Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
or, perhaps common sense and a sense of humanity?
tell me again why peaceful protesters had to be moved in the first place.

000063 has explained this multiple times now. Are you paying any attention to this thread? Because at this point, it really looks like you're willfully ignorant on this score.
 
....


Straw man. I provided a link where the police deal with chains.
Every other protestor should have had arms removed just above the elbows, and 'no more chain'. Are you sure that's what you wanted?

Seems overly cruel to me. :)
 
...

You have to know that police DO arrest protestors in similar situations without pepper spray, right?
Not yet demonstrated. When chains or handcuffs or some other metallic or plastic devices are being used to link people together or to an inanimate object it is obvious those restraints can be cut off.

Have you actually looked at the (entire) video of events previously posted in this thread? I'd guess: no.
 
no he hasn't.
he is ignoring the facts, as are you.
police acted like pigs against seated peaceful protesters.
they assaulted peaceful protesters.
perhaps it is you who is not paying attention.
Ah, yes, the unsupported gainsay.

The protestors threatened and obstructed the officers. They were no longer "peaceful", unless you would also apply that definition to a gunman going "get me the helicopter or I start killing hostages!" or someone going "get me my money, or I'm going to stop asking nicely". Except that both of those would have to outnumber the individual in question by several times. I've heard estimates of 100 and 200, but prefer to stick to a fairly conservative and still-damning "dozens" in the crowd.

So, crowd of dozens threatening cops, and already actively obstructing them. The people on the ground were part of that crowd, and were, at the very least, actively trying to keep the police from transporting their prisoners. I count at least two state laws broken. I'd cite them, but I already did so in the other thread, and I suspect you'd just ignore them anyway.

Do you know what they were supposedly protesting? Aside from the usual OWS stuff, whatever it is this week, it was a "gesture of solidarity" with students getting jabbed with nightsticks by police during a protest. At another school. I'm not sure what UC Davis has to do with police response at UC Berkley, nor what protesting it would do.

The police dismantled the camp after issuing three verbal warnings, dismantled it, arrested those who tried to interfere, at which point the crowd of dozens surrounded them and started yelling demands, such as the release of prisoners. The students seated were closest to the cops, and there were standing students beyond them, who moved aside a few seconds before the normal version of the video starts. Pike warns the students, and after the police try to disengage them from each other by verbal command and gentle compulsion, they resorted to pepper spray, which was the minimum effective use of force.

The students were actually the aggressors. The police would have left them alone if they had not actively obstructed the law. Pike was able to step over them, but you cannot transport prisoners safely across such a line. There is a reason the usual video doesn't show the warnings, or the threats; because they make it clear the protestors were the bad guys here.

You can keep saying they were "peaceful" all you want. The fact remains that they obstructed and threatened police, and pepper spray was the minimum amount of force necessary to disengage them for arrest.

 
Not yet demonstrated. When chains or handcuffs or some other metallic or plastic devices are being used to link people together or to an inanimate object it is obvious those restraints can be cut off.

Have you actually looked at the (entire) video of events previously posted in this thread? I'd guess: no.
Don't bother, he left the thread. Apparently, he thought everyone was "brow beating" him.
 
"the law is an ass."
(and so is pike....as well as a pig)
You don't have any substantiative objections, do you? Just automatic gainsaying and insults. Not a single bit of logic after I point out your peaceful protestors weren't there to protest and they weren't peaceful.
 
"the law is an ass."
(and so is pike....as well as a pig)

And that's what passes for "facts" for you?

Strangely enough, you can't even say which law, just "the law" (kind of like "the man"). You are one of the people MLK warned about that want anarchy. The very idea of laws that should be enforced is apparently distasteful to you.
 
And that's what passes for "facts" for you?

Strangely enough, you can't even say which law, just "the law" (kind of like "the the law is an ass,"man"). You are one of the people MLK warned about that want anarchy. The very idea of laws that should be enforced is apparently distasteful to you.

"the law is an ass," is a quote from charles dickens, in oliver twist.
i was just assuming that most posters here would be well read.
 
"the law is an ass," is a quote from charles dickens, in oliver twist.
i was just assuming that most posters here would be well read.

I know where it's from, but that's pretty irrelevant. You were still presenting it as your argument, and cannot actually defend it as such.

Oh, and the phrase actually predates Dickens, though he popularized it.
 
Ah, yes a blog. Those have not been particularly objective with regards to OWS. Here's another blog entry on the matter.

Swearing aside, can someone discuss what legal weight this has?

Interesting point on that blog about the attempted restriction of use of social media re flash mobs. I'm tending to side with Wildcat's analysis after reading that.

It's too bad for OWS they didn't start right out of the gate with a document like that and insisted with all this "rebuilding society from the ground up" crap that we all new could lead to nothing but a gong show.
 
Disobeying a lawful police command will get you arrested most of -- if not all of -- the time.

Your choice.

Yes, there's that and once the police have you in custody, they're legally responsible for you.
 
"the law is an ass," is a quote from charles dickens, in oliver twist.
i was just assuming that most posters here would be well read.

A little fake sophistication goes a long way.

The actual line is "the law is a ass."

You savor Dickens so much, but you never noticed the highly unconventional use of the article in this phrase?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom