Proof of God's existence! 1 million dollar challenge at the end! Randi better pay-up!

WE CAN "NEVER"??? WHAT A STUPID ASS COMMENT... WE CAN NEVER KNOW HOW LIFE CAME TO EXISTENCE? WE CAN NEVER PLANT VEGETABLES UNDER SEA? EVEN THE ATHEIST BRAINWASHED CULTS HERE SAY "ITS POSSIBLE THAT WE CAN CREATE LIFE FORMS", SO WHAT ARE YOU? DISSAGGREEING WITH ATHEISTS? AGNOSTIC? HECK, ILL BE EMBARASSED BEING CALLED AN ATHEIST AT THIS POINT...

We can never know another reality, because we don't live in another reality. It's just about that simple.

Vegetables under the sea? Abiogenisis in the labs? What does this have to do with other realities, and what of A-theism?

And I see you Caps Lock is still misbehaving.
 
neutrino_cannon said:


We can never know another reality, because we don't live in another reality. It's just about that simple.

Vegetables under the sea? Abiogenisis in the labs? What does this have to do with other realities, and what of A-theism?

And I see you Caps Lock is still misbehaving.

what is the "another" reality? Something outside of the laws of nature?

If the word "supernatural" is defined as "something outside of the laws of nature"..

THEN WHY DONT YOU TELL ME "ALL" OF THE LAWS OF NATURE, SO THAT IF SOMETHING IS NOT LISTED, THEN IT MUST BE SUPERNATURAL..

DO YOU KNOW ALL OF THE LAWS OF NATURE?

IF SO, TELL ME "FEW" OF IT... AND ILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE OF AN EXISTING "SUPERNATURAL" MATTER... I SHALL AWAIT FOR YOUR RESPONSE......

NOTE: I THANK YOU FOR RESPONDING AND GETTING IN THE CONVO, FOR FINALLY THE PROOF OF GOD WILL BE GIVEN.. JUST RESPONSE...:)
 
muscleman said:


what is the "another" reality? Something outside of the laws of nature?

If the word "supernatural" is defined as "something outside of the laws of nature"..

THEN WHY DONT YOU TELL ME "ALL" OF THE LAWS OF NATURE, SO THAT IF SOMETHING IS NOT LISTED, THEN IT MUST BE SUPERNATURAL..

DO YOU KNOW ALL OF THE LAWS OF NATURE?

IF SO, TELL ME "FEW" OF IT... AND ILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE OF AN EXISTING "SUPERNATURAL" MATTER... I SHALL AWAIT FOR YOUR RESPONSE......

NOTE: I THANK YOU FOR RESPONDING AND GETTING IN THE CONVO, FOR FINALLY THE PROOF OF GOD WILL BE GIVEN.. JUST RESPONSE...:)

Another reality would be a universe where the fundamental setup is different from ours.

And I'm not quite sure why you go on and on about this supernatural bit. I never mentioned the supernatural.

And supposing I was to list all of the known laws of physics (some of which, by the way would be overlaping and contradictory), then things outside of those, such as stock market reports would be supernatural?

Don't get me wrong, the stock market is complicated and chaotic, but most certainly not supernatural.

WTF is a convo?

So, here is a partial list of some of the known laws of nature:

Boyle's law. If the volume of a container is increased, the pressure decreases.

If the volume of a container is decreased, the pressure increases
PV = k

First law of thermodynamics, energy is conserved

principal of causality (you watching Franko?): causes must exist for all efects, and the causes must precede the effects.

density/heat laws: at constant pressure, density and temperature vary inversely: the warmer the air, the less dense it is

That's what I could think of for now. Why?
 
neutrino_cannon said:


And supposing I was to list all of the known laws of physics (some of which, by the way would be overlaping and contradictory), then things outside of those, such as stock market reports would be supernatural?

Don't get me wrong, the stock market is complicated and chaotic, but most certainly not supernatural.

Incase u didnt know, its the atheists here wanting for us theist to prove something supernatural exist (JR even offers a million dollar..).

But this is strange, because by YOUR OWN WORDS, the laws of physics can be "overlapping" and "contradictory" to each other..

Now if we define something to be supernatural only if it "CONTRADICTS" the laws of physics, and at the same time by your admittance, the other laws of physics may "CONTRADICT" it, THEN IN THIS CASE, THE WORD "SUPERNATURAL" ATHEISTS ARE ASKING NEVER EXIST RIGHT?

note: Ill respond to the other after u respond to this.......
 
Neutrino_Cannon,

I do like your user name but surely a such a device would be highly ineffective? :)

Also, a number of your 'laws' only hold in the case of an 'ideal gas'.

I know none of this has anything to do with the thread. My apologies.
 
I guess Randi's million-dollars aren't any more at risk than they were before MM showed up. Still no evidence or proof of a god.
 
Incase u didnt know, its the atheists here wanting for us theist to prove something supernatural exist

That was the claim made by the originator of this thread.

Silly readers have been waiting for this proof, in vain, apparently.

--J.D.
 
Franko
What makes you assume that you cease to exist when you die? Pessimism?
You are the one that keeps saying that everything is controlled by TLOP, which means a completely physical existence. So why not answer your own question?
Are we completely controlled by TLOP = material existence.
There is a part of us that exists after we die = non-material existence (not controlled by TLOP)

Pretend there are no consequences for your actions instead? Yeah, burn you hand on the stove and then let’s talk …
That consequence is only relevant if I’m:
1. Alive
2. Have freewill

If I’m alive but have no freewill then the entity that caused me to place my hand against the stove has committed an evil act, ATBE.


muscleman
I ALREADY ADMITTED THAT GOD IS GOOD TO THOSE WHO SERVE HIM, AND GOD IS EVIL TO THOSE WHO HATE HIM.
But you also said that god created them that way. What choice did they have?

ATLEAST NOT A "DIRECT" CONSCIOUSNESS, MAYBE THE CAUSE (AS THE CAUSE OF COMPUTER IS HUMAN INTELLIGENCE, AND HUMAN INTELLIGENCE OFF GOD INTELLIGENCE...)
and the cause of god’s intelligence is IPUs.

I AM READY NOW TO TALK ABOUT "INTELLIGENT DESIGN" IF THE TOPIC COMES THIS WAY CHILD. YOU JUST GOT DEBUNKED TWICE AGAIN
You can’t count very well can you? I’m beginning to wonder if you even managed to pass grade school.

MATERIAL? WHAT IS MATERIAL? SOMETHING WE CANT DETECT? SUBSTANCIAL? PHYSICAL? I HAVE DEALT WITH THAT TO ANOTHER ATHEIST EARLIER, WHAT LIES "SUBSTANCIAL" BY ADMITTANCE TO SOME CULT MEMBERS HERE, LIES ON THEIR "FAITH".... REGARDLESS IF KING HENRY REALLY EXIST OR NOT, HE EXIST JUST IN YOUR MINDS, FOR YOU HAVE NOT TOUCHED HIM, OR SEEN HIM....
One has nothing to do with the other. By material existence, now that you are echoing Franko, we would be completely controlled by TLOP and there is no existence once the matter that we are composed of has ceased to function, death is the end. Now are you claiming that we have a non-material existence which would mean that some part of us isn’t controlled by TLOP(god) or that we are completely controlled which would negate any sort of afterlife and your precious justice.

OH YES THAT WILL BE DONE... BUT FIRST, I MUST CLEARLY LEARN WHAT THE WORD "SUPERNATURAL" MEAN.........
Earlier I gave you an example of a supernatural phenomena. I’m still waiting.

Incase u didnt know, its the atheists here wanting for us theist to prove something supernatural exist (JR even offers a million dollar..).

But this is strange, because by YOUR OWN WORDS, the laws of physics can be "overlapping" and "contradictory" to each other..
Your reading comprehension skills are appalling. Seriously now, did you manage to graduate high school?

neutrino_cannon
Got it in one. :D

Ossai
 
Ossai:
You are the one that keeps saying that everything is controlled by TLOP, which means a completely physical existence. So why not answer your own question?
Are we completely controlled by TLOP = material existence.
There is a part of us that exists after we die = non-material existence (not controlled by TLOP)

In my reality … sure. In yours … ?

In my reality individual consciousnesses are actually particles in a “more real” Universe (the Omniverse). This Universe is simply an elaboration of the Truer Reality.

[burning hand on stove …]That consequence is only relevant if I’m:
1. Alive
2. Have freewill

If I’m alive but have no freewill then the entity that caused me to place my hand against the stove has committed an evil act, ATBE.

Not if the God that generates this Universe didn’t make you.

Look, maybe you are just nuts? Maybe you like burning your hand? Maybe it feels “good” from your perspective? Similarly some people “like” being pessimist. They like their negativity, they like spreading it around … insane …

Ossai, what would you call a person who sincerely thought they had a “choice” about whether to stop at a red traffic light or not? Suppose there was an individual who believed that for him personally whether he stopped at a red light was entirely his “free will” “choice”?

Likewise some of us have the “free will” to burn our hands on the hot stove over and over again, while others of us lack this … “ability”.

The Muscles:
I ALREADY ADMITTED THAT GOD IS GOOD TO THOSE WHO SERVE HIM, AND GOD IS EVIL TO THOSE WHO HATE HIM.

Ossai:
But you also said that god created them that way. What choice did they have?

I’m sure he will correct if I am wrong, but as far as I know the Muscle agrees with me that the God who generates this Universe is not the same entity that created your Soul. Why do you continue to harp on the same point over and over again even thought it has been explained to you many times?

Why is it the QUAKE programmers fault that You suck at QUAKE?
 
Interesting:

In my reality individual consciousnesses are actually particles in a ?more real?. . . .

which is not confirmed by current scientific understanding of consciousness. This point has been raised before and, for some reason, ignored.

Thus a small lesion in the midbrain which blocks passage of signals from the ascending reticular activating system to the thalamus and forebrain and ceases consciousness does what to these particles?

--J.D.
 
franko
In my reality individual consciousnesses are actually particles in a “more real” Universe (the Omniverse). This Universe is simply an elaboration of the Truer Reality.
So basically you are making the entire thing up and every time someone points out an inconsistency you rewrite what you believe.


If I’m alive but have no freewill then the entity that caused me to place my hand against the stove has committed an evil act, ATBE.
Not if the God that generates this Universe didn’t make you.
Notice my above quote. I said entity that is controlling not created. Another not so cleverly constructed straw man.

Likewise some of us have the “free will” to burn our hands on the hot stove over and over again, while others of us lack this … “ability”.
My bold. Franko just said that we have freewill! 100 points

Ossai
 
Doctor X: (hard-core)
[The Omniverse …]which is not confirmed by current scientific understanding of consciousness. This point has been raised before and, for some reason, ignored.

Yes, I keep asking You A-Theist what SPECIFICALLY is the “YOU” that is suppose to be making these “free will” decisions, and for some reason that question keeps being … Ignored … ???

All I see is chemicals – just like any other – doing what chemicals do. Why should I believe that this “consciousness” you speak of is nothing more than an illusion – like red or green or blue are illusions of the underlying reality of oscillating photons?

Thus a small lesion in the midbrain which blocks passage of signals from the ascending reticular activating system to the thalamus and forebrain and ceases consciousness does what to these particles?

Your “physical body” is an algorithm running on top of another algorithm (Your Graviton). Essentially your “physical body” is an interface algorithm – it enhances your ability to communicate (transmit and receive information (energy)). Damage to the subordinate algorithm leaves the primary algorithm (relatively) unaffected.
 
So basically you are making the entire thing up and every time someone points out an inconsistency you rewrite what you believe.

Hmmm … perhaps that is what You are doing? I’m just a figment of your imagination … remember?

But, if I were a real boy, then I would like to think that I would be the type of person who would modify my beliefs when an inconsistency was pointed out in them. Obviously you believe this is a “bad strategy” yourself?

If I’m alive but have no freewill then the entity that caused me to place my hand against the stove has committed an evil act, ATBE.

What entity are you referring too?

If Solipsism is True then don’t You make everybody do everything?

Notice my above quote. I said entity that is controlling not created. Another not so cleverly constructed straw man.

I’m sure we must have had the conversation where you were whining that the reason you sucked at the computer game QUAKE wasn’t actually because You suck, it had more to do with the guy who programmed QUAKE sucking. Obviously the stupid evil idiot who programmed QUAKE undertook that endeavor solely to make you look like an imbecile. Let’s face it … when “God” is a pessimist … everyone is out to get you.

Franko:
Look, maybe you are just nuts? Maybe you like burning your hand? Maybe it feels “good” from your perspective? Similarly some people “like” being pessimist. They like their negativity, they like spreading it around … insane …

Ossai, what would you call a person who sincerely thought they had a “choice” about whether to stop at a red traffic light or not? Suppose there was an individual who believed that for him personally whether he stopped at a red light was entirely his “free will” “choice”?

Likewise some of us have the “free will” to burn our hands on the hot stove over and over again, while others of us lack this … “ability”.

Ossai:
Franko just said that we have freewill! 100 points

Yeah, unfortunately those points aren’t being awarded for intellectual honesty or SKEPTICISM on your part.

Style over substance, take your word for it … You a Mystic!
 
OSSAI, YOU ARE FINISHED.. ITS OVER, I MAY NOW TALK ABOUT SUPERNATURAL 4 GOOD

Ossai said:


muscleman
But you also said that god created them that way. What choice did they have?

and the cause of god’s intelligence is IPUs.

You can’t count very well can you? I’m beginning to wonder if you even managed to pass grade school.

One has nothing to do with the other. By material existence, now that you are echoing Franko, we would be completely controlled by TLOP and there is no existence once the matter that we are composed of has ceased to function, death is the end. Now are you claiming that we have a non-material existence which would mean that some part of us isn’t controlled by TLOP(god) or that we are completely controlled which would negate any sort of afterlife and your precious justice.

Earlier I gave you an example of a supernatural phenomena. I’m still waiting.

Your reading comprehension skills are appalling. Seriously now, did you manage to graduate high school?

neutrino_cannon
Got it in one. :D

Ossai

OSSAI, FIRST OF ALL, YOU SAID THAT IN ORDER FOR ONE TO MAKE "CONTROLL", IT HAS TO BE CONSCIOUS...

YOU OBVIOUSLY ARE INCREDIBLY STUPID FOR MAKING UP YOUR OWN DEFINITON, THE FACT THAT THE WORD "CONTROL" IN THE DICTIONARY DOESNT ONLY APPLY FOR ONE THAT IS CONCSIOUC, BUT FOR MATTERS THAT ARE NON-CONSCIOUS AS WELL (SEE YOUR DICTIONARY..)


THEN YOU MAY SAY THAT A COMPUTER CONTROLLING IS NOT ITS OWN, BUT HUMAN DESIGNED IT, THEREFORE COMPUTER IS CONSCIOUS...

WHAT AN IDIOT. A COMPUTER MAYBE DESIGNED (ACCORDING TO ATHEISTS, BY LIGHTNING, HURRICANE, AND TORNADO BY "LUCK"..) BUT A COMPUTER IS "NOT" CONSCIOUS.. YOU ARE NOT THE LAWS OF PHYSICS, YOU "ARE" A PRODUCT OF THE LAWS OF PHYSICS..

A COMPUTER IS NOT A "HUMAN BEING" WHO IS CONSCIOUS, A COMPUTER IS A PRODUCT OF A HUMAN BEING..

THATS THE FIRST DEBUNKED STATEMENT...

THE SECOND ONE IS, YOU SAID THAT "GOD CREATED MAN TO BE EVIL, THEREFORE HE NEVER HAD A CHOICE BECAUSE HE CANNOT BE GOOD , EVEN IF HE WANTS TO, BUT WILL ALWAYS BE EVIL AS GOD CREATED HIM TO BE EVI. ITS LIKE GHOD MAPPED OUT A ROAD FOR HIM, AND HE JUST FOLLOW THE PATH, AND NOT HAVING THE CHOICE TO DO OTHERWISE.."

FIRST OF ALL. WHO IS THE EVIL MAN? OR THE GOOD MAN? YOU ARE NOT ALL-KNOWING, YOUR NOT GOD, YOUR NOT THE JUDGE, AND YOU DONT KNOW IF I AM EVIL IN THE END OF MY LIFE OR NOT (AS U SAID, AFTER HE IS GOING TO HELL, HE HAVE NO CHOICE TO DO OTHERWISE..).

WELL KNOW, BECAUSE U JUMP INTO CONCLUSION AS FOR SOMEONE BEING "EVIL" ALREADY UP AHEAD OF TIME, THAT HIS LIFE HAS ALREADY BEEN LIVED.. WHAT ABOUT THIS...

I SAY GEORGE WASHINGTON DOESNT HAVE A FREEWILL, BECAUSE HE COULD HAVE CHOSEN TO BE A BOXER, BUT HE OBVIOUSLY IS A PRESIDENT, EVEN IF HE WANTED TO, HE STILL CANT BECAUSE HE OBVIOUSLY IS A PRESIDENT...

FIRST OF ALL, BY YOUR "OWN DEFINITION" OF FREEWILL, IT NEVER EXIST WHETHER GOD IS MENTIONED OR NOT...SO YOU CANNOT SAY FREEWILL/OMNISCIENCE CANNOT CO-EXIST. BECAUSE FREEWILL NEVER EXIST TO BEGIN WITH!!! ACCORDING TO YOUR OWN PERSONAL TRANSLATION........

AND SECONDLY, THE WORD "FREEWILL" DOESNT MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED", BUT IT MEANS "OWN ACCORD".. OWN ACCORD IS MORE LIKELY TO BE TRANSLATED AS "OWN EXISTENCE", AS WE ARE OUR OWN, AND PARENTS ARE SEPARATE ENTITY. OR REMOPTE CONTROLLED CAR IS ITS OWN ACCORD, AND THE HUMAN CONTROLLER IS ITS OWN ENTITY...

THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR HAVE ITS "OWN ACCORD", OWN "FREEWILL" (MAYBE NOT CONSCIOUS FREEWILL, BUT IT IS ITS OWN EXISTENCE)...

THATS WHAT THE WORD FREEWILL MEANS AS DEFINED BY WEBSTERS...

THATS WHY THE OMNISCIENCE/FREEWILL ARGUMENT DOES CO-EXIST (THE CATHOLIC CHURCH STRONGLY DEFENDS THIS...), ITS THE STUPID ATHEISTS THAT MAKES UP THEIR OWN DEFINITION..

IN THE SAME WAY THERE IS NO BIBLE CONTRADICTIONS, ITS THE STUPID IGNORANT ATHEIST WHO MAKES IT CONTRADICTORY WITH THEIR TWISTED THINKING...

NOW IM NOT AGAINST FRANKO, HE IS OK WITH HIS PHILOSOPHY, OBVIOUSLY HE JUST GOT TAKEN AWAY TO HOW ATHEISTS DEFINE "FREEWILL".. HE IS FAR MORE CLOSER TO THE TRUTH THAN ANY OF YOU BRAINWASHED DELUSIONAL KIDS ARE....
 
OSSAI YOUR FINISHED, IM DONE WITH YOU...YOU CAN RAMBLE IF YOU WANT, BUT YOUR DONE....EVEN IF YOU DENY IT, YOUR DONE......


NOW LETS GET BACK TO TALKING ABOUT THE WORD "SUPERNATURAL", THE FINISHING TOUCH OF THE PROOF OF GOD.... :)
 
I SAY GEORGE WASHINGTON DOESNT HAVE A FREEWILL, BECAUSE HE COULD HAVE CHOSEN TO BE A BOXER, BUT HE OBVIOUSLY IS A PRESIDENT, EVEN IF HE WANTED TO, HE STILL CANT BECAUSE HE OBVIOUSLY IS A PRESIDENT...

That's convinced me, I'm gonna sign up. Do I have to apply to the pope?
 
AND TO BE SUPER-FINISHED WITH YOU OSSAI... EARLIER YOU TOLD ME THAT "WE DONT HAVE FREEWILL, BUT ON ONLY "IGNORANCE- OF-FREEWILL"...

OK ONCE AGAIN, THE WORD "FREEWILL MEANS OWN ACCORD.. THE WORD FREEWILL DOESNT MEAN "ALL-KNOWING". IT DOESNT MEAN "PSYCHIC KNOWING THE FUTURE", OR IT DOESNT MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED" (AS WE ARE ALL UNDER THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND/OR GOD (DEPENDS ON YUR BELIEF)...)..

BUT HERE IS THE REAL DEFINITION OF FREEWILL.

free·will ( P ) Pronunciation Key (frwl)
adj.
Done of one's own accord; voluntary.

IT MEANS "OWN ACCORD" BEING DONE IN ONESELF. IT DOESNT MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED""... A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR RUNS AND IS ITS OWN ACCORD, EVEN IF IT IS CONTROLLED BY A HUMAN BEING, WHEN THE CAR RUNS, BEEPS ITS HORN, MAKES NOISES, THE CONTROLLER DOESNT RUN, BEEPS, OR BLOW ITS HORN YOU MORONS!!!

HERE IS A LINK...

IM SO SURE YOU AND YOUR CULTS ARE LIKE THIS CHILDREN HERE.....A MEMBER HERE POSTED IT, MAYBE HE REALIZED YOU GUYS REALLY ARE A CULT....

http://www.tektonics.org/fundyath.html
 
To begin, the actual quote was:

In my reality individual consciousnesses are actually particles in a "more real" Universe (the Omniverse). This Universe is simply an elaboration of the Truer Reality.

which renders this:

[The Omniverse ?]which is not confirmed by current scientific understanding of consciousness. This point has been raised before and, for some reason, ignored.

rather not surprisingly misleading.

The Hound Worried Bigotted Coward et Liar et Hypocrit attempts, again, to avoid his responsibility to provide basis for his proclamations.

He, again, made a statement concerning consciousness.

He, again, tries to avoid providing evidence.

He, again, tries to hide from the Science of Consciousness [Cue Thunderclap.--Ed.].

Why?

Instead of an answer, he tried to alter the direction of the conversation from his FAILURE to provide support.

Yes, I keep asking You (sic) A-Theist (sic) what SPECIFICALLY is the "YOU" that is suppose to be making these "free will" decisions, and for some reason that question keeps being "Ignored" ???

As stated, the tactic Hound Worried Bigotted Coward et Liar et Hypocrit of trying to turn to discussion to a slogan upon his sandwich board is too well-known now to work. As also stated, he attempt to make arguments for others inorder to attack the others through the made-up arguments.

The tactics of a tyro, certainly, but, other than temper-tantrums, it is the only tactics he apparently has.

Nevertheless, he made the assertions.

He must support them.

Now, as also previously stated I remain, despite all appearances, an optimist. Thus, allow me to recognize a subsequent attempt to address the subject:

All I see is chemicals. . . .

Perchance a somewhat more magnified perspective will assist matters. He forgets the structure created by the chemical. However, allow him to continue:

Why should I believe that this "consciousness" you speak (sic) of is nothing more than an illusion. . . .

The individual used the term and made statements concerning it.

Now, if he wishes to consider it all an "illusion" and wander down the freshman-philosophy path of "I-cannot-prove-the-tree-exists-when-I-close-the-door-give-me-another-hit"
then he is free to that waste of time.

Nevertheless, an "illusion" of consciousness exists, and in the case presented here, and before, it does not. This is a rather consistent "illusion." In fact, as with other scientific theories worthy of sodium chloride, one can make successful predictions based upon the anatomy and physiology involved.

However, credit where credit is due, he continues:


MoiThus a small lesion in the midbrain which blocks passage of signals from the ascending reticular activating system to the thalamus and forebrain and ceases consciousness does what to these particles?

Your "physical body" is an algorithm running on top of another algorithm (Your Graviton). Essentially your "physical body" is an interface algorithm ? it enhances your ability to communicate (transmit and receive information (energy)). Damage to the subordinate algorithm leaves the primary algorithm (relatively) unaffected.

Placing a word in quotation marks does not, in and of itself, render it any more or less real. Given his prediliction to argumentum ad hominem, one can understand his faith in the magical nature of words.

Accept, for a moment, his terms; we can consider analogies, even the ridiculous.

He implies that damage to the body--his "subordinate algorithm"--leaves the "primary algorithm"--"Graviton"--intact.

Really.

Unfortunately, in the case described the patient does not recover consciousness though he will usually "progress" to a permanent vegetative state.

Whither then his "Graviton?"

This is not simply an exercise in pinning a person down with his own words. Theories must fit reality. Thus, one can switch off this area, obliterate consciousness, and then switch the person back on.

Thus where did his "Graviton" go?

What difference, then, exists between the first patient who never regains consciousness from the second who have both suffered a relatively small--anatomically writing--lesion?

I understand that I have the individual--and perhaps most of the Readership still awake--at some disadvantage. Quite some time ago, I provided background evidence on the science of consciousness in the apparently vain hope that the individual would explain how his theories fit the reality that contradicted them.

One or two posters thanked me for the information. I must confess I assumed he ignored it.

I am more than willing to provide it again, though, I further confess, I generally only help gentlemen. To behave as such may place an onerous burden upon the individual, but I can assure him that he will benefit from the ordeal.

--J.D.

[Edited for various scribal errors.--Ed.]
 
Could you repeat that one part again? You know, that one part?

I didn't catch it the first 72 times.
 
Franko

Hey I got my 100 points, what more do you want?



Muscleman
A COMPUTER IS NOT A "HUMAN BEING" WHO IS CONSCIOUS, A COMPUTER IS A PRODUCT OF A HUMAN BEING..
Exactly, a computer is just a tool humans use in order to control something.

From Merriam-Webster
Control
1 a archaic : to check, test, or verify by evidence or experiments b : to incorporate suitable controls in <a controlled experiment>
2 a : to exercise restraining or directing influence over : REGULATE b : to have power over : RULE c : to reduce the incidence or severity of especially to innocuous levels
Now what conscious control does the computer have? None. You are misusing the word, just like Franko has been continually misusing obey.

AND SECONDLY, THE WORD "FREEWILL" DOESNT MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED", BUT IT MEANS "OWN ACCORD".. OWN ACCORD IS MORE LIKELY TO BE TRANSLATED AS "OWN EXISTENCE", AS WE ARE OUR OWN, AND PARENTS ARE SEPARATE ENTITY. OR REMOPTE CONTROLLED CAR IS ITS OWN ACCORD, AND THE HUMAN CONTROLLER IS ITS OWN ENTITY...
So I run down the girl scout with a remote controlled car, the police impound the car and I walk away free and clear.

THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR HAVE ITS "OWN ACCORD", OWN "FREEWILL" (MAYBE NOT CONSCIOUS FREEWILL, BUT IT IS ITS OWN EXISTENCE)...

THATS WHAT THE WORD FREEWILL MEANS AS DEFINED BY WEBSTERS...
Not only are your reading comprehension skills substandard but now I’m concerned about your general cognitive abilities as well. Lets change your analogy a bit. Now instead of killing the girl scout with a remote controlled car, I just walk up to her and shoot her. After all the bullet is the one guilty of killing her, not me. Again I walk away free and clear.

THATS WHY THE OMNISCIENCE/FREEWILL ARGUMENT DOES CO-EXIST (THE CATHOLIC CHURCH STRONGLY DEFENDS THIS...), ITS THE STUPID ATHEISTS THAT MAKES UP THEIR OWN DEFINITION..
Shall we post the definition of freewill and omnipotent again?

IN THE SAME WAY THERE IS NO BIBLE CONTRADICTIONS, ITS THE STUPID IGNORANT ATHEIST WHO MAKES IT CONTRADICTORY WITH THEIR TWISTED THINKING...
I’ve got a list of over 300. The only response you gave in the other thread dealing with that subject is to have Jesus’s gay lover step forward and try to defend you.

AND TO BE SUPER-FINISHED WITH YOU OSSAI... EARLIER YOU TOLD ME THAT "WE DONT HAVE FREEWILL, BUT ON ONLY "IGNORANCE- OF-FREEWILL"...
I did not tell you that. I used it to clarify your position. If god is omnipotent and has mapped out the life and afterlife of everyone then we don’t have freewill all we have is ignorance; because how could we go against the will of god?

BUT HERE IS THE REAL DEFINITION OF FREEWILL. … IT MEANS "OWN ACCORD" BEING DONE IN ONESELF. IT DOESNT MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED""... A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR RUNS AND IS ITS OWN ACCORD, EVEN IF IT IS CONTROLLED BY A HUMAN BEING, WHEN THE CAR RUNS, BEEPS ITS HORN, MAKES NOISES, THE CONTROLLER DOESNT RUN, BEEPS, OR BLOW ITS HORN YOU MORONS!!!
Lets just carry this one out a bit further. Now I can kill everyone that annoys me as long as I use a tool to do it, cool. Because the tool, doesn’t matter what tool, is doing it of it’s own accord and I’m not responsible for the deaths.
What level do you operate on? We’ve already ruled out high school. The above rules out 8th grade, so, I’m leaning toward elementary level.

Ossai
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom