Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Protest everything! Claim responsibility for any good stuff that happens!

Hey, that sounds like it might be a good hobby.
 
Perhaps some Americans would like to see a focus on gay rights, women's reproductive rights AND addressing corporate welfare, income inequality, and a recession caused by top-level financial gambling, and trying to pay for two wars while reducing taxes on the top 1%.

There seems to be precious little link between protecting the so-called job creators from a small tax hike and actually creating jobs.

As you pointed out, equal rights for women and gays already have activist groups. Who speaks for the rest?

... Our senate and congress does not address these. Instead they focus on gay marriage, the war on women and meaningless vague phrases like "job creators."

Both tea partiers and OWS are driven by the feeling that our government is an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few.

You seemed to imply that this was an either/or proposition, and that the Senate and Congress's focus on those matters should be secondary to addressing what you describe as the concerns of the people and OWS, and the gov't's concern with such ideas is part of them being "an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few."

Gay rights and reproductive rights in America are not by any definition the concerns of the "very few", regardless of which sides of the issues they are on. Jobs not actually being created by the tax breaks to those who the gov't says would do so is quite different from "job creators" being a "meaningless vague phrase".

Incidentally, the 1% actually pay more taxes than everyone else.

http://www.usatoday.com/money/perfi/taxes/story/2011-09-20/buffett-tax-millionaires/50480226/1

Note how it quotes someone who says says 46% of Americans, mostly "the 99%", will pay no federal income taxes whatsoever. Instead of the 1% paying less taxes than everyone, they actually get more, and pay most of the taxes, in greater proportion than the percentage of income they represent.

But hey, as long as we're talking about "small tax hikes", lets make everyone pay for their fair share of taxes, eh? Everyone pays 29.1%, how's that sound?
 
Last edited:
You seemed to imply that this was an either/or proposition, and that the Senate and Congress's focus on those matters should be secondary to addressing what you describe as the concerns of the people and OWS, and the gov't's concern with such ideas is part of them being "an insulated little bubble of self-interest beholden to only a very few."

Gay rights and reproductive rights in America are not by any definition the concerns of the "very few", regardless of which sides of the issues they are on.

Incidentally, the 1% actually pay more taxes than everyone else.

http://www.usatoday.com/money/perfi/taxes/story/2011-09-20/buffett-tax-millionaires/50480226/1

Note how it quotes someone who says says 46% of Americans, mostly "the 99%", will pay no federal income taxes whatsoever. Instead of the 1% paying less taxes than everyone, they actually get more, and pay most of the taxes, in greater proportion than the percentage of income they represent.

But hey, as long as we're talking about "small tax hikes", lets make everyone pay for their fair share of taxes, eh? Everyone pays 29.1%, how's that sound?

Incidentally, the 1% actually own 40% of wealth in the US, the top 5% own 20%. If you combine the top 20 they own 80%. Of course they pay more taxes. The 80% that are left are dividing 20% of the wealth of the US. So yes, many of them will be a low-income or poverty bracket which is not taxed.

To continue to give tax cuts to the people who own 80% of the wealth is not fiscally sound.
 
But hey, as long as we're talking about "small tax hikes", lets make everyone pay for their fair share of taxes, eh? Everyone pays 29.1%, how's that sound?

Sounds good to me, as long as I get to decide where that money goes: e.g. more into universal healthcare, education, etc., and less into wars and corporate bailouts.
 
Occupy Chicago throws a party, and few show up:
Although the room where various people spoke this morning was mostly full, it was clear that the event's organizers expected more people to attend. Other rooms streaming a live video feed of the speeches and filled with hundreds of chairs for overflow crowds were either empty or had only a handful of spectators.

The primary room was decorated with art and props from the Occupy movement, including life-size paintings of Obama and Mayor Rahm Emanuel wearing dark suits and holding handguns.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/chi-nato-chicago-occupy-protest,0,665113.story

The movement is dead. 200 people show up in a metro area of 8 million, and many of them are from elsewhere.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom