One Million Rupees Offer to prove "Homeopathy is Paranormal"

[Ashles]

Write mails to [email protected] , yahoo.com and gmail.com and ask for the rules.

I am not asking about the rules.

I am asking about the prize money.

Is there anywhere we can ascertain it exists?

I have asked this question at the NCH Pakistan forums with no answer.

Obviously you cannot answer this question either.

Do you not wonder if it really exists?

 

[Mojo]

good comment.

No, it was a good question. Please provide a simple yes or no as an answer.

Do you accept that matter is composed of atoms?

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Do you not wonder if it really exists?

Did you send mail at Dr. MAS email address?

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

No, it was a good question. Please provide a simple yes or no as an answer.

Do you accept that matter is composed of atoms?

yes

 

[Mojo]

Dr Sheikh, what is your first name, please?

Perhaps it's something like this?

 

[Ashles]

Did you send mail at Dr. MAS email address?

Why should I email Dr Mas? It isn't his money is it.

And I personally like the anonymity of the internet - I don't provide my e-mail address to people I don't know or trust.

Why can nobody answer this simple question in a public forum?

 

[Non-Sense Homeopath]

The man who is liar is always afraid of many things.

 

[delphi_ote]

The man who is liar is always afraid of many things.

That explains why Mas won't come over here and talk facts.

 

[Qureshi1_78]

You have visited that forum so you are not liar? talk like that from the mouth of skeptic is not good.

 

[delphi_ote]

You have visited that forum so you are not liar? talk like that from the mouth of skeptic is not good.

Once again, I did not make those posts and you know it. You faked my name, because you are a pack of liars.

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Perhaps it's something like this?

If you will post your first name, I will too.

 

[Hawk one]

Again, the main question is:

When will Dr. MAS take the Million Dollar Challenge and prove - against the laws of physics and chemistry - that homeopathy is objectively effective?

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

in which format you will accept it? define the protocol?

 

[Hawk one]

The protocol will be mutually accepted between MAS and JREF. Read the challenge rules, they are on this site. Stop making excuses and apply.

 

[Garrette]

Let's start with this:

If presented with two bottles of water which, by outward appearances, are identical, can you determine which has been homeopathically prepared and which has not?

 

[Garrette]

Or what Hawk said. That's better by far.

 

[Mojo]

If you will post your first name, I will too.

I don't actually give a damn about your first name. I was just having a joke at your expense, Alan (anag.).

 

[Ashles]

I am not asking about the rules.

I am asking about the prize money.

Is there anywhere we can ascertain it exists?

I have asked this question at the NCH Pakistan forums with no answer.

Obviously you cannot answer this question either.

Do you not wonder if it really exists?

I'm glad this old thread has been resurrected. It gives me the chance to ask this question again.

Aside from the intellectual dishonesty of having a 'prize' set up to be awarded in such a way that allows someone to simply choose not to award the prize, would it at any point be possible to get any evidence that the prize fund exists?

If not, why not?

The man who is liar is always afraid of many things.

Yet another stranger to irony.

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

I commented without visiting the link. So I have no idea about the joke.

 

[Zep]

I've just had a look at that website you linked to. Nowhere does Dr MAS demonstrate that he has a million rupees. Or a thousand rupees. Or even just 100 rupees. In fact his whole appearance is of a man who is so poor that he lives hand-to-mouth in a tiny "office". Although I don't know if that's true, or he just cultivates the appearance.

In summary, Dr MAS has shown no evidence at all that the million rupee prize exists, despite being asked to do so. Which suggests his offer is merely bluff, and the money is a lie. His problem is that some skeptics want to take up his offer even if it is bogus, so now he is inventing all sorts of "rules" that allow him to cheat and never allow it to be awarded even if the claimaint qualified for the prize.

So Dr MAS is a liar and a cheater... Now tell us again, Sheikh, why we should take his word about anything?