Pennsylvania Man Claims to Burn Salt Water

The breakdown is to a H. + HO.

I would expect you to get some hydrogen out of it if you threw enough energy at it.

I'm asking you where are you getting this from? Hydrogen peroxide does not break down to form Hydrogen. There is no known way to get hydrogen using just radiation.

When you apply an electromagnetic field to a conductor, eddy currents form in the conductor. Salt water is a conductor. Thus, no surprise that electrolysis can occur.

Oh it is a surprise. I'm still skeptical this is even what is happening.

Other methods would be simply heating the water. Eventually, it dissociates into hydrogen and oxygen.

Yeah, if you can build something that can contain water or steam at that pressure, very dangerous situation. I think around 3000K water does experience thermal decomposition, but guess what immediately happens to hydrogen and oxygen at 3000K? Yep. It turns back into water. Is heating water in a high pressure container, a very expensive container, using electromagnetic radiation to produce electrolysis? No. Unless you count heat and pressure as EM, and thermal decomposition as electrolysis, in which case I would be wrong. :)

Incidentally, catalysts don't allow processes that would otherwise never occur. They simply lower energy barriers to make the process more convenient or practical.

Indeed. Which is interesting. This patent from 2003 claims:
A method of using radio frequency waves to imitate the presence of a catalyst and artificially create catalytic action in a catalyst-free chemical
http://www.freepatentsonline.com/20040099523.html

As I understand it, he patented using RF to create catalytic action without a physical catalyst present, which "scientist" claimed is impossible, (of course). It might be what is occurring in the test tube. If so, this is without a doubt, some of the most amazing stuff to come along in a while. If you can electrolyze salt water with no physical contact, and no catalyst, it open the door for a whole lot of interesting and unknown stuff. And the patent holder is going to either get rich, or ripped off.

It isn't hard to see why most "scientist" simply don't believe what is being shown in the video. It has to be fake. You simply can't do that. If you can induce salt water to break apart with radio (or lower) frequencies, the entire Universe as we know it, starts to change.

Or so it would seem.
 
I'm asking you where are you getting this from? Hydrogen peroxide does not break down to form Hydrogen. There is no known way to get hydrogen using just radiation.

Wasn't talking about Hydrogen peroxide.

http://www.millipore.com/publications.nsf/docs/5a5j28

Some of those H. radicals are going to combien. Would expect most to interact with water molicules mind although the obvious routes there would appear either to kick out hydrogen and an OH. radical or an H. radical
 
Wasn't talking about Hydrogen peroxide.

http://www.millipore.com/publications.nsf/docs/5a5j28

Some of those H. radicals are going to combien[sic]. Would expect most to interact with water molicules[sic] mind although the obvious routes there would appear either to kick out hydrogen and an OH. radical or an H. radical

No, there will be no elemental hydrogen created from these reactions. It doesn't work like that.
 
Last edited:
From "What's New" by Robert L. Parks

1. WARNING! TURN OFF THE RADAR BEFORE THE OCEAN IGNITES.

All week long I’ve been getting URLs, for which I’m grateful, about some guy in Erie, PA who discovered a way to burn salt water. It’s an AP story, but the warning signs are all there: Described as a "cancer researcher," the protagonist built an RF generator with the idea of killing cancers by heating metallic nanoparticles injected into the cancer. I guarantee that it’s possible to kill cancers with RF, along with the host. Anyway, he’s not exactly a cancer researcher, he’s a retired TV station engineer who discovered that retirement sucks - but that’s been discovered before. He then decided to see if his RF generator would desalinate water, but when he tried the water caught on fire. He needed a scientist. Instead, he found Rustum Roy, an emeritus chemistry professor at Penn State, who called it "the most remarkable discovery in water science in 100 years." That would include "polywater," which Roy fell for 40 years ago. Roy said that RF weakens chemical bonds, releasing hydrogen which burns. It’s the Bush "hydrogen initiative" fallacy again http://bobpark.physics.umd.edu/WN03/wn013103.html . Must I now lecture a chemistry professor on thermodynamics? More energy is needed to free hydrogen than you get by burning it. The story was shunned by major news outlets, except, of course, Fox News, which did point out that Rustum Roy is also "a specialist in holistic medicine and Christian sexuality."
 
Man, I want one of those RF generators. If you can make salt water burn, think of what you could do with really dangerous solutions. :D

You've got one. It's called a microwave oven. If you want to see something dangerous happen, just put anything flammable, in a closed bottle, with a little piece of metal in it. Any metal, aluminum foil will do. Now if you can start if with a remote, from a far, protected place, that would be better for you continued existence with all of your limbs. Microwaves can heat up metals to thousand degrees in a few seconds.

the Kemist
 
One experiment I did a few years ago with my students was fill a microwave oven with Jell-O and let it set. The Jell-O had a pigment that changed red when it cooked. The clear Jell-O had a pattern that revealed that the waves were interfering. It worked better than I had expected.

That's a cool experiment for wave physics. And also a nice way to map hot spots in a food microwave for chemistry:D. Not every lab has the funds to buy the specially built monomode machines (they cost 25000$ plus). I did use an ordinary food microwave for my first experiments. You could put that in a paper, you know !

the Kemist
 
That's a cool experiment for wave physics. And also a nice way to map hot spots in a food microwave for chemistry:D. Not every lab has the funds to buy the specially built monomode machines (they cost 25000$ plus). I did use an ordinary food microwave for my first experiments. You could put that in a paper, you know !

the Kemist


The usual microwave oven medium is chocolate.

Do a Google search for "Measuring the speed of light with chocolate".
 
"This is the most abundant element in the world. It is everywhere," Roy said.
I don't know if he was referring to hydrogen or water, but either way with statements like that he doesn't deserve to call himself a chemist.
 
No, there will be no elemental hydrogen created from these reactions. It doesn't work like that.

Why? it would appear to be a fairly standard termination reaction.
 
I don't know if he was referring to hydrogen or water, but either way with statements like that he doesn't deserve to call himself a chemist.

Somehow I find that putting 'Rustum Roy' and 'chemist' in the same sentence is quite insulting to me.

the Kemist
 
I visited Mr. Kanzius’ lab in Erie, PA and confirmed for myself the demonstrations which he is seen performing in the original video clip from the Cleveland TV Station. In addition, Mr. Kanzius brought his relatively simple equipment to our (microwave) lab in the Materials Research Lab at Penn State for the day. He explained his work, and the process was demonstrated before some dozen senior faculty and research personnel from various departments using our personnel, chemicals and glassware.

It is clear that Mr. Kanzius has demonstrated the ability to dissociate aqueous solutions of sodium chloride at normal sea water concentrations into hydrogen and oxygen. Of course, it is the hydrogen and oxygen (emerging from the water) which are being burned in the video, not the water or NaCl.
http://www.rustumroy.com/response_to_email.htm
 
Oh it is a surprise. I'm still skeptical this is even what is happening.
Why? The same possibility occurred to me. Seems plausible, if horribly inefficient.

Indeed. Which is interesting. This patent from 2003 claims:

http://www.freepatentsonline.com/20040099523.html
Gak. That reads like a cross between microwave chemistry and sympathetic magic.

It isn't hard to see why most "scientist" simply don't believe what is being shown in the video. It has to be fake. You simply can't do that. If you can induce salt water to break apart with radio (or lower) frequencies, the entire Universe as we know it, starts to change.

Or so it would seem.
No-one else seems to think this. All the responses I've seen are "Yes, he's doing electrolysis. What's the efficiency like?"
 
Rustum Roy?

Do you also want to get John Edward, Bob Lazar, Sylvia Browne, Peter Popoff, Uri Gellar and John Hutchenson to weigh in on this while you're at it?
In all fairness, what Professor Roy said in that response is straightforward and reasonable. It's just everything else he's said that's crazy.
 
Professor Roy is a respected materials science researcher (mainly ceramics) with a huge publication history. He is - at the same time - a crank who believes in water memory and is given to strange and sometimes vitriolic attacks on mainstream science. Look here to find a list of publications by Roy-the-esteemed-scientist and here to find some examples of Roy-the-crank. Mind you, the former list contains scattered gems such as
766. R. Roy, W. A. Tiller, I. Bell, M.R. Hoover, “The Structure of Liquid Water; Novel Insights from Materials Research; Potential Relevance to Homeopathy,” Mat. Res. Innov. 9:4 , 577-608, December (2005)​
​
 
What ad hom? Many of the recent homeopathy threads here have involved Professor Roy's work on the structure of water, which is utterly incompetent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom