Coalition of the Willing" and involved in Veitnam, doesn't make either of them right.
 
Last edited:
And right there is exactly why the US has a bad reputation, because Americans feel they have the right to force their ways on other countries. How would you feel if the Chinese decided that they had the right to invade the US and remove the Goverment because the US is habouring "terrorists" involved in the Tiananmen Square protests or Falun gong?

So long as we're going to speak in terms of hypotheticals I'd like to know what you think should have been done? Put yourself in the President's shoes. America was attacked, the guys that did it are inside Afghanistan calling for a holywar and the group that thinks it's the government won't give them up.

What would your course of action have been?
 
This is quite an interesting debate you guys have got going here.

Both sides have raised some good points, but I really think this is a case of the truth being somewhere in the middle! :)
 
<Giggle>. You think they should've tested ALL of the WTC's steel ?

Really ?



Of course, there's no telling what they can do. Like other imaginary things, it's up to the guy writing the script.
< Pick my nose>? I'm sure that NIST would have liked more samples to examine, what investigative body is satisfied with less? My point was that NIST was unable or unwilling to examine the majority of the columns in the impact zones, and their own numbers prove it.
 
It's good to see that we all agree that the US government was in error in it's invasion of Iraq.
 
This entire thread has been all over the map.

There's almost as many tangential arguments as there are posts. What the heck was this thread even about again?



Oh yeah, the video of the collapse that so clearly shows no explosives.
 
However Afghanistan didn't actually, nor were they planning to attack them, which is why the US mostly used the North Alliance to do the dirty work, again. The other countries have sent in troops since the Taliban ran away for peace keeping and rebuilding (something that would have been far more useful back in 1989.)


The US was attacked by forces based in Afghanistan, that were supported by those that controlled Afghanistan. Invading Afghanistan was a legitimate act of self defence.

I'm not just talking about countries that sent in forces for rebuilding. I am talking about the many nations (including our own) that sent combat forces into Afghanistan to be involved in operations to defeat Al Qaeda and the Taliban.



Perhaps, but then they hadn't had an offically recognised government since 1973.

The Northern Alliance leaders were officially recognised by the UN and most nations as the legitimate government of Afghanistan, right up until 2001.


Which is rather interesting considering they never showed any interests outside of Afghanistan, yet other countries that show similar disrespect for their peoples, though not because of religion just get given a book on slums. I guess that says it all about the UN.


A book on slums? I'm not with you.

Care to identify any nations that you consider were threats to peace and security, that had not been identified as such?


eta: and having other countries support your actions doesn't always make it right either, plenty of countries were in the "Coalition of the Willing" and involved in Veitnam, doesn't make either of them right.


Well it depends a lot on your definition of "right" doesn't it? :)

-Gumboot
 
It's good to see that we all agree that the US government was in error in it's invasion of Iraq.

Uh, speak for yourself. We do not all agree on that. Most people on here believe that, but not all of them.

Uh oh, I envision another derail coming.....
 
< Pick my nose>? I'm sure that NIST would have liked more samples to examine, what investigative body is satisfied with less? My point was that NIST was unable or unwilling to examine the majority of the columns in the impact zones, and their own numbers prove it.

NIST, nevertheless had enough to investigate the mechanics of failure. Despite what you think this does not compromise their findings.
 
< Pick my nose>? I'm sure that NIST would have liked more samples to examine, what investigative body is satisfied with less? My point was that NIST was unable or unwilling to examine the majority of the columns in the impact zones, and their own numbers prove it.


They were able to examine as much as they wanted. They specifically chose the pieces they wanted, and they chose a sufficient amount to do their job. Or are you calling the staff at NIST liars?

-Gumboot
 
It's good to see that we all agree that the US government was in error in it's invasion of Iraq.
"We all"? I certainly don't recall discussing my opinion about that, here. And I fail to see how it is relevant to the topic of the thread.

Hans
 
Now, fortunately, we have just a tiny bit more to go by than color. You see, some people actually collected some of the dust ans nalayzed it quite throughly.

No steel power (or iron oxide).



I hear some Fins are very fond of Vodka :rolleyes:.

OK, if you were to look for evidence for a nuclear blast, what would you investigate? Colors?? :dio:

Hans
There are estimates of one million tons of smoke and dust that were released into the air from the WTC disaster. As much as 4% of that volume was in the form of iron particles. That's 40,000 tons of vaporized steel. And let's not forget the lakes of molten steel left after the collapses, which is further evidence of high temperatures from a nuclear explosion.
 
They were able to examine as much as they wanted. They specifically chose the pieces they wanted, and they chose a sufficient amount to do their job. Or are you calling the staff at NIST liars?

-Gumboot
No, I believe they examined what they could. If the had been able to identify all of the severed core columns, they would have gladly used them in their simulations, rather than relying on cases of suspected damage. I'm not calling them liars. Show me where NIST claims that they were able to locate all of the damaged columns from the impact zones.
 
There are estimates of one million tons of smoke and dust that were released into the air from the WTC disaster.
For crying out loud, are you the most credulous person on Earth? I suggest you compare that million ton figure to the total mass of the WTC buildings, and to the mass of debris that was removed from the site. You will be surprised at how absurd your statement is. Please refrain from "people say" and "there are estimates" arguments. They are childish and meaningless.
 
There are estimates of one million tons of smoke and dust that were released into the air from the WTC disaster. As much as 4% of that volume was in the form of iron particles. That's 40,000 tons of vaporized steel. And let's not forget the lakes of molten steel left after the collapses, which is further evidence of high temperatures from a nuclear explosion.

Given that the estimated weight for each building was around 500,000tons, I presume you are saying that both towers were completely "dustified" then?
Where on Earth are you getting this one million tonnes estimate from?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom