Pennsylvania Man Claims to Burn Salt Water

Electrolysis is huge for producing hydrogen gas.

No, it is huge for producing a lot of things, but hydrogen is a small market. However, the electrolysis of salt water is used for sodium hydroxide and chlorine, (the two main products of electrolysis of salt water). The hydrogen isn't the most important product at all. If this were a new, and energy efficient process to do electrolysis of salt water, it is nothing less than earth shaking, economics wise. As I said, it doesn't seem to be this at all. Of course without analysis of the gas and salt water after the RF, nobody can say.

There is no science here because there is no data.

Nonsense. Using RF to cause salt water electrolysis is astounding new science. We don't know (yet) if it is hydrogen and oxygen, or hydrogen and chlorine, or hydrogen, oxygen, chlorine being burned, but no matter what it turns out to be, it is new science. It is a huge discovery. Ignore the dumb claim it overturns the laws of physics, free energy, that crap. Look at what is happening. Electromagnetic energy is turning sodium chloride and water into hydrogen, and something else. This is unheard of. No kidding. Somebody figured out something completely new and unknown until now. (Unless the video and testimony is all fake, doubtful at this point).

If this is for real, (never mind the "free energy crap"), it is new. A discovery.

So according to him, it's the hydrogen, not the sodium, that is burning.

If that is the case, and it was reported earlier by another lab that it is hydrogen, it is really amazing. Getting just hydrogen from salt water is a completely novel concept. No other method of electrolysis can do this.

... So this really is a non-story after all? (Or at least a story on how lacking the press is on scientific news coverage?)

It is a story, it just isn't about the real science of the matter.

This nonsense about free energy is dumb. The real story is about using RF to break molecular bonds in salt water. Every claim for this in the past has been considered either a scam or just bad science, or a con job.

If this isn't a scam, it is something new in science.
 
The thing that cracks me up is that time and time again so-called journalists fall for these claims as being the panacea.


The bitter fact is a lot of Journalists are incredbly ignorant of science.
How much of it is ignorance and how much is "we don't care if it's crap we will put it on the air anyway" is debatable,but I get the feeling that a lot of it is genuine ignorance
 
Nonsense. Using RF to cause salt water electrolysis is astounding new science. We don't know (yet) if it is hydrogen and oxygen, or hydrogen and chlorine, or hydrogen, oxygen, chlorine being burned, but no matter what it turns out to be, it is new science. It is a huge discovery. Ignore the dumb claim it overturns the laws of physics, free energy, that crap. Look at what is happening. Electromagnetic energy is turning sodium chloride and water into hydrogen, and something else. This is unheard of. No kidding. Somebody figured out something completely new and unknown until now. (Unless the video and testimony is all fake, doubtful at this point).


Massive energy influx causes molecular breakdown. Film at 11.


Gosh, too bad a real scientist didn't spend 5 minutes with a cheap spectrometer and a Seal-A-Meal to capture and analyze the outflow. I guess we'll have to wait for the new suckers ... uh, I mean investors, to pony up a few dollars before we can see the next report on this earth shattering discovery.
 
I can't believe people fall for this crap, and then I remember - this is what journalism has descended to :rolleyes:
 
Here's a rather crude animation of what I think is happening:

tubeemf.gif


Basically if he puts enough high power rf field energy into salt water, which is a decent coductor there will be an "antenna" effect, causing charges within the water.

I really don't think there is anything "huge" considering that it creates a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen which is dangerous as hell to store and dangerous to seperate and that it is almost certainly throwing some sodium and sodium hydroxide and chlorine gas into the mix. Not to mention the massive amount of energy needed.
 
Basically if he puts enough high power rf field energy into salt water, which is a decent conductor there will be an "antenna" effect, causing charges within the water.

Dr Buzzo, it is good to see some scientific thought on this. Assuming the video and other "evidence" isn't some scam, we are watching something that just is not explainable by current scientific understanding. As you realize it seems. RF inducing current flow in salt water? And electrolysis occurring without an anode or cathode? WTF? How is that possible?

Where are the electrons coming from? RF is photons, not electrons. Where are the electrons coming from to produce the current? And what is acting as the anode? The cathode? You don't get hydrogen from water without electricity. That is the energy that is used to measure electrolysis!

Faraday's 1st Law of Electrolysis

The mass of a substance produced at an electrode during electrolysis is proportional to the number of moles of electrons (the quantity of electricity) transferred at that electrode.

This is as basic as it gets. The mass is connected to the electricity used. RF is not electricity. I'm thinking those plates he puts the test tube between are cathode and anode, not an antenna. It isn't RF, it is electricity flowing between the plates, Not RF.

Faraday's 2nd Law of Electrolysis
The number of Faradays of electric charge required to discharge one mole of substance at an electrode is equal to the number of "excess" elementary charges on that ion.

If it is just RF causing this, then something is seriously whack here.

Perhaps he has found some way of creating a virtual cathode/anode situation, which is still pretty amazing. That he has salt water electrolysis occurring without a physical anode and cathode touching the water. But is this the case? If that were true, he would be generating hydrogen and chlorine, which are far more dangerous than hydroxygen. Hydrogen and chlorine burn like crazy, forming hydrochloric acid. Is that what is happening? If not, is the chlorine building up in the water? Is the oxygen being released? Or forming sodium hydroxide? Frustrating not being able to try this at home. :D

Watching that video raises far more important questions than can it be used to run a friggin motor, or get free energy, or whatever. Yes, the News agencies don't seem to have a clue.

I really don't think there is anything "huge" considering that it creates a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen which is dangerous as hell to store and dangerous to separate and that it is almost certainly throwing some sodium and sodium hydroxide and chlorine gas into the mix. Not to mention the massive amount of energy needed.

Forget the energy required, we don't know what is even happening here. Is the salt water only giving up hydrogen AND oxygen? How much sodium is also burning? Is it sodium giving it that yellow color? (hydrogen and oxygen produce a clear flame) Is it just hydrogen? If so, what is happening to the oxygen? Is chlorine is also being released, along with oxygen? If sodium hydroxide is not being produced, if oxygen, hydrogen and chlorine is being formed, then is it isolating the sodium in the water. WTF? If hydrogen, oxygen, and chlorine are being released as a gas, then sodium is being concentrated in water??? How is THAT happening? How can that even happen?

A lot of questions, based on a video with no analysis of either the gas or what is left in the tube. It sure looks like salt water is creating a flame, with no physical contact from an electrical current. Amazing.

But is it true?
 
Last edited:
Where are the electrons coming from? RF is photons, not electrons. Where are the electrons coming from to produce the current? And what is acting as the anode? The cathode? You don't get hydrogen from water without electricity.

It is also a powerful electric field. Electro-magnetic radiation, remember?

If that were true, he would be generating hydrogen and chlorine, which are far more dangerous than hydroxygen.
That depends- what's the overvoltage in an electrodeless system? Water is easier to oxidize than the chloride ion; you often get chlorine forming in electrolysis because there is an overvoltage for the formation of oxygen (i.e., it's thermodynamically favourable, but is a lot slower than the alternative).

Hydrogen and chlorine burn like crazy, forming hydrochloric acid. Is that what is happening? If not, is the chlorine building up in the water? Is the oxygen being released? Or forming sodium hydroxide? Frustrating not being able to try this at home.
Well, chlorine is quite soluble in water, so it's possible that it's building up (if it's forming at all).

Forget the energy required, we don't know what is even happening here. Is the salt water only giving up hydrogen AND oxygen? How much sodium is also burning? Is it sodium giving it that yellow color? (hydrogen and oxygen produce a clear flame)

Yes, it is sodium giving the flame that yellow colour. That DOES NOT mean that the sodium itself is burning- it's just that the gas that's formed is carrying a lot of solution with it, and the sodium ions in solution are enough to change the colour of the flames. Sodium does not have to be in the elemental state in order to change the colour of the flame, and there is no way in rule18 that you'll form metallic sodium from an aqueous solution, unless you've got a mercury electrode there to extract the sodium as it's being formed.

If sodium hydroxide is not being produced, if oxygen, hydrogen and chlorine is being formed, then is it isolating the sodium in the water. WTF? If hydrogen, oxygen, and chlorine are being released as a gas, then sodium is being concentrated in water???
Now you're starting to sound like a woo.

Something must be formed along with the hydrogen.

If it is oxygen, then no other products will be formed.

If it is chlorine (which is possible), then sodium hydroxide will also be formed.

If it's a mixture of chlorine and oxygen, then you'll get -some- sodium hydroxide being formed.

But you won't be forming any sodium metal.
 
The use of microwaves in chemistry is not a new thing. They can also be used to melt metals and salts. We even have a specially built microwave oven in my lab for chemical reactions.

Without actual data on the actual temperature, power and pressure used, I can't tell exactly what is happening in the solution. But I can tell you this guy is not very careful with his life. Playing around with chemistry and microwave is quite risky, and the first labs to do so had daily explosions. We had a couple in our own lab, but our equipment is made to handle them.

For my part, I do not think that what is happening is electrolysis. From fooling around in microwave chemistry, I have encountered a quirky phenomenon called "hot spot". It is what causes one side of your meal to be boiling and the other part to be still cold when you reheat it in a microwave. That happens because microwaves will cancel each other in some places, add up in other places due to the reflectiveness and shape of the inside of the oven. By shaping a reflective surface in a certain way, you can obtain a very concentrated hot spot, and when applied to a substance that absorbs microwaves, such as water, you can obtain incredible temperatures locally. Some unusual reactions can take place in just that spot.

the Kemist
 
I noticed that the flame isn't burning like a normal flame. I find it fascinating that this was just an accidental discovery, the real cool part is the cancer killing ability of these frequencies, combined with nanoparticles.
I noticed he isn't claiming over unity.

The skeptics who will agree that it is possible to burn salt water - and there are plenty who won't even go that far - argue that at best the energy required to burn it would be greater than the energy produced by burning it.

Kanzius admits that is the case now in this very early stage of development.

But he add that he never claimed this would replace oil. In fact, he says only that his discovery is "thought provoking."

Remember, this was nothing but a fascinating accident in his search for a cancer cure.
http://www.firstcoastnews.com/news/mostpopular/news-article.aspx?storyid=85990&provider=top

I also noticed that he gets a flame using a paper towel as a wick. What is up with that? It really does look like it is salt water burning, rather than hydrogen gas.

Man, I want one of those RF generators. If you can make salt water burn, think of what you could do with really dangerous solutions. :D
 
Last edited:
From fooling around in microwave chemistry, I have encountered a quirky phenomenon called "hot spot". It is what causes one side of your meal to be boiling and the other part to be still cold when you reheat it in a microwave. That happens because microwaves will cancel each other in some places, add up in other places due to the reflectiveness and shape of the inside of the oven.

One experiment I did a few years ago with my students was fill a microwave oven with Jell-O and let it set. The Jell-O had a pigment that changed red when it cooked. The clear Jell-O had a pattern that revealed that the waves were interfering. It worked better than I had expected.
 
BTW: I've looked into some other reports and I don't think this thing is microwave-based. It looks more like it's in the HF range (under 50Mhz). That would explain why there would not be as much noticable heating and how it might cause electrical effects on a brine solution
 
Philip Ball, who writes for Nature, has just covered it.

http://www.nature.com/news/2007/070910/full/070910-13.html

He offers up such gems as these:

It's easy to scoff, but if the effect is genuine then it is also genuinely intriguing. Plain tap water apparently doesn't work, but test tubes of salt water can be seen burning merrily with a bright yellow flame in the radiofrequency field. The idea, articulated with varying degrees of vagueness in news reports when they bother to think about such things at all, is that the field is somehow dissociating water into oxygen and hydrogen. Why salt should be essential to this process is far from obvious. You might think that someone would raise that question.

But no one does. No one raises any questions at all. The reports offer a testament to the awesome lack of enquiry and critical thought that makes news media everywhere quite terrifyingly defenceless against bogus science.

His best guess as to what it is? Brown's gas.
 
Another perpetual motion machine is what it sounds like, and the flaws have been explained above; but it does bring to mind something related that I also saw on TV recently, but sounds a lot more sensible. It was a stable metal alloy reaction with water that released hydrogen while combining with the oxygen.

The point being that it amounted to a safe and efficient method of storing energy in the form of "virtual" hydrogen if you will. Just add water to the car and then run it on hydrogen. Reconstitute the metal catalyst when needed and so on.

I can't remember the numbers, but it sounded plausible.
 
BTW: I've looked into some other reports and I don't think this thing is microwave-based. It looks more like it's in the HF range (under 50Mhz). That would explain why there would not be as much noticeable heating and how it might cause electrical effects on a brine solution

There is nothing in current scientific knowledge that explains how ANY electromagnetic radiation can turn salt water into something that burns like crazy. It just isn't possible. As far as we know. It doesn't matter if it is sound or X-rays, there isn't any known mechanism to use vibrational energy of any kind to turn salt water into something that burns.

You have to use electricity or a catalyst. No other method is known to science.

.. I also saw on TV recently, but sounds a lot more sensible. It was a stable metal alloy reaction with water that released hydrogen while combining with the oxygen.

The point being that it amounted to a safe and efficient method of storing energy in the form of "virtual" hydrogen if you will. Just add water to the car and then run it on hydrogen. Reconstitute the metal catalyst when needed and so on.

I can't remember the numbers, but it sounded plausible.

It is aluminum and gallium. It was discovered in 1967.
http://www.physorg.com/news98556080.html
 
Nonsense. Using RF to cause salt water electrolysis is astounding new science. We don't know (yet) if it is hydrogen and oxygen, or hydrogen and chlorine, or hydrogen, oxygen, chlorine being burned, but no matter what it turns out to be, it is new science. It is a huge discovery. Ignore the dumb claim it overturns the laws of physics, free energy, that crap. Look at what is happening. Electromagnetic energy is turning sodium chloride and water into hydrogen, and something else. This is unheard of. No kidding. Somebody figured out something completely new and unknown until now. (Unless the video and testimony is all fake, doubtful at this point).

If this is for real, (never mind the "free energy crap"), it is new. A discovery.


You can do it with UV radition at 254nm. Not very efficient and inverse square law would suck on any attempt to scale up.
 
I think UV produces hydrogen peroxide from water, not hydrogen. H2O2 produces oxygen on decomposition, but not hydrogen. There could be some research I don't know about. Do you have links to any studies on this? It would be new to my knowledge.
 
I think UV produces hydrogen peroxide from water, not hydrogen. H2O2 produces oxygen on decomposition, but not hydrogen. There could be some research I don't know about. Do you have links to any studies on this? It would be new to my knowledge.

The breakdown is to a H. + HO.

I would expect you to get some hydrogen out of it if you threw enough energy at it.
 
There is nothing in current scientific knowledge that explains how ANY electromagnetic radiation can turn salt water into something that burns like crazy. It just isn't possible. As far as we know. It doesn't matter if it is sound or X-rays, there isn't any known mechanism to use vibrational energy of any kind to turn salt water into something that burns.

You have to use electricity or a catalyst. No other method is known to science.



It is aluminum and gallium. It was discovered in 1967.
http://www.physorg.com/news98556080.html

When you apply an electromagnetic field to a conductor, eddy currents form in the conductor. Salt water is a conductor. Thus, no surprise that electrolysis can occur.

Other methods would be simply heating the water. Eventually, it dissociates into hydrogen and oxygen.

Incidentally, catalysts don't allow processes that would otherwise never occur. They simply lower energy barriers to make the process more convenient or practical.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom