Obstruction of Justice

We already do. And it's a hell of a lot cheaper to drop the grand for someone who is not guilty than spend the hundreds of thousands to pay for them to stay in jail from 10 years to life. Not to mention the money that winds up being paid to people who are exonerated, usually a settlement for the time they spent in prison and often a stipend for some designated time afterward. You talk about costs, but you're completely ignoring the outstanding costs of keeping innocent people in jail for long stretches of time, even when they're later found to be innocent.

Got a source for this? I have not heard that wrongful convictions generaly got much in the way of monetary compensation unless there was serious misconduct proven.
 
Surely any new evidence that might over turn a conviction is the responsibility of a defense lawyer to acquire. It's not the police's job to help support convicted criminals' appeal efforts.

To say that officials are preventing these people having DNA testing is false. They just won't do it on the criminal's behalf. Just like they won't do anything else towards an appeal case on a a criminal's behalf.

How is the defense supposted to get the evidence from the case with out the police giving it to them?
 
Got a source for this? I have not heard that wrongful convictions generaly got much in the way of monetary compensation unless there was serious misconduct proven.

What? What the heck are you asking a source for? Look into the story for every one of the fellows freed via the Innocence Project-- they are compensated for every year they served in prison during the wrongful conviction. The price tag differs per state for those who pay per year-- in Florida, for example, it's $50k per year-- but not every state pays by year. Some pay by days served, and more than half of the states in the US don't have any set legislation, resulting in a number of lawsuits for compensation.

The point is that the justice system doesn't get to just let go people it's had in the prison system for 15-20 years with a "whoops, my bad" and a few well wishes. The system, often in the form of state tax money, usually winds up having to foot a notable bill to pay for the time that they've held someone in the prison system on a wrongful conviction.

Why would you even doubt this?
 
What? What the heck are you asking a source for? Look into the story for every one of the fellows freed via the Innocence Project-- they are compensated for every year they served in prison during the wrongful conviction. The price tag differs per state for those who pay per year-- in Florida, for example, it's $50k per year-- but not every state pays by year. Some pay by days served, and more than half of the states in the US don't have any set legislation, resulting in a number of lawsuits for compensation.

The point is that the justice system doesn't get to just let go people it's had in the prison system for 15-20 years with a "whoops, my bad" and a few well wishes. The system, often in the form of state tax money, usually winds up having to foot a notable bill to pay for the time that they've held someone in the prison system on a wrongful conviction.

Why would you even doubt this?


I think there is some confusion as to the use of the term. Usually these compensations occur when actual innocence can be shown and/or state misconduct can be proven. The Florida law is described as applying to those who did not commit the crime, which suggests something beyond a mere wrongful conviction.

If it is simply a wrongful conviction based on something like improper rulings at trial and the state declines to retry the case it is unlikely the accused will be paid absent proof of actual innocence.
 
I think there is some confusion as to the use of the term. Usually these compensations occur when actual innocence can be shown and/or state misconduct can be proven. The Florida law is described as applying to those who did not commit the crime, which suggests something beyond a mere wrongful conviction.

If it is simply a wrongful conviction based on something like improper rulings at trial and the state declines to retry the case it is unlikely the accused will be paid absent proof of actual innocence.

If a DNA test for a rape case shows that the person who is in prison wasn't the guy who performed the rape, then I'd say what I've been talking about applies pretty accurately. What you're saying applies only when tackling the more broad issue of changes in rulings that may come after-the-fact. Since 1989, I believe there have been nearly 200 cases of prisoners freed by proving their innocence through improved DNA testing alone. That number, when taking into account the costs involved with having them incarcerated, the possibility of them receiving compensation after being released, and the overall costs of the extra court time, the cost of allowing a few DNA tests for convicts then begins to look smaller in comparison.
 
I honestly don't see why two wrongs equal a right.

I suppose there are DNA tests and DNA tests but a quick Google shows tests at accredited labs from $80 US up. Since there is a chance that this person may be innocent, does anyone think that it is too much to pay. Let him or his family or anyone pay for it. If it turns out that it proves he is innocent, is this not justice done? :boggled:
I think the point was allocating limited resources. However, I think any murder conviction, and any conviction based on mostly or all eyewitness testimony should require DNA testing if DNA is available.
 
Last edited:
What about the waste of money brains and time?

You can't read, can you?

It's a waste of money, brains, and time, if the evidence on which the person was convicted was sufficiently compelling that there's not much chance that a DNA test would clear him. Remember that INRM was saying that the test should be done because the case against him was so strong, just to shut him up.

That's absolutely Alice-in-Wonderland reversed to reality. You want to spend the time and money on the cases where DNA testing is likely to have an effect.
 
I think that anyone should be allowed to pay their own money to do a DNA test, of course in a registered, etc, lab that won't contaminate the results.

If they are found not guilty, then they ought to get back a lot more than the money they spent on the test.
 
You can't read, can you?

It's a waste of money, brains, and time, if the evidence on which the person was convicted was sufficiently compelling that there's not much chance that a DNA test would clear him. Remember that INRM was saying that the test should be done because the case against him was so strong, just to shut him up.

That's absolutely Alice-in-Wonderland reversed to reality. You want to spend the time and money on the cases where DNA testing is likely to have an effect.

Um, that's because "compelling" is a subjective term. I believe it's already been mentioned about the television interview with the woman who was raped that identified her accuser, both in photos and a line-up, only to find many years later that he wasn't actually the guy who did it. This woman was positively convinced, no doubt in her mind, that she'd picked the right fellow. Not a shred of doubt. And even when faced with the evidence she wasn't willing to believe at first.

Cases like that are precisely why having something like DNA evidence admissible is the right thing to do.
 
A prosecutor was trying to block a death row inmate from having his conviction reopened on the basis of new evidence, and Judge Stith, of the Missouri Supreme Court, was getting exasperated. ''Are you suggesting,'' she asked the prosecutor, that ''even if we find Mr. Amrine is actually innocent, he should be executed?''

Frank A. Jung, an assistant state attorney general, replied, ''That's correct, your honor.''

That reminded me of this story from 15 years ago:

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1295/is_n3_v57/ai_13510311/

The U.S. Supreme Court has plunged to a depth of barbarity surprising even to its harshest critics. It has ruled that solid evidence of innocence can be considered irrelevant to the case of a prisoner condemned to death. It ruled that the courts don't have to listen to the evidence. It ruled that the state may kill the probably innocent prisoner anyway, because he missed a filing deadline.
 
Thanks for the answers correcting me about these being old cases wanting to exploit new DNA technology. Regarding access too the evidence, what is the current standard practise if the defense wants access to evidence for an appeal? Do they get a court order for the police to release it, or what? Presumably there must be an existing process for this.
 
Because in your universe, neither money nor lab time are in limited supply?

Have you done the math? I haven't, but let's take a quick stab.

A legally binding DNA test seems to run about $250 (http://www.gtldna.com/). That's a hard cost in that it's an extra $250 somebody has to pay.

Let's put the cost per year per prisoner at $20K. It varies by state (http://www.ojp.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/spe01.pdf), but this is close enough for our purposes. The problem is, this is a soft cost. If you release one prisoner, you won't realy save $20K in cash. If his cell stays empty, you're still paying for the building and much of the utilities. You'll still need the same amount of staff.

However, there are definite hard costs per prisoner. There's food, water, clothing, bedding, maintenance and outside medical care. What's the number? Hell if I know, but I think $2K (about $5.50 per day) would be in the ballpark.

What about the average remaining sentence? Since we're talking DNA, you gotta figure quite a few sex crimes are involved. Drug crimes are unlikely to have DNA evidence, but violent crimes may have blood and other physical evidence where DNA is involved.

The best we can do is speculate. According to this site (http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/ascii/aasps.txt) the average sentence for a rape conviction is 14 years. To keep the math simple, let's say we can save 10 years of prison time by freeing someone unjustly convicted.

That means a savings of $20K in cold hard cash before for each conviction that gets overturned. This makes the break-even point in overturning a conviction once for every 80 tests. And that's assuming the state pays for the test.

What we haven't factored into this are the government costs for the test. I say it's mostly a soft cost in that the current system could absorb it. It would only be a hard cost if the volume were so high that we needed extra staff involved to handle it. Considering that prisoners file lawsuits all the time, I doubt this would be the case.

I am sure there are hard costs associated with the processing required to free someone, but that's a price I think society is more than willing to pay. We don't like locking up people who are innocent.

This quick look at the situation tells me that it's worth investigating further. Keeping people in prison ain't cheap, and keeping the wrongfully convicted in prison just doesn't sit well.
 
Last edited:
Have you done the math? I haven't, but let's take a quick stab.

A legally binding DNA test seems to run about $250 (http://www.gtldna.com/). That's a hard cost in that it's an extra $250 somebody has to pay.
While I agree with your larger point, that price range appears to be for a paternity type DNA test, those are simpler procedures than a forensic examination for a number of reasons, mainly because paternity usually deals with high quality samples as those tests aren't dealing with a bloodstain or whatever. That lab doesn't have a lot of information about forensic testing. Non-optimal samples usually are more expensive, same with chain of custody issues and analysis of poor samples, reaching conclusions as to what is a weak data point and what is an artifact and so on.

Just sending suspicious raw data from the state lab to a good private lab for an independent review pushes four figures...

We usually spend in the 1K - 3K range depending on the circumstances and what is to be tested. I don't think this effects your final analysis though as the number of cases where DNA is likely to help is quite limited.
 
You can't read, can you?

It's a waste of money, brains, and time, if the evidence on which the person was convicted was sufficiently compelling that there's not much chance that a DNA test would clear him. Remember that INRM was saying that the test should be done because the case against him was so strong, just to shut him up.

They had all that witness testimony against him, that was good enough to convict so why revisit it? It is just a useless waste of resources. You were clear.

You were clear on your positions, you just prefer to resort to personal attacks than admitting you didn't examine this clearly.
 
They had all that witness testimony against him, that was good enough to convict so why revisit it?

Because witness testimony without supporting physical evidence is not especially reliable.

You were clear on your positions,

I was indeed, but you didn't bother either to read my positions (or the posts to which I was responding) or to think about their implications.
 
I'd say two months to get the results is pretty quick.

It is. Astonishingly so, to the point of unavailability.

Again, you're confusing the nice, simple, clean-and-recent-sample paternity test with the sort of test that would actually be required in this instance.

You couldn't get this test done for less than $1000,... .and I'd be surprised if you got it back in less than six months. (and, of course, if you need it quickly,... well, you pay for rush processing.)
 
You couldn't get this test done for less than $1000,... .and I'd be surprised if you got it back in less than six months. (and, of course, if you need it quickly,... well, you pay for rush processing.)

I am holding in my hands a memo from my investigator telling me that as of March Cellmark (a very respected DNA outfit) told us four to six weeks, but they had been running closer to four. No rush processing involved.

The cost of re-analysis of state lab data plus the testing of a new sample was quoted at $2190.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom