Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
From 6 September 2021
WHO study Annex, p131.
With regard to the matter of morbidity and mortality in miners in a mine in Mojiang, Yunnan Province, where bats were present, Professor Shi said that the events had been clarified in an addendum to her Nature article. Doctors sent her the samples for testing after something like three months of illness. Miners had been to the cave 2-3 times and it was 1 meter thick with bat feces. Professor Shi’s team went there in 2012-15 about seven times to look for novel viruses. They found no viruses close to SARS-CoV but there was a rat henipa-like virus (Mojiang paramyxovirus), as reported by another group in China. Samples taken during subsequent visits to the cave were found to contain no viral sequence related to SARS-CoV-2 (like RaTG13). However, none of them has higher similarity to SARS-CoV-2 than the RaTG13 has. Therefore, none of them are the progenitor virus of SARS-CoV-2 (this would usually entail >99% in genome). None could be isolated. The reported illnesses associated with the miners, according to the WIV experts, were more likely explained by fungal infections acquired when removing a thick layer of guano.
Google 'shi nature article miners'
Addendum: A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin by 28 authors and Zheng-Li Shi. Published 17 November 2020.
Here we provide further information about the bat SARS-related coronavirus (SARSr-CoV) strain RaTG13 reported in our Article. Between 1 July and 1 October 2012, we received 13 serum samples collected from 4 patients (one of whom was deceased) who showed severe respiratory disease. These patients had visited a mine cave in Tongguan town, Mojiang County, Yunnan Province, China, to clean bat faeces in order to mine copper before being admitted to the First Affiliated Hospital of Kunming Medical University on 26–27 April 2012. The samples we received were collected by the hospital staff in June, July, August and September 2012. To investigate the cause of the respiratory disease, we tested the samples using PCR methods developed in our laboratory targeting the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRp) of Ebola virus, Nipah virus and bat SARSr-CoV Rp3, and all of the samples were negative for the presence of these viruses. We also tested the serum samples for the presence of antibodies against the nucleocapsid proteins of these three viruses, and none of the samples gave a positive result. Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein—which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with bat SARSr-CoV Rp3—and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.
These samples from the miners had no coronaviruses and no antibodies to them in late 2012. Possibly not widely known outside of this group of 29 scientists. Shi and her colleges have known since 2013 that the miners were not infected by those viruses.
 
Last edited:
Could you explain this? I don't quite understand the "would happen regardless bit",


If the fact that some lab accidents have been documented, is "evidence" for a lab leak then it's evidence every single time there is a disease outbreak even the ones that didn't come from a lab. It can't be used to to decern when something is a lab leak because it always says everything is a lab leak whether it really was one or not.


If the the mere existence of lab accidents is evidence for a lab leak, surely it's also evidence Zika came from a lab. And Ebola. And H1N1. And SARS. And AIDS. And so on. Every major disease outbreak of a new disease or strain brings accusations of it having come from a lab and every time the CT can be supported by "lab accidents have occurred" (even though none of these has ever caused a major human disease outbreak.)

Why is the fact that natural spillover occurred in the past being used as evidence for a natural spillover theory, but the fact that lab leaks have occurred in the past discounted as evidence for a lab leak theory?

Spillover is the norm and ahs occured an uncountable number of times in the last. Lab leaks occurred rarely at best and have never caused a major human disease outbreak. The side making the extraordinary claim needs to present evidence.

Its not her ethnicity that is the issue, its the fact that she is a Chinese citizen and thus under the control of the CCP.

Not un-coincidentally, the majority of such people are ethnically Chinese...

In Shi's case we have a conformed track record of her following the science even when it conflicted with the Chinese governments narrative.
 
Last edited:
Do you have evidence of a survey of these virologists because what I see are that some support spillover, a few support the lab origin and the majority agree both origin hypotheses are still on the table.


Don't confuses someone saying "it's not impossible" with them saying there is any evidence it happened that way. It's like saying "god did it", sure you can't prove that god didn't do it but that doesn't put it on par with actual scientific arguments that have actual evidence behind them.

The published science is heavily weighted to research into it being a naturally evolving virus that crossed over to humans from a wild animal population. In fact there is precisely NO convincing scientific evidence for a lab leak.
 
"Influential"? To whom besides yourself?

I think the things revealed by DRASTIC have been influential in getting people to recognize Daszak's conflict of interest, his manipulation of the direction of the investigation and his lying to other researchers about the Lancet opinion piece. DRASTIC's uncovering of the two contemporary theses based on the infected miners in Yunnan in 2012 did a lot to dispel Shi's claim the miners died of a fungus. And DRASTIC exposed the fact, with evidence, there are hundreds of SARS-like CoV specimens that have been collected from the area yet there is little record of them in what the WIV has released. They have also documented the fact there are indeed live bats kept at the WIV, another thing Shi denies.

Their misleading and out of context quote mining is directly borrowed from the attacks on climate scientists over the last 2 decades. In fact they are even leveraging the same misinformation network to sell their attacks on science. Eg you personally have cited climate denier websites like polarbearsceince for "evidence" of a lab leak.
 
Not un-coincidentally, the majority of such people are ethnically Chinese...

In Shi's case we have a conformed track record of her following the science even when it conflicted with the Chinese governments narrative.

Cant quite parse "not uncoincidentally": Could you rephrase? It seems like you are saying its a coincidence that someone living in China is ethnically Chinese? Despite being wrong, I fail to see the relevance.

Anyone who is living under the control of the CCP is by definition, under control of the CCP. Their ethnicity has nothing to do with it. Non ethnically Chinese people living in China are also under the control of the CCP and subject to the same laws and restrictions.

And to the last point, once again China era 2003 is not China 2021. Its a completely different beast, the government and the security services behave completely differently. They will not tolerate dissent from anyone internally, they will not allow the official narrative to be challenged. Her historical track record could be used as evidence if all things were equal, and we were still living in that era. We are not.
 
Cant quite parse "not uncoincidentally": Could you rephrase? It seems like you are saying its a coincidence that someone living in China is ethnically Chinese? Despite being wrong, I fail to see the relevance.

Anyone who is living under the control of the CCP is by definition, under control of the CCP. Their ethnicity has nothing to do with it. Non ethnically Chinese people living in China are also under the control of the CCP and subject to the same laws and restrictions.

And to the last point, once again China era 2003 is not China 2021. Its a completely different beast, the government and the security services behave completely differently. They will not tolerate dissent from anyone internally, they will not allow the official narrative to be challenged. Her historical track record could be used as evidence if all things were equal, and we were still living in that era. We are not.
This ^. The ophthalmologist who notified colleagues outside of China that there was an unusual pneumonia outbreak in Wuhan was threatened by the authorities and told to shut up. He later died of COVID and got a posthumous apology from the government.

And, what do we know about Shi's scientific integrity? We have good evidence she lied about the miners' cause of death. We have good evidence she lied about not having any live bats at the WIV and about claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV. And we have both Shi and Daszak currently refusing to share their databases on the coronavirus genome records.
 
Well, we talked before about the Nipah conference that Zhengli Shi attended. Now our friend Dr Quay has a theory that the WIV is going to make a new pandemic by messing around with Nipah.

Well, he's got a book to flog with Great Barrington Declaration co-signer, Professor Angus "four in a row is against the laws of physics" Dalgliesh.
 

Attachments

  • prof devi sridhar.jpg
    prof devi sridhar.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 3
  • Quay on Nipah.jpg
    Quay on Nipah.jpg
    30.9 KB · Views: 4
  • Quay Dalgliesh Covid book.jpg
    Quay Dalgliesh Covid book.jpg
    21.1 KB · Views: 3
I really have no idea what Steven Quay is claiming here.

He says something like "when patients were sampled in December at a hospital in Wuhan, samples sent to the WIV, they are put on a special sequencing machine, it's American technology actually, ... it generates copies of everything in the sample, but it's so sensitive it generates copies of everything in the laboratory. We actually found twenty different things that shouldn't have been in the patient. We found honeysuckle genes, okay the plants, and so what I did was I looked at research publications from the WIV over the last two years, I was able to identify 18 out of 20 prior publications. The two I couldn't was a deadly influenza virus...and the Nipah virus! And we found a third of the virus in a vector as it's called which is something used to make large copies of something and this is something unmistakable, this is a smoking gun for the Nipah virus. This is what you'd have expected to see two years ago for SARS-CoV2"

I have no idea what that means....

Does anyone else know what Dr Quay is talking about here? I can't even understand what he means about how some equipment manages to copy everything in the lab, or how he got hold of these samples, or whether these were written in some raw data in a paper.

But if it is a "smoking gun" I am sure he will write up his findings and publish them, or just put them on a pre-print server or something.

Link
 
Oh, so it looks like Dr Quay did write a paper, with Yuri Deigin and Daoyu Zhang and some other guy.

Link

Abstract
We report the detection of Nipah virus in an infectious clone format, a BSL4-level pathogen and
CDC-designated Bioterrorism Agent, in raw RNA-Seq sequencing reads deposited by the Wuhan
Institute of Virology (WIV) produced from five December 2019 patients infected with
SARS-CoV-2. Research involving Nipah infectious clones has never been reported to have
occured at the WIV. These patient samples have been previously reported to contain reads from
several other viruses: Influenza A, Spodoptera frugiperda rhabdovirus and Nipah. Previous
authors have interpreted the presence of these virus sequences as indicative of co-infections of
the patients in question by these pathogens or laboratory contamination. However, our analysis
shows that NiV genes are encapsulated in synthetic vectors, which we infer was for assembly of
a NiV infectious clone. In particular, we document the finding of internal N, P/V/W/C and L
protein coding sequences as well as coverage of the G and F genes. Furthermore, the format of
Hepatitis D virus ribozyme and T7 terminator downstream of the 5’ end of the NiV sequence is
consistent with truncation required at the end of the genome for a full length infectious clone.
This indicates that research at WIV was being conducted on an assembled NiV infectious clone.
Contamination of patient sequencing reads by an infectious NiV clone of the highly pathogenic
Bangladesh strain could indicate a significant breach of BSL4 protocols. We call on WIV to
explain the purpose of this research on infectious clones of Nipah Virus, the full chronology of
this work, and to explain how and at what stage of sample preparation this contamination
occurred.

Does anyone understand this?
 
I really have no idea what Steven Quay is claiming here.

He says something like "when patients were sampled in December at a hospital in Wuhan, samples sent to the WIV, they are put on a special sequencing machine, it's American technology actually, ... it generates copies of everything in the sample, but it's so sensitive it generates copies of everything in the laboratory. We actually found twenty different things that shouldn't have been in the patient. We found honeysuckle genes, okay the plants, and so what I did was I looked at research publications from the WIV over the last two years, I was able to identify 18 out of 20 prior publications. The two I couldn't was a deadly influenza virus...and the Nipah virus! And we found a third of the virus in a vector as it's called which is something used to make large copies of something and this is something unmistakable, this is a smoking gun for the Nipah virus. This is what you'd have expected to see two years ago for SARS-CoV2"

I have no idea what that means....

Does anyone else know what Dr Quay is talking about here? I can't even understand what he means about how some equipment manages to copy everything in the lab, or how he got hold of these samples, or whether these were written in some raw data in a paper.

But if it is a "smoking gun" I am sure he will write up his findings and publish them, or just put them on a pre-print server or something.

Link

The sequencing reaction has to make a copy of the DNA template to derive the sequence.
 
Oh, so it looks like Dr Quay did write a paper, with Yuri Deigin and Daoyu Zhang and some other guy.

Link



Does anyone understand this?

Sort of. Looks like they could have been making pseudotyped viruses hence the HIV vector. I'm not sure about the conclusion that "the Hepatitis D virus ribozyme and T7 terminator downstream of the 5’ end of the NiV sequence is
consistent with truncation required at the end of the genome for a full-length infectious clone".
 
"claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV" quote

This ^. The ophthalmologist who notified colleagues outside of China that there was an unusual pneumonia outbreak in Wuhan was threatened by the authorities and told to shut up. He later died of COVID and got a posthumous apology from the government. ...
More misinformation. This is Li Wenliang.
30 December 2019: The Wuhan CDC alerted local hospitals to be on the lookout for pneumonia of unknown cases after doctors had noticed them.
Li read that memo and posted that there were 7 cases of SARS on a private WeChat group of his medical school classmates. Screenshots were shared on the Chinese internet.
3 January 2020: he was one of eight people reprimanded for "spreading rumors".
7 February 2020: Li died of COVID-19.
The local authorities reacted with a tribute and condolences. Later the Chinese government honored Li "as a "martyr," which is the highest honor the government can bestow on a citizen who dies from serving China".

Repeating fantasies does not make Shi into a liar.
Has anyone seen any any quote "claiming there were no in vitro CoV cultures at the WIV" from Shi?

A Shi refusing to share the WIV database on the coronavirus genome records fantasy. No one seems to have asked for that database that was taken offline due to hacking. Probably because they know that the majority of the records are available elsewhere. Ditto for Daszak and seemingly a personal database.
 
Last edited:
Well this is interesting and maybe significant, maybe not.

There was a finding of a Nipah related virus in rats in the Mojiang mine in 2012, 6 months after the miners died.
Novel Henipa-like Virus, Mojiang Paramyxovirus, in Rats, China, 2012
Our study showed the presence of a rodent-origin, henipa-like virus, MojV, in China. R. flavipectus rats are the natural reservoir of MojV. This finding and its context indicate that Henipavirus spp. viruses might infect more mammalian hosts than previously thought and that bats may not be the only hosts of henipaviruses

IIRC it was not found again and was ruled out as the virus that infected the miners. I'd have to go look at citations from pages back. And this may or may not be relevant. But the following could be more than just a coincidence.

One from the above link to the Quay et al report:
Abstract:
Previous authors have interpreted the presence of these virus sequences as indicative of co-infections of the patients in question by these pathogens or laboratory contamination....

Intro:
Here we document the presence of Nipah virus (NiV) sequences, Banglisash strain, interpreted as likely for assembly of a NiV infectious clone, found in raw sequencing reads by the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) from five patients infected with SARS-CoV-2 sampled by the Wuhan Jin Yin-Tan Hospital at the beginning of the COVID-19 outbreak (Zhou et al. 2020).
...

Given that the coverage of the NiV by this pooled dataset is c. 42% and in particular coverage of the G and F gene sequences are low, it is possible that the NiV sequence is an unpublished, closely related strain to NiV Bangladesh (AY9688601.1). ...

Chakraborty (2020a) and Abouelkhair (2020) interpreted the presence of these virus sequences as indicative of co-infection of early Wuhan COVID-19 infected patients with these microbes. However Quay et al. (2021) discuss the presence of a sequence H7N9 Hemagglutinin A segment 4 gene found in a synthetic vector in these COVID-19 patient samples and found contamination the likely cause, while Zhang (2020) identified the presence of a NiV infectious clone in the datasets. Here we review the recovery of a partial infectious clone of a Bangladesh strain of Nipah virus, a BSL4 level virus, with sequences joined directly to synthetic vector DNA.

And then there is this: Science, 2013: In a new study, U.S. researchers estimate that there are more than 320,000 unknown viruses lurking in mammals alone.
To estimate how many viruses might be lurking in in wild mammals, researchers from Columbia University and EcoHealth Alliance[/], a conservation organization in New York City, studied flying foxes in Bangladesh. From 2006 to 2010, they caught hundreds of the big bats and collected urine and fecal samples as well as throat swabs before releasing them. They then fished out all the viral sequences they could find belonging to nine virus families, including the coronaviruses, herpesviruses, and influenza A viruses. Each family was chosen because it is already known to include human pathogens and because good tests are available for finding new viruses in the family, says Simon Anthony, a virologist at Columbia University and one of the authors on the paper. They found 55 viruses in all, 50 of which had never been seen before, including 10 in the same family as the Nipah virus that has caused numerous outbreaks in South Asia since surfacing in 1999.

That was after SARS 1 but before the miners got sick.

The specimens were first sequenced by the WIV so contamination is certainly on the table.
Significant contamination at Wuhan sequencing facilities was previously documented by Zhang et al. (2021) with MERS-r CoV and SARS-r CoV genomes recovered from agricultural sequencing datasets.
 
And to the last point, once again China era 2003 is not China 2021.

Other than being significantly more developed now what do you *think* has changed? The current regime is simpler a continuation of the one that has ruled China or decades.

If you are so worried about China don't you think it's worth investing in the critical thinking skills needed to figure out what they are really up to? I don't trust China so I'm willing to believe anything anyone says about it isn't exactly a good way to protect yourself, it just opens you up for manipulation.
 
I really have no idea what Steven Quay is claiming here.

He says something like "when patients were sampled in December at a hospital in Wuhan, samples sent to the WIV, they are put on a special sequencing machine, it's American technology actually, ... it generates copies of everything in the sample, but it's so sensitive it generates copies of everything in the laboratory. We actually found twenty different things that shouldn't have been in the patient. We found honeysuckle genes, okay the plants, and so what I did was I looked at research publications from the WIV over the last two years, I was able to identify 18 out of 20 prior publications. The two I couldn't was a deadly influenza virus...and the Nipah virus! And we found a third of the virus in a vector as it's called which is something used to make large copies of something and this is something unmistakable, this is a smoking gun for the Nipah virus. This is what you'd have expected to see two years ago for SARS-CoV2"

I have no idea what that means....

Does anyone else know what Dr Quay is talking about here? I can't even understand what he means about how some equipment manages to copy everything in the lab, or how he got hold of these samples, or whether these were written in some raw data in a paper.

But if it is a "smoking gun" I am sure he will write up his findings and publish them, or just put them on a pre-print server or something.

Link
While it is unfortunate Quay is interviewed on Fox and worse by an anchor who states right out that the lab hypothesis is true, I looked for corroboration separate from Quay even though there are 3 other names on the cited paper. I found this:
A Canadian news source, Aug 2021: Samples From Early Wuhan COVID Patients Had Genetically Modified Henipah, One of Two Types of Viruses Sent From Canadian Lab
The Epoch Times asked Joe Wang, PhD, who formerly spearheaded a vaccine development program for SARS in Canada with one of the world’s leading pharmaceutical companies, to verify the finding. Wang is currently the president of NTD Television Canada, the sister company of The Epoch Times in Canada.

After examining the evidence, Wang said he was able to replicate Quay’s findings on the Henipah virus. He explains that the genetic manipulation of the virus was likely for the purposes of vaccine development.



In that same news link is a new rabbit hole:
Henipah was one of the two types of viruses sent to China by Chinese-born scientists from a Canadian laboratory at the centre of a controversy over the firing of the scientists and collaboration with Chinese military researchers. It is not clear whether the virus found in the Chinese samples is related to the samples sent by the Canadian lab, which were shipped in late March 2019. ...

The firing of Chinese-born scientist Xiangguo Qiu and her husband, Keding Cheng, from the National Microbiology laboratory (NML) in Winnipeg has been the subject of much controversy in Canada, with opposition parties pressing the government for more details on the case, and the government refusing to release information citing national security and privacy concerns.

Qiu and Cheng along with several Chinese students were escorted out of NML, Canada’s only Level 4 lab, in July 2019, amid a police investigation. The two scientists were formally fired in January 2021. ...

During her time at NML, Qiu travelled several times in an official capacity to WIV, helping train personnel on Level 4 safety. The Globe and Mail later reported that scientists at NML have been collaborating with Chinese military researchers on deadly pathogens, and that one of the Chinese military researchers worked at the high-security Winnipeg lab for a period of time.

Documents and emails released by PHAC show that the shipment of Henipah and Ebola samples was done with the permission of NML authorities. ...

After the House of Commons issued an order for the government to disclose the information, the government took the Speaker of the House to court to obtain confirmation from a judge that it can withhold the documents. The government later dropped its court case once Prime Minister Justin Trudeau called an election and Parliament was dissolved.



On a separate note, here's the main Quay Tweet minus the childish replies you see when you click on the post: https://twitter.com/quay_dr

I don't understand why one sees two different Tweet threads, the one you linked to: https://twitter.com/quay_dr/status/1450236918956838912 and Quay's main Twitter thread without the troll replies. It would seem the troll replies are still there somewhere but not visible in the main Twitter account.
 
While it is unfortunate Quay is interviewed on Fox and worse by an anchor who states right out that the lab hypothesis is true, I looked for corroboration separate from Quay even though there are 3 other names on the cited paper. I found this:
A Canadian news source, Aug 2021: Samples From Early Wuhan COVID Patients Had Genetically Modified Henipah, One of Two Types of Viruses Sent From Canadian Lab




In that same news link is a new rabbit hole:




On a separate note, here's the main Quay Tweet minus the childish replies you see when you click on the post: https://twitter.com/quay_dr

I don't understand why one sees two different Tweet threads, the one you linked to: https://twitter.com/quay_dr/status/1450236918956838912 and Quay's main Twitter thread without the troll replies. It would seem the troll replies are still there somewhere but not visible in the main Twitter account.

I wouldn’t consider any of that to be “corroboration”. The guy who apparently “replicated” the findings is President of the New Tang Dynasty network. I mean, huh? He is not a working scientist then, but someone who heads up the Epoch Times, Falun Gong’s right-wing media outlet.

Sorry, I am sure that Falun Gong suffered a lot of persecution by the Chinese government but it is still a wacko cult and their news media is to the right of Fox News. Seriously, they make Fox News look like the BBC.
 
Other than being significantly more developed now what do you *think* has changed? The current regime is simpler a continuation of the one that has ruled China or decades.

If you are so worried about China don't you think it's worth investing in the critical thinking skills needed to figure out what they are really up to? I don't trust China so I'm willing to believe anything anyone says about it isn't exactly a good way to protect yourself, it just opens you up for manipulation.

I don’t think that’s fair. From what I can see Graculus has not said that it’s definitely a lab leak, but only said that the Chinese government cannot be trusted and has become even more intolerant of dissent in recent decades compared with the fairly brief relative opening up of China in the nineties and early 2000s. It seems China no longer feels the need to be ambiguous about its aims regarding Hong Kong (where Graculus lives) or Taiwan which it has openly said it will take over one way or another.
 
I wouldn’t consider any of that to be “corroboration”. The guy who apparently “replicated” the findings is President of the New Tang Dynasty network. I mean, huh? He is not a working scientist then, but someone who heads up the Epoch Times, Falun Gong’s right-wing media outlet.

Sorry, I am sure that Falun Gong suffered a lot of persecution by the Chinese government but it is still a wacko cult and their news media is to the right of Fox News. Seriously, they make Fox News look like the BBC.
Everyone you don't agree with is lying and with those who evidence shows are actually lying like Shi and Daszak, you dismiss the evidence.

There's a reason why a lot of this evidence is coming to light from right-wing sources and in preprints. Many scientists, especially virologists, are reluctant to criticize things like GoF research that might limit their own research, and they've been cowed by the efforts to label the lab leak as a CT.

Vanity Fair: Throughout 2020, the notion that the novel coronavirus leaked from a lab was off-limits. Those who dared to push for transparency say toxic politics and hidden agendas kept us in the dark.
The Lancet statement effectively ended the debate over COVID-19’s origins before it began. To Gilles Demaneuf, following along from the sidelines, it was as if it had been “nailed to the church doors,” establishing the natural origin theory as orthodoxy. “Everyone had to follow it. Everyone was intimidated. That set the tone.”

The statement struck Demaneuf as “totally nonscientific.” To him, it seemed to contain no evidence or information. And so he decided to begin his own inquiry in a “proper” way, with no idea of what he would find. ...

And yet, in the wake of the Lancet statement and under the cloud of Donald Trump’s toxic racism, ... one possible answer to this all-important question remained largely off-limits until the spring of 2021. ...
That's only a couple months ago.

A months long Vanity Fair investigation, interviews with more than 40 people, and a review of hundreds of pages of U.S. government documents, including internal memos, meeting minutes, and email correspondence, found that conflicts of interest, stemming in part from large government grants supporting controversial virology research, hampered the U.S. investigation into COVID-19’s origin at every step. In one State Department meeting, officials seeking to demand transparency from the Chinese government say they were explicitly told by colleagues not to explore the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s gain-of-function research, because it would bring unwelcome attention to U.S. government funding of it. ...

In late March, former Centers for Disease Control director Robert Redfield received death threats from fellow scientists after telling CNN that he believed COVID-19 had originated in a lab. “I was threatened and ostracized because I proposed another hypothesis,” Redfield told Vanity Fair. “I expected it from politicians. I didn’t expect it from science.” ...

Dr. Richard Ebright, board of governors professor of chemistry and chemical biology at Rutgers University, said that from the very first reports of a novel bat-related coronavirus outbreak in Wuhan, it took him “a nanosecond or a picosecond” to consider a link to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Only two other labs in the world, in Galveston, Texas, and Chapel Hill, North Carolina, were doing similar research. “It’s not a dozen cities,” he said. “It’s three places.”

Then came the revelation that the Lancet statement was not only signed but organized by a zoologist named Peter Daszak, who has repackaged U.S. government grants and allocated them to facilities conducting gain-of-function research—among them the WIV itself. David Asher, now a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute, ran the State Department’s day-to-day COVID-19 origins inquiry. He said it soon became clear that “there is a huge gain-of-function bureaucracy” inside the federal government.
BTW, I believe someone upthread tried to downplay the whistleblower ophthalmologist case:
In January 2020, a Wuhan ophthalmologist named Li Wenliang, who’d tried to warn his colleagues that the pneumonia could be a form of SARS was arrested, accused of disrupting the social order, and forced to write a self-criticism. He died of COVID-19 in February, lionized by the Chinese public as a hero and whistleblower.



Are you suggesting Quay made his findings up and conned the other researchers to sign on? Maybe like Daszak did re the Lancet article? :rolleyes:

The present study was initiated to validate the results obtained in earlier studies by Aboulkhair 20201, Quay2021,3and Zhang 20214and to correlate the overall findings from these studies. We also wanted to find out why the non-SARS-CoV-2 sequences were seen in these early patients, the nature of the sequences, and their probable origin.

References

1) Aboulkhair, M. (2020). Non-SARS-CoV-2 genome sequences identified in clinical samples from COVID-19 infected patients: Evidence for co-infections. PeerjDOI 10.7717/peerj.10246.
I'm looking for this paper and will post it when I find it. In the meantime, here's this one:

4) Zhang D. (2021) Vector sequences in early WIV SRA sequencing data of SARS-CoV-2 inform on a potential large-scale security breach at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic https://zenodo.org/record/4486195#.YNM6uuhKjO

February 1, 2021Dataset Open Access
Vector sequences in early WIV SRA sequencing data of SARS-CoV-2 inform on a potential large-scale security breach at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic; Daoyu Zhang
So if the conclusions about the genome data findings are simply false, I'm sure we'll hear about it soon enough. Maybe you could use that as your bases of discrediting Quay et al's findings instead of attacking the sources.

I get it something claimed without evidence by Fox News or the Epoch Times has no value. But this is a detailed paper with detailed methodology and results and it corroborates past work and is in turn corroborated by another researcher who claims to have been able to repeat the results.


It would move this discussion along if people addressed the actual evidence instead of basing their sole arguments on discrediting sources. Quay was dismissed at the beginning of the thread as not understanding Bayesian analyses, as having a private company, and whatever else was said about the physical connection to the line 2 subway he noted. The man is not stupid, he is well qualified by education and experience and he's been dismissed with few specifics that actually address the papers he's put forward.

Obviously his politics are not his best quality. I find them less suspect than Daszak's whose blatant conflict of interest has been exposed at every turn.

To review what Daszak said in that 2019 podcast interview just before the pandemic emerged, here it is in another article addressing the bias in investigating the lab leak theory: Oct 5th 2021; Origins of COVID-19: Who Opened Pandora’s Box at Wuhan – People or Nature? Yes the article was written by Nicholas Wade. But he makes a well supported case that speaks for itself.

On December 9, 2019, before the outbreak of the pandemic became generally known, Dr. Daszak gave an interview in which he talked in glowing terms of how researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology had been reprogramming the spike protein and generating chimeric coronaviruses capable of infecting humanised mice.

“And we have now found, you know, after 6 or 7 years of doing this, over 100 new SARS-related coronaviruses, very close to SARS,” Dr. Daszak says around minute 28 of the interview. “Some of them get into human cells in the lab, some of them can cause SARS disease in humanised mice models and are untreatable with therapeutic monoclonals and you can’t vaccinate against them with a vaccine. So, these are a clear and present danger…

“Interviewer: You say these are diverse coronaviruses and you can’t vaccinate against them, and no anti-virals – so what do we do?

“Daszak: Well I think … coronaviruses – you can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily. Spike protein drives a lot of what happen with coronavirus, in zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence, you can build the protein, and we work a lot with Ralph Baric at UNC to do this. Insert into the backbone of another virus and do some work in the lab. So you can get more predictive when you find a sequence. You’ve got this diversity. Now the logical progression for vaccines is, if you are going to develop a vaccine for SARS, people are going to use pandemic SARS, but let’s insert some of these other things and get a better vaccine.” The insertions he referred to perhaps included an element called the furin cleavage site, discussed below, which greatly increases viral infectivity for human cells.

And what followed:
One can only imagine Dr. Daszak’s reaction when he heard of the outbreak of the epidemic in Wuhan a few days later. He would have known better than anyone the Wuhan Institute’s goal of making bat coronaviruses infectious to humans, as well as the weaknesses in the institute’s defense against their own researchers becoming infected.

But instead of providing public health authorities with the plentiful information at his disposal, he immediately launched a public relations campaign to persuade the world that the epidemic couldn’t possibly have been caused by one of the institute’s souped-up viruses. “The idea that this virus escaped from a lab is just pure baloney. It’s simply not true,” he declared in an April 2020 interview.
 
Yeah. We’ve been through all of this before. I don’t believe Redfield received death threats from fellow scientists. At least there is surely no way he knows particular scientists that have given him death threats as that is illegal and he could have them prosecuted. Maybe he received anonymous ones but if so he doesn’t know they are from scientists.

That said Fauci, Daszak and Shi have doubtless been receiving all kinds of threats .
 
So does anybody here know of any reviewable records of scientific laboratory tests, under a microscope, analyzing and identifying the COVID-19 delta variant (SARS-CoV-2 Delta Variant) virus from isolated samples extracted from a human being?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom