Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

Here we go again.

I like to ask atheists here:


1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?
​

Define 'prove', if you mean YOUR idea of proving, which mainly involves ignoring everything that is said to you unless it matches your forgone conclusion then probably not, if you mean that god made him/herself known to the world in a physical, tangible sense then it would be foolish to say that he does not exist.


2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​


Yrreg

See conditions above, else no.
 
Those who answer yes to 1 and 2, shall we work together on the how?
Yrreg

1. Strictly define your terms, to eliminate the possibility for errors of equivocation.

2. Come up with a doable experiment (which is not "thought experiments" a.k.a. woolgathering, speculation, and convoluted rationalisations for what you want to be true) that will address all or part of the question.

3. Do the experiment, with proper controls and protocols to eliminate all the errors by which we fool ourselves.

4. Accept what the results show, whether it agrees with what we want to be true or not.
 
For me, all it would require is for GMOE to appear before me, answer a few simple questions, and re-arrange the stars to spell out a sweet message for the missus.

Done deal.
 
The questions are:
1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

​



1. Yes.
2. Yes, an atheist can find evidence for the existence of a god or gods on his or her own. Bit redundant, isn't it?



I understand, Foster, that you used to be a Christian, a believer in God, but now you are an atheist.


Still you answer yes to the first question and yes to the second question.


Can you explain yourself?

Or you find nothing or no reason or no need whatever to explain, at least to yourself?

Or to the God of the Christian faith of which you used to be a professed adherent?





Yrreg
 
Those who answer yes to 1 and 2, shall we work together on the how?


Ah, so you are referring to your hypothetical atheist in question 2. Darn, I was hoping the "himself" referred to your god, as that would be a far more interesting question.

Anyway, regarding the "how", since you are apparently talking about proving it to a single, specific atheist rather than all atheists in general, it is even easier than the methods discussed by the other posters. Simply induce a stroke or epileptic seizure at a specific location and time in the atheist's brain, and there is a good chance he or she will believe in the existence of your type of god. The brain is a funny thing, and is susceptible to damage and being fooled (or fooling itself), which is why the scientific method and critical thinking are so important in understanding the whats and whys of the universe as it really is, rather than how we want it to be.
 
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists

Dang it, I got to the thread late!

1. yes
2. yes, if I'm understanding you correctly.
 
Anyway, regarding the "how", since you are apparently talking about proving it to a single, specific atheist rather than all atheists in general, it is even easier than the methods discussed by the other posters. Simply induce a stroke or epileptic seizure at a specific location and time in the atheist's brain, and there is a good chance he or she will believe in the existence of your type of god. The brain is a funny thing, and is susceptible to damage and being fooled (or fooling itself), which is why the scientific method and critical thinking are so important in understanding the whats and whys of the universe as it really is, rather than how we want it to be.


So belief in God can be a result of possession of a damaged brain?
 
Are you trying to get me infracted, O agent of Satan? ;)


But seriously, yes, it can. Then again, extraordinary musical talent can also be a result of possession of a damaged brain, so take that how you will.


I know some very talented musicians, and you could be onto something there.
 
Those who answer yes to 1 and 2, shall we work together on the how?

I can already see in your responses that you are assuming anyone who answered yes to both questions believes in a god. I answered yes because it is true in the same way that it is possible to convince an atheist that there is an invisible pink unicorn riding a teakettle around planet X. Evidence is all it takes.

But you've never presented such evidence in any of your many threads. So no thanks, I'm not interested in working with you to manufacture some.
 
The questions are:

1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
Thanks! It's been so long that I'd forgotten.


I understand, Foster, that you used to be a Christian, a believer in God, but now you are an atheist.
That is correct.

Still you answer yes to the first question and yes to the second question.
That is also correct.

Can you explain yourself?
I found that the claims of evidence in favor of the existence of the Christian god were logically flawed. I also came to realize that the claims regarding the existence of all gods were similarly flawed. The total lack of evidence for the existence of any gods has led me to lack belief in gods as anything other than a human imaginary construct. However, if actual evidence that met proper scientific standards were to show that some form of god or gods exist then I will possess as much belief in said god or gods as I do in electricity or stars. But I will not play semantic games such as defining "god" as the physics that define the function of nature.
 
The questions are:
1. Is it possible to prove to an atheist that God maker of everything exists?

2. And is it possible for himself to prove to himself that God maker of everything exists?
​

​



Before anything else we have to -- that is you anyone and everyone who answer yes to 1 and yes to 2 -- determine whether an atheist has the capability for cognitive certainty.


That means that he is intelligent and also psychologically receptive to proof for the attainment of certainty.


How do we determine that an atheist is intelligent and is psychologically receptive to proof?






Yrreg
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom