Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that really true? I would say that in a recombination event, the only thing that is needed is that the two combining RNA strings will be able to make up 100% of the SARS-CoV-2 genome. This could be done by, say 97% of bat virus, and 3% pangolin.
But we have no evidence of the recombination result that suggests we have found the source.

We have a partial match in bats and a partial match in pangolins. We don't have a combined match that is close enough to jump.
 
I know but thanks. I try to say non-human primates but it gets tedious.

I was hoping you'd join this thread. I'm interested in your take.


I don't think we have enough information. There are so many possibilities. There are lots of bats and lots of viruses. Bat caves are cleaned out of bat guano for copper mining and those individuals got sick. Plenty of opportunities there for virus mixing and adaptation to humans.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
What other analogy can I use to point out 97% is not close enough?


I don't have one. Virologists don't tend to use analogies, they just look at sequence trees and nod their heads.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I don't think we have enough information. There are so many possibilities. There are lots of bats and lots of viruses. Bat caves are cleaned out of bat guano for copper mining and those individuals got sick. Plenty of opportunities there for virus mixing and adaptation to humans.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This isn't really the case. The changes that allow Covid to spread in humans could not have evolved in a bat because the spike structure attaches poorly to bat ACE2 receptors.

Similarly the virus could not have spread to humans and evolved from there because the spike that can attach to bat ACE2 doesn't readily attach to human ACE2.

It also doesn't seem to be a case of it evolving into an intermediate form that can infect either, because the Covid-19 spike contains the distinct signature of recombination with a virus that infects Pangolines.

This gives us a really good idea about what happened. A host, almost certainly a Pangolin, was infected by both viruses. The two viruses attacked the same cell, which in RNA viruses commonly causes genetic material from one to get spliced into the other. (Recombination) The result was a bat virus with a spike that that strongly resembled the one in the Pangolin virus.

This had to have happened in a host where that spike structure could attack to the ACE2 binding domain, or the virus would not have been able to propagate any further. It could have been something other than a Pangolin but that would have required BOTH viruses to jump to another species before the recombination event.

The most likely case is the Pangolin itself because the spike was already evolved to attach to Pangolin ACE2 binding and one of the viruses already circulated regularly in Pangolins so all that would have been required is for a sick Pangolin to come into contact with the bat virus.

Since the new virus already had a spike suitable for infecting Pangolins it could have spread and perhaps even evolved in them until one of the infected animals ended up in the Wuhan market where the virus jumped to humans.

From there it would take ~8 weeks before it became clear there was a new virus circulating. Since it started in the market, most of the initial spread would have been between workers and visitors but there was sufficient time for cases to have spread away from the market as well.
 
This isn't really the case. The changes that allow Covid to spread in humans could not have evolved in a bat because the spike structure attaches poorly to bat ACE2 receptors.

Similarly the virus could not have spread to humans and evolved from there because the spike that can attach to bat ACE2 doesn't readily attach to human ACE2.

It also doesn't seem to be a case of it evolving into an intermediate form that can infect either, because the Covid-19 spike contains the distinct signature of recombination with a virus that infects Pangolines.

So when the scientists found viruses in Yunnan that are able to infect directly (in human cell cultures) and SARS-related antibodies from local villagers, then why not?

I'm not saying it happened for SARS-CoV-2, but it does seem to happen for SARS-related viruses- at least the ones in that cave in Yunnan. (it doesnt seen to happen in other bat populations tested)

Even recently, for SARS-CoV-2, the Chinese scientists do not rule out direct infection:

From a paper this year (submitted 9/20, published 1/2021):
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2095927321000475?via=ihub

Bat coronavirus (CoV) RaTG13 shares the highest genome sequence identity with SARS-CoV-2 among all known coronaviruses, and also uses human angiotensin converting enzyme 2 (hACE2) for virus entry. Thus, SARS-CoV-2 is thought to have originated from bat. However, whether SARS-CoV-2 emerged from bats directly or through an intermediate host remains elusive.
 
Last edited:
What other analogy can I use to point out 97% is not close enough?

Here’s the he thing:

The closeness is what is giving rise to the lab hypothesis in the first place. This is why they are suggesting that either it is a similar virus or the Ratg13 that has been given supercharged in the lab.

It seems most virologists are discounting it on the basis that creating SARS CoV 2 from that particular virus would involve science not yet known, and are thus dismissing the lab leak or at the very least saying it makes it highly unlikely.

If you’re saying it is not close at all then it seems you are agreeing with them that it diminishes the lab leak theory.

On the other hand it seems that the wide distribution of SARS CoV-similar viruses makes the likelihood that another family member in the wild is the culprit.
 
So when the scientists found viruses in Yunnan that are able to infect directly (in human cell cultures) and SARS-related antibodies from local villagers, then why not?

I'm not saying it happened for SARS-CoV-2, but it does seem to happen for SARS-related viruses- at least the ones in that cave in Yunnan. (it doesnt seen to happen in other bat populations tested)

Even recently, for SARS-CoV-2, the Chinese scientists do not rule out direct infection:

From a paper this year (submitted 9/20, published 1/2021):
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2095927321000475?via=ihub

Assumption alert (IANAV): I’m assuming the Ratg13 virus required a much higher viral load than SARS CoV 2. Maybe the workers had to be in very close proximity to a lot of the stuff in a confined space breathing it in.

On the other hand, SARS CoV 2 shows signs of “better adaptation to humans” hence the “hypothesis” that it was this virus that had been subjected to gain of function experiments.

The virologists are drawing different conclusions, from what I can gather saying that this type of discovery points to the fear that there were way more similar viruses out there getting ever closer to creating a new pandemic given the opportunities of recombining within wildlife, farmed, and domestic animals.

Organizations such as EcoHealth Alliance and others have been worrying about how ecological destruction and of course wet markets, etc... are increasing the chances that one of the similar viruses spills over.

I think it comes to a different view of what the Wuhan Institute of Virology is doing.
 
Worth noting that this theory is a more plausible example of "face saving" in that frozen food would take culpability away from the cultural practice of live animals in wet markets.

Yes, I was thinking something along those lines.

Even if the lab is cleared, there are many aspects of this that point the finger at China in general.

Another one is that the virologists have been pointing to the sensitivity that surrounds whichever region this virus is seen to originate from.
 
lomiller said:
IOW “I’m not saying, I’m just saying”. Sorry but this isn’t the least bit convincing. ANY science can be overturned with the next new discovery. When we have an explanation that works we don’t “keep the door open” to alternative expansions with no evidence behind them just because new evidence “could come along”. We change our minds WHEN there is evidence for these alternative theories, not before.
I stated that the jury is still out and you are not convinced I mean it?:rolleyes: Stop with the accusations please.



Moving on. This was interesting. There is at least one paper in Nature (posted above) that concludes there can't be a direct jump from bats to humans. I've been looking at papers from the WIV written before Nov 2019 to see what they were researching at the lab.

PLoS 2017 WIL: Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus
Abstract
A large number of SARS-related coronaviruses (SARSr-CoV) have been detected in horseshoe bats since 2005 in different areas of China. However, these bat SARSr-CoVs show sequence differences from SARS coronavirus (SARS-CoV) in different genes (S, ORF8, ORF3, etc) and are considered unlikely to represent the direct progenitor of SARS-CoV. Herein, we report the findings of our 5-year surveillance of SARSr-CoVs in a cave inhabited by multiple species of horseshoe bats in Yunnan Province, China. The full-length genomes of 11 newly discovered SARSr-CoV strains, together with our previous findings, reveals that the SARSr-CoVs circulating in this single location are highly diverse in the S gene, ORF3 and ORF8. Importantly, strains with high genetic similarity to SARS-CoV in the hypervariable N-terminal domain (NTD) and receptor-binding domain (RBD) of the S1 gene, the ORF3 and ORF8 region, respectively, were all discovered in this cave. In addition, we report the first discovery of bat SARSr-CoVs highly similar to human SARS-CoV in ORF3b and in the split ORF8a and 8b. Moreover, SARSr-CoV strains from this cave were more closely related to SARS-CoV in the non-structural protein genes ORF1a and 1b compared with those detected elsewhere. Recombination analysis shows evidence of frequent recombination events within the S gene and around the ORF8 between these SARSr-CoVs. We hypothesize that the direct progenitor of SARS-CoV may have originated after sequential recombination events between the precursors of these SARSr-CoVs. Cell entry studies demonstrated that three newly identified SARSr-CoVs with different S protein sequences are all able to use human ACE2 as the receptor, further exhibiting the close relationship between strains in this cave and SARS-CoV. [/B]This work provides new insights into the origin and evolution of SARS-CoV and highlights the necessity of preparedness for future emergence of SARS-like diseases.

Was this all theoretical or was this based on lab experiments only a couple years before the pandemic? Or was it based on finding and collecting the relevant strains?

From the body of the paper:
We have carried out a five-year longitudinal surveillance (April 2011 to October 2015) on SARSr-CoVs in bats from a single habitat in proximity to Kunming city, Yunnan province, China, which was mainly inhabited by horseshoe bats....

The full-length genome sequences of all 15 SARSr-CoVs from the surveyed cave were screened for evidence of potential recombination events....
That is all collecting and analyzing wild virus.


Then we get to experiments:
... when Vero E6 cells* were respectively infected with the two successfully rescued chimeric SARSr-CoVs, WIV1-Rs4231S and WIV1-Rs7327S, and the newly isolated Rs4874, efficient virus replication was detected in all infections (Fig 7). To assess whether the three novel SARSr-CoVs can use human ACE2 as a cellular entry receptor, we conducted virus infectivity studies using HeLa cells** with or without the expression of human ACE2. All viruses replicated efficiently in the human ACE2-expressing cells. The results were further confirmed by quantification of viral RNA using real-time RT-PCR (Fig 8).

Research was done with cultured bat virus, they did not collect live bats in this report. But they did demonstrate that bat coronavirus could replicate in human cells.

That doesn't mean they created COVID-19, only that they were working with CoV that could infect humans.

*Green Monkey cells used to culture viruses
**Henrietta Lacks cells Human cells that don't die out, used to culture and test viruses.


Nature 2013: Isolation and characterization of a bat SARS-like coronavirus that uses the ACE2 receptor
Abstract
...attempts to isolate the progenitor virus of SARS-CoV from bats have been unsuccessful. ...Here we report whole-genome sequences of two novel bat coronaviruses from Chinese horseshoe bats (family: Rhinolophidae) in Yunnan, China: RsSHC014 and Rs3367. These viruses are far more closely related to SARS-CoV than any previously identified bat coronaviruses, particularly in the receptor binding domain of the spike protein. Here we report whole-genome sequences of two novel bat coronaviruses from Chinese horseshoe bats (family: Rhinolophidae) in Yunnan, China: RsSHC014 and Rs3367. These viruses are far more closely related to SARS-CoV than any previously identified bat coronaviruses, particularly in the receptor binding domain of the spike protein. Most importantly, we report the first recorded isolation of a live SL-CoV (bat SL-CoV-WIV1) from bat faecal samples in Vero E6 cells, which has typical coronavirus morphology, 99.9% sequence identity to Rs3367 and uses ACE2 from humans, civets and Chinese horseshoe bats for cell entry. ...

More importantly:
Preliminary in vitro testing indicates that WIV1 also has a broad species tropism. Our results provide the strongest evidence to date that Chinese horseshoe bats are natural reservoirs of SARS-CoV, and that intermediate hosts may not be necessary for direct human infection by some bat SL-CoVs.
Not that the virus came from a cave in Yunnan, but that there were cultures of risky viruses at the WIV. And the virus would be completely natural, not one that was even a chimera made in the lab.


Again I point out the initial outbreak was in the neighborhood of the WIV.
 
Did they have dangerous viruses in the lab? Sure, it's a BSL-4 lab.

Did they have SARS CoV2 in the lab? No evidence.

So what is the theory here?
 
In its simplest and ideal form, the testable proposition would be that if the WIV did not exist, this pandemic would not be happening.
 
I wanted to return to this...because I have been looking into it...

I posted this upthread:

But I wanted to post this from a link in that paragraph to a blog: Matt Ridley, Rational Optimist*Does that sound like there are no virologists questioning the WHO investigation?

However, the public scientific consensus had been slowly shifting even before the announcement. A growing number of top experts including (ordered alphabetically by last name) Drs Francois Balloux, Ralph S. Baric, Trevor Bedford, Jesse Bloom, Bruno Canard, Etienne Decroly, Richard H. Ebright, Michael B. Eisen, Gareth Jones, Filippa Lentsoz, Michael Z. Lin, Marc Lipsitch, Stuart A. Newman, Rasmus Nielsen, Megan Palmer, Nikolai Petrovsky, Angela Rasmussen, and David A. Relman have stated publicly (several in early 2020) that a lab leak remains a plausible scientific hypothesis to be investigated, regardless of how likely or unlikely. We informed and obtained consent from each expert for their inclusion in this list.

Remember that my question before was which virologists support the lab leak theory.

The above list is actually what reminds me of a Gish Gallop, because the assumption is that each of the names mentioned above, represent the following:

a) they are virologists
b) they support the theory that the virus leaked from a lab

However,
Francois Balloux is not a virologist and in the video, from 7:55 he says, “Where did it come from? There are many viruses around in China and can jump around...the most likely is a natural spillover from an animal? Did it come from a lab? It’s difficult to say, no evidence it has been manipulated...” etc... He DOES NOT support the lab leak theory.

Ralph S. Baric, I don’t know if he is a virologist as such, but in the paper cited by Ridley he says, “How, then, did the virus emerge? Anderson et al. cite multiple lines of strong evidence that argue, instead, in favor of various mechanisms of natural selection, either in an animal host before the virus was transmitted to humans or in humans after the zoonotic transmission event(s). These possibilities will be reviewed below. Nevertheless, speculation about accidental laboratory escape will likely persist, given the large collections of bat virome samples stored in labs in the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the facility’s proximity to the early outbreak, and the operating procedures at the facility”. Hardly strong support for a lab leak. In fact, looking on Twitter, it seems a lot of people think he is part of the conspiracy given his work with Zheng-li Shi.

Trevor Bedford, in the very source that Ridley uses, Bedford says: “I've written before that #COVID19 has no evidence of genetic engineering and the "bioweapon" theory has no grounds. See, for example https://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1224207086013149184. In this thread I wanted to directly address the theory of escape from lab in Wuhan. 1/21” and “We have public figures making televised statements promoting this lab escape theory and I believe it needs to be addressed directly. Not because it has evidence, but because a vacuum permits these theories room to expand. 2/21”

Okay, look, I said before that I checked a few and got some similar results. I am getting bored and annoyed by this.

Almost all of Ridley’s claims regarding “A growing number of top experts... have stated publicly (several in early 2020) that a lab leak remains a plausible scientific hypothesis to be investigated” turn out to be them saying the almost complete opposite.

This is exactly the kind of thing we see in conspiracy theorizing. Someone says something like, “Yes, I think we need to look into it” and a conspiracy theorist seizes on the comment to say that this person supports the conspiracy theory.

I predict that anyone going through the other names in the list will find very similar results. But of course it is time-consuming to look into each one. Pure, pure Gish Gallop on the part of Matt "climate change is not a problem lets keep burning fossil fuels" Ridley!

Yet the biggest proponents of this theory are way, way out of their field.

Bill "vaccines are bad" Maher
Bret "vaccines are at least dodgier than we hear; the election fraud claims need to be looked into; I became famous after being cancelled and now have made a career out of appearing on Joe Rogan, hanging out with Jordan Peterson, questioning the natural origins of Covid, coming up with crackpot theories about evolution and angering Richard Dawkins, the left is the real problem even though I totally am a liberal, honest!" Weinstein.
Steven "not even other conspiracy theorists take my paper seriously" Quay.


etc...
 
What were the results of the serology tests on the lab workers?
Surely they were all tested as soon as possible. I can't find anything on it.

The first confirmed patient in Wuhan was December 8- Man, mid forties, office worker.. He said his parents went to a wet market (a different one). Parents tested negative. No other contact tracing information was given.

Upon hearing the man describe how his parents went to the wet market, Peter Daszak said:

Daszak said the Chinese scientists, looking into the case as part of the government's response, assured the WHO team the patient's parents had tested negative for the disease, yet the Chinese did not appear to have traced the parents' contacts in that market.
"If you find out the patients are negative, it is not obvious to contact-trace them. But it is worth doing now because we understand something of the spread of Covid around Wuhan," Daszak said.
This patient had no known connection to the Huanan seafood market..

How about the people in his office building, his apartment building, his local takeout place, his friends, etc.. ? This 40-something man did not live in a parental bubble. Why focus on the parents who tested negative? Odd, yes?

Seems other scientists were surprised at the lack of info into this first patient:

Other scientists expressed surprise and even disbelief that the further investigations, into both the first patient's contact history and the supply chain to the Huanan market that the WHO sought, had apparently not already been performed by China.
Professor Maureen Miller, an infectious disease epidemiologist at Columbia University, said: "It's implausible that this research has not been done. It's not realistic, given they have world-class scientists there, and the technology invested in over the last 20 years. They are sophisticated, they understand transmission pathways, and have been working on them for years."

(CNN article here)
 
I wanted to return to this...because I have been looking into it...

Remember that my question before was which virologists support the lab leak theory.
So your premise is you are not hearing about any virologists that suspect the lab ergo there are none?

Do you think the virologists in the WIV are free to speak up? Think other virologists in China are free to speak up?

I don't see where this line of inquiry, 'majority vote' can go very far given the limitations.

But do carry on. However this:
This is exactly the kind of thing we see in conspiracy theorizing. Someone says something like, “Yes, I think we need to look into it” and a conspiracy theorist seizes on the comment to say that this person supports the conspiracy theory.
Has no place in this thread. You are ridiculing people instead of addressing specific evidence.

And I can certainly cite the opposite, remember Project Steve?


I predict that anyone going through the other names in the list will find very similar results. But of course it is time-consuming to look into each one. Pure, pure Gish Gallop on the part of Matt "climate change is not a problem lets keep burning fossil fuels" Ridley!

Yet the biggest proponents of this theory are way, way out of their field.

Bill "vaccines are bad" Maher
Bret "vaccines are at least dodgier than we hear; the election fraud claims need to be looked into; I became famous after being cancelled and now have made a career out of appearing on Joe Rogan, hanging out with Jordan Peterson, questioning the natural origins of Covid, coming up with crackpot theories about evolution and angering Richard Dawkins, the left is the real problem even though I totally am a liberal, honest!" Weinstein.
Steven "not even other conspiracy theorists take my paper seriously" Quay.


etc...
No one has brought up any of these people here. Why do you keep insisting on dragging CTs into this thread. Please stop.

If you think any discussion of the possible origin within the WIV belongs in the CT forum, post over there.
 
Last edited:
So your premise is you are not hearing about any virologists that suspect the lab ergo there are none?

Do you think the virologists in the WIV are free to speak up? Think other virologists in China are free to speak up?

Another goalpost shift.

"Where are the virologists who support the lab leak theory?"
"There are loads: look at these."
"They're not virologists and/or they don't support it!"
"So? So? Maybe there are others who have to keep quiet! Also, the ones who don't support it are compromised by big money, China and other stuff"
"So are we talking about a conspiracy?"
"You're not allowed to say conspiracy. That's my rule! That's for another forum!"

I don't see where this line of inquiry, 'majority vote' can go very far given the limitations.

It isn't "majority vote". Again, this is a mischaracterization. The issue is whether we are talking about relevant experts vs. non-relevant experts.

But do carry on. However this:
Has no place in this thread.

And I can certainly cite the opposite, remember the Steve Project?

I don't know what that is.
 
Did they have dangerous viruses in the lab? Sure, it's a BSL-4 lab.

Did they have SARS CoV2 in the lab? No evidence.

So what is the theory here?
I just posted evidence. Care to address the specific viruses the WIV was studying prior to 2019?

Post #229
 
No one has brought up any of these people here. Why do you keep insisting on dragging CTs into this thread. Please stop.

If you think any discussion of the possible origin within the WIV belongs in the CT forum, post over there.

Really? You haven't brought up Steven Quay?

Except here...

This is from the Aussie version of Spectator. I think the US version if they are related is a right-leaning news magazine.

Covid cuckoo clock - Australia is stuck in a viral Groundhog Day

It's mostly about treatments saying if you can't beat them treat them while lamenting shut down economies. But there is this:
There's an assertion that Western universities are involved in a coverup. That plus the Steven Quay paper really drift off into CT territory. ( Bolded just so you know I am trying to be objective here even though I know some of you don't believe that.)

Is there a link to the Quay paper here? The number 99+% certainty rings a bell.

Here are the two Quay papers:

Zenodo. Where Did the 2019 Coronavirus Pandemic Begin and How Did it Spread? The People’s Liberation Army Hospital in Wuhan China and Line 2 of the Wuhan Metro System Are Compelling Answers. Steven Carl Quay. October 28, 2020. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.4119262

Zenodo. A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived. Dr. Steven Quay. January 29, 2021.

https://zenodo.org/record/4477081#


In the acknowledgements:


From the executive summary:So Zhengli Shi's own work.


Controls:


So no gradual changes in the human infection and earlier I posted a reference to the fact that the genetic evidence is this pathogen has only been in the human population recently.

So it was a perfect match on the first jump? Quay compares this to SARS (1) which was not. I'm going to leave it to the people in this thread who "are not impressed" to sift through this scientific paper and find the faults in it. I'm not seeing them.

Oh wait...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom