Proof of God's existence! 1 million dollar challenge at the end! Randi better pay-up!

MRC_Hans said:
Now, suppose the mast breaks. You are now being controlled by the (unconscious) wind and current.

So youre ultimately saying that the wind and current are controlling your thoughts?
 
One of the most obvious examples of being controlled by a less conscious thing is a simple cold. This virus, which is arguably not even alive, is making your nose run and your eyes water and a whole list of other symptoms. The best brains in medical science can do little to alleviate the symptoms.

Other brainless germs and viruses can kill you. Some we can control, some we can partially control, some we cannot control at all.

So next time you take an antihistamine to try to regain partial control of your body, think of who is really being controlled by what.
 
muscleman
WHOEVER MENTIONED THAT TO BE OK? THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR WAS USED AS ANALOGY,
You did in a previous post.

THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR WAS USED AS ANALOGY TO HUMAN RACE, AND A CONTROLLER TO GOD...
So it’s wrong when a person does it but ok when it’s god? Ever hear of a double standard?

EVEN IF GOD WAS PART OF THE WORLD ( LIKE PRESIDENT BUSH) WHAT MADE YOU THINK YOU CAN ARREST GOD WHO CREATED YOU? HE CREATED YOU, AND YOUR WORLD. YOU HAVE NO AUTHORITY OVER HIM MORON.. NEITHER DO YOU HAVE THE POWER...
Again a double standard. From all available evidence your god is the worlds most irresponsible, sadistic entity.

IT IS LIKE A 4 MONTHS OLD BABY TRYING TO ARREST AND PUNISH A PROFESSIONAL BODY BUILDER. OR A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR TRYING TO PUNISH THE CONTROLLER, YOU ARE JUST INCAPABLE
Just because the baby or the remote is incapable of punishing the controller doesn’t mean the controller isn’t guilty.

ATHEISTS IN THE OTHER HAND BLAIMS "GOD" BECAUSE HE IS CONTROLLING US,
atheist = one who lacks a belief in god(s). So how are atheists blaming an imaginary entity?

WHY THEN DONT YOU BLAIM THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND NATURE MORONS? BECAUSE IT IS NOT CONSCIOUS? WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE?
Physics is not a conscious entity. It didn’t suddenly decide that I should kill someone. However, you keep insisting that god controls everything, which would mean that god decided that I should kill someone and I don’t have the power to go against what god wishes.

YOU ATHEISTS ARE BEING A MORON FOR THINKING ABOUT PUNISHING GOD BUT NOT WANTING TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY
Again your inability to grasp a simple concept shines through.
Should the controller be punished for controlling the car/gun/person or should the controller not be punished?

AGAIN IT IS ONLY LOGICAL THAT BOTH THE CONTROLLER, AND CONTROLLED PAY THE PRICE.
That’s what I’ve been asking for the past few pages. Now that you have answered lets apply your answer to the situation you have set up.
God controls everything and everyone (omnipotent)
Some people commit evil acts, killing, raping, theft, etc.
God, by controlling them, caused the people to commit evil. (they were unable to go against the will of god)
God is responsible for evil.
God should be punished.

JESUS DIED FOR YOUR SINS, HE SUFFERED AND WAS CRUCIFIED, AND IN THIS EARTH, DIDNT DESERVE IT, BUT HE DID IT FOR YOU
Then Jr’s sacrifice is meaningless because Big Daddy is the one that should have suffered. Jr was also only punished once yet Big Daddy continues to control everything causing more evil.

THE ONLY THING YOU FIND CONTRADICTORY IS THAT YOU WANT GOD TO SUFFER MORE THAN HE ALREADY DID, YOU WANT HIM TO ROAST IN HELL FOR ALL ETERNITY.
Hey, if god is sending someone to hell for something god caused them to do then yes god should suffer in hell for all eternity.

WHY ARE U DEFENDING THE EVIL MAN? BECAUSE YOU ARE LIKE THEM?
Because, according to you, god made them evil. Why not just make everyone good?

I ALREADY AGREED WITH YOU, GOD IS FULL OF VENGEANCE, BUT YOU ALSO TOOK THAT OUT OF CONTEXT. GOD ALSO CREATED GOOD MAN. AND HE IS ALSO FULL OF MERCY AND LOVE, THAT YOU CAN ASK FOR FORGIVENESS, AND YOU WILL BE FORGIVEN.
Vengeance does not leave much room for mercy and love.

More later.

Ossai
 
wraith said:


So if someone asked you "how did you crash your car?"
Your reply will be along the lines of "the car made me do it"
:rolleyes:
Could you at least TRY to suppress your compulsory strawman reflex? I was making an example of how a conscious being in a given situation was effectively controlled by something non-conscious.

Hans
 
wraith said:


So youre ultimately saying that the wind and current are controlling your thoughts?
Could you at least TRY to suppress your compulsory strawman reflex? I was making an example of how a conscious being in a given situation was effectively controlled by something non-conscious.

And I was certainly not talking about my thoughts.

Hans:rolleyes:
 
muscleman
Nature as chance= DEBUNKED...
Faith is stupid= DEBUNKED...
Only whats observed exist, we label as "physical"= DEBUNKED...
Omnscience/freewill cannot co-exist= DEBUNKED..
Your straw men have already been exposed once. I feel no need to do so again.

Supernatural dont exist= PENDING...
I gave an example of what I would consider supernatural, twice. You have ignored both posts.

AFTER THIS, THERE SHALL BE NOTHING LEFT FOR THE ATHEISTS TO ARGUE, NOTHING.. THERE SHOULD NOW BE NO REASON TO NOT BELIEVE IN GOD
But I already believe in IPUs.


wraith
"If God controls me, then how can I be responsible for my actions?" It's an aparent contradiction, though ultimately it isnt.

Afterall, it's YOUR MPB that God is running....
Then the question becomes who made the MPB?
As for your whole concept of MPB, what test would you set up to debunk or prove it?


MRC_Hans
I was making an example of how a conscious being in a given situation was effectively controlled by something non-conscious.
But the person isn’t really being controlled. Their options are just being severally limited in that instance. While driving down the road, suddenly hitting an icy patch and the car starts to tailspin the drivers options are limited: stay in car, try to jump out, duck, slide into the back seat, etc.

Ossai
 
muscleman said:
I have answered your questions, but because your blind and you dared me, now I will only deal with u this time, this time, there is no escape, i will annihilate your post as I did to Beleth (and of course yur all a cult members, u sure will b on her side always.)......
All right, listen up, you faithless, illogical hack.

Just because I said I wasn't going to post any more doesn't mean that I'm not reading this. I notice that as soon as I say I'm not going to post any more, you start waving my name around like it's my head on a pike or something. In other words, you're attacking someone who has left the battlefield. Just like a rotten, spoiled child would.

You come here, a field of logic and reason, to argue the existence of God, and yet you don't know what a "straw man" is? Go grow a brain.

You argue for the existence of a God that you yourself don't even have any faith in? Hypocrite. Jesus hates hypocrites, you know, and you're one of the biggest I've seen.


You think stones act.
You think a glass with half cyanide and half water is safe to drink.

You have no reasoning skills whatsoever.


Someone read to you (I'm sure you didn't read it yourself) something out of a really nice book, with a leather cover and gold edged pages, and probably with certain passages highlighted in red, and you think that that's the only book worth reading. I got news for you, pal - there have been many books written since then that both elaborate on and debunk much of the stuff in that book, and you are missing out on the most fulfilling parts of faith if you limit yourself to that one book.

You ignore questions put to you and claim victory for no reason.

You are doing more damage to your professed-but-not-believed faith than the rest of the atheists here put together. You are making believers look like fools because you, sir, are a fool.


And now you have dragged me down to your level. Bra-frikkin-vo.


Go move mountains or something. You are only doing Satan's work here.
 
Muscleman can't tell the difference between Satan and somebody saying something he doesn't like, so naturally he would be open to such a being's influence, if such a thing existed as he described it.
 
Beleth said:
And now you have dragged me down to your level. Bra-frikkin-vo.

Go move mountains or something. You are only doing Satan's work here.
You needn't worry, Beleth. No thinking person would class you along with the Muscleman type of theist (if he even deserves that label).
 
Tricky said:

You needn't worry, Beleth. No thinking person would class you along with the Muscleman type of theist (if he even deserves that label).

Unlike Muscleman, we foul atheists can distinguish between particulars.
 
muscleman said:
By your admittance, OUR REALITY "MAY" CONTAIN GODS? LOL, SO YOUR ACCUSING
AGAINST YOUR OWN BELIEF, saying that God dont exist (by your belief atheism, u may
not claim, but you do believe he dont exist.)... You must be agnostic, otherwise how incredibly
stupid of you (ILL BE EMBRARRASED TO BE AN ATHEIST.).......
I do not know everything this reality contains; therefore, I cannot tell you if a god or gods do
or do not exist in this reality, or for that matter, a great deal many other things fanatical and
improbable. Why would you be embarrassed to be an atheist?
WE CAN "NEVER"??? WHAT A STUPID ASS COMMENT...
We can never be a part of another reality. We exist only in this reality. Anything resembling
us in another reality will only be at best a xerox copy and not the original, but we need not
worry about the matter as we will never know what happens to them.
WE CAN NEVER KNOW HOW LIFE CAME TO EXISTENCE?
WE CAN NEVER PLANT VEGETABLES UNDER SEA?
We may in fact learn of the past and the processes that resulted in life. And, we may through
a future technology, if we so choose, plant all sorts of creatures in the sea. The past, present,
and future all belong to this reality.
EVEN THE ATHEIST BRAINWASHED CULTS HERE SAY "ITS POSSIBLE THAT WE CAN
CREATE LIFE FORMS", SO WHAT ARE YOU? DISSAGGREEING WITH ATHEISTS? AGNOSTIC?
HECK, ILL BE EMBARASSED BEING CALLED AN ATHEIST AT THIS POINT...
No, not an atheist. Applying Frankonian terminology, I'm an omnignostic. Atheism and theism
exist as but mere points contained within a much larger set apantheism and panthiesm that
itself exists within a lager set of the asupernatural and supernatural and so on. I carry a lot of
baggage, no? Yet it weighs absolutely nothing.

Hm. Are you afraid of being embarrassed and therefore cannot take any other positions?
NOW YOUR TELLING ME IS THAT WHAT WE LEARNED IN SCIENCE, IS ALL THERE
IS TO KNOW, AND THERE IS NO OTHER THINGS TO LEARN.. WHAT A STUPID ASS
COMMENT... EVEN SCIENCE AGREES THERE ARE MORE THINGS TO LEARN. ARE
YOU KNOW GOING TO CALL ME "TROLL" TOGETHER WITH YOUR BRAINWASHED
CULTS?
This is very different from Frankonian philosophy where the laws of physics are fixed,
unchanging, and limited in number. Are there limits to knowledge? I simple don't know.
WHAT IS A REALITY WITH GODS? OR WITHOUT GODS? WHATS THE DIFFERENCE?
Many religions state the existence of god or gods, and the god or gods act altering reality,
creating, destroying, and otherwise leaving their mark upon the world. Yet curiously we can't
find good evidence that they did so in the past. The best available evidence does not reveal
anything beyond the ordinary natural processes ongoing daily. Short of building a time machine,
one cannot accept claims made with certainty.
BECAUSE WITH GODS, THERE IS EVIL?
AND WITHOUT GODS THERE IS NO EVIL?
CARE TO CLARIFY THE DIFFERENCE?
Problem one, how does one know there is evil in the world?
Problem two, how does one know that gods create evil?
For all the world they may not create evil, but are innocent bystanders.
Problem three, what prevents the natural world from creating evil?
Because I do not know the how evil works or it possible sources, I cannot clarify the difference.
BUT FIRST, I MUST CLEARLY LEARN WHAT THE WORD "SUPERNATURAL" MEAN.........
What is the "another" reality? Something outside of the laws of nature?
If the word "supernatural" is defined as "something outside of the laws of nature"..
Here we slam into a Frankonian wall. The modern usage of 'laws of nature' refers to our
descriptions of nature, or more accurately, the behavior of things in nature. Why? As an example:
The First Law of Thermodynamics describes the behavior of natural systems observed through
countless experiments and states that the total energy within, entering, leaving, remains constant.

The other and older meaning of the 'laws of nature' refer to underlying unchanging fixed, possibly
logical rational rules that govern not just nature but reality itself. From this view one might might
look at the Conservation of Energy Principle, a part contained within the First Law, and say that
this constitutes a general underling rule for reality. One tiny problem, cosmic microwave background
photons left over from the start of the observed universe do not follow the First Law, energy seems
to be destroyed as space expands. Which begs the question do 'laws of nature' as in rules for this
reality exist or just the illusion of a deranged mind?

A reality is just a set of things that exist together although they may be separated by time and
space. We only know of one, we can only know of one, all others do not exist for us and remain
forever unreal to us.

Supernatural therefore has two possible meanings. One, the supernatural violates the underlying
rules of reality that by definition cannot be possible or the rules aren't really rules as we define them.
Two, the supernatural exists in reality beyond our current limited understanding of the world we call
the natural and can do things that violate our laws and theories, or if you prefer, descriptions and
explanations. I think most people agree with this idea of the supernatural.
IN THE SAME WAY THERE IS NO BIBLE CONTRADICTIONS, ITS THE STUPID
IGNORANT ATHEIST WHO MAKES IT CONTRADICTORY WITH THEIR TWISTED THINKING...
If no one reads a book then it is not contradictory. In other words is this a universal property of books?
JESUS DIED FOR YOUR SINS, HE SUFFERED AND WAS CRUCIFIED, AND IN THIS EARTH,
DIDNT DESERVE IT, BUT HE DID IT FOR YOU (FOR HE IS ONLY THE SON OF THE FATHER,
NOT THE FATHER, AND THE FATHER IS THE GREATEST SOURCE OF THE TRINITY...)
YES...GOD CREATED BOTH, LIGHT AND DAY, GOOD AND EVIL, HEAVEN AND HELL...
Alas, unverifiable in the important parts, and not for a lack of trying. :(
 
hmmm. maybe in his world he's correct. In ours, he's definitely insane.

Scott
ps: there's no need to argue with someone who is insane or
bases their position on irrational foundation.
 
Blue Monk said:
Is it proof yet?

it sounds so horrible... but I really think people who have a clue
about thinking, reality, etc... shouldn't worry so much about those
who can't think for themeselves.

Unless there is an intelligent theist anywhere.. every single
theist I've seen here falls back upon faith or ad hominem.

There is no proof. The "proof" they offer is patently absurd.
It wouldn't proove anything anywhere else, other than to
those who already know know the result is the only possible
result and there can't even be the POSSIBILITY of any other result (which means it's hardly any proof at all).

It's not a debate... it's preaching.

Scott

--
Theist:

It is so because it is so.

--
Anyone who disagrees with the theist (not just atheist, but anyone
else who doesn't share their exact faith):

doing the debbyls work... satan... you name it.



Listen up people. I am not afraid of the truth. I am not afraid
of being wrong. My reality doesn't go away when I stop believing
in it. I don't have to force people to believe in my reality for it
to be real. I don't have to kill people to convince them to believe
in my reality. Calling me names doesn't make your reality true!
Insulting (er, rather, trying to insult) me dodges the point.

Something either is, or isn't (and lets not throw the usual
QM / multiverse (not franko def, but the real one)... in here.

Can someone be somewhat right in that there is somewhat
of a god? Can you be right in believe in a god, but believing
in the wrong one?

Scott
 
a pig is one of those animals with the big floppy ears and there was a story about one that could fly by flapping its ears. Oh yeah, nevermind, that was dumbo the elephant. Actually, no, DUMBO WAS A PIG, HOW COULD YOU SAY HE WAS AN ELEPHANT? WHAT A STUPID ASS COMMENT.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom