Pride Month 2025

First of all, there is a significant amount of overlap between those opposing gay rights and those opposing trans rights.
It looks to me like you are confusing overlap in the set of people involved with overlap in the set of ideas to be considered.
303 Creative LLC v. Elenis was about same sex marriage, and conservatives ruled on it 6-3
The recognition of same-sex marriage by the states was not implicated in that case. Procedural shenanigans aside, it is arguable whether same-sex marriage (and opposite sex marriage, come to think of it) would be endangered in the event that we fail to legally compel artists and creative enterprises to create content in support of those unions. That said, this is at least responsive to the OP so I shouldn't fail to give you credit on that score.
What makes you think we haven't considered the reasoning between Roe or Dobbs?
The fact that you keep talking about the justices rather than what they wrote.
 
Last edited:
All highlighting below is mine.

No. Modern justices regularly quote various legal propositions from long-dead jurists who had all kinds of awful ideas which have been rejected since the Civil War. In doing so, they do not incorporate all of the views of those jurists, only the specific ones which they are citing.

It is telling that people here are unwilling to closely consider the reasoning of Roe or Dobbs, but would prefer to channel discussion to the character defects of someone who has been safely buried for several generations. It speaks to a preference for circumstantial ad hominem over anything resembling judicial reasoning .
Sir Matthew Hale was "safely buried" in 1676. If I were a math guy, I could figure out that he died a full century before the Declaration of Independence was signed. If I were at all concerned with what US law had to say about cases such as Roe or Dobbs, I would be a fool to argue that Hale's opinions are precedents the SCOTUS is bound to follow, or that the legal status of abortion in England, in 1676, is binding upon the nation that broke with England a full century later and quickly began to develop a system of constitutional and other law that departed quite deliberately from the English reliance upon common law.

But Justice Samuel Alito is that kind of fool. He repeatedly cited Hale's 17th century opinions of England's common law as though they were binding upon a nation an ocean away, founded a full century later, facing the circumstances of a world three and a half centuries later, under a legal system that was designed not to maintain but to replace Hale's English system of common law.

Quotations in the spoiler. (Citations mostly omitted. My editorial comments are indented, in parentheses, in blue italics.)

...but the great common-law authorities—Bracton, Coke, Hale, and Blackstone—all wrote that a post-quickening abortion was a crime.

The “eminent common-law authorities (Blackstone, Coke, Hale, and the like),” Kahler v. Kansas, 589 U. S. ___, ___ (2020) (slip op., at 7), all describe abortion after quickening as criminal.
​
(Kahler v. Kansas had nothing to do with abortion. Justice Kagan cited those antique common-law authorities in the course of arguing that Kansas had done nothing more than modify the very old idea of an insanity defense. Justices Breyer, Ginsberg, and Sotomayor dissented, saying Kansas had gone too far. Thus the only purpose of the quotation immediately above is to establish that SCOTUS had previously described Hale "and the like" as "eminent common-law authorities" of long ago.)​

Two treatises by Sir Matthew Hale likewise described abortion of a quick child who died in the womb as a “great crime” and a “great misprision.”

(Hale's use of the word "misprision" reminds us he was writing long ago. The majority opinion had to explain that word in its preceding sentence. The sentence that follows the sentence quoted above does not even cite Hale directly, citing instead a secondary source written 60 years following Hale's death.)​

Hale and Blackstone explained a way in which a pre-quickening abortion could rise to the level of a homicide.

(This involved some contortions because, as the Dobbs opinion goes on to explain, you couldn't have a murder without “malice aforethought, . . . either express or implied.” It took some effort for those distinguished 17th century jurists just to come up with "implied".)​

Hale wrote that if a physician gave a woman “with child” a “potion” to cause an abortion, and the woman died, it was “murder” because the potion was given “unlawfully to destroy her child within her.”

(The word "unlawfully" was italicized by Alito. Which undercut his reasoning. For that reasoning to be relevant at the time of the Dobbs decision, abortion would have to have been unlawful in the US, at the time of the Dobbs decision. Which it wasn't. Alito goes on to quote Blackstone's speculative reasoning for why it would have been unlawful in the 17th century; if it had been plainly unlawful even in the 17th century, Blackstone wouldn't have had to tie himself in knots.)​

Notably, Blackstone, like Hale, did not state that this proto-felony-murder rule required that the woman be “with quick child”—only that she be “with child.”

(So Alito is trying to suggest that, to Hale and Blackstone, it didn't matter whether the child had been perceived to move within the womb. If so, I'd have to wonder whether they would have considered all manner of modern contraceptive methods to be murder as well. But Hale and Blackstone didn't actually say that. We are reading Alito's personal opinion, phrased to mislead readers into thinking Alito's opinion was backed by the authority of Hale and Blackstone.)​

And it is revealing that Hale and Blackstone treated abortionists differently from other physicians or surgeons who caused the death of a patient “without any intent of doing [the patient] any bodily hurt.”

(That claim is, as they say, conclusory. Two sentences later, Alito reveals that the sentence quoted above relies upon his very own personal opinion that an abortion would have been unlawful both then (17th century) and now (2022).)​

These other physicians—even if “unlicensed”—would not be “guilty of murder or manslaughter.” Hale 429. But a physician performing an abortion would, precisely because his aim was an “unlawful” one

(Alito then admits that "common-law authorities differed on the severity of punishment for abortions", but "none endorsed the practice." Although Alito and his fellow right-wingers like to characterize their pro-choice opponents as pro-abortion, hardly anyone actually endorses abortion as a positive good, even today. In that respect, Alito is failing to identify a real difference between his 17th century authorities and modern pro-choice opinions.​
​
Alito then turns to an early American edition of Blackstone's 18th century Commentaries, along with several other late 18th century quotations of such. Recognizing, perhaps, that quoting an Englishman's opinion of British common law is not a legal precedent for 21st century American jurisprudence, Alito cites a Maryland case. A case decided in 1652.)​

But as we have seen, great common-law authorities like Bracton, Coke, Hale, and Blackstone all wrote that a post quickening abortion was a crime—and a serious one at that. Moreover, Hale and Blackstone (and many other authorities following them) asserted that even a pre-quickening abortion was “unlawful” and that, as a result, an abortionist was guilty of murder if the woman died from the attempt.

(Here Alito is repeating his questionable conclusions in the hope readers will accept them as authoritative. Note, however, that even Alito concedes that his favorite 17th and 18th century English authorities would not have counted abortion as murder unless the woman dies from the procedure.​
​
And that's it, folks. I believe I have quoted at least a few words from every one of Alito's references to Sir Matthew Hale's 17th century opinions.)​


You've seen mostly personal attacks about the character of the justices and those whom they have quoted, rather than any arguments based on the logic of the cases themselves .
In what I wrote above, and in the spoiler, I believe I have addressed the "logic" of the majority opinion in Dobbs, without attacking the character of any justices. I have, however, expressed some opinions concerning the "logic" of one Justice Alito.

The fact that you keep talking about the justices rather than what they wrote .
You cannot deny that the spoiler addresses what the Dobbs majority wrote or signed onto.
 
The recognition of same-sex marriage by the states was not implicated in that case. Procedural shenanigans aside, it is arguable whether same-sex marriage (and opposite sex marriage, come to think of it) would be endangered in the event that we fail to legally compel artists and creative enterprises to create content in support of those unions. That said, this is at least responsive to the OP so I shouldn't fail to give you credit on that score.
The fact that you keep talking about the justices rather than what they wrote.
It should also apply to race and religion then, don't support black people? you don't have to do business with them.
 
I made no predictions about whether SCOTUS will overturn Obergefell, only expressed skepticism at those who have done so.

Right, which is the same difference but whatever. You've received detailed reasons why those who disagree think SCOTUS absolutely can and will. Justice Clarence Thomas has already changed his mind on a ruling he made about 15 years ago. Be skeptical all you want but those who aren't in agreement are no more right or wrong than you are. You have no more evidence than those who oppose you do, and arguably those who oppose you have more evidence because of the history of the justices on the court. They've lied to get confirmed, they've overturned established law, they've extended POTUS's authority and legal umbrella, and they've certainly shown disdain for the law.

Do you have any patterns of behavior or evidence to support what you're saying? No, not really. Some flippant comments by the justices, but other than that, as I said, you're really just saying, "no they won't because". Nothing more.
You've seen mostly personal attacks about the character of the justices and those whom they have quoted, rather than any arguments based on the logic of the cases themselves.

Those personal attacks about their character are known in the industry as pointing out character flaws. It's supporting evidence for who the people are and the way they've acted in the past. That past generally dictates how they'll act in the future.

Now I generally agree with you that same sex marriage won't be overturned, but I don't hold that belief because of who the SCOTUS justices are by any means. Those miserable ◊◊◊◊◊ would overturn Obergefell in a heartbeat given the chance. I think the only reason they won't overturn it now is because of the Respect for Marriage Act, which is actual law and even then I'm not 100%. The SCOTUS has done crazier things in its time.
Someone else made the leap from one set of cases to another set of cases, I merely pointed out how far they jumped.

Sure, sure.
 
You've received detailed reasons why those who disagree think SCOTUS absolutely can and will.
Not particularly persuasive reasons, from where I'm sitting. The argument that conservatives must see LGBTQ as a single bloc which have to be attacked or defended as a coalition strikes me as particularly silly, given that conservative cultural identity is formed in opposition to progressive ideas such as intersectionality. The idea that three conservative justices are cleverly biding their time rather than openly concurring with Alito and Thomas was also a bit daft, given that there is not particular need for long-term strategic subtlety if they already have five votes.
You have no more evidence than those who oppose you do...
I do not need to marshal evidence, since I am not the person making a prediction about what will happen.
Some flippant comments by the justices, but other than that, as I said, you're really just saying, "no they won't because".
Again with the strawman put in quote marks. o_O
Those miserable ◊◊◊◊◊ would overturn Obergefell in a heartbeat given the chance.
Unless you have some text, this is just mindreading.
 
Last edited:
I do support the right of Catholic priests to refuse to officiate Protestant weddings, but this isn't exactly the time and place for that discussion.
And the creative types need to be able to refuse as well. Baker hates cathlics they can refuse to deal with them. Hate blacks the same. Own up that you want to end antidiscrimnination laws. Photographers who don't want to shouldn't have to photograph black people.
 
Not particularly persuasive reasons, from where I'm sitting.

Cool, neither is your "they won't overturn it, trust me bro" line of arguing either. Just so you don't bitch about it, that wasn't a quote, it was a summary of your argument. I put it in quotations rather than a quote box so that people wouldn't confuse it for an actual quote from me and I put context clues around it to help people see where it was coming from. Apparently you're having a hard time realizing when people do that so I figured I'd lay it bare for you.
The argument that conservatives must see LGBTQ as a single bloc which have to be attacked or defended as a coalition strikes me as particularly silly,

Overturning Roe vs. Wade didn't strike you as particularly silly? That was conservatives seeing women as a single bloc that had to have their reproductive rights attacked.
given that conservative cultural identity is formed in opposition to progressive ideas such as intersectionality.

I'm going to blow your mind, conservatives often hold conflicting viewpoints. We see it all of the ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ time. One of the biggest being they want "small government" but also want the government determining who people can marry, what women can do with their bodies, and if people can get transgender health care. So, you'll have to excuse me if this isn't a very convincing argument from you.
The idea that three conservative justices are cleverly biding their time rather than openly concurring with Alito and Thomas was also a bit daft, given that there is not particular need for long-term strategic subtlety if they already have five votes.

Or perhaps the case wasn't attacking the legal argument they're looking to use to overturn the case. They may be aware of the other cases coming through the court systems that they could better use to overturn Obergefell. You don't know, do you?
I do not need to marshal evidence, since I am not the person making a prediction about what will happen.

No, but you're making specific claims as to why it won't happen. You are required to support those claims, whether you think so or not. Dope cop out though, it looks logical on its face.
Again with the strawman put in quote marks. o_O

It's not a strawman, you literally just said in the sentence before that you didn't feel the need to "marshal evidence". You don't feel the onus is on you to provide reasoning for the things you're saying so my summary of your position is accurate. If you don't like it then don't use that as your argument and I won't call it out.
Unless you have some text, this is just mindreading.

Sure, sure.
 
Last edited:
Just after you admit that this is an attempt at deliberately derailing the topic.
You argued dirrectly against them for certain businesses at least with regard to homosexuals. Why shouldn't those same principles apply to race and religion? Sure you could just hate the gays instead of having some kind of thought out position on antidiscrimination laws but I was giving you the benefit of the doubt.
 
Again with the strawman put in quote marks. o_O

Done with your nonsense.

It wasn't a strawman and I specifically said it wasn't and explained why it wasn't. Your lame ass dodge is duly noted though.

What a ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ joke, why do you even bother? You already said you blocked me forever ago in this very thread. Feel free to leave it that way, you have nothing of value to contribute.
 
It wasn't a strawman
Of course it was, you never once quoted me saying anything remotely like "they won't overturn it, trust me bro."
You already said you blocked me forever ago in this very thread.
I was most likely mistaken to undo that block, since you insist on arguing with made up positions which no one here has affirmed.
 
You argued dirrectly against them for certain businesses at least with regard to homosexuals.
Putting aside your attempted derail, do you believe there should be any limits to anti-discrimination laws when it comes to compelling people to perform services?

For example, my mother's church fell on the inclusive side of a major denominational split in Methodism, but many of her co-religionists disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church and left for a more traditional venue. Should pastors at the more traditional denomination be required to officiate same-sex weddings, or is it okay to leave that to those pastors who are happy to do so?
 
Putting aside your attempted derail, do you believe there should be any limits to anti-discrimination laws when it comes to compelling people to perform services?

For example, my mother's church fell on the inclusive side of a major denominational split in Methodism, but many of her co-religionists disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church and left for a more traditional venue. Should pastors at the more traditional denomination be required to officiate same-sex weddings, or is it okay to leave that to those pastors who are happy to do so?
And of course doctors need to be able to refuse to serve homosexuals as well, because we only cater to certain bigotries. Look clearly no business should ever be forced to serve a homosexual, I get that is your position.
 
Of course it was, you never once quoted me saying anything remotely like "they won't overturn it, trust me bro."

I specifically said it wasn't a direct quote but a summation of your argument because you said you weren't supplying evidence for the things you are saying. You said that wasn't your responsibility.
I was most likely mistaken to undo that block,

Feel free to leave it in place permanently, forever. Neither of us will miss each others input I assure you.
since you insist on arguing with made up positions which no one here has affirmed.

It was a summary of your words. Anyone in this thread can go back and read the posts and see my accurate summation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom