Proof of God's existence! 1 million dollar challenge at the end! Randi better pay-up!

Ossai said:


Muscleman
Exactly, a computer is just a tool humans use in order to control something.

From Merriam-Webster
Now what conscious control does the computer have? None. You are misusing the word, just like Franko has been continually misusing obey.

I AM MISUSING THE WORD? FALSELY ACCUSING ME OF WHAT YOUR DOING? YOU ARE THE ONE WHO SAID THAT IN ORDER FOR SOMETHING TO TAKE CONTROL, IT MUST BE CONSCIOUS..

AND YOU DID "NOT" QUOTE THE REST OF THE DEFINITION. IT ALSO DID SAY THAT THE WORD CONTROL CAN ALSO BE USED FOR SOMETHING THAT HAS NO INTELLIGENCE... I POSTED IT ABOVE, I POST IT AGAIN...

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=control

con·trol ( P ) Pronunciation Key (kn-trl)
tr.v. con·trolled, con·trol·ling, con·trols

An instrument or set of instruments used to operate, regulate, or guide a machine or vehicle. Often used in the plural.
A restraining device, measure, or limit; a curb: a control on prices; price controls.

THERE, I POSTED WHAT YOU HAVE SKIPPED, YOU ARE DEBUNKED IN THIS STATEMENT YOU STUPID....

Ossai said:

So I run down the girl scout with a remote controlled car, the police impound the car and I walk away free and clear.

Not only are your reading comprehension skills substandard but now I’m concerned about your general cognitive abilities as well. Lets change your analogy a bit. Now instead of killing the girl scout with a remote controlled car, I just walk up to her and shoot her. After all the bullet is the one guilty of killing her, not me. Again I walk away free and clear.

WHOEVER MENTIONED THAT TO BE OK? THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR WAS USED AS ANALOGY, JUST AS EARLIER I USED THE ANT TO A PERSON AS ANALOGY TO GOD AND THE HUMAN RACE.. I DIDNT MEAN THAT IF U KILLED AN ANT, YOU KILLED A HUMAN BEING YOU MORON...

THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR WAS USED AS ANALOGY TO HUMAN RACE, AND A CONTROLLER TO GOD...

IT WOULD FIT MORE IF YOU USE THE ANALOGY AS A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR HITTING ANOTHER REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR, THEN THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR THAT HIT THE OTHER WAS ALSO DESTROYED FOR THE SAKE OF JUSTICE...

THAT FITS THE ANALOGY BETTER YOU MORON..


WHATS NEXT? ARE YOU GONNA QUOTE MY ANALOGY EARLIER ABOUT ANTS AND SAY " HEY MUSCLEMAN, SO IF I PUT AN ANT ON THE MAZE AND KILL IT, SHOULD I BE ARRESTED AND BE PUT TO PRISON FOR 50 YRS?"

YOU SACK OF SHEEP, THE ANT WAS ANALOGY, AS A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR...



THE FACT HERE IS, IN THE REAL WORLD, WE GIVE JUSTICE TO WHAT WE CAN "DETECT" AS THE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE EFFECT, AND IT MUST BE CONSCIOUS IN OUR WORLD...

EVEN IF GOD WAS PART OF THE WORLD ( LIKE PRESIDENT BUSH) WHAT MADE YOU THINK YOU CAN ARREST GOD WHO CREATED YOU? HE CREATED YOU, AND YOUR WORLD. YOU HAVE NO AUTHORITY OVER HIM MORON.. NEITHER DO YOU HAVE THE POWER...

IT IS LIKE A 4 MONTHS OLD BABY TRYING TO ARREST AND PUNISH A PROFESSIONAL BODY BUILDER. OR A REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR TRYING TO PUNISH THE CONTROLLER, YOU ARE JUST INCAPABLE... (OR AS YOU ATHEISTS WOULD LIKE TO CALL, A BLOB OF TISSUE THINGY ARRESTING AN ADULT, NOT HUMAN...)

BUT IT IS ONLY LOGICAL IN OUR NATURE THAT BOTH THE CONTROLLER, AND THE CONTROLLED PAYS THE PRICE...NOT JUST THE CONTROLLER, THAT IS NOT HOW OUR NATURE WORKS..

IF YOU INSIST THAT WHEN A CAR HITS AGAINST A TREE, BUT YOU WOULD ONLY WANT THE DRIVER TO GET WRECKED, BUT NOT THE CAR, THEN YOU ARE BEING DELUSIONAL LIKE BELETH, DENYING THE LAWS OF NATURE AND PHYSICS.

IF YOU SPEAK ABOUT "RESPONSIBILITY", I AS A THEISTS AM NOT THE ONE WHO BLAIMS THE "CAUSE" INSTEAD OF TAKING RESPONSIBILITY AS A CONSCIOUS BEING...ATHEISTS IN THE OTHER HAND BLAIMS "GOD" BECAUSE HE IS CONTROLLING US, WHY THEN DONT YOU BLAIM THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND NATURE MORONS? BECAUSE IT IS NOT CONSCIOUS? WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE? WHETHER IT IS CONSCIOUS OR NOT, IT IS CONTROLLING US, AND THAT IS THE REASON WHY YOU ARE BLAIMING GOD, NOT BECAUSE HE IS CONSCIOUS...

AND IN OUR WORLD, THE ONE THAT IS CONSCIOUS PAYS RESPONSIBILITY. BUT THE FACT IS, EVEN IF GOD LIVES AMONG US JUST AS PRESIDENT BUSH, WE CAN SEE WITH OUR NAKED EYE THEREFORE WE KNOW FOR A FACT HE IS CONSCIOUS, AGAIN, YOU ATHEISTS ARE BEING A MORON FOR THINKING ABOUT PUNISHING GOD BUT NOT WANTING TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY...

AGAIN IT IS ONLY LOGICAL THAT BOTH THE CONTROLLER, AND CONTROLLED PAY THE PRICE...YOU THINK THIS ISNT FAIR? YOU THINK THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND THE LAWS OF NATURE ISNT FAIR? IF A KID WAS BRAINWASHED INTO KILLING 30 MAN, AND WAS TOLD IT WAS OK, WAS PUT TO PRISON AND HIS BRAINWASHER, DO YOU THINK THIS ISNT FAIR? DO YOU THINK ONLY THE BRAINWASHER SHOULD GO TO PRISON, BUT THE KILLER SHOULD B FREE???

IF SO, WHY DONT U JUST LIVE OUTSIDE OF PLANET EARTH AND GO SOMEWHERE ELSE WHERE THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND THE LAWS OF NATURE WORKS AS YO DESIRE IT TO BE... WHERE YOU ARE THE GOD, AND THE LAWS OF PHYSICS OBEY YOUR ORDERS.....

JESUS DIED FOR YOUR SINS, HE SUFFERED AND WAS CRUCIFIED, AND IN THIS EARTH, DIDNT DESERVE IT, BUT HE DID IT FOR YOU (FOR HE IS ONLY THE SON OF THE FATHER, NOT THE FATHER, AND THE FATHER IS THE GREATEST SOURCE OF THE TRINITY...)

THE ONLY THING YOU FIND CONTRADICTORY IS THAT YOU WANT GOD TO SUFFER MORE THAN HE ALREADY DID, YOU WANT HIM TO ROAST IN HELL FOR ALL ETERNITY....

WELL LET ME TELL YOU SOMETHING IN THE REAL WORLD. WHEN A CAR GETS TOTALLY WRECKED, THE DRIVER ALSO SUFFERS, BUT MAY RECOVER. BUT THE CAR MAYBE WRECKED FOREVER, AND THE DRIVER MAY LOOK FOR ANOTHER CAR INSTEAD SINCE THERE ARE PLENTY OF THEM AROUND...

YOU CANNOT SAY "WELL I WANT THE DRIVER TO BE WRECKED FOREVER WITH THE CAR", BECAUSE THE CAR HAVE NO AUTHORITY OVER THE DRIVER, BUT THE DRIVER HAVE AUTHORITY OVER THE CAR..

WHOS THE BOSS? YOU OR GOD?

ANOTHER THING THAT YOU FIND CONTRADICTORY IS THAT YOU THINK GOD IS MALICIOUS FOR SENDING EVIL MAN TO HELL WHERE THEY BELONG, AND YOU THINK GOD IS EVIL FOR SENDING GOOD PEOPLE TO HEAVEN WHERE THEY BELONG...WHY ARE U DEFENDING THE EVIL MAN? BECAUSE YOU ARE LIKE THEM?

YOU ALSO THOUGHT GOD IS EVIL FOR CREATING EVIL MAN... AND I ALREADY AGREED WITH YOU, GOD IS FULL OF VENGEANCE, BUT YOU ALSO TOOK THAT OUT OF CONTEXT. GOD ALSO CREATED GOOD MAN. AND HE IS ALSO FULL OF MERCY AND LOVE, THAT YOU CAN ASK FOR FORGIVENESS, AND YOU WILL BE FORGIVEN..

SO YOUR RIGHT, GOD IS GOOD AND EVIL..

GOD IS GOOD TO THOSE WHO LOVE HIM, GOD IS EVIL TO THOSE WHO HATE HIM.. AND GOD CREATED THEM BOTH...

YES...GOD CREATED BOTH, LIGHT AND DAY, GOOD AND EVIL, HEAVEN AND HELL...

I SEE NO CONTRADICTION, BECAUSE MY MIND ISNT AS NARROW MINDED AS YOURS.......AND THE REST OF THE BRAINWASHED ATHEISTS CULT...

Ossai said:

Shall we post the definition of freewill and omnipotent again?

OMNSCIENCE= ALL KNOWING..

FREEWILL= DONE IN ONES OWN ACCORD....

GOT IT?

Ossai said:

Lets just carry this one out a bit further. Now I can kill everyone that annoys me as long as I use a tool to do it, cool. Because the tool, doesn’t matter what tool, is doing it of it’s own accord and I’m not responsible for the deaths.
What level do you operate on? We’ve already ruled out high school. The above rules out 8th grade, so, I’m leaning toward elementary level.

Ossai

WHAT A COMPLETE MORON, AGAIN THE REMOTE CONTROLLED CAR WAS ANALOGY, I DIDNT MEAN THAT IT WAS A LITERAL CONSCIOUS HUMAN BEING. BUT IT WAS ANALOG AS A CONSCIOUS HUMAN BEING, AND GOD BEING THE CONTROLLER........STUPID...


YOUR DONE, I AM NOT GONNA RESPOND TO YOUR STUPIDITY ANYMORE, ONLY THE BRAINWASHED CULTS HERE AGREES WITH YOU. THE REST WHO ARE "NORMAL" SHOULD BY NOW SEE THAT THIS ATHEISTIC ARGUMENT IS PURE STUPIDITY.......
 
5 MAIN ARGUMENTS FOR ATHEISM...

Nature as chance= DEBUNKED...
Faith is stupid= DEBUNKED...
Only whats observed exist, we label as "physical"= DEBUNKED...
Omnscience/freewill cannot co-exist= DEBUNKED..

Supernatural dont exist= PENDING...

4 DOWN, AND ONE MORE TO GO.....

NOW ITS TIME TO ANNILATE THE FINAL ARGUMENT FOR ATHEISTS... THIS TOO SHALL BE ANNHILATED TOGETHER WITH THE 4......

AFTER THIS, THERE SHALL BE NOTHING LEFT FOR THE ATHEISTS TO ARGUE, NOTHING.. THERE SHOULD NOW BE NO REASON TO NOT BELIEVE IN GOD..

IF THERE IS ANYMORE "NEW" ARGUMENTS.. I SHALL DEBUNK THAT ALSO, I AWAIT FOR IT CHILDREN....:)
 
muscleman said:
ATHEISTS IN THE OTHER HAND BLAIMS "GOD" BECAUSE HE IS CONTROLLING US, WHY THEN DONT YOU BLAIM THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND NATURE MORONS? BECAUSE IT IS NOT CONSCIOUS? WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE? WHETHER IT IS CONSCIOUS OR NOT, IT IS CONTROLLING US, AND THAT IS THE REASON WHY YOU ARE BLAIMING GOD, NOT BECAUSE HE IS CONSCIOUS...

They hate the idea of being controlled. Thats why "free-will" looks so appealing. Even if TLOP was random, they are still obeying random TLOP.

However, the soft-core athiest isnt all that bad when trying to comprehend being controlled by God. If they reason this view, it's quite reasonable to ask the question "If God controls me, then how can I be responsible for my actions?" It's an aparent contradiction, though ultimately it isnt.

Afterall, it's YOUR MPB that God is running....
 
ANOTHER THING THAT YOU FIND CONTRADICTORY IS THAT YOU THINK GOD IS MALICIOUS FOR SENDING EVIL MAN TO HELL WHERE THEY BELONG, AND YOU THINK GOD IS EVIL FOR SENDING GOOD PEOPLE TO HEAVEN WHERE THEY BELONG...

'God' doesn't do either of these things. He can't, him not existing and all.


;)
 
muscleman said:
I AM MISUSING THE WORD?
Yes you are, muscleman.
AND YOU DID "NOT" QUOTE THE REST OF THE DEFINITION. IT ALSO DID SAY THAT THE WORD CONTROL CAN ALSO BE USED FOR SOMETHING THAT HAS NO INTELLIGENCE... I POSTED IT ABOVE, I POST IT AGAIN...

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=control

con·trol ( P ) Pronunciation Key (kn-trl)
tr.v. con·trolled, con·trol·ling, con·trols

An instrument or set of instruments used to operate, regulate, or guide a machine or vehicle. Often used in the plural.
A restraining device, measure, or limit; a curb: a control on prices; price controls.

THERE, I POSTED WHAT YOU HAVE SKIPPED, YOU ARE DEBUNKED IN THIS STATEMENT YOU STUPID....
Did you notice the term I highlighted? Doesn't it beg the question "used by whom"?

Seems to me something with no intelligence cannot use something that does have intelligence. Unless of course you think my kitchen scissors are going to climb out of the drawer some night and stab me in the chest.

I snipped everything else because he yells too much.
 
Of course, there is such a thing as automations. You can easily create an instrument that controls something. You probably have a thermostat in your home; it controls the heating in order to give you a (more or less) constant room temperature.

Now, if you were a prisoner and was only allowed to have light between, say, 7AM and 9:30PM, a simple clock-driven switch could be connected to the light in your cell. Thus, a non intelligent thing would be controlling you. Of course, this particular thing would have to be created by a conscious being, but others are not. For instance, the rising and setting of the Sun to some degree controls us.

Hans

Edited to add: The kitchen scissors thing is what we call a straw man ;)
 
MRC_Hans said:
Of course, there is such a thing as automations. You can easily create an instrument that controls something. You probably have a thermostat in your home; it controls the heating in order to give you a (more or less) constant room temperature.

Now, if you were a prisoner and was only allowed to have light between, say, 7AM and 9:30PM, a simple clock-driven switch could be connected to the light in your cell. Thus, a non intelligent thing would be controlling you. Of course, this particular thing would have to be created by a conscious being, but others are not. For instance, the rising and setting of the Sun to some degree controls us.

Hans

Edited to add: The kitchen scissors thing is what we call a straw man ;)
Dammit, I was trying not to do that. It was really a stab at humour, heh heh ahem.

Right, the sun. Did the sun make anything? Did it consciously say one day "Let there be man?"

Ah, but that's the basic question isn't it?

My opinion, for what it's worth, is no. We're a chance byproduct of nature and genetics, and I think we're damn lucky to be here in the first place.
 
Then I might have misunderstood you. You said:
Seems to me something with no intelligence cannot use something that does have intelligence.
Of course, what makes me react to that is that this is Franko's argument why TLOP must be a superior consciousness (and since I have established meself as a Franko-basher .... hehehe). But I disagree. An intelligence can be controlled by a lower consciousness or even something unconscious.

I do agree with your last post, except perhaps the luck bit. I think that we might find out that Life is almost inevitable wherever conditions allow. And I also think we may find that life inevitably evolves towards conscious beings.

Cheers, Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Then I might have misunderstood you. You said: Of course, what makes me react to that is that this is Franko's argument why TLOP must be a superior consciousness (and since I have established meself as a Franko-basher .... hehehe). But I disagree. An intelligence can be controlled by a lower consciousness or even something unconscious.

I do agree with your last post, except perhaps the luck bit. I think that we might find out that Life is almost inevitable wherever conditions allow. And I also think we may find that life inevitably evolves towards conscious beings.

Cheers, Hans
Thanks Hans, but might I clarify: I stated "NO intelligence", not lower intelligence. I consider something with no intelligence to have no consciousness.

As for Franko, I await the day he realizes that the laws of physics are manmade, meaning a description, and there is no TLOP god. Sometimes he seems to be getting there, but...well.


I'd also like to add: it's scary sometimes coming in here and posting my views. Thanks for being sweet.
 
Mmm, you're welcome, actually that ought to be the norm, but when you spend so much time around people who seem to be intrinsically obnoxius, you sometime forget your manners and lash out at some hapless bystander. I have done it too, I must confess :(

Hans
 
muscleman said:
5 MAIN ARGUMENTS FOR ATHEISM...

Nature as chance= DEBUNKED...
Faith is stupid= DEBUNKED...
Only whats observed exist, we label as "physical"= DEBUNKED...
Omnscience/freewill cannot co-exist= DEBUNKED..

Supernatural dont exist= PENDING...

4 DOWN, AND ONE MORE TO GO.....

NOW ITS TIME TO ANNILATE THE FINAL ARGUMENT FOR ATHEISTS... THIS TOO SHALL BE ANNHILATED TOGETHER WITH THE 4......

AFTER THIS, THERE SHALL BE NOTHING LEFT FOR THE ATHEISTS TO ARGUE, NOTHING.. THERE SHOULD NOW BE NO REASON TO NOT BELIEVE IN GOD..

IF THERE IS ANYMORE "NEW" ARGUMENTS.. I SHALL DEBUNK THAT ALSO, I AWAIT FOR IT CHILDREN....:)
Lol, I'd love to see you running the Academy awards...
Best actor...Muscleman
Best director...Muscleman
Best Theist in a supporting roll..Muscleman
Best...etc,etc,etc.

Unfortunately writing "debunked" doesn't mean it is true... You actually have to present something of substance...uppercase rants just don't cut it...sorry.

So, having said that I would just like to award myself victory...

And the oscar for the best poster goes to....you guessed it, The Fool.
 
Lets look at a few strawmen:

muscleman said:
5 MAIN ARGUMENTS FOR ATHEISM...

Only those are not the arguments of athests, they are what YOU claim is atheist's arguments = Strawman....

Nature as chance= DEBUNKED...

Atheism does not imply belief in creation through randomness = Strawman...

Faith is stupid= DEBUNKED...

Athism does not imply that faith is stupid (just that it is irrational) = Strawman...

Only whats observed exist, we label as "physical"= DEBUNKED...

Its the other way around: What exists is observable = Strawman....

Omnscience/freewill cannot co-exist= DEBUNKED..

Some may believe that, but its the theists here on this board that make this particular claim. = Strawman....

Supernatural dont exist= PENDING...

No, it's "there is no evidence for the supernatural" = Strawman...

4 DOWN, AND ONE MORE TO GO.....

NOW ITS TIME TO ANNILATE THE FINAL ARGUMENT FOR ATHEISTS... THIS TOO SHALL BE ANNHILATED TOGETHER WITH THE 4......

AFTER THIS, THERE SHALL BE NOTHING LEFT FOR THE ATHEISTS TO ARGUE, NOTHING.. THERE SHOULD NOW BE NO REASON TO NOT BELIEVE IN GOD..

At least we'll probably stop believing in strawmen :rolleyes:

IF THERE IS ANYMORE "NEW" ARGUMENTS.. I SHALL DEBUNK THAT ALSO, I AWAIT FOR IT CHILDREN....:)

Well, it that is going to be in your usual way, you'd better hope for some children, 'cause you are not gonna make much impression on adults ;)

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
An intelligence can be controlled by a lower consciousness or even something unconscious.

...and your prisoner example supports this view?
Explain how....
 
wraith said:


...and your prisoner example supports this view?
Explain how....
Which part do you not understand?

Plenty of other examples have been given. We can take the now-classical car example: You control your car, but if you drive too fast on a slippery road, you may loose control, in which case the car effectively controls you.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
Which part do you not understand?

Plenty of other examples have been given. We can take the now-classical car example: You control your car, but if you drive too fast on a slippery road, you may loose control, in which case the car effectively controls you.

Hans
Sorry Hans, I must disagree.

Whatever happens to the car, it's the person driving who controls it. So if there's an accident, it's not the car coming alive and steering, it's you making a mistake.
 
Buki, that seems to be the moral implication you are talking about. If you loose control of your car, you are culpable for not driving carefully enough. Of course.

However, quite mechanically, once you are in that sideways skid, you are totally in the mercy of outside, non conscious forces. My point is exactly that the car does NOT come alive, but that you are being controlled by something unconscious.

Lets use a different example: Take to the sea in a small sail-boat, no engine no oars. Provided you know how to sail, you can sail it around the world: You are in control. (there might be a food and water problem, but thats another story, heheh)

Now, suppose the mast breaks. You are now being controlled by the (unconscious) wind and current.

Hans
 
buki said:
Sorry Hans, I must disagree.

Whatever happens to the car, it's the person driving who controls it. So if there's an accident, it's not the car coming alive and steering, it's you making a mistake.

The thing that makes me laugh is how the "everything must be controlled by a superior conciousness" rule suddenly disappears when we get to Franko's imaginary friend...What superior conciousness controls his god? Suddenly the rule vanishes....why could the rule simply not vanish at the human level? It would save having to manufacture an infinite number of gods all supervising the one below...

Franko says this is an arrogant attitude and means I am proclaiming myself god....hmmmm, well, would you rather be arrogant or have a toadying complex? Desperately manufacturing things to worship.
 
The Fool said:


The thing that makes me laugh is how the "everything must be controlled by a superior conciousness" rule suddenly disappears when we get to Franko's imaginary friend...What superior conciousness controls his god? Suddenly the rule vanishes....why could the rule simply not vanish at the human level? It would save having to manufacture an infinite number of gods all supervising the one below...

Franko says this is an arrogant attitude and means I am proclaiming myself god....hmmmm, well, would you rather be arrogant or have a toadying complex? Desperately manufacturing things to worship.
What interests me is that he seems to think that the laws of physics are a real, conscious being. Every time he posts "TLOP CONTROLS YOU, CONTROLS ETC", I sit back and boggle.
 
MRC_Hans said:
You control your car, but if you drive too fast on a slippery road, you may loose control, in which case the car effectively controls you.

So if someone asked you "how did you crash your car?"
Your reply will be along the lines of "the car made me do it"
:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom