Pride Month 2025

...its irrelevant at this point since he has already gotten Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife on the supreme court, and they can rule as they please.
What is your best evidence that these two justices are hoping to overturn Obergefell and the Respect for Marriage Act?

Someone upthread made a persuasive argument that Alito and Thomas would do so, but I haven't really seen anything on Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett.
 
What is your best evidence that these two justices are hoping to overturn Obergefell and the Respect for Marriage Act?

Someone upthread made a persuasive argument that Alito and Thomas would do so, but I haven't really seen anything on Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett.

“What is your best evidence that the fascists will continue to do fascism?” asks Serious Thinker who is unaffected by the fascism and therefore can blithely ignore it.
 
If Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett could be relied upon to promote fascist ideology, they would have provided the third and fourth votes to grant certiorari in Davis v. Ermold.
 
If Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett could be relied upon to promote fascist ideology, they would have provided the third and fourth votes to grant certiorari in Davis v. Ermold.
There were no first or second votes either. Certiorari was denied without any recorded votes of dissent.

Justice Clarence Thomas composed a statement concerning that denial of certiorari, in which he was joined by Justice Samuel Alito. That statement ends with a paragraph in which Thomas and Alito say they "concur in the denial of certiorari."
 
If Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett could be relied upon to promote fascist ideology, they would have provided the third and fourth votes to grant certiorari in Davis v. Ermold.
Ummm, no.

The Davis v. Ermold case was probably seen as extremely weak. The fact that the supreme court did not hear the arguments or rule on the arguments does not mean that if another case that addresses the issue of gay marriage comes along (one that has more merit) that Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife won't jump on the "gay marriage is bad" bandwagon.
 
If Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett could be relied upon to promote fascist ideology, they would have provided the third and fourth votes to grant certiorari in Davis v. Ermold.

Yes, because fascism is either pursued consistently or not at all. Airtight logic.

Tell us more about how rules and norms will keep us safe from the people who defy rules and norms.
 
What is your best evidence that these two justices...
Keep in mind that I am not just suspicious that Kavenaugh and Barret (a.k.a. Drunky Mcrapeface and the stepford wife) will overturn gay marriage. I have the same concerns about ALL the conservative justices. (I just don't have unique nicknames for them.)
...are hoping to overturn Obergefell and the Respect for Marriage Act?
Seriously? I've already given my reasoning.

- A lack of integrity. During their confirmation hearings they said abortion was "settled law", but they overturned it. They had no interest in preserving 'Stare decisis' (and abortion had been legal a lot longer than gay marriage), no qualms about lying to congress about their true intentions. When you engage in that type of behavior, do not be surprised if people are suspicious of ALL your activities

- As I have pointed out before, they regularly rule against LGBTQ rights. Not ALL Their rulings have been anti-LGBTQ, but I cited 2 cases (there have been others) where yes, they have treated LGBTQ people as secondary citizens.
 
That statement ends with a paragraph in which Thomas and Alito say they "concur in the denial of certiorari."
Fair enough, and thank you for the correction. Eight justices had the chance to join Thomas in saying that there remain "important questions about the scope of our decision in Obergefell" and that it was a bad idea to "privilege a novel constitutional right over the religious liberty interests explicitly protected in the First Amendment." Only one did, but several people here are afraid that the others are secretly hoping to overturn gay marriage despite refusing to say so when given the opportunity.
During their confirmation hearings they said abortion was "settled law", but they overturned it.
Every justice since Bork made affirmative noises about stare decisis and settled law during the confirmation process and then went on to help overturn court precedents both major and minor. Don't act like this is unique to conservatives.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fair enough, and thank you for the correction. Eight justices had the chance to join Thomas in saying that there remain "important questions about the scope of our decision in Obergefell" and that it was a bad idea to "privilege a novel constitutional right over the religious liberty interests explicitly protected in the First Amendment." Only one did, but several people here are afraid that the others are secretly hoping to overturn gay marriage despite refusing to say so when given the opportunity.

Yes, this is a good point. One hallmark of fascism throughout history is that they never hide their true intentions and are always completely transparent in everything they do. Well argued.

Every justice since Bork made affirmative noises about stare decisis and settled law during the confirmation process and then went on to help overturn court precedents both major and minor. Don't act like this is unique to conservatives.

I see the pivot from “It’s not going to happen” to “If it does happen, it is within accepted norms” has begun.
 
First we're told we're not allowed to accept our orientation, then we're told we're not allowed to have pride, then we're told we're not allowed to worry. I do so love it when people tell me what I'm allowed to feel about things! Isn't that what Pride Month is all about? Gay people being ordered to shut up about their concerns?
 
Yeah...but he's got a profile pic of him at Pride rally. Isn't that enough to show that he truly has the best interest of the LGBTQ+ community at heart?

No one is arguing that justices don't change their minds on a ruling after getting appointed to the SCOTUS. It does happen, but Amy and Brett both made it very clear that they had no intention of doing so and it was a blatant lie. Would I like to believe that the SCOTUS would leave Obergefell alone? Sure. Has Congress put forth effort to help reinforce it so that it can't be overturned so easily? Sure. Am I positive it won't get overturned? Hell no, not with this SCOTUS. Since Trump's first term they've arguably made some of the worst rulings we've seen this century.
 
Every justice since Bork made affirmative noises about stare decisis and settled law during the confirmation process and then went on to help overturn court precedents both major and minor. Don't act like this is unique to conservatives.
First of all, as another poster pointed out, it seems you have gone from "it will never happen" to "if it happens its OK" in your reasoning. Does that mean that you are now acknowledging that yes, we should have concerns that they will overturn same-sex marriage?

Secondly, it is true that decisions do get overturned. But generally:

- If it happens, it generally involves IMPROVING human rights. (For example, segregation allowed in Plessy v Ferguson was overturned by Brown v. Board of Education.) Reversing human rights (taking away a right that was previously given) seems like a huge step backwards and runs counter to other significant reversals.

- If you are going to reverse a major decision, you need some pretty solid reasoning to do so. As I pointed out before, the supreme court ruling that reversed Roe v. Wade involved the legal work done by a guy who once prosecuted women for witchcraft. If you have to go back that far and pick a questionable source, people might be suspicious that your ruling was done with a pre-determined outcome in mind and you were just trying to find ANYTHING to defend your position.
 
First of all, as another poster pointed out, it seems you have gone from "it will never happen" to "if it happens its OK" in your reasoning.
No, I'm still highly skeptical of those predicting same-sex marriage will join abortion on the (very) short list of civil rights granted and then pulled away by the high court.
Reversing human rights (taking away a right that was previously given) seems like a huge step backwards and runs counter to other significant reversals.
I can only think of maybe three times this has happened, but I might be spacing out.
As I pointed out before, the supreme court ruling that reversed Roe v. Wade involved the legal work done by a guy who once prosecuted women for witchcraft.
It boggles my mind that you believe this tells us anything about whether Roe was well reasoned in the first place.
 
Last edited:
No, I'm still highly skeptical of those predicting same-sex marriage will join abortion on the (very) short list of civil rights granted and then pulled away by the high court.
I hope you're right.

As I pointed out before, the supreme court ruling that reversed Roe v. Wade involved the legal work done by a guy who once prosecuted women for witchcraft.
It boggles my mind that you believe this tells us anything about whether Roe was well reasoned in the first place.
It certainly says a great deal about how well Dobbs was reasoned.

Edited to add this link to the Dobbs decision, which can be searched for its fifteen references to Sir Matthew Hale and his opinions.
 
Last edited:
First of all, as another poster pointed out, it seems you have gone from "it will never happen" to "if it happens its OK" in your reasoning.
No, I'm still highly skeptical...
Yet nowhere have you ever addressed the reasons why some of us have concerns... namely the lack of integrity of the majority of Supreme court justices combined with their willingness to rule against LGBTQ rights in other cases.

The fact that you think "a bunch of extremely corrupt judges ruled against various LGBTQ rights before, but they won't cross THIS particular threshold" is not exactly very reassuring.
...of those predicting same-sex marriage will join abortion on the (very) short list of civil rights granted and then pulled away by the high court.
Ummm...yes, civil rights tend not to be pulled away. That was my original point. The trend is the opposite... the courts tend to expand civil rights. Which is why we are concerned. the current court was willing to do something very rare... took away reproductive rights for women.
As I pointed out before, the supreme court ruling that reversed Roe v. Wade involved the legal work done by a guy who once prosecuted women for witchcraft.
It boggles my mind that you believe this tells us anything about whether Roe was well reasoned in the first place.
First of all, interesting tactic... me pointing out how Dobbs was decided (by referring to a guy who prosecuted women for witchcraft) says absolutely nothing about my opinion of Roe. Not sure how you make that massive leap in reasoning.

Secondly, lets look at Roe... It was decided largely on the issue of privacy (which is assumed to be an implied right.) Most importantly, the Roe v. Wade ruling was a 7-2 decision, with multiple judges (nominated by both democrats AND republican presidents) agreeing with the right to abortion. When you have such broad support. it suggests that there is some pretty solid reasoning behind the decision, and that it wasn't just some "activist judges pushing a left-wing agenda".

Compare that to the Dobbs decision... ONLY republican nominated judges ruled against abortion rights. Of those, 3 of those were nominated by a racist con-artist, all of which lied during confirmation. The other two have significant ethical problems (justice pubic hair accepting gifts like a motorhome from a man that he has ruled on cases involving, the other accepted luxury vacations from wealthy benefactors.) The lack of bi-partisan acceptance of the Dobbs decision suggests the ruling was made more along political lines rather than legal.
 
Yet nowhere have you ever addressed the reasons why some of us have concerns... namely the lack of integrity of the majority of Supreme court justices combined with their willingness to rule against LGBTQ rights in other cases.
I do not accept your premise that ruling against TQ rights means they will likely rule against LGB rights; we are trying to predict the behavior of conservatives but those letters were concatenated together by progressives.
The fact that you think "a bunch of extremely corrupt judges ruled against various LGBTQ rights before, but they won't cross THIS particular threshold" is not exactly very reassuring.
I would appreciate it greatly if you would avoid falsely attributing quotations.
pointing out how Dobbs was decided (by referring to a guy who prosecuted women for witchcraft) says absolutely nothing about my opinion of Roe.
You will not find any mention of witchcraft in the reasoning of either case, this is a pile of smoked herring.
When you have such broad support. it suggests that there is some pretty solid reasoning behind the decision...
No, it does not. This is textbook bandwagon fallacy.
 
Last edited:
It certainly says a great deal about how well Dobbs was reasoned.
No. Modern justices regularly quote various legal propositions from long-dead jurists who had all kinds of awful ideas which have been rejected since the Civil War. In doing so, they do not incorporate all of the views of those jurists, only the specific ones which they are citing.

It is telling that people here are unwilling to closely consider the reasoning of Roe or Dobbs, but would prefer to channel discussion to the character defects of someone who has been safely buried for several generations. It speaks to a preference for circumstantial ad hominem over anything resembling judicial reasoning.
 
Last edited:
It is telling that people here are unwilling to closely consider the reasoning of Roe or Dobbs, but would prefer to channel discussion to the character defects of someone who has been safely buried for several generations. It speaks to a preference for circumstantial ad hominem over anything resembling judicial reasoning.

You haven't provided any judicial reasoning to speak to. So far all you've really said is, "I don't think they'll overturn it because" then you've gone on to explain why everyone else isn't presenting compelling reasons to support their argument.

In fact, the bulk of your argument boils down to quoting a poster and saying, "nuh uh". I've seen a handful of well crafted posts that have explained why this SCOTUS could overturn gay marriage with absolutely nothing of substance from you in rebuttal.

It is telling that you're specifically pointed out the, as you said, "TQ" part. I think we're getting closer to what your actual gripe is, but I'll wait until I can pull out my standard, "Take it to the ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ thread". You're heading straight for it so it should just be a matter of time.
 
Yet nowhere have you ever addressed the reasons why some of us have concerns... namely the lack of integrity of the majority of Supreme court justices combined with their willingness to rule against LGBTQ rights in other cases.
I do not accept your premise that ruling against TQ rights means they will likely rule against LGB rights; we are trying to predict the behavior of conservatives but those letters were concatenated together by progressives.
First of all, there is a significant amount of overlap between those opposing gay rights and those opposing trans rights. The fact that they are focusing more on Trans than Gays at the moment is probably because they are an easier target.

Secondly, while some recent supreme LGBTQ court rulings have been about trans rights, not all of them have. For example 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis was about same sex marriage, and conservatives ruled on it 6-3

The fact that you think "a bunch of extremely corrupt judges ruled against various LGBTQ rights before, but they won't cross THIS particular threshold" is not exactly very reassuring.
I would appreciate it greatly if you would avoid falsely attributing quotations.
Anyone who has read my post and the context would recognize that it is a summary of your position, not a direct quote.

You would have to be pretty gulliable/naive to think it was a direct post. Most of us are not that foolish. Don't project your own failings on other people.
pointing out how Dobbs was decided (by referring to a guy who prosecuted women for witchcraft) says absolutely nothing about my opinion of Roe.
You will not find any mention of witchcraft in the reasoning of either case, this is a pile of smoked herring.
While they did not mention witchcraft in the Dobbs decision, it is still useful to point to Hale and his "reputation" for a number of reasons:
- It shows how far back into history/law that Alito had to go in order to find justification for turning women into second class citizens. What next, point to the laws of Hammarabi?
- It illustrates his mindset. If he is gong to prosecute women for witchcraft, just how backwards was his thinking? (Another poster pointed to a reference that suggested that even for his time, he was a pretty sexist individual.)

When you have such broad support. it suggests that there is some pretty solid reasoning behind the decision...
No, it does not. This is textbook bandwagon fallacy.
Seriously? THAT is your argument? Wow, that is just... wow.

First of all, this is not some mob of uneducated hicks, or people dealing with minimal information. These are supreme court justices. A very small group of people who have spent years dealing with the law (both in academics, and in the courtroom). They get days to hear oral arguments, hundreds/thousands of pages of supporting briefs, and weeks/months to make a ruling. This is not the type of situation that lends itself to people "jumping on the bandwagon".

Secondly, if you really think supreme court justices are prone to "bandwagon jumping" then why so many 6-3 rulings? Why didn't Kaggan or Sotamayer "jump on the bandwagon" to join Justice Pubic Hair, Drunky McRapeface and the stepford wife on the Dobbs decision? Why didn't they join the majority when they ruled that discrimination against same sex marriage is A-Ok? Or is it only republican-nominated judges that are prone to "bandwagon jumping".

It is telling that people here are unwilling to closely consider the reasoning of Roe or Dobbs, but would prefer to channel discussion to the character defects of someone who has been safely buried for several generations. It speaks to a preference for circumstantial ad hominem over anything resembling judicial reasoning.
What makes you think we haven't considered the reasoning between Roe or Dobbs?

The fact is, probably few of us if any have a legal background. I can point to the reasoning behind Roe (the right to privacy, partly from the 14th amendment), and I trust the judgement of the original judges who made the ruling (since they tended to have bipartisan support during their confirmations.) Naming individual precedence cases is outside my wheelhouse. However, I CAN easily point to the corruption of various supreme court members. I CAN point to recent LGBTQ rulings.
 
So far all you've really said is, "I don't think they'll overturn it because"
I made no predictions about whether SCOTUS will overturn Obergefell, only expressed skepticism at those who have done so.
I've seen a handful of well crafted posts that have explained why this SCOTUS could overturn gay marriage with absolutely nothing of substance from you in rebuttal.
You've seen mostly personal attacks about the character of the justices and those whom they have quoted, rather than any arguments based on the logic of the cases themselves.
It is telling that you're specifically pointed out the, as you said, "TQ" part.
Someone else made the leap from one set of cases to another set of cases, I merely pointed out how far they jumped.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom