Yet nowhere have you ever addressed the reasons why some of us have concerns... namely the lack of integrity of the majority of Supreme court justices combined with their willingness to rule against LGBTQ rights in other cases.
I do not accept your premise that ruling against TQ rights means they will likely rule against LGB rights; we are trying to predict the behavior of conservatives but those letters were concatenated together by progressives.
First of all, there is a significant amount of overlap between those opposing gay rights and those opposing trans rights. The fact that they are focusing more on Trans than Gays at the moment is probably because they are an easier target.
Secondly, while some recent supreme LGBTQ court rulings have been about trans rights, not all of them have. For example 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis was about same sex marriage, and conservatives ruled on it 6-3
The fact that you think "a bunch of extremely corrupt judges ruled against various LGBTQ rights before, but they won't cross THIS particular threshold" is not exactly very reassuring.
I would appreciate it greatly if you would avoid falsely attributing quotations.
Anyone who has read my post and the context would recognize that it is a summary of your position, not a direct quote.
You would have to be pretty gulliable/naive to think it was a direct post. Most of us are not that foolish. Don't project your own failings on other people.
pointing out how Dobbs was decided (by referring to a guy who prosecuted women for witchcraft) says absolutely nothing about my opinion of Roe.
You will not find any mention of witchcraft in the reasoning of either case, this is a pile of
smoked herring.
While they did not mention witchcraft in the Dobbs decision, it is still useful to point to Hale and his "reputation" for a number of reasons:
- It shows how far back into history/law that Alito had to go in order to find justification for turning women into second class citizens. What next, point to the laws of Hammarabi?
- It illustrates his mindset. If he is gong to prosecute women for witchcraft, just how backwards was his thinking? (Another poster pointed to a reference that suggested that even for his time, he was a pretty sexist individual.)
When you have such broad support. it suggests that there is some pretty solid reasoning behind the decision...
No, it does not. This is textbook bandwagon fallacy.
Seriously? THAT is your argument? Wow, that is just... wow.
First of all, this is not some mob of uneducated hicks, or people dealing with minimal information. These are supreme court justices. A very small group of people who have spent years dealing with the law (both in academics, and in the courtroom). They get days to hear oral arguments, hundreds/thousands of pages of supporting briefs, and weeks/months to make a ruling. This is not the type of situation that lends itself to people "jumping on the bandwagon".
Secondly, if you really think supreme court justices are prone to "bandwagon jumping" then why so many 6-3 rulings? Why didn't Kaggan or Sotamayer "jump on the bandwagon" to join Justice Pubic Hair, Drunky McRapeface and the stepford wife on the Dobbs decision? Why didn't they join the majority when they ruled that discrimination against same sex marriage is A-Ok? Or is it only republican-nominated judges that are prone to "bandwagon jumping".
It is telling that people here are unwilling to closely consider the reasoning of Roe or Dobbs, but would prefer to channel discussion to the character defects of someone who has been safely buried for several generations. It speaks to a preference for circumstantial ad hominem over anything resembling judicial reasoning.
What makes you think we haven't considered the reasoning between Roe or Dobbs?
The fact is, probably few of us if any have a legal background. I can point to the reasoning behind Roe (the right to privacy, partly from the 14th amendment), and I trust the judgement of the original judges who made the ruling (since they tended to have bipartisan support during their confirmations.) Naming individual precedence cases is outside my wheelhouse. However, I CAN easily point to the corruption of various supreme court members. I CAN point to recent LGBTQ rulings.