Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Argument by assertion. I'm not going to put up with that again. I'm tired of it.

I'm tired of the brow beating. Why can't we have a discussion? I DID read it. If you think it "means" something else then tell me what you think it means? Otherwise that's my last response to you.
Absolutely mind-boggling.

You claim that the rankings have a relationship to how dangerous the method ranked is. Show your work. Quote the part of the document you think supports your claim that the higher the ranking the more dangerous that use of force is.

I suspect you will fail completely, because I have actually read the document and you obviously haven't, despite claiming you have. But maybe there's something I missed? :rolleyes:
 
:rolleyes: I responded two posts back. But, given your refusal to knock off the attitude and brow beating, you are about a post away from being put on ignore. I doubt you care and that's fine. Hey, I'm not so egotistical as to suppose I'm important in the scheme of, well, anything. I'm just sick of the attitude. I had hoped our history would give me some consideration but I guess not.

Your choice.
It's an opinion poll, not an objective assessment or set of statistics. Of course, since you think it supports your point, that's as good as, right? You did notice that the reporting form included the circumstances in which force was employed, right? Of course you didn't, because you did not read it. If you did, you badly misinterpreted it.

Don't you think it's odd that you have to Ignore or threaten to Ignore so many people? Other people with your opinion manage not to Ignore their opponents in job lots, why can't you? Why is just seeing a quote from someone you've Ignored so upsetting? What's the common factor here? Tell me about your mother.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by IDB87
Then you read Chapter 6, page 71, where it said the use of pepper spray may lead to fewer injuries of suspects and officers?

And again.....

Need commentary, RandFan. This is in the document you provided, which was supposed to illustrate the dangers of Pepper Spray.
 
The report is about excessive force. To that end the report attempts to rank force.
That's not the part that explains what the rankings mean, Exhibit 4-11 isn't even the right chart. Exhibit 4-13 is the chart we're talking about. I'll quote it for you:
Exhibit 4–13 notes the large number of arrests (4,305 or 57.3 percent of all 7,512 arrests) at a ranking of 28.2. In these arrests, the most forceful behavior by the police was handcuffing. The exhibit also reveals that there was variation among arrests in which some form of forceful action was taken. Some actions, such as the display or the use of a handgun, were very forceful and generate a Maximum Force ranking of 55.4 and 81.7.

The Maximum Force measure captures a number of activities, such as police chasing suspects in a car, that are not counted as force in our definitions of Physical Force, Physical Force Plus Threats, and in departmental policies on the Continuum of Force. In addition, this measure takes into account differences, sometimes severe, between types of force. Grabbing a suspect and using a firearm are both examples of Physical Force and are counted equally in that measure; in the Maximum Force measure, grabbing ranks at 33.0 and using a handgun at 81.7. Thus, this measure captures items that officers think involve force and weigh the amount of force based on a scale that can range from 1 to 100.
Nothing at all about dangerousness, or injuries. Yet that is what you are asserting it means!

Why not stop being a dick and just directly tell me what YOU think it means? Why can't we have a discussion without all of this subterfuge? Why the "gotcha" tactics?
It was explained to you many, many posts back. And many times. You just keep ignoring it. It just measures officers perceptions about how they rank any particular force on a scale of 1-100. It is not a measurement of the dangerousness of the force. And further on in the same document it says pepper spray may be the safest choice (in terms of injuries) when it comes to arresting protesters who resist.
 
Last edited:
Can we PLEASE for the love of god and everybody's sanity move on from this idiocy?

Ok, in other OWS news, they have stolen a home and given it to homeless family that has never lived there and has never owned it.

OWS is going with this lie, about the home located at 702 Vermont Street, Brooklyn NY, 11207:

An Occupy Wall Street organizer, Beka Economopoulous said, "We've moved this family into a Bank of America-owned property."

According to Property Shark and Bank of America (they list forclosures for sale) the house is not owned by Bank of America and there is no evidence that it is a foreclosure (it's was just vacant). OWS demands stuff for free and now when that doesn't work, they just steal it.

http://gothamist.com/2011/12/07/protesters_family_occupy_foreclosed.php#photo-1

http://www.propertyshark.com/mason/nyc/Reports2/showsection.html?propkey=224888

http://realestatecenter.bankofamerica.com/pages/map-search
 
Last edited:
It was explained to you many, many posts back.
Without conceding your point, NO IT WASN'T. You just asserted that I was wrong.

And many times. You just keep ignoring it. It just measures officers perceptions about how they rank any particular force on a scale of 1-100. It is not a measurement of the dangerousness of the force. And further on in the same document it says pepper spray may be the safest choice (in terms of injuries) when it comes to arresting protesters who resist.
"may". I'll concede the point. Would have been nice if you had said that. I'll admit I did miss that.

Still doesn't really address my argument. You ignored the rest.
 
Last edited:
Without conceding your point, NO IT WASN'T.
Yes it was. It is not my responsibility to keep track of your rapidly-growing ignore list. I'm not going to repeat everyone's posts just in case you have them on ignore.

Still doesn't really address my argument. You ignored the rest.
Your entire argument rests on the assumption that pepper spray is more likely to cause injury or death than other forms of non-lethal force. That pdf was what you claimed as evidence of that, and it clearly isn't.

What does your evidence consist of now? Your intuition?
 
Without conceding your point, NO IT WASN'T. You just asserted that I was wrong.

"may". I'll concede the point. Would have been nice if you had said that. I'll admit I did miss that.

Still doesn't really address my argument. You ignored the rest.
You didn't ask for the argument to be addressed, just your evidence. Your argument is based largely on this report and the ACLU paper. Without that, you have just the ACLU paper. Or more poetically, a one-legged stool. No knowledge, ACLU only, Final Destination.

Everyone, note that he still hasn't actually mentioned the bit IDB87 mentioned, which was quoted a few posts back by Noah.
 
Well, predictably there is no comment regarding the part in the PDF that states Pepper Spray is helpful in protecting both the perp and the officer.

I can only conclude intellectual dishonesty, aka "twoofer syndrome".

RandFan - I've asked THREE TIMES for you to comment on that. THREE TIMES you've ignored it.

Why?

Because it shows that maybe you could be mistaken?

Yes.
 
Just for funny ha-ha's:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Someone other than a person who was ignored
Then you read Chapter 6, page 71, where it said the use of pepper spray may lead to fewer injuries of suspects and officers?


YOUR PDF states this.

I'd like your input, please.
 
Occutard SF cleared. Their damage to park estimated at $50,000 and nobody can use it untill the council fixes it up.

Lee said the plaza site will remain closed for repairs. Recreation and Park Director Phil Ginsburg estimated there was up to $50,000 worth of damage to the area, including dead grass and irrigation system problems. The department is working to reopen the area as soon as possible, but the grassy areas and bocce ball courts, a large portion of what was once the Occupy SF encampment, will remain closed for weeks as they are restored.

http://www.sfexaminer.com/local/2011/12/occupy-sf-cleared-plaza-restoration-work-remains
 
Occutard SF cleared. Their damage to park estimated at $50,000 and nobody can use it untill the council fixes it up.



http://www.sfexaminer.com/local/2011/12/occupy-sf-cleared-plaza-restoration-work-remains

Yeah, took a little walk about during my lunch break today.

Before:

occupySF17-L.jpg


After:

tardless-1.jpg


What remains are the core activists, about 40 - 50 who've regrouped at the Federal Reserve and reportedly attempted to retake their former campground.



Sad really.
 
Time beclowns itself by declaring the Obamavilles the US news story of the year.

But many in the movement see their cause as part of a more global zeitgeist, in keeping with the anti-austerity demonstrations in Europe and the leaderless uprisings of the Arab Spring. The Occupy movement has remained leaderless, amorphous and spontaneous — demonstrators carry signs advocating everything from financial reform to healthcare reform to a ban on fracking — it's still unclear what sort of real lasting political effect the movement can have. But the sheer persistence of the occupations, galvanized by incidents of heavy-handed policing in New York and California that shocked the nation, have given the protesters' appeals for economic justice a weight that may play a real role in the upcoming presidential election.
 
Last edited:
Occutards smash up building. Cause $30,000 worth of damage.

SANTA CRUZ, Calif- Santa Cruz Police are asking for the public's help in identifying Occupy Santa Cruz suspects who took over a building on River Street last week.

According to Santa Cruz Police, the suspects left behind more than $30,000 worth of damage to the vacant Well Fargo building before finally leaving Sunday night.

http://www.kionrightnow.com/story/16214929/santa-cruz-police-looking-to-identify-occupy-suspects

They also smashed the doors of the courthouse and wrote a stupid letter to the police saying they should be allowed to break the law.

http://www.ksbw.com/news/29946895/detail.html
 
Several posts removed to AAH (I only went back a couple of pages, so there are likely earlier posts still in the thread). Stay on topic and stop the bickering. For reference - the topic is not who you've put on ignore.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles
 
Edited for rule 11. Posting off topic in direct response to a warning not to post off topic is really not the best idea, especially after you've already had one such response removed.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles

Actually, it's more like 2:00.

I feel your pain! ;)

He says prior to its invention, police had trouble dealing with threats to them, threats to the innocent, or threats to property. Someone who is under the influence (which he uses as a single example, not the single example) is not a "mentally deranged criminal". We've already established that other compliance measures would risk more harm to both the officers and students.

"We" in your bubble....

Kamran Loghman, who developed pepper spray, says it was not designed to be used to control passive protestors. It was developed as an alternative to lethal force against people who are violent (against themselves or others) and out-of-control and need to be immobilized. This includes violent, mentally deranged people.

Democracy Now! interviews Kamran Loghman:

"... the most inappropriate and improper use of chemical agents that he has ever seen."

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Cuddles: 
Edited response to moderated post.


"We" in your bubble....

Kamran Loghman, who developed pepper spray, says it was not designed to be used to control passive protestors. It was developed as an alternative to lethal force against people who are violent (against themselves or others) and out-of-control and need to be immobilized. This includes violent, mentally deranged people.
Do you want to play semantics? Boo said it was developed for use against the mentally disturbed, period. The guy who co-made it says it was made for use against the violent. Unless Bookitty is willing to clarify what she meant, the reasonable conclusion from her statement is that it was only developed for use against the mentally deranged.

Incidentally, there are many mentally disturbed people who are not violent. Now you claim she was referring only to the intersect of the mentally deranged and the violent, which is just be moving goalposts. She said crazy people, not violent crazy people.


Democracy Now! interviews Kamran Loghman:

"... the most inappropriate and improper use of chemical agents that he has ever seen."

Did he see the full video, with protestors obstructing and threatening the police? Because unless he did, his opinion is just as uninformed as anyone else.

The use was just absolutely out of the ordinary and it was not in accordance with any training or policy of any department that I know of. I personally certified 4,000 police officers in the early '80s and '90s and I have never seen this before.
For the record, there are hundreds of thousands of cops in the US, and Loghman says he trained people in the use of pepper spray over ten years ago. His knowledge, whether he invented it or not, is out of date.

He also brings up the "under the influence" thing again. Nothing about mentally deranged.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom