On Again Off Again Airfones

Obstruction of justice!! Hmmmm I like the sound of that. Kinda thing that gets a person jail time I would think.
 
Additional point: 28 Jan 2001 is a *Sunday*. Maintenance, of course, happens on Sundays, but do document revisions get released on Sundays?

January 2001
S M Tu W Th F S
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
 
Our mechanic told us.. prove it wrong.



If you know anything about manuals and doing revisions. each last revision date is on the page itself... not every page has the same date... have you ever revised your manual?

The page itself obviously wasn't revised since the date noted.. but I'm sure other pages in the manual were. Ever seen a revision log at beginning of manuals? Not every revision is the whole manual. And if they do replace full manuals, they do not revise a date on a page that hasn't been revised.
This is the exact opposite of how controlled quality documents work. If an AS9100 audit found a manual with pages with different dates he would want to know how he is to know if the other pages are up to date. Documents like this are numbered and given a rev level, this is then entered into a master control log. If you were allowed to change individual pages, you would have to have an entry for every page. This is simply not done in any quality system I have ever seen.
 
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]United States v. Zacarias Moussaoui
[/FONT]
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Criminal No. 01-455-A
[/FONT]


[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Prosecution Trial Exhibits[/FONT]

[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Exhibit Number [/FONT] [FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Description [/FONT][FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]P200054 [/FONT] [FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Summary of Flight 77 depicting: the identity of pilots and flight attendants, seat assignments of passengers, and telephone calls from the flight [Listener discretion is advised. This exhibit also includes information about the other three flights hijacked on September 11] [/FONT]http://www.vaed.uscourts.gov/notablecases/moussaoui/exhibits/prosecution/flights/P200054.html

You can download the zip file that shows the seating charts of where the airphone calls are made from. Flight 77 shows zero calls from a seat.

IMO this issue is kind of silly no matter what. Looks like LyteBright is once again reaching for somthing that isn't there.
 
Flight 77 - The flight attendant had an air phone to use. This is a fact.
At 9:12 a.m., flight attendant Renee May called her
10 parents on an air phone. Ms. May told her mother that her flight
11 had been hijacked by six men who had moved them to the rear of the
12 plane. Ms. May asked her mother to call American Airlines to make
13 sure they knew about the hijacking, giving her three Northern
14 Virginia phone calls -- phone numbers to call.
It does not say what Olson used to make the call.
At 9:15 a.m. and at 9:26 a.m., Flight 77 passenger
20 Barbara Olson called her husband, Ted Olson, and spoke to him for
21 about one minute before the call was cut off. Barbara Olson
22 reported that the flight had been hijacked by hijackers wielding
23 knives and box cutters and that all the passengers were in the
24 back of the plane.
What about United 757s? Did they have working phones? Could Olson used the air phone in the back for the crew? Cell phones can work in flight. This is too funny. Griffin is the king of hearsay, and JDX is just too dumb to come up with good stuff. What does it mean for 77. How many calls are we talking about? If I was hijacked I would be in the back calling from the airplane phone. Why are truth movement people always making points that mean nothing?

the list is above, ocbe
 
Last edited:
This is the exact opposite of how controlled quality documents work. If an AS9100 audit found a manual with pages with different dates he would want to know how he is to know if the other pages are up to date. Documents like this are numbered and given a rev level, this is then entered into a master control log. If you were allowed to change individual pages, you would have to have an entry for every page. This is simply not done in any quality system I have ever seen.


Yup. I'm not sure, and I'd have to check but I think that there may be a different revision level for each ATA chapter(ie... 23 is Communication, 24 is Electrical, 27 is Flight Controls, etc etc...) in the AMM/IPC, because technically each chapter(back when they were in hardcopy anyway) is a seperate manual...
 
Last edited:
I'm Done. Unless they can provide a valid reason why part of the "g" is missing, when it clearly should not, if the form is legitimate (you know with line spacing and all) than it is FAKE...EOS.

TAM:)
I suppose you will have to find out:
1.The model and ink level of the original printer used to print the manual and the page.
2. The model of the computer and the scanner used to scan the page. (image scan errors) as well as the condition of the glass on the scanner hardware to ensure no errors might occur.
3. All of the computer programs used to scan the page, convert it, and email the file to make sure there are no errors with the program or reproduction capabilities.
4. Then you will have to have an expert in digital imagery reproduce the missing tail of a g to verify that it can happen outside of intentional human intervention to verify the document is authentic.

On a side note, then you will have to call AA and get Mr. Kinder to change his email and the confirmation of his email as it can be used to support the authenticity of the document. If the document is proven to be a fake, then you will have to prove Mr. Kinder is mistaken or lying. If so, then you will have to contradict the official story, and I don't think anyone wants to do that here.
 
Yup. I'm not sure, and I'd have to check but I think that there may be a different revision level for each ATA chapter(ie... 23 is Communication, 24 is Electrical, 27 is Flight Controls, etc etc...) in the AMM/IPC, because technically each chapter(back when they were in hardcopy anyway) is a seperate manual...

Yes, each chapter could be revised individually because each is a stand alone. They would have their own indicator numbers and rev levels in the front of the manual and in the master log as well.
 
Last edited:
I suppose you will have to find out:
1.The model and ink level of the original printer used to print the manual and the page.
2. The model of the computer and the scanner used to scan the page. (image scan errors) as well as the condition of the glass on the scanner hardware to ensure no errors might occur.
3. All of the computer programs used to scan the page, convert it, and email the file to make sure there are no errors with the program or reproduction capabilities.
4. Then you will have to have an expert in digital imagery reproduce the missing tail of a g to verify that it can happen outside of intentional human intervention to verify the document is authentic.

On a side note, then you will have to call AA and get Mr. Kinder to change his email and the confirmation of his email as it can be used to support the authenticity of the document. If the document is proven to be a fake, then you will have to prove Mr. Kinder is mistaken or lying. If so, then you will have to contradict the official story, and I don't think anyone wants to do that here.

Why don't we just start with another page from the same manual. Wouldn't that be easier?

Lyte? Any more pages to from this manual?
 
- That the redactor is attempting to disguise the page revision date at upper left as the software revision date, by blacking out the actual revision numbers and date that appear in the blacked-out field next to "Software Release." This is supported by:

1. There is no reason to conceal the software release; it could not possibly identify the individual user.

2. A software release is usually identifed by a revision number, and sometime also by a date. But what else is needed? If the software "REV" number (62) and date are visible on the line below, what other information about the software release would be left to appear on the line above?

I'm even skeptical that "REV 62" refers to a version of some software package. It's standard practice to use decimal numbers to designate software versions so as to differentiate between major and minor revisions. Not to say that it couldn't be, but I'd love to be able to verify it.
 
Perhaps those of you who doubt the authenticity of the document as well as the public relations officer for AA could follow up with your own investigation, then you might have a leg to stand on. The burden of proof is now upon the debunker's shoulders.

You of course would forget that the original burden of proof falls upon truthers. So ask yourself, what purpose would it serve to try to present faked evidence to support a cause that is based upon truth? Do you think these folks want to discredit themselves? Mistakes and further information is one thing, but to fake something that could easily be verified or debunked makes no sense at all and would only hurt the truth movement itself.
<snip>

I'm sorry, haven't you encountered Lauro Chavez yet? Or "Mike the EMT"? These were easily debunked frauds that the Twoofers embraced with open arms.

Incidentally, aren't the odds of those dates being identical the result of 365 x 365? I.e. 133,225 to 1. Maybe not astronomical, but in the upper reaches of the atmosphere.

I may have become cynical, but my BS antennae began to twitch the instant I saw date fields blacked out.
 
So you have proof cell phones do work in flight, that checks with my actual use. Darn, we do not need seat phones.

You still have problems with fuel being like a cloud? Too bad, gee water is clear, Jet fuel is clear, and when you dump them in air, they sometimes form a white cloud.

Cell phones do work in flight, I have used them in 2001 and before. But it I can make anything work.
[/COLOR]
Ahh the jet fuel at altitude is white when dumped through high pressure nossles. I never disputed that. What I did dispute was how that same logic changed from 20000 feet to below ground is what you never explained nor could you as it can't. But that is off topic.
Of course at flight could mean 20 feet off the ground as well.

Do you have empirical proof that cell phones worked at 25,000 feet at over 300mph with connections lasting a couple of minutes in 2001? If you can't, then the airphones would most likely have to be used, which may explain Ted's revision and the current conundrum.
 
I suppose you will have to find out:
1.The model and ink level of the original printer used to print the manual and the page.
2. The model of the computer and the scanner used to scan the page. (image scan errors) as well as the condition of the glass on the scanner hardware to ensure no errors might occur.
3. All of the computer programs used to scan the page, convert it, and email the file to make sure there are no errors with the program or reproduction capabilities.
4. Then you will have to have an expert in digital imagery reproduce the missing tail of a g to verify that it can happen outside of intentional human intervention to verify the document is authentic.

Or, much simpler, we simply get hold of a copy of the manual and check "Pace 1". EOS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom