Robin
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2004
- Messages
- 14,971
So you are suggesting that Yrreg's rational argument to prove that God exists is:Oh, I think it's pretty easy to see.
yrreg assumes that if an atheist becomes a theist, it must be because he has discovered the Truth and "come to know God" through the "exercise of his reason." But if a theist becomes an atheist, yrreg assumes that it is because he is denying The Truth and is angry at God.
Of course, two can play that game. I could assert that when a theist becomes an atheist, it is because he has used his intelligence and reason to examine the evidence (or lack thereof) and discover how he has been misled (by himself or others). And that, conversely, when an atheist becomes a theist, that it is because he has chosen to indulge in a fantasy because he is scared of dying.
That's not actually my position, mind you: I think people change their minds on this issue for a variety of reasons, sometimes logical and sometimes emotional.
But the point is this: yrreg's little game gets us nowhere. Let's forget the atheist/theist labels for a minute.
Person X claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, B is true.
Person Y claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, A is true.
Where does this get us? Nowhere. In order to decide which change of position is logical and which is not, we would have to evaluate the logical arguments in favor of A and B, respectively. So we're right back to square one.
The proposition P is true because Sam, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.
If so then as you say it would apply equally to not P
Also this would imply that Sam would have to state something like:
The proposition P is true because Fred, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.
And Fred:
The proposition P is true because Alice, having disbelieved P came to believe it through reason.
And so ad infinitum. Or otherwise someone, somewhere along this chain had another reason for believing in God and that is the reason we should be hearing.
But as I said Antony didn't even write his book on the subject and Francis' reasons did not make sense when C.S. Lewis said them the first time.
Yes.In other words, yrreg, just present your argument for god, rather than futzing around with these logical cul-de-sacs.