Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, the banking scandal and resulting recession and high unemployment rates are the fault of OWS. And attacking protestors is the solution. BTW: I've been criticized for claiming that OWS are frequently dismissed as dirty.

Fishing with doughnuts is not protesting the banking scandal/recession, it is being provocative toward the police. Soap and job applications could actually help to improve the personal situation for some OWS members.
 
Fishing with doughnuts is not protesting the banking scandal/recession, it is being provocative toward the police.
Being provocative toward the police is a tradition that goes back before the civil rights protests. But they used it to much success.

Soap and job applications could actually help to improve the personal situation for some OWS members.
Because ad hominem is all you have.
 
Sorry, but if you chant "fk the police" then smash up shop windows and throw smoke bombs in them, then you're just an idiot.
 
time and manner restrictions are old news, Cox vs. New Hampshire and so on. No city should be able to restrict free speech and I agree with you there, no matter how democratic the restriction is but these various city ordinances such as the 10 p.m. noise ordinances that is so commonplace in so many city's, is most definitely constitutional as are the park hours and camping restrictions in public parks. You made a good argument earlier about civil disobedience in this regard, but certainly no argument that this is a restriction on free speech and assembly which some OWSers imagine this to be. Their free assembly and speech is not being infringed, they only imagine it to be. We, the other 99%, can make decisions on our park hours and whether people can camp in them or not. The minority can't dictate these regulations to us and claim "free speech".

Unless they have lots of money, right?
 
Sorry, but if you chant "fk the police" then smash up shop windows and throw smoke bombs in them, then you're just an idiot.
The tactics of the 60s demonstrators. I think most people in this thread are inconsistent. They would defend the civil disobedience of the civil rights activists but not OWS. Of course, you can always fall back on special pleading.
 
Call them tards, okay. I call the Tea Party "tea baggers"

Only difference is that the tea party were proud to tea bag, until they going out what the slang term meant....
I don't think any OWS protesters have claimed to be tards.
 
Grade a skeptic proof evidence that is.
Nice attempt to change a clearly identified opinion into a claim of fact so you can bash it for lack of evidence.

Do you think provoking the policing is benefitting OWS?
 
Nice attempt to change a clearly identified opinion into a claim of fact so you can bash it for lack of evidence.
Fair enough. What you "think" isn't compelling and if you are trying to be persuasive I don't think it's working. It certainly isn't advancing any argument or discussion. But it's your opinion. Thanks.

Do you think provoking the policing is benefitting OWS?
Looking back at the protests of the 60s and 70s I can't tell you what worked and what didn't work. I was too young to see the effect the protests had on the civil rights act but I was later aware of the tactics used. I can tell you that at the time I was absolutely convinced that the protests were not working to change the hearts and minds of people. I didn't think the war would end.

So, since I was so wrong then I hardly think I'm of any mind to know for certain and I'm skeptical of my bias.

That said, yeah, I think it is more likely than not helping. I honestly do. But then, that's just my opinion. Then again, it's not just what I "think".
 
Last edited:
Socks with Birkenstocks!!?? To borrow a phrase from my 10yo - NERD!! :D

That's just with shorts though

A pair of long pants and you can totally rock the socks with sandals look. :)

That's a little horizontal pedagogy in action there, screw the fashion industry and their fascist rules ! My look is based on lived experiences.
 
Looking back at the protests of the 60s and 70s I can't tell you what worked and what didn't work. I was too young to see the effect the protests had on the civil rights act but I was later aware of the tactics used. I can tell you that at the time I was absolutely convinced that the protests were not working to change the hearts and minds of people. I didn't think the war would end.

So, since I was so wrong then I hardly think I'm of any mind to know for certain and I'm skeptical of my bias.

That said, yeah, I think it is more likely than not helping. I honestly do. But then, that's just my opinion. Then again, it's not just what I "think".

Of course back then we didn't have every minute detail of the protest tactics being delivered to our screens in what pretty much amounts to real time. Who knows, if we had that in the '60s and '70s, things might have worked out differently.

I doubt it though, the civil rights movement had goals that were actually obtainable. Occupy...not so much.
 
Apparently you can just dress up in black and smash up shops whenever you want and say "bleh bleh civil rights bleh bleh" as an excuse.

Of course the people doing it would say its because they hate capitalism. A hatred of capitalism permeates the whole movement. They're always going on about it.
 
Unless they have lots of money, right?

wrong. That's not what I said at all. Do you think OWS should be able to dictate to the rest of the community our park regulations and supersede the democratic process in place for changing those regulations and whine about the various current park rules as unbearable oppression?
 
Of course back then we didn't have every minute detail of the protest tactics being delivered to our screens in what pretty much amounts to real time. Who knows, if we had that in the '60s and '70s, things might have worked out differently.

I doubt it though, the civil rights movement had goals that were actually obtainable. Occupy...not so much.
Raising awareness about corporate corruption and changing the status quo is a difficult goal but not impossible.
 
Changing it to what? Many of the protestors are quite vocal about their desire for a socialist state or no state at all.


Unfortunately for them, the number of Americans that support that is quite a bit smaller than 99%.
 
Last edited:
Changing it to what? Many of the protestors are quite vocal about their desire for a socialist state or no state at all.

Unfortunately for them, the number of Americans that support that is quite a bit smaller than 99%.
Many of the protestors of the 60s and 70s were vocal about communism. Change is good enough. If enough people realize that power corrupts and corporations have a lot of power then we will see change. More oversight, better regulation.
 
Last edited:
Raising awareness about corporate corruption and changing the status quo is a difficult goal but not impossible.

That message is long gone though. All we get now is misfit loner anarchists with unresolved anger issues compering for attention and occupiers whining about how restrictions against their tents are a violation of their rights.

It's sort of like thinking about the true meaning of Christmas on black friday.
 
wrong. That's not what I said at all. Do you think OWS should be able to dictate to the rest of the community our park regulations and supersede the democratic process in place for changing those regulations and whine about the various current park rules as unbearable oppression?

Do you think that they should, if they had enough money to rent the parks?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom