Because in your universe, neither money nor lab time are in limited supply?
Have you done the math? I haven't, but let's take a quick stab.
A legally binding DNA test seems to run about $250 (
http://www.gtldna.com/). That's a hard cost in that it's an extra $250 somebody has to pay.
Let's put the cost per year per prisoner at $20K. It varies by state (
http://www.ojp.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/spe01.pdf), but this is close enough for our purposes. The problem is, this is a soft cost. If you release one prisoner, you won't realy save $20K in cash. If his cell stays empty, you're still paying for the building and much of the utilities. You'll still need the same amount of staff.
However, there are definite hard costs per prisoner. There's food, water, clothing, bedding, maintenance and outside medical care. What's the number? Hell if I know, but I think $2K (about $5.50 per day) would be in the ballpark.
What about the average remaining sentence? Since we're talking DNA, you gotta figure quite a few sex crimes are involved. Drug crimes are unlikely to have DNA evidence, but violent crimes may have blood and other physical evidence where DNA is involved.
The best we can do is speculate. According to this site (
http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/ascii/aasps.txt) the average sentence for a rape conviction is 14 years. To keep the math simple, let's say we can save 10 years of prison time by freeing someone unjustly convicted.
That means a savings of $20K in cold hard cash before for each conviction that gets overturned. This makes the break-even point in overturning a conviction once for every 80 tests. And that's assuming the state pays for the test.
What we haven't factored into this are the government costs for the test. I say it's mostly a soft cost in that the current system could absorb it. It would only be a hard cost if the volume were so high that we needed extra staff involved to handle it. Considering that prisoners file lawsuits all the time, I doubt this would be the case.
I am sure there are hard costs associated with the processing required to free someone, but that's a price I think society is more than willing to pay. We don't like locking up people who are innocent.
This quick look at the situation tells me that it's worth investigating further. Keeping people in prison ain't cheap, and keeping the wrongfully convicted in prison just doesn't sit well.