Pride Month 2025

There's a lot of stuff about promoting "healthy marriage" and then page 481 defines what they consider "healthy marriage".

Protect faith-based grant recipients from religious liberty violations and maintain a biblically based, social science–reinforced definition of marriage and family. Social science reports that assess the objective outcomes for children raised in homes aside from a heterosexual, in tact marriage are clear: All other family forms involve higher levels of instability(the average length of same-sex marriages is half that of heterosexual marriages); financial stress or poverty; and poor behavioral, psychological, or educational outcomes. For the sake of child well-being, programs should affirm that children require and deserve both the love and nurturing of a mother and the play and protection of a father. Despite recent congressional bills like the Respect for Marriage Act that redefine marriage to be the union between any two individuals, HMRE program grants should be available to faith based recipients who affirm that marriage is between not just any two adults, but one man and one unrelated woman.
 
We knew well in advance (from around the mid 80s) that Alito had it out for Roe and Casey.  Have we any similar indications that the sitting justices have been fighting for decades against constitutional or statutory protections for same-sex rights?
Yes. In 2015, they recorded their opposition to same-sex marriage in the dissents they wrote for the Obergefell decision.

Clarence Thomas, a sitting justice, has continued to put his opposition to same-sex marriage in writing. Here is one such example:
For that reason, in future cases, we should reconsider all of this Court’s substantive due process precedents, including Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell. Because any substantive due process decision is “demonstrably erroneous,” ..., we have a duty to “correct the error” established in those precedents....
(Dobbs v. Jackson, 2022, page 3 of Justice Thomas's concurrence, citations omitted)

Samuel Alito, who is another sitting justice, has continued to say he thinks Obergefell was wrongly decided. In 2020, he joined with Justice Thomas's statement regarding a denial of certiorari, which concludes with this paragraph:
This petition implicates important questions about the scope of our decision in Obergefell, but it does not cleanly present them. For that reason, I concur in the denial of certiorari. Nevertheless, this petition provides a stark reminder of the consequences of Obergefell. By choosing to privilege a novel constitutional right over the religious liberty interests explicitly protected in the First Amendment, and by doing so undemocratically, the Court has created a problem that only it can fix. Until then, Obergefell will continue to have “ruinous consequences for religious liberty.”
It is hard to interpret "the Court has created a problem that only it can fix" as anything other than a declaration that Justices Thomas and Alito regard Obergefell as a problem the Supreme Court could fix.

On the other hand, Justice Alito has said “Obergefell is a precedent of the court that is entitled to respect afforded by the doctrine of stare decisis.”

Which is, as we all remember, the reason Justice Alito refused to overturn Roe v. Wade. Oh, wait...
 
Last edited:
John Oliver did a bit about how Clarence Thomas signals for states or AGs to bring cases before them by writing "in future cases" in his dissents. It was pretty telling as well. It was in the same episode that he talked about Clarence being bribed with the RV.
 
Portland Public Schools board just voted to recognize June as Pride Month. A week after school ended for the year.

There is still no word on when PPS will recognize an education month.
 
There's a lot of stuff about promoting "healthy marriage" and then page 481 defines what they consider "healthy marriage".
Okay, so who is drafting proposals to legally carve out an exception to the Respect for Marriage Act so as to help fulfill their stated goal of supporting “healthy marriage” rather than the newer and somewhat broader idea of two consenting adults? I’ve seen loads of other culture war bills, are federal marriage bills just not making the news?
 
(Dobbs v. Jackson, 2022, page 3 of Justice Thomas's concurrence, citations omitted)

Samuel Alito, who is another sitting justice, has continued to say he thinks Obergefell was wrongly decided. In 2020, he joined with Justice Thomas's statement regarding a denial of certiorari, which concludes with this paragraph:

It is hard to interpret "the Court has created a problem that only it can fix" as anything other than a declaration that Justices Thomas and Alito regard Obergefell as a problem the Supreme Court could fix.
It looks like you accidentally pasted the Dobbs link in twice in a row here. Presumably you meant to link to the denial of cert in Davis v. Ermold in the second instance. That was a sad ending for culture warriors on the counterattack against progressive marriage reforms, given that only 2/9 justices (on a 6/3 conservative court) were willing to revisit whether same-sex marriage should be legal nationwide.
 
Last edited:
Okay, so who is drafting proposals to legally carve out an exception to the Respect for Marriage Act so as to help fulfill their stated goal of supporting “healthy marriage” rather than the newer and somewhat broader idea of two consenting adults? I’ve seen loads of other culture war bills, are federal marriage bills just not making the news?

Serious Thinker wants to see evidence that lawless fascist bigots will continue to be lawless fascist bigots and assumes they will just stop being lawless fascist bigots absent this evidence.
 
Okay, so who is drafting proposals to legally carve out an exception to the Respect for Marriage Act so as to help fulfill their stated goal of supporting “healthy marriage” rather than the newer and somewhat broader idea of two consenting adults? I’ve seen loads of other culture war bills, are federal marriage bills just not making the news?
RfM only protects marriages that were already performed in states in which they were legal. Idaho's proposal and the law suit from that judge in Waco are asking them to recognize or perform such marriages is a violation of their First Amendment rights. Much like the Voting Rights Act and Roe, it's never just one big attack. These acts are performative to see what support they have and what SCOTUS is willing to give them.
 
RfM only protects marriages that were already performed in states in which they were legal.
All 50 of them, last I checked. I'm unsure why you seem to believe that Idaho is about to revert to banning same-sex marriage, so far as I can tell the furthest they've gotten so far is failing to pass a resolution calling on the Supreme Court reverse their position in a case which may never arise, given that no American jurisdictions (not even Samoa) are currently refusing to license same-sex marriages.
 
All 50 of them, last I checked. I'm unsure why you seem to believe that Idaho is about to revert to banning same-sex marriage, so far as I can tell the furthest they've gotten so far is failing to pass a resolution calling on the Supreme Court reverse their position in a case which may never arise, given that no American jurisdictions (not even Samoa) are currently refusing to license same-sex marriages.

Serious Thinker assures everyone that the lawless fascist bigots who are openly and gleefully lawless fascist bigots will fail at being lawless fascist bigots because they will randomly decide to stop being lawless fascist bigots.
 
All 50 of them, last I checked. I'm unsure why you seem to believe that Idaho is about to revert to banning same-sex marriage, so far as I can tell the furthest they've gotten so far is failing to pass a resolution calling on the Supreme Court reverse their position in a case which may never arise, given that no American jurisdictions (not even Samoa) are currently refusing to license same-sex marriages.
Again, they will sue for the right to. The same as with all the other attempts at rolling back to the 1850s.

32 states currently have trigger laws ready to go if Obergfell gets overturned. Again, they are just looking for how SCOTUS will do so.
 
Again, they will sue for the right to. The same as with all the other attempts at rolling back to the 1850s.

32 states currently have trigger laws ready to go if Obergfell gets overturned. Again, they are just looking for how SCOTUS will do so.
The following states already have laws on the books that ban same-sex marriage. Those laws are unenforceable so long as Obergefell remains in effect, but would prevent same-sex marriages from being performed in those states immediately or shortly after any repeal of Obergefell. (Some of the listed states might move expeditiously to repeal some of those laws if Obergefell were overturned, although that might take a while if the ban has been added to the state's constitution. And some state attorneys general might decline to enforce such bans while waiting for the laws to be repealed.)
  1. Alabama
  2. Alaska
  3. Arizona
  4. Arkansas
  5. Florida
  6. Georgia
  7. Idaho
  8. Indiana
  9. Iowa
  10. Kansas
  11. Kentucky
  12. Louisiana
  13. Michigan
  14. Mississippi
  15. Missouri
  16. Montana
  17. Nebraska
  18. North Carolina
  19. North Dakota
  20. Ohio
  21. Oklahoma
  22. Pennsylvania
  23. South Carolina
  24. South Dakota
  25. Tennessee
  26. Texas
  27. Utah
  28. Virginia
  29. West Virginia
  30. Wisconsin
  31. Wyoming
 
A testable prediction! Will it happen this year? Whom would Idaho name as defendants in the case?

Serious Thinker insists that lawless fascist bigots will not perform acts of lawless fascist bigotry unless a specific prediction of said lawless fascist bigotry can be made, demonstrating a Profound Understanding of how lawless fascist bigotry works.
 
Last edited:
One of the few things I would give Trump credit for was his response to calls to overturn Obergfell.

Republican President-elect Donald Trump said he’s “fine” with same-sex marriage as the law of the land, calling the issue “settled” by the Supreme Court.

The comments — in Trump’s first television interview since winning the presidency — sharply contrast with his party’s orthodoxy, his running mate’s longtime position and comments he made during the Republican primaries.

“It’s law,” he said in an interview with CBS’ “60 Minutes” that aired Sunday. “It was settled in the Supreme Court. I mean, it’s done.”
It was smart politically, since it removed a cultural war issue that the GOP was in the minority on. This may have been a hot-button issue for the GOP 20 years ago, but it's probably down near "fight climate change" these days on issues that matter to the Republican base. I think a test case sent to the Supreme Court would only get the three ultra-conservative votes in favor of overturning. Unlike abortion, this is not really an issue you can turn back to the states because of the Full Faith and Credit clause.
 
One of the few things I would give Trump credit for was his response to calls to overturn Obergfell.


It was smart politically, since it removed a cultural war issue that the GOP was in the minority on. This may have been a hot-button issue for the GOP 20 years ago, but it's probably down near "fight climate change" these days on issues that matter to the Republican base. I think a test case sent to the Supreme Court would only get the three ultra-conservative votes in favor of overturning. Unlike abortion, this is not really an issue you can turn back to the states because of the Full Faith and Credit clause.

Oh good, that’s a relief because Trump isn’t at all an unstable lunatic who will sometimes contradict himself in the same sentence and Republicans definitely aren’t fascists and they always respect the rule of law, so nothing to worry about.
 
Last edited:
One of the few things I would give Trump credit for was his response to calls to overturn Obergfell.
Republican President-elect Donald Trump said he’s “fine” with same-sex marriage as the law of the land, calling the issue “settled” by the Supreme Court.
Ummm... first of all, why exactly are you trusting trump on this (or, on anything)?

Trump has a reputation for lying and for saying contradictory things. Just a few short years before, he was saying he was against gay marriage. So why believe him now?

Secondly, Trump claimed same sex marriage was "settled law". But... Abortion was also "settled law", and had been accepted for decades longer than Oberfell. Yet it was overturned.

Lastly, as I pointed out before, even if Trump himself was all for same-sex marriage, its irrelevant at this point since he has already gotten Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife on the supreme court, and they can rule as they please.
It was smart politically, since it removed a cultural war issue that the GOP was in the minority on.
The GOP was also in the minority on the Abortion issue. How is that working out for American women?

The republicans do not have to worry about being "in the majority". They just have to do stuff that 1) appeal to their evangelical christian base, since they are a reliable voting block, and 2) hope that there are enough idiots around who think "I don't have to worry, they will never touch gay marriage". That's what happened with abortion... how many people wanted abortion rights protected but still voted republican because they thought Roe v. Wade was "settled law"?

This may have been a hot-button issue for the GOP 20 years ago, but it's probably down near "fight climate change" these days on issues that matter to the Republican base.
The "republican base" is extremely gullible and can easily be manipulated into thinking "same sex marriage is destroying America and must be stopped".
I think a test case sent to the Supreme Court would only get the three ultra-conservative votes in favor of overturning.
There are five ultra-conservative judges. You know, the ones who ruled against providing proper health care for Trans kids in United_States v. Skrmetti. The ones who said discrimination is A-Ok in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis.
Unlike abortion, this is not really an issue you can turn back to the states because of the Full Faith and Credit clause.
Conservatives on the supreme court overturned abortion rights by citing a guy who once prosecuted people for witchcraft. They ruled that Trump cannot be charged for crimes related to his "official duties", despite that not being anywhere in the constitution.

I am sure if/when the opportunity presents itself, conservatives will rule against same sex marriage, and they will do so regardless of whatever laws or precedents exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom