Pennsylvania Man Claims to Burn Salt Water

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&lr=&newwindow=1&safe=off&q=Rustum+Roy&btnG=Search

I never heard of Rustum Roy before this. Seems to have a lot of science stuff published. In real science magazines, like, Science, Nature, Journal of Materials Research, all sorts of valid stuff. Why is he considered so woo by you?

I can't seem to find any crazy writings from him. What is the deal?

Maybe you need to read what he's written in rags like 'Homeopathy', preferably after a good grounding in chemistry. He writes utter nonsense backed up by faulty experiments to 'prove' his wishful thinking. Then he rants at the reviewers of serious publications who tell him what to do with his stuff. What is worse, he tries to undermine classic chemsitry teaching by saying that new findings contradict it. That means that either :

a) He has utterly no understanding of how science works

b) He is being very dishonest for the sake of self-publicity

Personnally, having not met him, I can't decide between the two. From having read his homeopathy crap, I have concluded that he has very poor understanding of basic chemistry concepts, like thermodynamic equilibrium, hydrogen bonding, ect.

Having work published in one specialty does not make you an expert in other fields. Linus Pauling did promote quack cures for cancer, also using faulty experimental design, even if he was an excellent chemist.

It is said that only 1% of people have the capacity to become experts in different scientific fields. Those two aren't, and so far most scientists (including very high level ones) I know have confirmed this saying for me.

the Kemist
 
I don't really care about Rustum Roy. I find the burning salt water fascinating. Forget any over unity crap, running sterling engines off of the heat, or the other smoke screens.

I want to know what happens when you put blood in that field. Or an animal. What if you direct that frequency into a large body of salt water? Immerse the antennae? What is the power output? What kind of parabolic reflector is he using? If we are seeing sodium in the flame, does that mean some sodium ions are being lost to the solution?

Has anyone here ever tried to get a steady flame from hydroxegen? Browns Gas, whatever you call it? The hydrogen goes POP! All at once, there is no steady burning. How is that machine allowing a steady release and burn of hydrogen? From salt water?

No really. Usually any hydrogen, (especially mixed with oxygen), burns so fast you have to keep adding a flame source or spark. How is that flame staying lit?

Is it really a 3000K flame?
 
Has anyone here ever tried to get a steady flame from hydroxegen? Browns Gas, whatever you call it?
I haven't personally, but I've seen it done, and it is in reasonably widespread use. "Water torches" are used by jewelers; running the thing off electrolysis saves having to keep gas cylinders around.

The hydrogen goes POP! All at once, there is no steady burning.
:rolleyes:

Yeah, a free stoichiometric mixture of hydrogen and oxygen will go POP. A free stoichiometric mixture of butane and oxygen will go BANG! A controlled stream of either will burn steadily.

How is that machine allowing a steady release and burn of hydrogen? From salt water?
I dunno - electrolysis, maybe?

No really. Usually any hydrogen, (especially mixed with oxygen), burns so fast you have to keep adding a flame source or spark.
Baloney.

Is it really a 3000K flame?
No idea.
 
I don't really care about Rustum Roy. I find the burning salt water fascinating. Forget any over unity crap, running sterling engines off of the heat, or the other smoke screens.

I want to know what happens when you put blood in that field. Or an animal. What if you direct that frequency into a large body of salt water? Immerse the antennae? What is the power output? What kind of parabolic reflector is he using? If we are seeing sodium in the flame, does that mean some sodium ions are being lost to the solution?

Has anyone here ever tried to get a steady flame from hydroxegen? Browns Gas, whatever you call it? The hydrogen goes POP! All at once, there is no steady burning. How is that machine allowing a steady release and burn of hydrogen? From salt water?

No really. Usually any hydrogen, (especially mixed with oxygen), burns so fast you have to keep adding a flame source or spark. How is that flame staying lit?

Is it really a 3000K flame?

Yes, Brown's gas will burn constant. I used a BG torch (aka water torch) and found it to have unusual characteristics; very small flame, but when contacting the material to be welded/cut, it gets extremely hot and burned through everything we threw at it, even bricks.

Some people have a problem when new discoveries are made serendipitously by "non-credentialed" amateurs outside the orthodoxy. Professionals in any field tend to dismiss outsiders out of hand especially when they can't explain the phenomenon. I ignore them.

Some of the greatest inventions ever conceived and discoveries came from those with no formal education.

Usually any hydrogen, (especially mixed with oxygen), burns so fast you have to keep adding a flame source or spark.
That is one reason why BG increases fuel mileage in an ICE.

I disagree with you on the PIH/EV issue, but in this case I think you have a valid point.
 
I don't really care about Rustum Roy. I find the burning salt water fascinating. Forget any over unity crap, running sterling engines off of the heat, or the other smoke screens.

I don't agree that what is happening is "burning." I think the explanation is fairly simple. It's an RF induced partial plasma of dissasociated H, O and possibly Cl and Na initiated by a sufficiently high E gradient at the surface of the salt water column. The salt water simply creates a much lower impedance path for the HF increasing the E field at the boundry which makes initiating the partial plasma easier.
 
As I understand it, he patented using RF to create catalytic action without a physical catalyst present, which "scientist" claimed is impossible, (of course). It might be what is occurring in the test tube. If so, this is without a doubt, some of the most amazing stuff to come along in a while. If you can electrolyze salt water with no physical contact, and no catalyst, it open the door for a whole lot of interesting and unknown stuff. And the patent holder is going to either get rich, or ripped off.

It isn't hard to see why most "scientist" simply don't believe what is being shown in the video. It has to be fake. You simply can't do that. If you can induce salt water to break apart with radio (or lower) frequencies, the entire Universe as we know it, starts to change.

Or so it would seem.

Not really. There are hundreds of references in microwave chemistry describing reactions which needed catalysts in conventional settings but don't need them with microwave heating. So it would seem that this 'scientist' is not very well informed.

the Kemist
 
Last edited:
Not really. There are hundreds of references in microwave chemistry describing reactions which needed catalysts in conventional settings but don't need them with microwave heating. So it would seem that this 'scientist' is not very well informed.

the Kemist

I'm guessing it is not microwave RF. Not in that open, unshielded environment that isn't conducive to hi-Q standing waves. Lower RF freqs are more easily controlled. One can have high, near field, E values and have rapid dropoff with distance. An 10MHz RF field creating that plasma wouldn't worry me observing it nearby. Not so if it was microwave.
 
Some people have a problem when new discoveries are made serendipitously by "non-credentialed" amateurs outside the orthodoxy. Professionals in any field tend to dismiss outsiders out of hand especially when they can't explain the phenomenon. I ignore them.
The problem is that it doesn't make any sense. The entire radio spectrum is being used in many different applications. Someone should have discovered this long before he did. I also find it odd that it was a supposed cancer treatment.
 
Last edited:
And at the end of the day, none of it matters. It takes more energy to seperate hydrogen than you will get from burning that seperated hydrogen.

It is the same brick wall we run into with all these new "alternative" fuels. I think what Robert Park said some years back about alternative medicine applies to alternative fuels as well. He said: "The reason they are called alternative medicines is because they don't work. If they worked, we would just call them medicine."
 
The problem is that it doesn't make any sense. The entire radio spectrum is being used in many different applications. Someone should have discovered this long before he did. I also find it odd that it was a supposed cancer treatment.

What doesn't make any sense is that this should be seen as remarkable at all. There is nothing unusual about creating a plasma from HF AC. The recombining of H and O ions as a result is inevitable. That it appears as some sort of "flame" is interesting but not surprising.

However, though explicitly not claiming net energy production, the allusion to burning and unlimited amounts of sea water is misleading to say the least.
 
Some people have a problem when new discoveries are made serendipitously by "non-credentialed" amateurs outside the orthodoxy. Professionals in any field tend to dismiss outsiders out of hand especially when they can't explain the phenomenon. I ignore them.

Some of the greatest inventions ever conceived and discoveries came from those with no formal education.

Quite true. I've been digging around in the past. If this stands up to replication, (it is already underway), it is astounding. It also might explain a few anomalies in other areas.

I disagree with you on the PIH/EV issue, but in this case I think you have a valid point.

I'm not sure which point you are speaking of, but thanks.

What doesn't make any sense is that this should be seen as remarkable at all.

I'm guessing most people will think that way. Because most people don't understand what this means, or how novel it woulod be, if it turns out to be for real.


Rustum Roy, a Penn State University chemist, held a demonstration last week at the university's Materials Research Laboratory in State College, to confirm what he'd witnessed weeks before in an Erie lab.

"It's true, it works," Dr. Roy said. "Everyone told me, 'Rustum, don't be fooled. He put electrodes in there.' "

But there are no electrodes and no gimmicks, he said.

Dr. Roy said the salt water isn't burning per se, despite appearances. The radio frequency actually weakens bonds holding together the constituents of salt water -- sodium chloride, hydrogen and oxygen -- and releases the hydrogen, which, once ignited, burns continuously when exposed to the RF energy field. Mr. Kanzius said an independent source measured the flame's temperature, which exceeds 3,000 degrees Fahrenheit, reflecting an enormous energy output.

As such, Dr. Roy, a founding member of the Materials Research Laboratory and expert in water structure, said Mr. Kanzius' discovery represents "the most remarkable in water science in 100 years."

But researching its potential will take time and money, he said. One immediate question is energy efficiency: The energy the RF generator uses vs. the energy output from burning hydrogen.

Dr. Roy said he's scheduled to meet tomorrow with U.S. Department of Energy and Department of Defense officials in Washington to discuss the discovery and seek research funding.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/07252/815920-85.stm

Interesting. I have to agree with Dr. Roy, you have to have electrodes to get electrolysis. If I hadn't seen video of this, and an AP report, I still wouldn't believe it.

There is a much better chance this is a scam, than the fact of RF creating hydrogen and oxygen from salt water.

Again, please PLEASE please forget about over unity and free energy. That crap sounds like the invention of the News reporters and other woos. It isn't true, it will not be true, it can't be true.

But if salt water electrolysis is taking place, without electrodes, that is astounding.
 
Quite true. I've been digging around in the past. If this stands up to replication, (it is already underway), it is astounding. It also might explain a few anomalies in other areas.

Why do you think this would be astounding:
1. Generate AC at, say 10MHz at high voltage, high impedance
2. Arrange a tube of salt water capacitively coupled to one source.
3. Arrange the other source as metal plates around the mouth of the tube at enough of a distance that the highest E field gradient by far is around the mouth of the tube holding the salt water. Set the AC voltage sufficiently high to disassociate the various molecules in the air including N2, O2, NaCl and H2O.

Turn on. Observe "flame" (The small amount of Na is the trick. It's far more luminous emitting lots of visible light as their energy state drops)


Again, please PLEASE please forget about over unity and free energy. That crap sounds like the invention of the News reporters and other woos. It isn't true, it will not be true, it can't be true.

But if salt water electrolysis is taking place, without electrodes, that is astounding.

Sure, I agree. Now if the guy that was doing it hadn't talked about all the water in the sea with all that suggests.... Well, nothing like taking in a few investors. He may not be doing that but that is the typical pattern.
 
You might want to check out this post I made:

http://depletedcranium.com/?p=106

One of the visitors to the site made a comment pointing out that what is going on seems to be indicative NOT of hydrogen production but rather of the thermal decomposition of sodium chloride, with the sodium reacting. Look at the video and read what he said and it seems that this "discovery" is not only not a means of producing energy, but it isn't even a good way of making hydrogen

Also on Rustum Roy. I have links to some of his stuff here: http://depletedcranium.com/?p=105

Not only is he into the "Whole body healing sciences" he's a homeopath and is into some BS called "Science guided by religion."

Excellent. I think that's exactly what's happening. I missed this post earlier.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom