Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

Which is why he absolutely refuses to look at or acknowledge the Japanese sources...........he reminds me of the myths of tenome, a ghost of a blind man who had eyes in his hands - bob is keeping his hands clinched tight inside leather gloves, sealed in wax and held behind him

If you look at the points they are basically pathetic minutia that CTers love to harp on and hope people will engage them on so they can bog them down in useless details and look like they are winning. An example of this would be BAC in the Vince Foster thread where he want, nay, begged people to debate him on the tiny details like an oven mitt found in Foster's car while ignoring the complete utter lack of evidence that Foster's body was placed in the park like his CT alleged. He hoped to look like he was getting the pwnage by trying to entangle opponents into long arguments, but there were few bites.

Bobby boy is playing to same game. He's desperately trying to point at a grandfather clock and complaining that the scratches on the outside woodwork aren't really that bad - all while ignoring the fact the clock is missing its pendulum, hour hand, and most of the internal gears.
 
I'm going to respond to Phil Jacobsen's attack on Leslie Grogan in parts, because to do the entire response in one message would require a massive message--and it'd take me a lot longer to do it. So, here's Part 1.

As I mentioned in another thread, I now have my own copy of Grogan's "Record for Posterity." I will cite it as RFP.

* Jacobsen simply resorts to outright invention when he claims that Grogan's good bearings "are 18 and 44 degrees off respectively from known Strike Force positions at those times" (p. 112). Jacobsen quotes Grogan as saying that on November 30 Grogan said the signals "came from North and West from Honolulu." He then argues that Grogan contradicted himself and quotes Grogan as saying that on December 2 the signals came from "NW by W from Honolulu." This is Jacobsen's entire--and very phony--basis for his assertion that Grogan's good bearings are 18 and 44 degrees off from strike force positions.

Jacobsen misrepresents Grogan on his bearings, partly by ignoring some of what Grogan said about December 2 bearings. Jacobsen sees some huge discrepancy between "North and West" and "NW by W." Jacobsen doesn't bother to tell the reader that in both cases Grogan plainly and clearly placed the signals, i.e., the task force, NW of Hawaii. Here's Grogan's full statement on the November 30 bearings:

"The main body of signals came from a Northwest by West area, which from our second night out from Los Angeles bound for Honolulu -- would be North and West of Honolulu." (RFP, p. 3)​

Note: "which . . . would be North and West of Honolulu." Which was exactly where the task force was at this time.

Here's what Grogan said about the bearings they took on December 2:

"We got good Radio Direction Finder bearings, mostly coming from a Northwesterly direction from our position. . . . and tonight's Radio Detection signals have come from a NW by W [sic] from Honolulu, and from the signals the Japs must be bunched up, biding time." (RFP, p. 4)​
Now, clearly, Grogan wasn't saying that the task force was moving "NW by W" but that the signals were coming from an area that was "NW by W" from Honolulu. Grogan had already made it clear on page 3 that the phrase "NW by W area" meant north and west of Honolulu ("which . . . would be North and West of Honolulu").

Furthermore, Grogan had also just stated, in the preceding paragraph on page 4, that the signals were "mostly coming from a Northwesterly direction from our position," which of course would put the task force NW of Hawaii. Jacobsen omitted this statement from his argument, one suspects because it would made it impossible for him to put forth his ridiculous inference that Grogan's bearings were somehow 18 and 44 degrees off from the strike force's position.

Such slipshod scholarship would get a high school student a big fat "F" on a paper. Jacobsen's shoddy attempt to paint Grogan's bearings as "18 and 44 degrees off" should serve notice to the reader that Jacobsen is not a reliable, factual critic. Let's continue.

* Jacobsen howls because Grogan misrecalled/misidentified Lt. Pease's rank as Lt. Cdr. instead of just Lt., and he insists that no one who knew anything about Navy ranks could make such an error (pp. 104-105).In point of fact, the two rank insignia were virtually identical, the only difference being a single narrow gold bar--both had two thick gold bars and a star.

Beyond that, as a 21-year military vet, I can tell you that sometimes you can misremember someone's rank even if their rank looked very different from the rank you mistakenly attributed to them. It just happens every now and then.

* Jacobsen suggests that Grogan knew Lt. Pease and that therefore he could not possibly have misrecalled/misidentified his rank (p. 105). But Jacobsen presents no evidence that the two men knew each other. Jacobsen's sole basis for this claim is the fact that Lt. Pease would go down to the docks to greet arriving commercial ships! Now, gosh, how silly is that? As Jacobsen surely knew, usually only the ship's command staff officers would interact with a Navy greeting officer; the rest of the crew would beat feet and had no interest in such formalities.

Also, to read Grogan's RFP, one gets the clear impression that Grogan had never met Pease before. Grogan describes Pease the way you would describe someone whom you had not known until that point.

* Continuing his silliness, Jacobsen wonders why Grogan didn't present his report to Pease during Pease's greeting visit when the Lurline first arrived (p. 105)! Uh, maybe because Grogan didn't know that Pease worked in the Navy's local intelligence office? Or, even if we assume that Grogan at least knew that Pease was an intelligence officer, it's entirely plausible that Grogan would have thought it would be appropriate to interrupt Pease's routine visit with the ship's command staff but wanted to wait until he had Pease's undivided attention later at 14th Naval District's intelligence office.

* Jacobsen serves up more silliness when he wonders why Grogan, "if" he thought his signals were important, didn't check with the local radio station to see if they had heard them (p. 105)! Um, maybe because he submitted a full report to the U.S. Navy, logically assumed that the Navy was on it, and took Pease's word that the info would be passed on?

* We get another dose of silliness when Jacobsen wonders why Grogan didn't go back on the Lurline to listen for the signals after it had docked (p. 105)! Gosh, really? Really? Just how silly can one get? A sensible person would assume that Grogan, having submitted a report to the U.S. Navy, thought the matter was being properly addressed and also wanted to enjoy his brief shore leave before the liner set sail back for California.

Furthermore, when the Lurline resumed its trip on December 5, Grogan did listen for the signals again (RFP, p. 4). Not surprisingly, he didn't hear the signals anymore because at that point the task force may indeed have been much quieter than it had been from November 30 to December 2; also, the horrific weather that had compelled inter-fleet communications between November 30 and December 2 had passed.

That'll do for now. Part 2 will be posted in a couple weeks, after I get back from vacation.




I am by no means an expert in this, but is not NW by W a specific compass bearing? See picture, would not the difference between the actual Kido Butai location on Dec 2 and Grogan's claimed direction be off by approx 35 degrees? Just as Jacobsen argued.
 

Attachments

  • KB_route_Compas_headings.jpg
    KB_route_Compas_headings.jpg
    114.3 KB · Views: 23
Last edited:




I am by no means an expert in this, but is not NW by W a specific compass bearing? See picture, would not the difference between the actual Kido Butai location on Dec 2 and Grogan's claimed direction be off by approx 35 degrees? Just as Jacobsen argued.

I think you're showing WNW there.
I had to double check, though.
NWbW is about 10 deg further round.
 
Ah yes you are correct .... updated pic.
 

Attachments

  • KB_route_Compas_heading_ proper NMbW.jpg
    KB_route_Compas_heading_ proper NMbW.jpg
    117.4 KB · Views: 18
Ah yes you are correct .... updated pic.


The dates on that chart are Tokyo time; you have to subtract 19 hours to get Hawaii time, the time zone Grogan probably used.

That is the wrong chart projection to plot radio bearings. Radio waves propagate over the surface of the Earth as Great Circles; they have to be plotted on a gnomonic chart projection. Google Earth uses a gnomonic projection. See my charts here:http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8683990&postcount=523 and here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8684057&postcount=527
 
Last edited:
I don't get the obsession with this RDF stuff. The Japanese say they never broke radio silence, there was no reason for them to break radio silence, and there is no evidence that they broke radio silence. All we have is a claim from someone remembering things from 70 years ago, using equipment that couldn't (as I understand it) really do what he claims it did. This is blue smoke and mirrors.
 
Ah, but you see, the Japanese records are lying. For some unexplained reason.
Well you can't trust those sneaky Japanese, nor anyone who was under that Commie FDR at any level, from cabinet level all the way down to the lowest private or seaman. They're all stooges or liars I tell ya!:rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
I don't get the obsession with this RDF stuff. The Japanese say they never broke radio silence, there was no reason for them to break radio silence, and there is no evidence that they broke radio silence. All we have is a claim from someone remembering things from 70 years ago, using equipment that couldn't (as I understand it) really do what he claims it did. This is blue smoke and mirrors.


BTF and some of his idols have attempted to imply, by handwaving, that the Japanese had to have used short-range radio (TBS, for Talk Between Ships, in US Navy parlance) in order to maintain communication between units of the strike force, and that they didn't realize that this could be picked up thousands of miles away.

I'm by no means an expert on radio communications, but my understanding is that this phenomenon occurs only very infrequently. I recall reading that this happened during the Battle of Midway, but it was Yamamoto's flagship that picked up the transmission from another Japanese force, leading the admiral to wonder why his subordinate was breaking radio silence. But it didn't continue for days on end.

Another bit of handwaving is the implication that orders from Tokyo to the strike force were updated frequently during the voyage, and that those orders had to be retransmitted to all of the smaller ships that lacked tall radio masts. First, there were no frequent changes in orders. Second, such information as might have been transmitted (including intelligence updates) would not have needed to have been passed on to those ships; the destroyers didn't need to know about the latest reports on the positions of ships in Pearl Harbor, for example.

IIRC there has also been some assertion that every message sent to the strike force required an acknowledgement that it had been received. Anyone with even the most basic understanding of wartime communication procedures knows that that's an absurd claim.
 
G-Monster, maybe you can answer something that's been bugging me -- did Kido Buta transmit?
 

I am by no means an expert in this, but is not NW by W a specific compass bearing? See picture, would not the difference between the actual Kido Butai location on Dec 2 and Grogan's claimed direction be off by approx 35 degrees? Just as Jacobsen argued.

But Grogan specified, in very plain English, that by "NW by W" he meant NW of Hawaii--specifically, that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Hawaii. Both times when he discussed the bearings, he made this as clear as English can state something. He was describing a location, not a direction of travel.

But Jacobsen hides this fact from the reader by snipping out part of what Grogan said.

We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.
 
But Grogan specified, in very plain English, that by "NW by W" he meant NW of Hawaii--specifically, that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Hawaii. Both times when he discussed the bearings, he made this as clear as English can state something. He was describing a location, not a direction of travel.

But Jacobsen hides this fact from the reader by snipping out part of what Grogan said.

We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.
The G-man hasn't responded, maybe you can tell me -- do the Japanese records show that Kido Buta transmitted?
 
NWbW is a specific bearing.
If, as he says later, he means "an area North and West of Honolulu" then that could be anything from WNW to NNW. It's so vague as to be little more than "over that way somewhere" <flappy hands>.

So, the only bearing we have is NWbW, and a vague "somewhere out there"...neither of which are correct.
 
But Grogan specified, in very plain English, that by "NW by W" he meant NW of Hawaii--specifically, that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Hawaii. Both times when he discussed the bearings, he made this as clear as English can state something. He was describing a location, not a direction of travel.

But Jacobsen hides this fact from the reader by snipping out part of what Grogan said.

We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.
But they weren't coming from Kido Butai. Do you know why?
 
But Grogan specified, in very plain English, that by "NW by W" he meant NW of Hawaii--specifically, that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Hawaii. Both times when he discussed the bearings, he made this as clear as English can state something. He was describing a location, not a direction of travel.

But Jacobsen hides this fact from the reader by snipping out part of what Grogan said.

We must keep in mind that this was in the days of manual typewriters. They had no word processors back then. So it's no surprise that, in each case, Grogan made it a point to specify that he was saying that the signals were coming from an area that was NW of Honolulu.

If your criteria is only as specific as "NW of Hawaii", then guess what else is in that area? The Pacific Ocean is a very big place, and the vague handwaving "NW of Honolulu" is not going to get you anywhere.

For the rest, I hold that Kido Butai did not transmit.
 
If your criteria is only as specific as "NW of Hawaii", then guess what else is in that area? The Pacific Ocean is a very big place, and the vague handwaving "NW of Honolulu" is not going to get you anywhere.
He could have been picking up the Northwestern, Time Bandit, Wizard, or the Cornelia Marie.
For the rest, I hold that Kido Butai did not transmit.
Funny, that's what the people who were there said.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom