Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

You miss the beef by going into an obiter, another sig line for you?

[...]

__________________

Ryokan is an ex Resident Buddhist here, but I changed him. - yrreg [ First sig line of Ryokan ]

[...]


I have another sig line for you, You miss the beef by going into an obiter.




I was so flattered someone here did that, unless he or she was just being funny, as many atheists claim to be when they cannot admit to having said what they did say earlier.



How are you doing with your trendish adoption of Buddhism for a worldview and religion, getting anywhere near enlightenment and thus clearing a lot of bad karma, all in the way of coming to final nirvana?

Here is a sincere tip for you in the way of clearing off bad karma, join the Carthusians, you can still do your own version of genuine pure 100% Buddhism as preached and practiced by the Buddha himself.


If you are really after solid spirituality instead of weekend or country club relief of boredom.


Buddha or Gautama he was a great guy for irrational words, erh, sorry, I should say meta-rational words.


By the way, where is Loss Leader, the Opinionated Jerk [ his own self description ]? haven't seen him around my posts for centuries in web forum time. He is the guy who reported me to a moderator and caused a ruckus, because according to him I was advocating genocide of Buddhists -- like Hitler of Jews.


Have fun in my threads, but remember we are all sincere seekers after true knowledge by the use of our reason, however not using it to eviscerate it in the process, like the non-self preached by some Buddhists when they do just the same duck when they see a stone cruising toward their head carelessly thrown by a child.





Yrreg
 
I have another sig line for you.

No thanks, I like the ones I've got. Although that one is pretty funny as well :)

Actually, I don't see the point of answering your questions. I've done so for years, and never gotten a good reply back for it. Which is why my posts in your threads these days are so short :)

Since you're fond of Latin, what about some quid pro quo? I've asked some questions in this thread. For every one of my questions you reply to, I will reply to one of yours. If you run out of questions from me, I will supply some more. Sounds fair, doesn't it?

I'll give you one for free: Yes, I'm still a Buddhist.

By the way, though, I think you're way off topic. But the topic doesn't seem to be going anywhere, so I don't really mind.
 
Last edited:
OK, it seems Yrreg is telling us he was just on a fishing expedition.

So what do you say we change direction and start taking the question seriously?

Otherwise there does not seem to be a point in continuing with the thread.

Is it possible to prove the proposition "There is a God" one way or the other?

First, in order to prove something exists you have to define it in a meaningful way.
Yrreg said:
God is the maker of everything and He does not have to make Himself.
The sentence is self-contradictory.
Why? Because it is not necessary to do so since He is already God the maker of everything
Yes, so if there is one thing that God didn't have to make then clearly there is something God didn't make. So he can't be the maker of everything.

So if Yrreg insists on the definition "maker of everything" we can demonstrate that God does not exist because the definition is logically impossible.

So what about "maker of everything that began to exist"? This is at least logically possible - the subject is now not necessarily contained in the set defined by the predicate.

And as I have pointed out, in order for this to be the definition used by billions of believers across the world we would have to add "the purposefully intelligent maker of everything that began to exist".

Since theists do not seem to be able to commit themselves to the proposition that God is intelligent then I will propose to definitions:

Weak Theism : "God is the maker of everything that began to exist"
Strong Theism : "God is the purposefully intelligent maker of everything that began to exist"

So this leads to two propositions:

1. There is one thing that made everything that began to exist
2. There is one purposefully intelligent thing that made everything that began to exist

So the question in the title of the thread is essentially asking if these are verifiable (or falsifiable) propositions, does everybody agree?
 
Last edited:
Thanks, SumDood for your reply, but first some words to others here.

Thanks, SumDood for your reply, but first some words to others here.


Number 1: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, except to people who are so sure of themselves to have come to all the evidence in the whole totality of existence as God has made the whole totality of existence and put it in an intelligent scheme of order.

Number 2: Not knowing the existence of someone is not evidence of his non-existence, see above Number 1 for why.

Number 3: No need to harp on the distinction of knowing and believing, and I have said already several times here that I am a rational theist, who maintain that reason can bring man to the certainty of God's existence; and I also said that for people who do have certainty from reason of God's existence when they use the words belief, believing, in regard to God's existence, it could be a diplomatic way in order to not appear overly forward in their language before atheists, but they do mean knowledge and knowing with belief and believing, i.e., knowledge of and knowing God from reason.*

​

.
.
​

Assuming 'come to the knowledge of God' you mean becoming a believer in god the maker of everything, i do not personally know any atheists who have done so, but i am reasonably certain that it happens. Kirk Cameron claims he was an atheist before he was a christian, and i have no reason not to believe him in this regard.

If my assumption about 'come to the knowledge of God' is not correct, please clarify so i may form a proper response.


Come to the knowledge means come to the human certainty or as someone here wants to insist reasonable certainty of God's existence.


I don't know about Kirk Cameron, but I know about other atheists who were notorious or of public renown to use a better term, who came to the knowledge of God by way of evidence acceptable to and sufficient to themselves later, whereas previously they had all kinds of objections supposedly grounded on the lack of evidence or its sufficiency to come to the knowledge of God.

Right away I can name Antony Flew and Francis Collins.



What am I heading at with the present discourse about atheists who have come to admit the existence of God?

Think, and you will see what I am driving at.


Read this line in reverse and if you can't make out what it is saying, approach an expert in sources of English terms, if you come to some really good expert, he will tell you what it means.


.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
​



Happy and productive thinking!



Best regards.




Yrreg



*However, I can understand and accept other people who are glad to have come to the certainty of God's existence by belief or faith which is then founded upon their own experience of God's existence, and I would encourage them to examine their faith in the light of reason, and get to know God more and better in the light of God's gift to man of reason.​
 
What am I heading at with the present discourse about atheists who have come to admit the existence of God?

Think, and you will see what I am driving at.
I have no idea what you are driving at and it is pretty clear, neither do you.
 
Think, and you will see what I am driving at.

I think you are ashamed of how little it took to convince you that god(s) exist and therefore will never admit to what it was.

I don't blame you. At least children stop believing in Santa Claus.
 
Number 3: No need to harp on the distinction of knowing and believing,

If you truly believe that then you must have an even poorer grasp of the English language than I previously thought. There is a big distinction between knowing and believing. There is not one theist who knows God exists. There can't be because there is zero evidence that God exists. Every theist that says they know God exists actually means that they believe God exists. You may want to try composing your posts in your native language and having someone who has better command of English translate for you.
 
Yrreg you have asserted you are a rational theist. Can we see some of the reasoning please. That is what we are waiting for

Thank you
 
Seems to me that when atheists come to believe in God then we could just look at the reasons that convinced them and see if they convince us.

But Antony Flew didn't even write the book that came out in his name and Francis Collins' reasons don't make any more sense than when C.S. Lewis said them the first time.
 
Last edited:
Number 1: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, except to people who are so sure of themselves to have come to all the evidence in the whole totality of existence as God has made the whole totality of existence and put it in an intelligent scheme of order.
I'm very aware that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. In the case of god beliefs, however, there is abundant evidence that men (usually, and sometimes women) across cultures and throughout history have made up stories and created supernatural mythologies to explain what they could not explain otherwise.

Number 2: Not knowing the existence of someone is not evidence of his non-existence, see above Number 1 for why.
This is exceedingly redundant to number 1.

Number 3: No need to harp on the distinction of knowing and believing, and I have said already several times here that I am a rational theist, who maintain that reason can bring man to the certainty of God's existence; and I also said that for people who do have certainty from reason of God's existence when they use the words belief, believing, in regard to God's existence, it could be a diplomatic way in order to not appear overly forward in their language before atheists, but they do mean knowledge and knowing with belief and believing, i.e., knowledge of and knowing God from reason.*
There is a HUGE difference between belief and knowledge, but I do at least feel rewarded for reading this paragraph, in learning that theists are only using the word "belief" diplomatically, so as not to offend the sensibilities of atheists. Instead of being so diplomatic about their terms, maybe you know a few theists who will offer up evidence which has led them to actual knowledge, and not simple belief.

What am I heading at with the present discourse about atheists who have come to admit the existence of God?

Think, and you will see what I am driving at.
Can't you do some of the heavy lifting yourself? If you are driving at something, state what it is, in clear English. Are you trying to be funny with the backwards latin? Either admit you don't want anybody here to come closer to your understanding of your god, or start making an actual point already.


*However, I can understand and accept other people who are glad to have come to the certainty of God's existence by belief or faith which is then founded upon their own experience of God's existence, and I would encourage them to examine their faith in the light of reason, and get to know God more and better in the light of God's gift to man of reason.
Nobody has come to the certainty of god's existence by belief or faith, unless you're talking again about your "human certainty" which is a synonym for "belief" and has no similarity to empirical truth.
 
I have no idea what you are driving at and it is pretty clear, neither do you.

Oh, I think it's pretty easy to see.

yrreg assumes that if an atheist becomes a theist, it must be because he has discovered the Truth and "come to know God" through the "exercise of his reason." But if a theist becomes an atheist, yrreg assumes that it is because he is denying The Truth and is angry at God.

Of course, two can play that game. I could assert that when a theist becomes an atheist, it is because he has used his intelligence and reason to examine the evidence (or lack thereof) and discover how he has been misled (by himself or others). And that, conversely, when an atheist becomes a theist, that it is because he has chosen to indulge in a fantasy because he is scared of dying.

That's not actually my position, mind you: I think people change their minds on this issue for a variety of reasons, sometimes logical and sometimes emotional.

But the point is this: yrreg's little game gets us nowhere. Let's forget the atheist/theist labels for a minute.

Person X claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, B is true.

Person Y claims: People who change their mind from position A to position B do so because they have used their intelligence. People who change their mind from B to A do so because they are acting illogically and emotionally. Therefore, A is true.

Where does this get us? Nowhere. In order to decide which change of position is logical and which is not, we would have to evaluate the logical arguments in favor of A and B, respectively. So we're right back to square one.

In other words, yrreg, just present your argument for god, rather than futzing around with these logical cul-de-sacs.
 
Yrreg said:
.noitalli telav essop da esse bA
Since most of us have already stipulated that it is possible for an atheist to come to personal certainly about the existence of God you are simply repeating yourself - dilly dallying.

How does this relate the the thread topic?
 
It doesn't. The only thing which would be relevant would be for Yrreg to present his reasons for theism. Not his feelings; not his beliefs; but his reasons. It is quite simple and it is quite obvious. For myself I propose to say nothing more until he does.

Yrreg so far as I am concerned the floor is yours: in your own time...
 
It doesn't. The only thing which would be relevant would be for Yrreg to present his reasons for theism. Not his feelings; not his beliefs; but his reasons. It is quite simple and it is quite obvious. For myself I propose to say nothing more until he does.

Yrreg so far as I am concerned the floor is yours: in your own time...

Or do like I did, insist on quid pro quo. He answers one of your questions, you answer one of his.

Without a system like that, we'll never get anywhere with Yrreg.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom