Proof of no demolition

Do you know how a hydrogen bomb works? Do you know how high the temperature gets in the initial moment of a thermonuclear detonation?

Oooh! Oooh! I know this one! Do I get to answer or do I have to wait for capracus to take a stab at it?


FYI capracus - if you want to try a W.A.G., as a reference, the sun's core temp is somewhere around 14e6 K. :)
 
Do you know how a hydrogen bomb works? Do you know how high the temperature gets in the initial moment of a thermonuclear detonation?


Rule Notice 2-A: This is an official warning. Please mind the rules. We are not allowed to ask questions, only to answer them.
 
Oooh! Oooh! I know this one! Do I get to answer or do I have to wait for capracus to take a stab at it?
Fire away, my good fellow!

Rule Notice 2-A: This is an official warning. Please mind the rules. We are not allowed to ask questions, only to answer them.
Rules, schmules! Rule are for the NWO dang it!
 
Oh, the standard "yea it was extremist Islamic factions, but you guys had it coming" argument.

Your knee-jerk reaction is not quite reflective of the intent of my statement.

As I recall (real) history, we (the U.S.) are responsible for radicalizing Islam as a tool to fight the U.S.S.R. in Afghanistan. And then, we abandoned them (and worse).

There is broad spectrums of CIA and Pentagon-based conspiracy theories with roots in these events that are magnitudes of degrees more plausible than "secret" bombs in tall buildings.
 
Your knee-jerk reaction is not quite reflective of the intent of my statement.

As I recall (real) history, we (the U.S.) are responsible for radicalizing Islam as a tool to fight the U.S.S.R. in Afghanistan. And then, we abandoned them (and worse).

There is broad spectrums of CIA and Pentagon-based conspiracy theories with roots in these events that are magnitudes of degrees more plausible than "secret" bombs in tall buildings.

If you consider 'real' history an ideologically-driven sophomoric simplification of actual history, then yes, I suppose you're right.
 
As I recall (real) history, we (the U.S.) are responsible for radicalizing Islam as a tool to fight the U.S.S.R. in Afghanistan. And then, we abandoned them (and worse).

Problem here is that the guys that did 9/11 aren't the same ones that the CIA trained and then dumped, but actually spent some time pre-2001 actually fighting the ones that the US had supported in Afghanistan (ironically after having fought beside them to remove the USSR.)

The Northern Alliance was the reminents of the Mujahideen and the Afghanistan government which was formed after 1989 then displaced by infaction fighting and the Taliban. Al Qaeda is a totally different group altogether.
 
Your knee-jerk reaction is not quite reflective of the intent of my statement.

As I recall (real) history, we (the U.S.) are responsible for radicalizing Islam as a tool to fight the U.S.S.R. in Afghanistan. And then, we abandoned them (and worse).

There is broad spectrums of CIA and Pentagon-based conspiracy theories with roots in these events that are magnitudes of degrees more plausible than "secret" bombs in tall buildings.

How could the CIA radicalize Islam? That doesn't even make sense. You're referring to the Mujahadeen of Afghanistan, correct? The CIA armed and trained some of them. They were a loose coalition of Afghan resistance fighters, not the precursor to Al-Qaeda. Foreign Arab Islamic extremist groups that fought with the native Afghan Mujahadeen, giving them financial and logistical support, later coalesced into Al-Qaeda, among other organizations. Nor did the U.S. "abandon" the Mujahadeen, whatever you mean by that.
 
Actually they did. As soon as the Soviets withdrew, the US cut off their funding. Steve Coll's excellent book Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and Bin Laden, from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001 does a good job of covering this period and how the CIA basically cut the Mujahideen off after the war.

How is that abandonment? We funded them for a specific purpose, to repel the Soviet Union. They achieved this. Why continue to fund and arm them when the war was over? So they could kill each other with it? Who expected us to continue to support them?
 
As I recall (real) history, we (the U.S.) are responsible for radicalizing Islam as a tool to fight the U.S.S.R. in Afghanistan. And then, we abandoned them (and worse).


Islam has been radicalised for longer than the USA has been a country.

-Gumboot
 
How is that abandonment? We funded them for a specific purpose, to repel the Soviet Union. They achieved this. Why continue to fund and arm them when the war was over? So they could kill each other with it? Who expected us to continue to support them?

I would tend to agree. Even though with hindsight it was a mistake to 'abandon' them, at the time what exactly should we have done once 'our bidding' was over?
 
How is that abandonment? We funded them for a specific purpose, to repel the Soviet Union. They achieved this. Why continue to fund and arm them when the war was over? So they could kill each other with it? Who expected us to continue to support them?

So what you're saying is that the US used them to fight a proxy war and since they really didn't give a toss about them,once they had done the US's bidding they were on their own, and that's perfectly okay. No help to rebuild the country, no help to re-establish the infrastructure, the goverment, the forces needed to keep the peace and law, all things that the US had helped destroy by providing weapons and training. No, they'd done what the US wanted and the US had zero interest in the area without the soviets there so they were expendable and it was fine to just drop them and ignore their cries for help.
 
So what you're saying is that the US used them to fight a proxy war and since they really didn't give a toss about them,once they had done the US's bidding they were on their own, and that's perfectly okay. No help to rebuild the country, no help to re-establish the infrastructure, the goverment, the forces needed to keep the peace and law, all things that the US had helped destroy by providing weapons and training. No, they'd done what the US wanted and the US had zero interest in the area without the soviets there so they were expendable and it was fine to just drop them and ignore their cries for help.



Yes.

-Gumboot
 
So what you're saying is that the US used them to fight a proxy war and since they really didn't give a toss about them,once they had done the US's bidding they were on their own, and that's perfectly okay. No help to rebuild the country, no help to re-establish the infrastructure, the goverment, the forces needed to keep the peace and law, all things that the US had helped destroy by providing weapons and training. No, they'd done what the US wanted and the US had zero interest in the area without the soviets there so they were expendable and it was fine to just drop them and ignore their cries for help.

Yeah, pretty much. It wasn't our prerogative to go nation building. It's certainly not working out so well for us in Iraq and Afghanistan today. Most of the Mujahadeen didn't want us there establishing a government any more than they wanted the Soviet Union there. They accepted money, logistics, and training from us to fight the other "infidel", but they didn't want us getting involved in their government. They didn't fight the Russians because they hated Communism, they fought the Russians because they hated an "infidel" power establishing a secular order in an Islamic land. The forces which later developed into the Taleban and the terrorist networks run by Bin Laden et al. would have fought us just the same had we tried to exert influence in the area, even if for purely humanitarian reasons.
 
Yeah, pretty much. It wasn't our prerogative to go nation building. It's certainly not working out so well for us in Iraq and Afghanistan today. Most of the Mujahadeen didn't want us there establishing a government any more than they wanted the Soviet Union there. They accepted money, logistics, and training from us to fight the other "infidel", but they didn't want us getting involved in their government. They didn't fight the Russians because they hated Communism, they fought the Russians because they hated an "infidel" power establishing a secular order in an Islamic land. The forces which later developed into the Taleban and the terrorist networks run by Bin Laden et al. would have fought us just the same had we tried to exert influence in the area, even if for purely humanitarian reasons.

And you wonder why 90% of the rest of the world dislikes Americans. No one was suggesting that the US should have gone in and set up a government and did "nation building." Sheeze, the place would have been a bigger mess than Iraq. There is this strange thing called Aid though, where western countries help with money and goods that are required to get war torn and devastated countries back on their feet without actually stomping in and doing it for them, especially when they helped to the damage in the first place. I guess however that it only works with countries the US has an interest in though, like Germany, Japan and South Korea. I mean, why help out a bunch of scruffy islamists who were fighting to regain control of their homeland, rather then having it run by a puppet government that was installed by the Soviets once they'd got rid of your enemy for you.

Perhaps you need to go and read up a little on the history of Afghanistan. The Mujahadeen were fighting for Religious reasons at all, but for freedom. The government they set up was secular, that's why the Taliban, who were formed from groups of extremists training in Religeous Schools in Northern Pakistan, hated them and took over. You seem to be as confused about the groups as SkepticGuy is.
 
I blame that dude... what was his name... oh yeah, Mohammed.

Actually scratch that. He was just carrying a theme. I blame Abraham.

-Gumboot

I don't. If you go and look at the beginings of Islam it was really based on a reasonable idea for the time. Unfortunately with the fighting in the region some of the teachings got a little coloured by the then current events. Most of the trouble has happened since, and the worst of it happened during the crusades when the Catholic commanders refused to negotiate with the Hethen and proceeded to slaughter large numbers of civilians causing the Muslims of the time to take up arms, and they have been fighting ever since.

More recent events haven't helped. WW1, WW2, the British and French conspiracy to trick the Israelis into attacking Eygpt in 1954 which has lead to the tensions in the ME ever since since then...

Most of the trouble in the Middle East has been because of the Western Countries meedling in the affairs there and extremism is the result. We're reapihg what our forebears have been sowing there for the past 600 years.
 
This is a fine example of the "conspiracy of conspiracy theories" concept that is gaining some traction.

It seems that every few months, the "hyperbolic speculation" gets turned up a few notches, and the theories become more and more sensationalist. The best guess is that the "Conspiracy Tycoons" are experiencing a waning of attention with last year's extreme ideas of "TV Fakery" and holograms... so it's time to roll out newer and more extravagant scenarios.

On this point we agree.


These ideas overwhelm and detract from much more mundane (but more plausible) conspiracy scenarios -- one being that covert (illegal) CIA operations pissed off extremist Islamic factions and inspired the terrorism upswing.

Which operations are you talking about?
 
And you wonder why 90% of the rest of the world dislikes Americans. No one was suggesting that the US should have gone in and set up a government and did "nation building." Sheeze, the place would have been a bigger mess than Iraq. There is this strange thing called Aid though, where western countries help with money and goods that are required to get war torn and devastated countries back on their feet without actually stomping in and doing it for them, especially when they helped to the damage in the first place.

While I will agree that the US could have provided a bit more aid at that time, I have to wonder what prevented any other country from doing so? If everyone all over the world saw that it was necessary why didn't they take the initiative? It seems no one else wanted to either and were content to simply point out that the US wasn't doing it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom