I looked up Dr Steven Quay, and he's a breast cancer doctor with a company trying to make money on COVID-19 nasal sprays and inhalers.
I looked up Dr Steven Quay, and he's a breast cancer doctor with a company trying to make money on COVID-19 nasal sprays and inhalers.
Daszak's company, Eco Health Alliance, partnered with the Wuhan lab (by invitation from China) in the SARS research- specifically looking into the bat caves in Yunnan.
https://www.ecohealthalliance.org/2...ke-viruses-spilling-over-into-people-in-china
He might be forthright as he sees it, but there is a serious conflict of interest there.
eta: I should mention that Eco Health Alliance also has a grant from the US NIH- though not specific to China. Wuhan also had US money for research, and there is a partnership with Duke Medical (yeah the NC school) with both of them. Duke has a campus in Wuhan. Like many relationships, it's complicated.
Still, Daszak seems to be bending over quite a bit in China's favor. I think I'll go google what other scientists think of his responses. .....
The research community is reacting with alarm and anger to the National Institutes of Health's (NIH's) abrupt decision to kill a grant that helped support research in China on how coronaviruses—such as the one causing the current COVID-19 pandemic—move from bats to humans.
The unusual 24 April move occurred shortly after President Donald Trump alleged—without providing evidence—that the pandemic virus had escaped from a Chinese laboratory supported by the NIH grant, and vowed to end the funding. The episode came as calls mounted for China to allow an independent investigation, perhaps led by the United Nations. “The whole world wants the exact origin of the virus to be clarified,” German Minister of Foreign Affairs Heiko Maas said on 4 May.
Many scientists are skeptical of the laboratory escape theory, and the Chinese virologist at the heart of the allegation rejects the idea. Critics of NIH's decision, meanwhile, say it represents an unacceptable intrusion of politics into the agency's grants process and possibly violated its rules.
Okay, I don't really see what the angle is here.
Was Daszak, EcoHealth Alliance and / or the Wuhan Institute of Virology doing this stuff in secret?
It seems that they were not. All of the "evidence" against them seems to be published studies and public broadcasts on podcasts etc...
We know that they were working on coronaviruses because they said they were!
This is not sleuthing! Rather much of this stuff is people who knew nothing at all about this, suddenly discovering stuff they didn't know and yelling "Eureka!"
EcoHealth Alliance, for example, is basically a very public pressure group trying to get people to understand the dangers of animal-borne viruses and trying to make ecological policies based on this. The stuff being dredged up in this thread seems to be waved around as though it is some kind of smoking gun, and the fact that these virologists are working with the Chinese on coronaviruses is somehow seen as being massively incriminating. No! This outbreak is exactly what they have been warning would happen for a very long time.
Similarly, EcoHealth Alliance has been working in Africa and southeast Asia on Ebola and the Nipah virus for the same reasons. Guess what! These diseases will also emerge again at some point. And in fact they often do over a very wide area. It is seldom clear where exactly they came from.
As for the whole conflict of interest, well, it seems because Donald Trump was peddling the "escaped from a lab" theory that he orchestrated the cutting in funding for EcoHealth Alliance.
Given he promotes his company and his products I can see why you describe Dr Quay with dismissive language. I know he promoted his work on NewsMax. If that's all I saw I might have mischaracterized the guy as well. But I looked at his paper and it was clear he was not a quack.I looked up Dr Steven Quay, and he's a breast cancer doctor with a company trying to make money on COVID-19 nasal sprays and inhalers.
Here are a couple of papers related to the nasal sprays you mentioned:Medical School & Residency
Massachusetts General Hospital
Residency, Anatomic and Clinical Pathology
University of Michigan Medical School
Certifications & Licensure
American Board of Pathology
Certified in Anatomic Pathology
[he's licensed in every state]
SPECIALTY
Pathology
Pathologists diagnose and characterize diseases. They analyze biopsied tissue or bodily fluids, and interpret medical tests, including tests done by other specialists like dermatologists and cardiologists. Most cancer diagnoses are done by pathologists.
SUBSPECIALTIES
Cytopathology
Anatomic Pathology
Guess he can walk and chew gum at the same time.Atossa Therapeutics, Inc. is a clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company seeking to discover and develop innovative medicines in areas of significant unmet medical need with a current focus on breast cancer and COVID-19. For more information, please visit www.atossatherapeutics.com.
Ferrioxamine-paramagnetic contrast agents for MR imaging, composition, apparatus and use
Patent number: 4637929
Abstract: The Ferrioxamine (FOM) family of chelates and amide homologs thereof provide excellent contrast agents for magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. The magnetic dipole generated by unpaired electrons within the paramagnetic Fe(III) atoms, cause a local reduction in the bulk magnetic field Bz of the MR system. The resulting shorting of the T1 (spin lattice) relaxation time in the local hydrogen protons within the area of interest, causes an intense "free induction signal" and a corresponding modulation in the collected scanning data. The contrast agent within the tissue or organ of interest causes the tissue to appear on the MR display as a high intensity or white area. Background tissue is displayed as darker or lower intensity greys.FOM does not penetrate the blood-brain-barrier under normal circumstances; and is therefore useful in detecting the extravasation of arterial blood in the extravascular space during cerebral hemorrhaging and in the endema fluid surrounding tumors.
Type: Grant
Filed: January 4, 1985
Date of Patent: January 20, 1987
Assignee: Salutar, Inc.
Inventor: Steven C. Quay
INTRADUCTAL METHODS OF TREATMENT OF BREAST DISORDERS
Publication number: 20210000920
Abstract: The present invention relates to intraductal methods and compositions for treating subjects having breast disorders. Compositions comprise repolarizing agents and polarization blockading agents capable of repolarizing M2-macrophages to M1-macrophages in the tumor microenvironment, decreasing M2-macrophages, increasing M1-macrophages and/or increasing sensitivity to chemotherapy in the subject.
Type: Application
Filed: December 20, 2018
Publication date: January 7, 2021
Applicant: Atossa Therapeutics, Inc.
Inventor: Steven C. Quay
About Steven Quay, M.D., Ph.D.
Dr. Steven Quay has 360+ published contributions to medicine and has been cited over 10,000 times, placing him in the top 1% of scientists worldwide. He holds 87 US patents and has invented seven FDA-approved pharmaceuticals which have helped over 80 million people. He is the author of the best-selling book on surviving the pandemic, Stay Safe: A Physician's Guide to Survive Coronavirus. He is the CEO of Atossa Therapeutics Inc. (Nasdaq: ATOS), a clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company developing novel therapeutics for treating breast cancer and COVID-19.
He received his M.D. and Ph.D. from The University of Michigan, was a postdoctoral fellow in the Chemistry Department at MIT with Nobel Laureate H. Gobind Khorana, a resident at the Harvard-MGH Hospital, and spent almost a decade on the faculty of Stanford University School of Medicine. A TEDx talk he delivered on breast cancer prevention has been viewed over 220,000 times. For more information, visit www.DrQuay.com
Yeah, I noticed that too. Seems to be a bit of a red flag.
If I am to give the benefit of the doubt, then presumably his work will find its way to the relevant experts and relevant publications. Then when his work is peer-reviewed by those relevant experts then maybe something can come of it.
However, if that does not happen, then we have to ask, why are the relevant experts not weighing in or accepting these conclusions?
The answers are either that the study isn't very good, or they take us to the realm of conspiracy theory.
Clearly this has been a serious problem.... As for the whole conflict of interest, well, it seems because Donald Trump was peddling the "escaped from a lab" theory that he orchestrated the cutting in funding for EcoHealth Alliance.
Speak for yourself. Yes, I do.
Oh I've only worked in occupational infectious disease for 30 years. I don't work with viruses in a lab..We don't understand this stuff, so we have to put a certain trust in the experts being able to police their own fields. That usually means, we accept the words of experts, particularly when there is an apparent consensus around certain issues such as this.
And it seems to me people need to get over this and look at the evidence that doesn't come from right wing peddlers. Take that **** back to the CT forum..It seems to me that the vast majority of the "escape from a lab" narrative is being pushed by right-wing sources such as Donald Trump, Mike Pompeo, Fox News, the Spectator - for obvious political reasons, and the "science" such as it is, seems to be a Gish Gallop of amateurs, cranks, quacks, people with some financial interests involved, and in some cases downright bigots (no, I am not referring to anyone here).
Is this because you can't judge that paper yourself?![]()
Clearly this has been a serious problem.
Speak for yourself. Yes, I do.
Oh I've only worked in occupational infectious disease for 30 years. I don't work with viruses in a lab.
And it seems to me people need to get over this and look at the evidence that doesn't come from right wing peddlers. Take that **** back to the CT forum.
We have posted legit sources here and the State Department was only one thing I posted way back at the beginning of this thread. I cited Spectator with plenty of caveats and instead went to the source they cited rather than relying on anything in the magazine.
Then I found this: TaiwanNews Feb 23, 2021: German scientist says 99.9% chance coronavirus leaked from Wuhan lab - Year-long study of pandemic's origin concludes it started with 'laboratory accident' in Wuhan The Chinese embassy in Germany is having a cow over it. But here's what the researcher based his conclusion on.
His evidence:No natural host found
Well-suited for hACE2 receptors
Wrong bats in Wuhan
History of making chimeras
Lax safety measures
Direct evidence of a lab leak
Re the Direct indications of lab leak:
Wiesendanger then cites several incidents that are indicative of a lab accident, such as reports that a young researcher in the lab, identified as Huang Yanling, was allegedly "patient zero" and had disappeared after contracting the disease. The WIV and Chinese government have vehemently denied she was infected, but over a year later, her whereabouts are still unknown, and all information about her has been scrubbed from the WIV website.
He also touched on analysis by American intelligence agencies of a private report purporting to have found evidence of a "shutdown" and "hazardous event" allegedly taking place at the WIV in October 2019. More recently, on Jan. 15, the U.S. State Department released a report stating that several scientists inside the lab had become ill with "symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses" in the fall of 2019.
The claim is false. It was spread without any evidence. As soon as this news started spreading like wildfire, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences issued a statement on their official website dated February 16, debunking these claims.
The statement highlights that false information is being circulated regarding the identification of Huang Yanling as ‘patient zero.’
The institute confirmed that she was a former student at the institute and had completed her master’s degree in 2015. They gave information about her area of expertise and that she has been living elsewhere after her graduation. She is in perfectly good health and has not been infected by the virus at all.
October 2014: US suspends risky disease research- Government to cease funding gain-of-function studies that make viruses more dangerous, pending a safety assessment.
https://www.nature.com/news/us-suspends-risky-disease-research-1.16192
Given the US ban on the risky research following lab leaks in the US, any research would have moved to labs outside the US. No wonder I could not find much done here after 2015.
November 2015: Engineered bat virus stirs debate over risky research
Lab-made coronavirus related to SARS can infect human cells.
https://www.nature.com/news/engineered-bat-virus-stirs-debate-over-risky-research- 1.18787#/b1
The paper of the second one has this note:
I do tend to believe the majority of scientists who have looked at it and determined it is not engineered- at least not the dice and splice way.
At the same time, I wonder why there was so much 'don't consider this theory!" so early when everything was speculation....and still is!
Every American should be outraged that the US has cut off funding for EcoHealth Alliance, an organization that supports wildlife sampling to discover viruses with pandemic potential in bats and other species. It is exactly that type of work that is needed to prepare therapeutics for the next pandemic. There is no scientific justification for such a move, only political motives.
I would also like to point out that due to pressure from a number of individuals who felt that determining the pandemic potential of SARS-like CoV in bats was too dangerous, a research moratorium on certain kinds of this research was imposed in 2014. I do hope the authors of that moratorium feel at least a small amount of regret as they look at the rising COVID-19 numbers. After all, Nature does not observe our moratoriums.
Now, as a consequence of this lack of vision, many people have died, economies have been destroyed, and the social structure of the world has changed. The US alone is spending trillions of dollars on recovery assistance. It would have been far cheaper to spend just billions for prevention.
Okay, so this goes to the question I was asking you about the so-called evidence for lab workers getting sick.
It seems that Huang Yanling is the person who many people tweeted about saying she was "patient zero".
I tried to look into this. Apparently...according to a website called Health Analytics Asia, the Wuhan Institute of Virology pointed out that she was a research student who graduated in 2015 and has since been living elsewhere.
Link
Unfortunately for that last bit we are stuck with the evidence having been found on Trump's watch making it unreliable.
There are other stories in the link that sound outrageous:
PLA experimented in Wuhan lab, covered up outbreak
2021/02/22 18:11
WHO inspector's 'natural hosts' experimented on in Wuhan lab
2021/02/20 17:59
WHO inspector's denial of bats in Wuhan lab contradicted by facts
2021/02/18 18:29
Vanished 150,000 elderly residents raise doubts about Wuhan's Covid death toll
2021/02/18 13:20
If you look at what I posted following that paragraph you will see I did not find the information on pt zero to be reliable:
Your post describes the claim patient zero came from social media.
If you want to add to the evidence by saying patient zero was debunked, at least acknowledge that I said that information from Wiesendanger was unreliable instead of still trying to drag this thread into CT territory.
Then I suspect you didn't actually look at Dr Quay's paper or his credentials which I spoon fed thread readers.The thing is, I don't even know if these papers you are citing actually are evidence.
Yeah well that's just crap. I have looked at a wide variety of sources posted in this thread both pro and con. I think I've made a damn good effort to keep an open mind. I still have one. If the source is found and it isn't the lab that would be overwhelming evidence it wasn't the lab.You give the impression that you have made up your mind on the escaped from a lab theory and then gone about finding confirming evidence to support it.
First, there are virologists on both sides of the aisle. So when you say "all of them" who are you referring to that aren't either directly from the lab, or at least compromised to some degree?Does it not give you pause that actual virologists have not supported the escaped from a lab theory?
What is your explanation for this?
They are too close-minded?
They are not very bright?
They are worried about upsetting China? All of them?
They are part of a conspiracy?
There is not a gish gallop in this thread.I have a better idea.
Instead of posting a Gish Gallop of unreliable BS and then inserting a few qualifiers about how maybe perhaps it is not the best information, how about not posting this crap at all.
First, there are virologists on both sides of the aisle. So when you say "all of them" who are you referring to that aren't either directly from the lab, or at least compromised to some degree?
"No scientist or group of scientists created this virus in a laboratory. That would require insight into [viral] pathogenesis and protein engineering that does not exist," said Robert Garry, Ph.D., virologist at Tulane University.
Garry explained that much of the genetic material of the virus that caused COVID-19 is similar to that found in viruses sampled from animals, and was unknown to science until after the pandemic, ruling out the possibility the virus was created beforehand in a lab.
The genetic material and genetic changes to the novel coronavirus are "all what you would expect from natural evolution and an animal source," said Amesh Adalja, MD, infectious disease fellow and senior scholar at Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.
Evidence to that compromise has been posted here. You have chosen to dismiss that evidence. Your particular bias on this has been quite blatant.
Right now the evidence is very strong for a lab accident.
First, it was the location.
Second, the source has not been found.
1. Natural selection in an animal host before zoonotic transfer
2. Natural selection in humans following zoonotic transfer
...Sufficient opportunity could have arisen if there had been many prior zoonotic events that produced short chains of human-to-human transmission over an extended period. This is essentially the situation for MERS-CoV, for which all human cases are the result of repeated jumps of the virus from dromedary camels, producing single infections or short transmission chains that eventually resolve, with no adaptation to sustained transmission25.
Studies of banked human samples could provide information on whether such cryptic spread has occurred.
Fourth, the lab has denied live bat research but the evidence is very strong they were doing research on live bats. And there's a lot more evidence what they were doing could have resulted in the kind of genetic recombinant event that would have resulted in COVID.
Fifth, it's undeniable China is restricting access to an investigation and an audit of the lab.
And finally, given the WHO team cannot say where the virus jumped, how are they so quick to say 'but it wasn't the lab'?
Why do some here seem so against skeptics exploring and looking at various information (reliable, total propaganda, or perhaps half-truths included). Some are dead ends, some are discounted after further reading, and some lead to more pieces to be explored. Minds are changed and things evolve in time as more research is done. That is how it goes for me and I enjoy learning. YMMV.