Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

Oh, I think it's pretty easy to see.

yrreg assumes that if an atheist becomes a theist, it must be because he has discovered the Truth and "come to know God" through the "exercise of his reason." But if a theist becomes an atheist, yrreg assumes that it is because he is denying The Truth and is angry at God.

Of course, two can play that game. I could assert that when a theist becomes an atheist, it is because he has used his intelligence and reason to examine the evidence (or lack thereof) and discover how he has been misled (by himself or others). And that, conversely, when an atheist becomes a theist, that it is because he has chosen to indulge in a fantasy because he is scared of dying.

That's not actually my position, mind you: I think people change their minds on this issue for a variety of reasons, sometimes logical and sometimes emotional.

But the point is this: yrreg's little game gets us nowhere. Let's forget the atheist/theist labels for a minute.

Person X claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, B is true.

Person Y claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, A is true.

Where does this get us? Nowhere. In order to decide which change of position is logical and which is not, we would have to evaluate the logical arguments in favor of A and B, respectively. So we're right back to square one.
So you are suggesting that Yrreg's rational argument to prove that God exists is:

The proposition P is true because Sam, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.

If so then as you say it would apply equally to not P

Also this would imply that Sam would have to state something like:

The proposition P is true because Fred, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.

And Fred:

The proposition P is true because Alice, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.

And so ad infinitum. Or otherwise someone, somewhere along this chain had another reason for believing in God and that is the reason we should be hearing.

But as I said Antony didn't even write his book on the subject and Francis' reasons did not make sense when C.S. Lewis said them the first time.

In other words, yrreg, just present your argument for god, rather than futzing around with these logical cul-de-sacs.
Yes.
 
Number 1: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, except to people who are so sure of themselves to have come to all the evidence in the whole totality of existence as God has made the whole totality of existence and put it in an intelligent scheme of order.


Yes, but in the absence of evidence, there is no reason to believe in the thing for which evidence is lacking.

Absence of evidence of unicorns is not evidence of absence of unicorns.

Absence of evidence of celestial teapots is not evidence of absence of celestial teapots.

Absence of evidence of time-travelling chimpanzees is not evidence of absence of time-travelling chimpanzees.

If, in the absence of evidence, you believe in God, then why not unicorns, celestial teapots and time-travelling chimpanzees.


Number 2: Not knowing the existence of someone is not evidence of his non-existence, see above Number 1 for why.


The Bigfoot threads are in the General Skepticism and the Paranormal forum.


Number 3: No need to harp on the distinction of knowing and believing, and I have said already several times here that I am a rational theist, who maintain that reason can bring man to the certainty of God's existence; and I also said that for people who do have certainty from reason of God's existence when they use the words belief, believing, in regard to God's existence, it could be a diplomatic way in order to not appear overly forward in their language before atheists, but they do mean knowledge and knowing with belief and believing, i.e., knowledge of and knowing God from reason.


It's not diplomacy, it's English.

If you maintain that you know God exists, by the standard definition of the term 'know', you a wrong.

Regardless, please provide the reasoning and logic that lead to your knowledge (as per yrreg's definition of the term). Endless, multi-page threads of assertion don't seem to be working.


I don't know about Kirk Cameron, but I know about other atheists who were notorious or of public renown to use a better term, who came to the knowledge of God by way of evidence acceptable to and sufficient to themselves later, whereas previously they had all kinds of objections supposedly grounded on the lack of evidence or its sufficiency to come to the knowledge of God.

Right away I can name Antony Flew and Francis Collins.


I think I see where you are going with this. You're argument is as follows:

P1: Atheists don't believe in God for lack of evidence.

P2: Some atheists come to believe in God and claim evidence supports their conclusions.

C: Therefore, atheists who don't believe in God simply haven't found the evidence that is out there to be found.

The problem with your argument is that most of the atheists on this forum are aware of the arguments put forward for God's existence (even though it seems very difficult to get these arguments out of yrreg in order to discuss them) and find them to be faulty.

So, please, present some convincing evidence and we'll see whether it holds water.


Read this line in reverse and if you can't make out what it is saying, approach an expert in sources of English terms, if you come to some really good expert, he will tell you what it means.


.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
​


We're doing riddles now?
 
Last edited:
I don't know about Kirk Cameron, but I know about other atheists who were notorious or of public renown to use a better term, who came to the knowledge of God by way of evidence acceptable to and sufficient to themselves later, whereas previously they had all kinds of objections supposedly grounded on the lack of evidence or its sufficiency to come to the knowledge of God.

Right away I can name Antony Flew and Francis Collins.



What am I heading at with the present discourse about atheists who have come to admit the existence of God?

Think, and you will see what I am driving at.


P1: Most people don't believe in fairies for lack of evidence.

P2: Some people have come to believe in fairies and claim evidence supports their conclusions.

C: Therefore, most people who don't believe in fairies simply haven't found the evidence that is out there to be found.*

*For said evidence, google 'Cottingley fairies' and 'Sir Arthur Conan Doyle'.
 
Oh, my, using a mirror I was able to decode his super secret code. And another one , hidden in an earlier post. I'll bet you god-hating atheists won't be able to decode it.
toidi na ma I.
 
Read this line in reverse and if you can't make out what it is saying, approach an expert in sources of English terms, if you come to some really good expert, he will tell you what it means.


.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
​

[/indent]

I read it yrreg!! Problem is (apart from you suggesting us go to an expert of English as opposed to Latin for this problem, lol) just because its in latin, and its a phrase, doesn't validate it. In this case it just simply isn't true.


I'll show you a latin phrase that is true for the situation at hand. Especially for you:
Parvus error in principiis, magnus in conclusionibus

I won't make you look it up. It means, "A small error in principles is large in conclusions"
 
Argument by Latin written in reverse. That has to be a new one.
 
I won't make you look it up. It means, "A small error in principles is large in conclusions"
The problem is that his "small error in principles" is not small...it is an epic fail in ginormous proportions.
 
The problem is that his "small error in principles" is not small...it is an epic fail in ginormous proportions.

I believe the second part of the quote hints at that outcome. =]

Besides, his latin quote pretty much offered a false dichotomy, lol. I could be mistaken in my translation though.
 

.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
​

So reversing it one gets:

Ab esse ad posse valet illation

and googling that one gets:

"did you mean 'Ab esse ad posse valet illatio ?"

(I've forgotten all i 'learned' from my year of latin at school. Does that last 'n' dramatically change the meaning?)

which leads one to:

http://www.upholdingtradition.com/catholicteaching/philosophy/axiomata.htm

"A Scholastic List of Philosophical Axioms"

In Latin: "Ab esse ad posse valet illatio."

In English: "The argument is valid only from being to the possibility of being"

Which is, of course, absurd.

I have read every post in this thread, but i don't remember if the question has been turned around for you, yrreg. So here's one for you:

Do accept the possibility that god does not exist? Why or why not?
 
I have read every post in this thread, but i don't remember if the question has been turned around for you, yrreg. So here's one for you:

Do accept the possibility that god does not exist? Why or why not?

If you have read the entire thread, you should know that Yrreg doesn't answer questions.
 
Think, and you will see what I am driving at.


Read this line in reverse and if you can't make out what it is saying, approach an expert in sources of English terms, if you come to some really good expert, he will tell you what it means.


.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
​



Happy and productive thinking!

Wow, I think I've had an epiphany! yrreg, you're a genius! Your posts, when contemplated in their totality, are a kind of koan, leading to in inescapable insight into the nature of reality. I understand now why you couldn't make your point any more plainly -- we atheists really have to THINK IT THROUGH to understand what you're getting at. This is it, right?

01111001011100100111001001100101011001110010110000100000011010010110011000100000011110010110111101110101001000000111011101100101011100100110010100100000011000010110111001111001001000000110110101101111011100100110010100100000011100110111010001110101011100000110100101100100001011000010000001111001011011110111010100100000011101110110111101110101011011000110010000100000011011100110111101110100001000000110001001100101001000000110001101100001011100000110000101100010011011000110010100100000011011110110011000100000011011100110000101110110011010010110011101100001011101000110100101101110011001110010000001110100011010000110010100100000011010010110111001110100011001010111001001101110011001010111010000101110001000000010000001010100011010000110010101110010011001010110011001101111011100100110010100101100001000000111010101101110011011000110010101110011011100110010000001111001011011110111010100100000011000010111001001100101001000000010001001110011011101010111001001100110011010010110111001100111001000000111011101101001011101000110100000100000011000010111001101110011011010010111001101110100011000010110111001100011011001010010110000100010001000000110100101110100001001110111001100100000011100000110111101110011011100110110100101100010011011000110010100100000011101000110100001100001011101000010000001111001011011110111010100100000011000010111001001100101001000000111010001101000011001010010000001101101011011110111001101110100001000000111001101110100011101010111000001101001011001000010000001110000011001010111001001110011011011110110111000100000011011110110111000100000011101000110100001100101001000000111011101101111011100100110110001100100011101110110100101100100011001010010000001110111011001010110001000101110001000000010000001000011011011110110111001100111011100100110000101110100011101010110110001100001011101000110100101101111011011100111001100100001
 
01001000 01100001 00100001 00100000 01001110 01101001 01100011 01100101 00101110 00100000 01010100 01101000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110111 01101000 01111001 00100000 01001001 00100000 01101100 01101111 01110110 01100101 00100000 01110100 01101000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01100110 01101111 01110010 01110101 01101101 00101110
 
You are all missing that he put it backwards. He clearly wants us to consider the obverse,which is "it is invalid to argue from impossibility to existence".

So clearly he is asking us to consider whether a "maker of everything" is possible.

Clearly he is asking us to consider that if even one thing exists that God did not make then God could not be the maker of everything.

So what he is asking us to do is to see if we can think of just one thing that might exist that God couldn't have created.
 
Last edited:
01001000 01100001 00100001 00100000 01001110 01101001 01100011 01100101 00101110 00100000 01010100 01101000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110111 01101000 01111001 00100000 01001001 00100000 01101100 01101111 01110110 01100101 00100000 01110100 01101000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01100110 01101111 01110010 01110101 01101101 00101110
I think you are making a category error in the second line.
 
You are all missing that he put it backwards. He clearly wants us to consider the obverse,which is "it is invalid to argue from impossibility to existence".

So clearly he is asking us to consider whether a "maker of everything" is possible.
!hoD
 
OMG! Gerry is Clara Peller!

If you are really after solid spirituality instead of weekend or country club relief of boredom.
Country club? No, last weekend we took our son to the zoo.

Buddha or Gautama he was a great guy for irrational words, erh, sorry, I should say meta-rational words.
You must idolize him.

By the way, where is Loss Leader, the Opinionated Jerk [ his own self description ]? haven't seen him around my posts for centuries in web forum time. He is the guy who reported me to a moderator and caused a ruckus, because according to him I was advocating genocide of Buddhists -- like Hitler of Jews.
That wouldn't surprise me. By the way, I was the one (or perhaps one of those) who reported you for suggesting that atheists should commit suicide.

Have fun in my threads, but remember we are all sincere seekers after true knowledge by the use of our reason, however not using it to eviscerate it in the process, like the non-self preached by some Buddhists when they do just the same duck when they see a stone cruising toward their head carelessly thrown by a child.
Gerry, why are you angry at the English language? Obviously a guy with such an impressive command of English vocabulary, such that he has no need of a thesaurus, is familiar with proper grammar. I can only conclude that you know proper sentence structure but refuse to avail yourself of it out of rebellious anger at the English language. Have you considered seeing a linguistic psychologist?
 
stele.jpg
 
Number 1: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, except to people who are so sure of themselves to have come to all the evidence in the whole totality of existence as God has made the whole totality of existence and put it in an intelligent scheme of order.
So you believe in unicorns then?

Number 2: Not knowing the existence of someone is not evidence of his non-existence, see above Number 1 for why.
Well it certainly isn't evidence that he does exist. See above unicorn example.

Number 3: No need to harp on the distinction of knowing and believing, and I have said already several times here that I am a rational theist, who maintain that reason can bring man to the certainty of God's existence; and I also said that for people who do have certainty from reason of God's existence when they use the words belief, believing, in regard to God's existence, it could be a diplomatic way in order to not appear overly forward in their language before atheists, but they do mean knowledge and knowing with belief and believing, i.e., knowledge of and knowing God from reason.
You keep saying that but you never lay out your argument. Do you really have one, or have you just convinced yourself that you must even though you can't describe it?

Come to the knowledge means come to the human certainty or as someone here wants to insist reasonable certainty of God's existence.
And how did you do that?

I don't know about Kirk Cameron, but I know about other atheists who were notorious or of public renown to use a better term, who came to the knowledge of God by way of evidence acceptable to and sufficient to themselves later, whereas previously they had all kinds of objections supposedly grounded on the lack of evidence or its sufficiency to come to the knowledge of God.
Given the abjectly stupid arguments that Kirk Cameron has come up with in support of his interpretation of Christianity is seems rather obvious that the atheism he observed in the past was not based on any intelligent reason.

Right away I can name Antony Flew and Francis Collins.
So what?

What am I heading at with the present discourse about atheists who have come to admit the existence of God?

Think, and you will see what I am driving at.
It's been transparently obvious from the start what you are driving at. You are making a really poor argument in which you intend to take atheists who have adopted theism as evidence of the veracity of theism, yet completely ignore the numerous cases of theists who have adopted atheism, Christians who have adopted Buddhism, etc.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom