Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
SG, I haven't been following the whole conversation and just jumped in, casually and posted this in a non-judgemental way.

I looked up Dr Steven Quay, and he's a breast cancer doctor with a company trying to make money on COVID-19 nasal sprays and inhalers.


Please don't think I'm trying to shame you for any lack of immunological expertise.

I'm just here for a discussion.


Right now the evidence is very strong for a lab accident.

First, it was the location.
Second, the source has not been found.
Third, Quay makes a good case that the virus was too perfect when it emerged.
As opposed to SARS 1 which wasn't.​
Fourth, the lab has denied live bat research but the evidence is very strong they were doing research on live bats. And there's a lot more evidence what they were doing could have resulted in the kind of genetic recombinant event that would have resulted in COVID.
Fifth, it's undeniable China is restricting access to an investigation and an audit of the lab.
And finally, given the WHO team cannot say where the virus jumped, how are they so quick to say 'but it wasn't the lab'?


I'm probably missing something.

Just discussing why it might be "a lab accident".

Location: Unknown. Evidence at blood banks has appeared that it was in Italy and France in November.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-020-00716-2
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620974755


Source: The source has not been found, yes, I agree.

And I think if there is any conspiracy, it's a mutual agreement between the WHO and relevant countries to protect Patient Zero in a kind manner.

Can you imagine being that person and being doxed? :eek::eek::eek:

So I don't think they should reveal the source.


Quay saying the virus is "too perfect"? Can you explain what you mean or just point me to your post saying that?

Do you mean a petri dish type lab accident?


My theory at present is that it happened in a lab by a wild farmed animal (bought at the Hunan market for medical testing) biting a scientist and giving them the virus.
 
Who is against what you are in favour of?
You accuse me of confirmation bias for the lab leak hypothesis and then you post blatant, it's all a CT snark, and when looking at the strongest evidence (location) you dismiss that, using all sorts of rationalizing and excuses, and then you take one of the strongest scientific papers in this thread to date and suddenly you are incapable of assessing its validity yourself, not even a cursory assessment.

So riddle me this, how is it you dismiss all the evidence that the WHO team and WIV laboratory scientists have reasons not to be forthcoming? How is that not confirmation bias?

WSJ Op Ed: Who Are the Covid Investigators? - Members of a WHO origin probe have conflicts of interest.
The world needs to learn all it can about the origins of the novel coronarivus, and the World Health Organization has been investigating. But there’s increasing reason to question the effort due to China’s lack of cooperation and conflicts of interest on the WHO team.

A Beijing-approved WHO delegation recently concluded a 12-day visit to Wuhan, where the virus emerged more than a year ago. The group visited local hospitals and sites like the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) and Huanan Seafood Market. But such field trips aren’t very helpful without unhindered access to raw data. The Chinese government, which controls research into Covid-19’s origin, has limited WHO access to such information.
(Part of the article is paywalled.)


Bulletin of Atomic Scientists (the guys with the Doomsday Clock): WHO: COVID-19 didn’t leak from a lab. Also WHO: Maybe it did
Ben Embarek said the team had dismissed the idea that a lab-leak hypothesis as “extremely unlikely” and said it wouldn’t be pursued any further.

But days after the presser, the remarks by Ben Embarek and the team were undercut when World Health Organization Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said no hypotheses had been ruled out: “I want to clarify that all hypotheses remain open and require further study.” Where the WHO investigators go from here remains to be seen.

I posted this upthread:
Yet, what makes the investigative team so certain of this? Not everything that is researched in labs is published. And from the published record, we know that scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, one of the labs in Wuhan that researched bat coronaviruses, had renamed viruses with sequences closely resembling SARS-CoV-2 in an apparent attempt to obfuscate their previous work with these viruses before the pandemic. Then there’s the fact that the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s virus database was taken offline at the beginning of 2020 for “security reasons.” Did the investigative team have access to the database? Did they scrutinize other lab records?

But I wanted to post this from a link in that paragraph to a blog: Matt Ridley, Rational Optimist*
However, the public scientific consensus had been slowly shifting even before the announcement. A growing number of top experts including (ordered alphabetically by last name) Drs Francois Balloux, Ralph S. Baric, Trevor Bedford, Jesse Bloom, Bruno Canard, Etienne Decroly, Richard H. Ebright, Michael B. Eisen, Gareth Jones, Filippa Lentsoz, Michael Z. Lin, Marc Lipsitch, Stuart A. Newman, Rasmus Nielsen, Megan Palmer, Nikolai Petrovsky, Angela Rasmussen, and David A. Relman have stated publicly (several in early 2020) that a lab leak remains a plausible scientific hypothesis to be investigated, regardless of how likely or unlikely. We informed and obtained consent from each expert for their inclusion in this list.

Information about what went on in the WIV laboratories remains scarce. Given that, as Dr David Relman of Stanford University points out, it has the world’s largest repository of bat coronaviruses, the lack of transparency and openness about their research, and inconsistencies in the information that has been released are bound to fuel speculation. This now includes whether there are clues to an accident in 2019 or to changes in bio-safety procedures. Meanwhile, in contrast to SARS, the anticipated evidence for the natural origin hypothesis has failed to materialise over an entire year.
Does that sound like there are no virologists questioning the WHO investigation?

Does everyone agree with the pangolin hypothesis?
The pangolin connection was put to the test when one of us (Chan, alongside a highly skilled collaborator, Dr Shing Hei Zhan of the University of British Columbia) discovered that for the pangolin viruses that most resembled SARS-CoV-2 in the key section of its spike protein, all four studies used the same dataset from a single batch of pangolins intercepted in Guangdong in March 2019. The journal Nature has since attached an editor’s note to one of the papers to alert readers that “concerns have been raised about the identity of the pangolin samples reported in this paper and their relationship to previously published pangolin samples.”
Dr Linfa Wang of the Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore, one of the scientists who discovered that bats were the natural reservoir of SARS viruses, told the Associated Press that “the search for the coronavirus in pangolins did not appear to be ‘scientifically driven.'” Dr Angela Rasmussen, of the Georgetown Center for Global Health Science and Security, said simply “the pangolin samples are a mess and likely not relevant.”
Do those not sound like virologists?


And corroborating a key piece of Quay's paper:
Furthermore, when one of us (Chan, in collaboration with Zhan) scrutinized the evolution of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 in the early months of their respective epidemics, the former was observed to have mutated rapidly in early human cases as the virus adapted to its new host, while the latter had not. "The virus was well adapted to human transmission from the moment it was first detected," the World Health Organization's global study on the origins of the virus commented in November.

You could, you know, join us delving into the science here instead of trying to drag this thread over to the CT forum. Come on over to the light side, angrysoba. ;)


*http://www.mattridley.co.uk/biography/
 
Last edited:
You accuse me of confirmation bias for the lab leak hypothesis and then you post blatant, it's all a CT snark, and when looking at the strongest evidence (location) you dismiss that, using all sorts of rationalizing and excuses, and then you take one of the strongest scientific papers in this thread to date and suddenly you are incapable of assessing its validity yourself, not even a cursory assessment.

Of course I am not capable of assessing it. For me, the evidence against is the evidence of the dog that didn't bark. Where are the experts who are in favour of this paper?

So riddle me this, how is it you dismiss all the evidence that the WHO team and WIV laboratory scientists have reasons not to be forthcoming? How is that not confirmation bias?

I've given a standard for how I will accept it. I am not going to go out on a limb on a paper that apparently no serious virologist takes seriously.


Yes, I know all of this. I have even said it myself. I get. I know. I know.

But not all the virologists are compromised. That's my point! That's why I asked about those other ones.


Bulletin of Atomic Scientists (the guys with the Doomsday Clock): WHO: COVID-19 didn’t leak from a lab. Also WHO: Maybe it did
Yep, okay, so here are the hypotheses that the WHO team is investigating then...

At the Feb. 9 briefing, the co-heads of the mission, Peter Ben Embarek and Liang Wannian, laid out the four origin hypotheses that formed the basis of the mission’s investigation:

The novel coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, jumped directly from an animal species to humans.
The virus leapt from one animal species to an intermediary animal host in which the virus adapted more before jumping to people.
The virus was introduced to Wuhan via the food chain, for example from frozen products.
The virus was accidentally released through a lab-related incident.

What's the issue? I have said it can not be categorically ruled out. But almost all the experts agree it is unlikely, as opposed to Dr Quay who apparently is 999999999.999999999999999999999999999% sure it was a lab.

I posted this upthread:

But I wanted to post this from a link in that paragraph to a blog: Matt Ridley, Rational Optimist*Does that sound like there are no virologists questioning the WHO investigation?

You have shifted the goalposts. I am not saying "nobody questions the WHO investigation".

I said:
Who are the virologists who argue that it was a lab leak?

Do you have anyone?

The ones you quote only say it needs to be among the possibilities. That is hugely different from what I asked you. Who supports the theory?

I have gone through a few of them. Many say something like "plausible, and worth investigating, but unlikely", including Angela Rasmussen who Dr Quay sent his paper to.

Does everyone agree with the pangolin hypothesis?

No. They don't. So?


And corroborating a key piece of Quay's paper:
Furthermore, when one of us (Chan, in collaboration with Zhan) scrutinized the evolution of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 in the early months of their respective epidemics, the former was observed to have mutated rapidly in early human cases as the virus adapted to its new host, while the latter had not. "The virus was well adapted to human transmission from the moment it was first detected," the World Health Organization's global study on the origins of the virus commented in November.

I need to point out, again, that this was already very well known about the virus. It doesn't "corroborate" what Dr Quay says. Papers had already been published. Like this one...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9

I posted that before, and you ignored it.


You could, you know, join us delving into the science here instead of trying to drag this thread over to the CT forum. Come on over to the light side, angrysoba. ;)

Thanks. I have already posted science stuff. See above.
 
SG, I haven't been following the whole conversation and just jumped in, casually and posted this in a non-judgemental way.

Please don't think I'm trying to shame you for any lack of immunological expertise.

I'm just here for a discussion.
I was trying to say I understood what you were pointing out. I'd have done the same thing if the first link I had gone to on Dr Quay was his webpage. I mean really, there's a picture of Bannon on one of the pages. :eek: And his little book is for sale on every page.

But he's a pathologist, not a breast cancer doctor per se though he's done a lot of research in the breast cancer field. And the pharmaceutical corporation he's the CEO of has done a lot of work in intranasal administration of meds. The ones for COVID are not anything one can buy as a lay consumer.


Just discussing why it might be "a lab accident".

Location: Unknown. Evidence at blood banks has appeared that it was in Italy and France in November.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-020-00716-2
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/2/20-4632_article
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620974755

Source: The source has not been found, yes, I agree.

And I think if there is any conspiracy, it's a mutual agreement between the WHO and relevant countries to protect Patient Zero in a kind manner.

Can you imagine being that person and being doxed? :eek::eek::eek:
That's not an issue here. I'm not sure the single patient zero can ever be found now after more than a year has gone by.

By source we mean the animal the virus jumped from into the human population. And that is detected genetically.


Quay saying the virus is "too perfect"? Can you explain what you mean or just point me to your post saying that?
When viruses jump species they are not perfectly adapted to the new host. The cells in the new species are never a perfect match to the cells of the originating species so the virus can't as efficiently enter the new host cells.

Take COVID, from humans it has jumped to minks, cats, dogs and zoo primates. It's well adapted to minks but it has also gone through some rapid genetic changes in that species. It's not well adapted to dogs so we are seeing infections but not enough viral replication to make them a source of human infections. Cats seem to be an in between match. Jumping from humans to non-human primates has been an issue. For most primate tissues they are going to be a close match across species.

We see the human cases of COVID have very little genetic diversity. That means the infection hasn't been in humans very long. Notice now after a year we are hearing about mutations. You can take the genetic differences in viruses and pretty much roll back the clock to see when those strains diverged.

What we see in COVID is a brand new pathogen in humans, it hasn't been percolating much more than a year. If it had, we would see a much greater diversity than we are seeing.

What Quay's paper looked at and what was also mentioned in my post above corroborating his hypothesis was how perfect COVID was for human cells when it jumped compared to how not perfect SARS was when it jumped from palm civet cats into humans. It took time and multiple mutations that were subject to selection pressures (natural selection) before SARS settled in as adapted to human cells.

How is it COVID came prepackaged as a perfect fit while SARS had to work its way to get there?

Going back to the SARS epidemic, it was being reported by medical professionals emailing other medical professionals several months before it was spread to Hong Kong. It had plenty of time to adapt to humans during that time. And we can see the adaptations by looking at the genetic diversity even if we don't have samples from the first patients in Guangdong. And we can look at the SARS in palm civet cats and see what the initial viral genome looked like before it jumped species.

Even taking bat viruses and pangolin viruses and merging them through a recombinant event (when two viruses mix) you don't get COVID. You get some pieces of it, including important genetic pieces. But you don't get a perfect match right out of the gate.

I've seen this with influenza. H5N1 looked really bad for a while. A few people had gotten infected in Hong Kong and there was a high fatality rate. And genetic research suggested it was only a couple of the right mutations away from being able to efficient multiply in human respiratory cells. But so far that hasn't happened. So a few people get infected but they don't pass it on very efficiently. Thus no flu pandemic yet. No perfect match right out of the gate.


Do you mean a petri dish type lab accident?
There are many ways a lab accident can happen from a puncture of your pressurized suit letting contaminated air in to an animal bite. Improper disposal of animal waste is another way.

My theory at present is that it happened in a lab by a wild farmed animal (bought at the Hunan market for medical testing) biting a scientist and giving them the virus.
There were no animals going back and forth between the lab and local markets.
 
Last edited:
... I am not going to go out on a limb on a paper that apparently no serious virologist takes seriously.
That is blatantly false.

.. But not all the virologists are compromised. That's my point! That's why I asked about those other ones.

[snip]
What's the issue? I have said it can not be categorically ruled out. But almost all the experts agree it is unlikely, as opposed to Dr Quay who apparently is 999999999.999999999999999999999999999% sure it was a lab.
No they don't! Good grief!

...
The ones you quote only say it needs to be among the possibilities. That is hugely different from what I asked you. Who supports the theory?

I have gone through a few of them. Many say something like "plausible, and worth investigating, but unlikely", including Angela Rasmussen who Dr Quay sent his paper to.
You checked a couple? A few? Plausible but you have no confirmation bias.:rolleyes:

You don't understand how Rasmussen corroborates Quay's premise that he based his analysis on? :boggled:

.. .
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0820-9

I posted that before, and you ignored it.
I didn't ignore that Nature citation. Do you not understand the discussion that followed? You seem to think that one paper proves the source has been determined. Why do you not know the pangolin/bat coronavirus is part of the ongoing discussion here?

I don't see how you can have even a cursory understanding of Quay's paper and think the pangolin source isn't part of the discussion.

And what goalpost? You mean my asking for the next step: If it came from a pangolin/bat recombination event, why are there no papers declaring eureka? We're done here, we know the origin. :rolleyes:
 
I didn't ignore that Nature citation. Do you not understand the discussion that followed? You seem to think that one paper proves the source has been determined. Why do you not know the pangolin/bat coronavirus is part of the ongoing discussion here? [

That's a complete lie. The paper doesn't say where it came from. The point is that

I don't see how you can have even a cursory understanding of Quay's paper and think the pangolin source isn't part of the discussion.

And what goalpost? You mean my asking for the next step: If it came from a pangolin/bat recombination event, why are there no papers declaring eureka? We're done here, we know the origin. :rolleyes:

You seem to think that Quay is the first person to notice that the virus is adaptive to humans and then all the other virologists are "corroborating his findings"

Bwahahahaha!

No expert has concluded it is from a pangolin. Nobody is saying that. Jesus! Talk about a strawman!

I even posted above a video of Daszak saying that SARS Cov2 might not need an intermediate host.
 
Skeptic Ginger, honestly some of your arguments are appalling.

False dichotomies!
Strawman arguments!
Moving the goalposts!
Reliance on far-right sources!
 
Until anyone takes Quay's paper seriously, I think we can just assume there is nothing to it.

Ask some experts. Use Twitter if you have to. Find someone, anyone, who takes it seriously.

See if it can actually get peer-reviewed and published somehwere. Otherwise, why would anyone take it seriously?
 
Skeptic Ginger, honestly some of your arguments are appalling.

False dichotomies!
Strawman arguments!
Moving the goalposts!
Reliance on far-right sources!
Looks like laboratory escape, and if anything SG is the open to all evidence one.
 
Okay, so what is the evidence?
If the virus jumped from Wuhan bats the dna evidence would be clear.
If the virus jumped from the Wuhan lab the Chinese government would punish any country that asked them to investigate by punishing that country's wine industry.
 
If the virus jumped from Wuhan bats the dna evidence would be clear.
If the virus jumped from the Wuhan lab the Chinese government would punish any country that asked them to investigate by punishing that country's wine industry.

That's ... brilliant.

:confused:
 
How do we know the virus wasn't perfect when it jumped if we don't know the source / what it jumped from?

How do we know there was no transport of farmed wild animals from the market to the lab if we don't know the location of the outbreak?
 
Last edited:
How do we know the virus wasn't perfect when it jumped if we don't know the source / what it jumped from?

How do we know there was no transport of farmed wild animals from the market to the lab if we don't know the location of the outbreak?

We know the location of the outbreak: In Wuhan near the lab. It wasn't the market where the first cases occurred because earlier cases were found that had no connection to the market.

It is thought now that the market was the location of a super spreader event and that brought the outbreak to people's attention.

The researchers in the lab collected specimens from southern China. There wasn't anything at the seafood/wet market they would have been interested in collecting.
 
Re Rasmussen, she says this:
LOL yes. Based on at least 5 things in this screen shot. Can you guess what they are?
Well no actually, I cannot guess what they are and scrolling down I don't find her answer.

Some other idiot replies in the comment that
Dude wrote a paper. Paid to have it published. An opinion piece? On the side it says the article wasn’t written by them.
Reminds me of people in this forum (not necessarily in the thread) that have one or two pony tricks about assessing published literature and they can't see past those tricks.

Whether he (or his company) paid to have PR Newswire post about the paper, it was published in an open access site user community at Zenodo on OpenAIRE
Coronavirus Disease Research Community - COVID-19
This community collects research outputs that may be relevant to the Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) or the SARS-CoV-2. Scientists are encouraged to upload their outcome in this collection to facilitate sharing and discovery of information. Although Open Access articles and datasets are recommended, also closed and restricted access material are accepted. All types of research outputs can be included in this Community (Publication, Poster, Presentation, Dataset, Image, Video/Audio, Software, Lesson, Other).

I would like to know what her issues were if anyone finds it.

My point in citing her was specifically about corroborating an underlying premise in the paper, not necessarily the paper itself.
 
So no gradual changes in the human infection and earlier I posted a reference to the fact that the genetic evidence is this pathogen has only been in the human population recently.

So it was a perfect match on the first jump? Quay compares this to SARS (1) which was not.

I'm going to leave it to the people in this thread who "are not impressed" to sift through this scientific paper and find the faults in it. I'm not seeing them

You were the one arguing "more evolution was needed" earlier in the thread. I told you several pages back that because we now know the spike from the Pangolin virus is ALREADY efficient at attaching to human ACE2 bindings that the resulting virus would be very infectious to humans as soon as the recombination event occurred.

The argument that this is a natural event is that this spike stricture was unknown prior to research into Covid-19 so no one knew it could infect humans until mid 2020. No researcher could have been working with it in 2019, and even if they were they would have had zero reason to expect it would help create a more infectious version of a bat virus.
 
Right now the evidence is very strong for a lab accident.

First, it was the location.
This isn’t evidence. Take almost any notable event and there will inevitably be coincidences surrounding it. Homing in on these coincidences is the bread and butter of conspiracy theories.
Second, the source has not been found.

An unknown source makes it unlikely that the Covid-19 virus was ever in a lab prior to the outbreak. This is evidence AGAINST a laboratory origin.
Third, Quay makes a good case that the virus was too perfect when it emerged.

This isn’t an argument for escaping from a lab it’s an attempt to argue that Covid-19 was genetically engineered, something that had been rejected repeatedly by mainstream science.
Fourth, the lab has denied live bat research but the evidence is very strong they were doing research on live bats. And there's a lot more evidence what they were doing could have resulted in the kind of genetic recombinant event that would have resulted in COVID.

Lots of allegations with very little evidence behind them.
Fifth, it's undeniable China is restricting access to an investigation and an audit of the lab.

Do you think The US or any other western country is going to give Chinese Scientists unrestricted access to their own BSK-4 labs? Such refusals means absolutely nothing because this type of access was never going to be granted under any circumstances.

And finally, given the WHO team cannot say where the virus jumped, how are they so quick to say 'but it wasn't the lab'?

There is enough know about the virus to indicate process that are perfectly normal and common in nature, but would literally make no sense as any form of research.
 
Why do some here seem so against skeptics exploring and looking at various information (reliable, total propaganda, or perhaps half-truths included). Some are dead ends, some are discounted after further reading, and some lead to more pieces to be explored. Minds are changed and things evolve in time as more research is done. That is how it goes for me and I enjoy learning. YMMV.

Minds are changes by published results, not the insistence that we need to be “skeptical” of the results that have already been published.

Much harm is done by purveyors of pseudo-science claiming to simply be "skeptics exploring and looking at various information". Climate science deniers, anti-vaxers, truthers, birthers and flat earthers would all describe themselves as "skeptics" who are just looking for reliable explanations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom