Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Comprehension problem? My quote did not say there is nothing to investigate, even though I don't think there is. In any event, again an investigation is not evidence that they did something wrong as you implied.
Comprehension problem?

You made a declarative statement re-read it.

You're late to the party. Again there was no need to investigate, but of course everyone including the chancellor called for it, to try to save her job. I detailed the rationale and likely outcome in a previous post.
No you are flip-floping. Oy vey. Again, tell that to the Yolo DA!

I saw the quote. What you fail to see is that pepper spray the way it was used at Davis is acceptable procedure. Odd that it would be that way if the way the engineering student was right, isn't it?
What the hell are you talking about.

Oh and how's your research on inalienable rights going?
Given you can't rebut my point that's over.
 
The two situations are entirely different.

You have not drawn any parallel between the two events except for the use of pepper spray.
The people sprayed were sitting down and peaceful. What is so difficult to understand about that is baffling.
 
Yes, that was more civil than spraying them. The protesters at U.C. Davis were not bound in mechanical devices, still had the ability of movement. Would you suggest they pull the chain apart with force? If I showed you a video of an officer attempting to pull a protester from the chain, and you saw how it didn't work, would you suggest that police officer pull harder next time?
The police actually have methods for chains they deal with them all of the time. They CUT the chains.
 
The people sprayed were sitting down and peaceful were verbally threatening the cops, preventing them from doing their job peacefully, and breaking campus rules.

FTFY. But they're people you find some common ground with, so of course you give them the pass.

For the Greater Good yes? :D

Edited by LashL: 
Edited to make it clear what was changed in the quote. If you change someone's post to write something different than what they originally wrote, please ensure that you make it clear what you have changed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
FTFY. But they're people you find some common ground with, so of course you give them the pass.

For the Greater Good yes? :D
Editing a quote without making the edit is clear is a prevarication and IIRC, against forum rules.
 
No you are flip-floping. Oy vey. Again, tell that to the Yolo DA!
The DA will do the job they were ordered to do, whether I want them to or not.

What the hell are you talking about.
The experts that say that what the Davis police did are acceptable and standard protocol. You think that those policies would be in place if you and engineering boy were correct about that case he cited?

Given you can't rebut my point that's over.
Odd. You're usually pretty good at conceding that you were wrong on a point. Guess that's not true on the inalienable rights issue.
 
The DA will do the job they were ordered to do, whether I want them to or not.
It's not the job of the Yolo DA or the sheriffs office. They are only experts recommending an investigation

The experts that say that what the Davis police did are acceptable and standard protocol. You think that those policies would be in place if you and engineering boy were correct about that case he cited?
I've provided sources that say otherwise. You've provided nothing. I suspect you do have the sources and I await the opportunity to look those over. My thanks in advance for that.

Odd. You're usually pretty good at conceding that you were wrong on a point.
I did it twice this week in the Social Issues forum. I pride myself on that. I think very carefully arguments made. If you had made persuasive arguments or provided evidence I would do just that.

Guess that's not true on the inalienable rights issue.
I've demonstrated conclusively why I'm not wrong. I gave the example of the inalienable right to life and why because of that a boss can't take that right away. I then demonstrated how a boss CAN take away my right of speech even when I'm not at work.

Can you honestly say you can't see a difference?
 
It's your claim. Back it up.

Nothing in that google search comes up with any relevant tactics you claimed police use. Perhaps you should be more specific in your search criteria?
The links demonstrate what police have done to remove chains. Thats a tactic but if you want to be pedantic I'll withdraw that for now and only claim that police cut chains and locks all the time without harming people. And really, isn't that the reasonable thing to do?
 
Well, Randfan has convinced me that the civil rights protestors of the 1960s were a bunch of pot-smoking non-showering hippies who didn't have a clue what they were protesting, but they did like raping chicks.

Or was there some other conclusion I was supposed to draw?
 
Well, Randfan has convinced me that the civil rights protestors of the 1960s were a bunch of pot-smoking non-showering hippies who didn't have a clue what they were protesting, but they did like raping chicks.

Or was there some other conclusion I was supposed to draw?

Typical rhetoric that I would find on Fox Garbage, no?
 
Well, Randfan has convinced me that the civil rights protestors of the 1960s were a bunch of pot-smoking non-showering hippies who didn't have a clue what they were protesting, but they did like raping chicks.

Or was there some other conclusion I was supposed to draw?
You? Trust me, I have no reasonable expectations. I think most reasonable people would conclude that anecdotes are intellectually lazy. That movements are composed of people. Some good some bad. If a bunch of hippies, communists, radicals, Protestants, Catholics could bring about such radical change even with all of the problems inherent to civil disobedience then perhaps so can OWS. But then that would require reason to conclude.
 
Woman stabbed at Occupy Baltimore.

According to a police report, officers arrived at McKeldin Square just after midnight for a report of an assault and spoke to the victim, who said she and 23-year-old Desiree Nicholson had gotten into an argument “because [Nicholson] was not taking care of her cat,” according to report.

She said Nicholson kicked her in the stomach, and then stabbed her on her arm and thigh with a knife. The victim was taken to Johns Hopkins Hospital for treatment, police said.

http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/ma...-baltimore-20111205,0,1089654.story?track=rss
 
Thanks for the link.

How do you think the two situations are similar?

The environmental activists were essentially immobilized. Tazing them, pepper spraying them, is obviously abusive. The activists at U.C. Davis had surrounded the much smaller number of police, prevented them from the arresting the people you agreed were breaking the law, and were verbally threatening the officers.

So, again, how are the two situations similar?
Also, the police had the means to safely remove the restraints without applying pepper spray.

The people sprayed were sitting down and immobilized. How are they NOT SIMILAR?
No, the people sitting down had immobilized themselves, and were fully capable of getting up and walking away. That would be rather more difficult for the lumber protestors, who were refusing to unlock themselves.

Wait, were they concerned about the people surrounding them or not? If the people surrounding them we're the cause for concern then SPRAY THEM.
So you think they should just indiscriminately spray a crowd, instead of the few people who were actively obstructing them.
 
A.) I'm not an expert but had the sprayed the protestors surrounding it likely would not have been justified.
Didn't you suggest that they should've sprayed the crowd if they were concerned only a few posts ago?

B.) The protestors they DID spray were NOT a threat. You are trying to use the actions of one group to justify actions taken against another,
Moving the goalposts. All of a sudden, the ones sitting down on the ground are not part of the larger group, even if all of them are trying to create an intimidating environment for the 5-0.

Let me get this right, had their only recourse had been deadly force the response would be to shoot the people sitting down? Really?
Yes, by definition of "only recourse", which means they could not do anything else. Fortunately, modern peace officers have an array of compliance options short of shooting people, and this is what they used. Nice attempt at equivalence, though, and I note you didn't actually answer the question.

:rolleyes: Sorry, pepper spray was ruled by the appeals court to be excessive force. See link.

:boxedin:
Pepper spray applied directly to the eyes via Q-Tips was, yes.

The people sprayed were sitting down and peaceful. What is so difficult to understand about that is baffling.
They weren't peaceful; they were impeding the cops in their duties, resisting peaceful removal, and being deliberately threatening. Or did you miss one of them going "F* THE POLICE!"? Did you miss the linked arms, deliberately meant to make it hard for the cops to remove them?

Seriously, Roark, you've been dodging direct questions for two pages now.
 
Last edited:
Pesky protestors. You can't kill them... but we've other means. First we need to strip them of their humanity. Call them dirty (a popular tactic of authoritarians) and then shift all of the blame of any action to them, then as heaven knows, anything goes.
[img goes here]
I have literally never seen anyone call OWS protestors "dirty hippies" or even "dirty", barring a sardonic or factual sense (IE referring to hygiene). Either you and other people who act like the term is in common usage are taking such uses in a different manner than intended, or you're making them up so you can put everyone who uses "military-grade chemical weapons" on protestors in a little box that you can shove in a corner and dismiss.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom