Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Absolutely mind-boggling.

You claim that the rankings have a relationship to how dangerous the method ranked is. Show your work. Quote the part of the document you think supports your claim that the higher the ranking the more dangerous that use of force is.

I suspect you will fail completely, because I have actually read the document and you obviously haven't, despite claiming you have. But maybe there's something I missed? :rolleyes:

You like using the word "fail", don't you?
 
Day 7? It was supposed to start at noon today.

This is the New York group, who are fasting to demand the use of private land.

"I feel really fatigued," he continues. "But I'm sitting down. I feel really at peace. You think of food, and the idea of food comes and you can taste it, and you know how it feels to have that, and you just release it. It's a really great feeling. It's so empowering to say, 'I don't need that.'"
 
Will you guys ever let up on this issue? Yikes!

At first the hypocrisy was funny but now it's just ridiculous. Some of you have ignored me because I might have made some "idiotic" statements, yet y'all keep posting messages calling people in the OWS "Occutards", posting videos that YOU think make them look "stupid" (when you're making yourself look that way), or you just keep ranting and trolling post after post about how these people should "take a shower". Maybe y'all need to take a shower!

...or maybe take a valium, or even a muscle relaxer or two!
 
Will you guys ever let up on this issue? Yikes!

At first the hypocrisy was funny but now it's just ridiculous. Some of you have ignored me because I might have made some "idiotic" statements, yet y'all keep posting messages calling people in the OWS "Occutards", posting videos that YOU think make them look "stupid" (when you're making yourself look that way), or you just keep ranting and trolling post after post about how these people should "take a shower". Maybe y'all need to take a shower!

...or maybe take a valium, or even a muscle relaxer or two!

Yeah, all this focus on a handful of people, or a single person in a video can be frustrating but it's all good. This is page 84 of this thread. Even the naysayers are talking about it. They might loathe it but they can't look away.

Corporate money used as free speech has been the bullhorn of political conversation. You can call OWS a stunt, get all riled up about the dirty hippies, etc, etc, but it worked. American citizens were finally louder than corporate money and it changed the tone of the national conversation.
 
Will you guys ever let up on this issue? Yikes!

At first the hypocrisy was funny but now it's just ridiculous. Some of you have ignored me because I might have made some "idiotic" statements, yet y'all keep posting messages calling people in the OWS "Occutards", posting videos that YOU think make them look "stupid" (when you're making yourself look that way), or you just keep ranting and trolling post after post about how these people should "take a shower". Maybe y'all need to take a shower!

...or maybe take a valium, or even a muscle relaxer or two!

The occupy movement produces plenty of video's that make themselves look stupid.
 
Yeah, all this focus on a handful of people, or a single person in a video can be frustrating but it's all good. This is page 84 of this thread. Even the naysayers are talking about it. They might loathe it but they can't look away.

Corporate money used as free speech has been the bullhorn of political conversation. You can call OWS a stunt, get all riled up about the dirty hippies, etc, etc, but it worked. American citizens were finally louder than corporate money and it changed the tone of the national conversation.

I'm not a big subscriber of the notion that simply being talked about is success. If the majority of people think I'm a total idiot, well - that's not good.

Lots of people talked about Charles Manson, too.
 
I'm not a big subscriber of the notion that simply being talked about is success. If the majority of people think I'm a total idiot, well - that's not good.

Lots of people talked about Charles Manson, too.

Lots of people also talked about Gandhi!
 
Yeah, all this focus on a handful of people, or a single person in a video can be frustrating but it's all good. This is page 84 of this thread. Even the naysayers are talking about it. They might loathe it but they can't look away.

The Occupy Movement is a lot like Lindsay Lohan.
 
Patience as they say, is a virtue.

There was no need to take down the occupation at that moment.

There was no need to clear those protestors at that moment.

A little more patience would have saved everyone a lot of grief and pain.
And there was "no need" for the crowd to obstruct the police at all. In fact, they were actively breaking the law by doing so. If they had just let the police go, that would've saved everyone the most trouble.

63; They had no right to use of force in the way they did. Dozens of police not available? Bingo Sierra. You need more police you call the county or you call the state or you call neighboring jurisdictions, or you call the railroad; All have officers and all would be available in the case of a mob action.
The officers on the scene would've been sufficient, had not a mob of dozens surrounded them and prevented them from getting out. At that point, it was, as always, the duty of the officers to resolve the situation in the most expedient and minimum force manner possible, which, as I have already argued, was pepper spray. You don't stick around in front of the people who threatened you seconds ago. All they have to do is let the new officers in, then surround them too, and you have the exact same situation.

I'm not sure state or city forces would even have jurisdiction, even if they had been summoned and arrived in...oh...a few minutes. In fact, I'd like you to back up that claim. Where do police manuals state that, or even have procedures? I think the Chancellor would have to make the request personally, and that would take hours for them to arrive, not minutes.

Yes, they were breaking the law, but while doing so were not a threat to themselves or others.
I did not merely say they broke the law, I said they obstructed and issued a threat to police. I said nothing about whether they were actually a threat, whether they would've acted on their demands, but I do think an angry mob issuing threats could be reasonably construed as one. With that in mind, the police acted in a professional manner, in my opinion, refusing to rise to the bait.

Any amount of time could have been allowed to elapse in the gathering of force to remove them bodily.
And as I already told you, any attempt to do so would be more likely to harm them than pepper spray. Doesn't matter how long they waited, or how many cops they used. In fact, the longer they wait, the more likely it becomes that the crowd gets up the nerve to attack them. You also seem to be forgetting the transport of the prisoners these people were deliberately obstructing. You did try my little experiment, right?

That all seems to me to apply exactly as I have been saying all along. When the subject is engaged in overt hostile ACTION and threat of harm to the officers is clearly imminenet, spray away. I have seen cops act a lot more accomdating toward violent drunks.
Dozens of them, surrounding the cops? Did the drunks have linked arms? I also quoted several manuals that advocate the use of pepper spray when subjects are resisting arrest, with nothing about violence. And let me quote a bit from the UC Davis manual proper...

Given that no policy can realistically predict every possible situation an officer might encounter in the field, it is recognized that each officer must be entrusted with well-reasoned discretion in determining the appropriate use of force in each incident. While it is the ultimate objective of every law enforcement encounter to minimize injury to everyone involved, nothing in this policy requires an officer to actually sustain physical injury before applying reasonable force.

Their training sucks.
A former Lt who literally wrote the book on Use Of Force seems to disagree.

The Army teaches the use of some on the neck, ears and nose.
That's military, not police. I thought you said their training sucked, but now you're expecting them to have military training?

Here's a scenario: The crowd and cameras see the police approaching protestors, then touching them in the nose and neck and ears, gripping, twisting. They writhe in pain, and try to get away. Either the protestor breaks free, and the police pounce on them, or the other protestors hang on, and the one who force has been applied to possibly ends up with the same injuries they would've ended up with wrestling with the cops. Heck, they'll probably whip their head back and forth and left and right dramatically, trying to keep the cops from touching them. Either way, it'll be compared by a sensationalist press to torture. (If these are military techniques, and the press finds out, then you'll get the comparison to "paramilitary forces" and "military-grade weapons" that we actually have now as a response to the event.) Assuming the protestor breaks free, the other students try to close the gap. Either the police prevent them (more wrestling) and then use the same technique on people on either side, or they get back together, and the entire grisly dance occurs again. And again, and again. There were well over a dozen people in that chain. If anything, it would look even worse on video, especially if the cops tried these techniques on multiple people at once, and would likely be compared to torture.

In fact, people would probably be asking why the cops didn't just use pepper spray.

So, you've had campus security avoid Scylla to fall onto...Scylla. These techniques you propose would lead to the same wrestling the cops were trying to avoid, and look worse to viewers at home unless the other seated protesters saw what the cops were doing and all instantly surrendered.

Not a bit.

Spraying them like bugs with a substance that can cause injury is.
So can pressure point techniques, as you said yourself. You said that they were "less likely" to cause injury than pepper spray, but now you're saying pepper spray is bad because, among other things, it "can cause injury". Funny thing; teenage and twenty-something students are generally not considered at-risk to have conditions aggravated by pepper spray.

He does not present a very professional appearance and demeanor. He looked to me like he was enjoying it. Appearances mean a lot in crowd control.
He looked to me like a guy applying pepper spray, after warning the students in a quiet voice earlier. And remember, the crowd was threatening the police seconds earlier, and chanting things like "Cops off campus!" and "**** the police!" Obviously, they don't like the 5-0. He could look as good as Brad Pitt and be handing out peppermints and kittens, and I doubt that would make much difference to their opinions of him. They'd probably lambaste him for handing out kittens to people who don't want them.
 
Last edited:
More important; they chose to commit a civil rights violation instead of being patient. I predict that few of them will have law enforcement careers in a year.
Which civil right would that be? We've already established that they were threatening and obstructing the cops, and were thus subject to the response standard to people who threaten and obstruct the cops. Doesn't matter if they were protestors as well. The first Amendment is not some sort of trump card. you can't get out of crimes just because you were exercising your right to Free Speech. In fact, the California definition of a riot specifically refers to people using that right to threaten violence and/or destruction.
 
Lots of people also talked about Gandhi!

What's that old saying? First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you and then you win. You wouldn't want us to skip that second part, would you?
 
'City of Cleveland Passes Emergency Vote to Support OWS'

"The Cleveland City Council pass an emergency resolution 1720-11 in support of Occupy Cleveland and the Occupy Movement in general. The final vote from all the Wards was 18 yea and 1 nay.

With the passing of the 1720-11 resolution Cleveland (a US City with a population of 2,250,000 people) joins other cities (Seattle, LA and Chicago etc.) that also have voiced their official support of the Occupy Movement. The following Resolution was sent to President Barack Obama and all members of the U.S. Congress.
"

The Resolution is a good read, giving deeper insights into the many different aspects of the 'Occupy' movement.
 
Any amount of time could have elapsed before the protestors got hungry and left to get something to eat.

Any amount of time could have elapsed before the protestors had to go to the bathroom and didn't want to sit in their own excrement.

Any amount of time could have elapsed before the protestors became tired and sore and needed to sleep or stretch their legs.

The police had all the time in the world ... yet they chose not to use it to their advantage.
I've noticed there seems to be very little concern for the police in your post. The police had prisoners they needed to transport. Your wool-gathering about what the police could've done glosses over what the crowd could have and chose to do.

The police did not have all the time in the world. The longer they waited, the higher chance that the crowd would rush, either to harm them, to get the prisoners back, or both. How many times could the police fend them off, do you think? How many injuries would the cops get, with a crowd of dozens closing in from all directions? And remember, they have to go to the bathroom and eat and stretch their legs too. They're humans, not robots.

The police were outnumbered and outmassed by angry people who have said they might harm them if they don't release the prisoners. They are actually the underdog here, not the students.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom