To begin, the actual quote was:
In my reality individual consciousnesses are actually particles in a "more real" Universe (the Omniverse). This Universe is simply an elaboration of the Truer Reality.
which renders this:
[The Omniverse ?]which is not confirmed by current scientific understanding of consciousness. This point has been raised before and, for some reason, ignored.
rather not surprisingly misleading.
The
Hound Worried Bigotted Coward et Liar et Hypocrit attempts, again, to avoid his responsibility to provide basis for his proclamations.
He, again, made a statement concerning consciousness.
He, again, tries to avoid providing evidence.
He, again, tries to hide from the
Science of Consciousness [Cue
Thunderclap.--Ed.].
Why?
Instead of an answer, he tried to alter the direction of the conversation from his
FAILURE to provide support.
Yes, I keep asking You (sic) A-Theist (sic) what SPECIFICALLY is the "YOU" that is suppose to be making these "free will" decisions, and for some reason that question keeps being "Ignored" ???
As stated, the tactic
Hound Worried Bigotted Coward et Liar et Hypocrit of trying to turn to discussion to a slogan upon his sandwich board is too well-known now to work. As also stated, he attempt to make arguments for others inorder to attack the others through the made-up arguments.
The tactics of a tyro, certainly, but, other than temper-tantrums, it is the only tactics he apparently has.
Nevertheless, he made the assertions.
He must support them.
Now, as also previously stated I remain, despite all appearances, an optimist. Thus, allow me to recognize a subsequent attempt to address the subject:
All I see is chemicals. . . .
Perchance a somewhat more magnified perspective will assist matters. He forgets the
structure created by the chemical. However, allow him to continue:
Why should I believe that this "consciousness" you speak (sic) of is nothing more than an illusion. . . .
The individual
used the term and made statements concerning it.
Now, if he wishes to consider it all an "illusion" and wander down the freshman-philosophy path of "I-cannot-prove-the-tree-exists-when-I-close-the-door-give-me-another-hit"
then he is free to that waste of time.
Nevertheless, an "illusion" of consciousness exists, and in the case presented here, and before, it does not. This is a rather consistent "illusion." In fact, as with other scientific theories worthy of sodium chloride, one can make successful predictions based upon the anatomy and physiology involved.
However, credit where credit is due, he continues:
MoiThus a small lesion in the midbrain which blocks passage of signals from the ascending reticular activating system to the thalamus and forebrain and ceases consciousness does what to these particles?
Your "physical body" is an algorithm running on top of another algorithm (Your Graviton). Essentially your "physical body" is an interface algorithm ? it enhances your ability to communicate (transmit and receive information (energy)). Damage to the subordinate algorithm leaves the primary algorithm (relatively) unaffected.
Placing a word in quotation marks does not, in and of itself, render it any more or less real. Given his prediliction to
argumentum ad hominem, one can understand his faith in the magical nature of words.
Accept, for a moment, his terms; we can consider analogies, even the ridiculous.
He implies that damage to the body--his "subordinate algorithm"--leaves the "primary algorithm"--"Graviton"--intact.
Really.
Unfortunately, in the case described the patient does not recover consciousness though he will usually "progress" to a permanent vegetative state.
Whither then his "Graviton?"
This is not simply an exercise in pinning a person down with his own words. Theories must fit reality. Thus, one can switch off this area, obliterate consciousness, and then switch the person back on.
Thus where did his "Graviton" go?
What difference, then, exists between the first patient who never regains consciousness from the second who have both suffered a relatively small--anatomically writing--lesion?
I understand that I have the individual--and perhaps most of the Readership still awake--at some disadvantage. Quite some time ago, I provided background evidence on the science of consciousness in the apparently vain hope that the individual would explain how his theories fit the reality that contradicted them.
One or two posters thanked me for the information. I must confess I assumed he ignored it.
I am more than willing to provide it again, though, I further confess, I generally only help gentlemen. To behave as such may place an onerous burden upon the individual, but I can assure him that he will benefit from the ordeal.
--J.D.
[Edited for various scribal errors.--Ed.]