On Again Off Again Airfones

:rolleyes:
I do not claim that it PROVES the phones weren't working on 9/11 and neither does PFT or DRG.

Trying to distance yourself from the big "find" already, I see. Gee, I wonder why.

What you actually said, in response to the OP's comment that

JamesB said:
David Ray Griffin can't even make up his mind whether there were airfones on AA77, now Rob Balsamo is claiming that maintanence manuals show that there weren't.
was the following:

LyteTrip said:

Sounds like you were certainly claiming that it "proved" something a few hours ago.
 
Last edited:
I only chimed in about this because I personally know and trust the source.

I do not claim that it PROVES the phones weren't working on 9/11 and neither does PFT or DRG.

If the implications we are suggesting as a result of this evidence are proven false it will have ZERO BEARING on the FACT that the low flying passenger jet that flew over Arlington timed perfectly with the explosion was on the north side of the citgo station and could not have caused the physical damage.

That evidence, my wannabe critical thinkers, is PROOF that 9/11 was an inside job.

Have fun working hard to debunk this frankly unnecessary evidence while the proof we have obtained remains forever intact.

Northside!

Timed explosives are certainly not a fact.
 
Or, much simpler, we simply get hold of a copy of the manual and check "Pace 1". EOS.

Agreed. However, it transition from paper to digital file, their could be unintentional errors made or intentional fraud.
Consider this one simple fact however: the rest of the document, as posted in the first page of this thread, was reproduced perfectly. No missing parts of letters, all characters sharp and easy to read. So that one area strangely exhibits a problem that is not on any other part of the document. This is curious to say the least.
Agreed.
What's funny is if this document was evidence in support of the official story Lyte and swing would be all OVER it with a microscope.
There is already one person at AA that confirms the suggestion of no air phone usage. The AA person's statements which support the official story verify the information suggested by the document. If this document is fake, which of course can be proven one way or another, then the examination of the AA person must be taken into account. If his statement is true, that all calls were made via cell phone, then the examination of cell phone usage at those particular altitudes and speeds should be undertaken to prove without a doubt that phone calls could be made for the stated length of time.
Apathoid-
What was the chain of custody of the scanned manual image?
An excellent question as you beat me to it.
 
Lyte's use of the words "evidence" and "Fact" make me giggle.

Lyte - When are you going to produce ACTUAL evidence and REAL facts?

You have yet to do so in any of your theories.
 
Agreed. However, it transition from paper to digital file, their could be unintentional errors made or intentional fraud.

Agreed.

There is already one person at AA that confirms the suggestion of no air phone usage. The AA person's statements which support the official story verify the information suggested by the document. If this document is fake, which of course can be proven one way or another, then the examination of the AA person must be taken into account. If his statement is true, that all calls were made via cell phone, then the examination of cell phone usage at those particular altitudes and speeds should be undertaken to prove without a doubt that phone calls could be made for the stated length of time.

An excellent question as you beat me to it.


No, that person confirms that 757s did not have airfones at the time he was contacted post-9/11. That is not under contention, in fact I was the first person to point out that airfones had been removed from 757s as of 2002.
 
No, that person confirms that 757s did not have airfones at the time he was contacted post-9/11. That is not under contention, in fact I was the first person to point out that airfones had been removed from 757s as of 2002.

Here was the original question to Mr. Kinder so you can place his statement in context:
Hello, on your website . . . there is mentioned that there are no seatback satellite phones on a Boeing 757. Is that info correct? Were there any such seatback satellite phones on any Boeing 757 before or on September 11, 2001 and if so, when were these phones ripped out?
Response:
Dear Mr. XXXXXXXX:
Thank you for contacting Customer Relations. I am pleased to have the opportunity to assist you.
That is correct we do not have phones on our Boeing 757. The passengers on flight 77 used their own personal cellular phones to make out calls during the terrorist attack. However, the pilots are able to stay in constant contact with the Air Traffic Control tower. Mr. XXXXXXXX, I hope this information is helpful. It is a privilege to serve you.
Sincerely,
Chad W. Kinder
Customer Relations
American Airlines

You may want to call and confirm that statement as DG and RB did.
 
Here was the original question to Mr. Kinder so you can place his statement in context:

Response:


You may want to call and confirm that statement as DG and RB did.

My mistake, that is a different e-mail than previously cited by Griffin. I have trouble keeping his stories straight, as apparently so does he.
 
But if all the calls were made from cell phones, what's the big find even if there were no airfones on that flight?
 
SO now, can someone refresh me on what exactly the issue here is?
I thought the issue was the authenticity of the document posted in the OP. If authentic, does it prove that all airphones were removed from AA airplanes? If so, how did passengers make airphone calls on 9/11?

I think that's the gist of it.

I think once Apathoid get back to work tomorrow, things will become more clear.
 
So I am just back for a check in. Lyte or Rob make a statement of the obviously forged document, in particular the "Pace 1" part that so clearly gives it away as a forgery.

From what I can see in the pages since, it is the one question Lyte has avoided like the plague.

TAM:)
 
So I am just back for a check in. Lyte or Rob make a statement of the obviously forged document, in particular the "Pace 1" part that so clearly gives it away as a forgery.

From what I can see in the pages since, it is the one question Lyte has avoided like the plague.

TAM:)

Not the only question he has avoided, he has avoiding answering why the dates at the top are blacked out since the first page.
 
ah...ok...I'll be by from time to time to check and see if the question has been answered.

TAM:)
 
Ad hominem attack.

What a typical reaction when you have nothing to counter the info.

I have never lied which is why you have not cited a lie to back up your hollow accusation.

Everything we claim we back up with hard researched evidence.


You are a complete fraud. You claim that you are in possession of the story of the century. Yet, you have not contacted a single reporter for any major daily, nor have you contacted any network news desk.

What's your excuse? Perhaps all the papers and all television and radio news outlets are part of the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy. Only the most pathetic simpletons of the fantasy movement will swallow that codswallop.

Tell a reporter that you can prove that the plane believed to have crashed into the Pentagon actually flew over it. Tell us why he rejects winning a Pulitzer Prize with your revelations.
 
Last edited:
But guys...lying for the Truth movement isn't the same as actually lying, because if lying is done in the service of Truth it can't be contrary to Truth, which is the opposite of Lies. Right, false skeptics? Debunk that![/DavidJayJordan]
 
Is there a “Northside'' gang sign that I can flash at my fly over homies at the next meeting?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom