...but the great common-law authorities—Bracton, Coke, Hale, and Blackstone—all wrote that a post-quickening abortion was a crime.
The “eminent common-law authorities (Blackstone, Coke, Hale, and the like),”
Kahler v.
Kansas, 589 U. S. ___, ___ (2020) (slip op., at 7), all describe abortion after quickening as criminal.
(Kahler v. Kansas had nothing to do with abortion. Justice Kagan cited those antique common-law authorities in the course of arguing that Kansas had done nothing more than modify the very old idea of an insanity defense. Justices Breyer, Ginsberg, and Sotomayor dissented, saying Kansas had gone too far. Thus the only purpose of the quotation immediately above is to establish that SCOTUS had previously described Hale "and the like" as "eminent common-law authorities" of long ago.)
Two treatises by Sir Matthew Hale likewise described abortion of a quick child who died in the womb as a “great crime” and a “great misprision.”
(Hale's use of the word "misprision" reminds us he was writing long ago. The majority opinion had to explain that word in its preceding sentence. The sentence that follows the sentence quoted above does not even cite Hale directly, citing instead a secondary source written 60 years following Hale's death.)
Hale and Blackstone explained a way in which a pre-quickening abortion could rise to the level of a homicide.
(This involved some contortions because, as the Dobbs opinion goes on to explain, you couldn't have a murder without “malice aforethought, . . . either express or implied.” It took some effort for those distinguished 17th century jurists just to come up with "implied".)
Hale wrote that if a physician gave a woman “with child” a “potion” to cause an abortion, and the woman died, it was “murder” because the potion was given “
unlawfully to destroy her child within her.”
(The word "unlawfully" was italicized by Alito. Which undercut his reasoning. For that reasoning to be relevant at the time of the Dobbs decision, abortion would have to have been unlawful in the US, at the time of the Dobbs decision. Which it wasn't. Alito goes on to quote Blackstone's speculative reasoning for why it would have been unlawful in the 17th century; if it had been plainly unlawful even in the 17th century, Blackstone wouldn't have had to tie himself in knots.)
Notably, Blackstone, like Hale, did not state that this proto-felony-murder rule required that the woman be “with quick child”—only that she be “with child.”
(So Alito is trying to suggest that, to Hale and Blackstone, it didn't matter whether the child had been perceived to move within the womb. If so, I'd have to wonder whether they would have considered all manner of modern contraceptive methods to be murder as well. But Hale and Blackstone didn't actually say that. We are reading Alito's personal opinion, phrased to mislead readers into thinking Alito's opinion was backed by the authority of Hale and Blackstone.)
And it is revealing that Hale and Blackstone treated abortionists differently from other physicians or surgeons who caused the death of a patient “without any intent of doing [the patient] any bodily hurt.”
(That claim is, as they say, conclusory. Two sentences later, Alito reveals that the sentence quoted above relies upon his very own personal opinion that an abortion would have been unlawful both then (17th century) and now (2022).)
These other physicians—even if “unlicensed”—would not be “guilty of murder or manslaughter.” Hale 429. But a physician performing an abortion would, precisely because his aim was an “unlawful” one
(Alito then admits that "common-law authorities differed on the severity of punishment for abortions", but "none endorsed the practice." Although Alito and his fellow right-wingers like to characterize their pro-choice opponents as pro-abortion, hardly anyone actually endorses abortion as a positive good, even today. In that respect, Alito is failing to identify a real difference between his 17th century authorities and modern pro-choice opinions.
Alito then turns to an early American edition of Blackstone's 18th century Commentaries, along with several other late 18th century quotations of such. Recognizing, perhaps, that quoting an Englishman's opinion of British common law is not a legal precedent for 21st century American jurisprudence, Alito cites a Maryland case. A case decided in 1652.)
But as we have seen, great common-law authorities like Bracton, Coke, Hale, and Blackstone all wrote that a post quickening abortion was a crime—and a serious one at that. Moreover, Hale and Blackstone (and many other authorities following them) asserted that even a pre-quickening abortion was “unlawful” and that, as a result, an abortionist was guilty of murder if the woman died from the attempt.
(Here Alito is repeating his questionable conclusions in the hope readers will accept them as authoritative. Note, however, that even Alito concedes that his favorite 17th and 18th century English authorities would not have counted abortion as murder unless the woman dies from the procedure.
And that's it, folks. I believe I have quoted at least a few words from every one of Alito's references to Sir Matthew Hale's 17th century opinions.)