Obstruction of Justice

Well, I'll be happy to let you pay for it, then.

We already do. And it's a hell of a lot cheaper to drop the grand for someone who is not guilty than spend the hundreds of thousands to pay for them to stay in jail from 10 years to life. Not to mention the money that winds up being paid to people who are exonerated, usually a settlement for the time they spent in prison and often a stipend for some designated time afterward. You talk about costs, but you're completely ignoring the outstanding costs of keeping innocent people in jail for long stretches of time, even when they're later found to be innocent.

Since forensic DNA tests cost about a grand each, you want to spend something like $160 million to release 25 prisoners. That works out to, what, fifty million dollars per false conviction?

The irony here is that you accuse me of "word salad" and you go and make up your own. Not every case is going to require DNA tests. Rapes and some murder cases would be the ones most often applicable for DNA testing. But the costs of trying and convicting someone who isn't guilty is a far greater WOMBAT than the grand it costs to get the DNA test to be sure.

Which is a greater waste of time: $1000 in an applicable case to certify guilt or innocence, or finding out 20 years later that the wrong guy was put away and having to repay the guy for all of those years of incarceration?
 
Well, I'll be happy to let you pay for it, then.

How many "cases" are being turned around in Texas? (The numbers I see are about 25, over the past ten years; feel free to correct me if I'm grossly inaccurate.)

Bear in mind that that is out of a total prison population per year of about 160,000. This suggest that fewer than 0.0156% the total population of prisoners in the past year have been overturned on DNA evidence, since many prisoners will have served out their sentences and been released.

Since forensic DNA tests cost about a grand each, you want to spend something like $160 million to release 25 prisoners. That works out to, what, fifty million dollars per false conviction?

DNA evidence is only collected in a small fraction of crimes, mostly cases of rape or murder. Calculating a cost based on testing the entire prison population is highly misleading.
 
They don't. But refusing a DNA test absent compelling grounds to demand it is hardly a wrong.

We don't know whether there are compelling grounds in the case but the article makes reference to "a prolonged series of legal appeals". This is a cost too for the state. Maybe the only evidence was eye witness evidence -- the weakest of all.

I'm not sure what "accredited" means in this instance,.... but I'm willing to bet large sums of money that it's not good enough for courts. The forensic standards for admissible evidence is quite high, and therefore quite costly. It's like the difference between the $5 home pregnancy tests with an 80% accuracy rate and the one your ob/gyn will give you to confirm that has a 99.9% accuracy rate, but costs several hundred dollars.
Look at http://www.gtldna.com/ to see the accreditations they have. Included is the one from the State of Texas -- "The TXDPS Crime Lab Accreditation Program was created on September 1, 2003. Laboratories performing forensic DNA analysis of criminal evidence must be accredited by DPS in order for that laboratory's results and testimony to be admissible in court or criminal proceedings."

Who's going to do the test? Are you going to let other criminals walk free while you deal with the backlog of spurious cases? Re-read the example I posted. It took a year and a half to get the test done. How much are you willing to contribute to that problem?

The court and legal systems are underfunded and bureaucratic. I am sure that private enterprise can do the analysis job faster. The state can take the next 17.5 months to do the database upload and matching.
 
And if he actually is not guilty, then it is not a waste of time.

I agree. But notice INRM's question, to which I responded. "If they're so sure the guy's guilty, why not just pay for the stupid test?"

At some level, we have to assume that the court system is reality-based, or at least reality-influenced. If someone is convicted, that probably means that the evidence for his guilt was strong enough to establish him as guilty "beyond a reasonable doubt," and therefore the chances of him being innocent are very small. If the police and DA are particularly confident of his guilt (beyond what they normally have in a conviction), that should translated to an even higher likelihood of his guilt.

You don't get to tie up the appellate court forever with increasingly silly theories that might clear you, on the off chance that you will get lucky someday. You don't get to tie up the already overworked police labs on the chance that someone might screw up a test or something. The courts are busy and don't have time for such nonsense; they (correctly) guard their docket space from wild-assed guesses and forlorn hopes.

So what's the chance that this will actually clear him? Well, we've already seen (from the article cited in the OP) that this argument is merely one in a "prolonged series of legal appeals." If DNA really is the "magic bullet" that will clear him, why only fire it now? Louisiana passed the law allowing post-conviction DNA testing in 2001. Yet "Mr. Reed has been seeking a DNA test for three years" -- since 2006. What the hell was he doing for the five years before that?
 
Look at http://www.gtldna.com/ to see the accreditations they have.


Yeah, thought so.

Look more closely at that site. The $89 special is not legally admissible because it violates the rules for "chain of custody" -- if you want a legally admissible test, it's $230.

And those tests are only for paternity, which is a substantially different test than identity (and much easier). The test is also based on recent samples (you take samples and send them to the lab within days, not within years), which also makes it much easier/cheaper.
 
I agree. But notice INRM's question, to which I responded. "If they're so sure the guy's guilty, why not just pay for the stupid test?"

At some level, we have to assume that the court system is reality-based, or at least reality-influenced. If someone is convicted, that probably means that the evidence for his guilt was strong enough to establish him as guilty "beyond a reasonable doubt," and therefore the chances of him being innocent are very small. If the police and DA are particularly confident of his guilt (beyond what they normally have in a conviction), that should translated to an even higher likelihood of his guilt.

You don't get to tie up the appellate court forever with increasingly silly theories that might clear you, on the off chance that you will get lucky someday. You don't get to tie up the already overworked police labs on the chance that someone might screw up a test or something. The courts are busy and don't have time for such nonsense; they (correctly) guard their docket space from wild-assed guesses and forlorn hopes.

So what's the chance that this will actually clear him? Well, we've already seen (from the article cited in the OP) that this argument is merely one in a "prolonged series of legal appeals." If DNA really is the "magic bullet" that will clear him, why only fire it now? Louisiana passed the law allowing post-conviction DNA testing in 2001. Yet "Mr. Reed has been seeking a DNA test for three years" -- since 2006. What the hell was he doing for the five years before that?

I understand your argument if performing a DNA test is an unreasonable burden or would prevent higher priority work from being done, but here's what the first paragraph of the article said:
In an age of advanced forensic science, the first step toward ending Kenneth Reed’s prolonged series of legal appeals should be simple and quick: a DNA test, for which he has offered to pay, on evidence from the 1991 rape of which he was convicted.

If it's "simple and quick" and he's offering to pay for it, then your argument stops being reasonable, no? Do we or do we not live in "an age of advanced forensic science"?

The other part is: What is the actual motivation of prosecutors at work here? Is it what you say it is, or is it because they want to keep their winning percentage up?
 
Straw Man?

Not at all. DNA testing should be available if it's likely to be useful. But to claim that "If there's a chance DNA evidence could exonerate a defendant, and the plea is "not guilty," a DNA test should be performed" is tantamount to saying that DNA testing should always be performed, regardless of the amount of other evidence available, and (equivalently) that conviction should be impossible without DNA evidence.

That's a preposterous bar to set.

If I find your tire tracks outside the motel room where I find the body of your estranged spouse, with your footprints in her blood and your fingerprints on the murder weapon, and I have three eyewitnesses who saw you enter the room with the crowbar and heard her scream, I shouldn't need to spend another $1000 and year and a half to convict you of her murder.

And you shouldn't be able to have your lawyer tie the appeals court in knots about how justice has been denied to you.

It's a little different, of course, if I didn't have the physical evidence, or if all three witnesses later recanted and said I had bribed them into testifying against you. Eyewitness testimony is unreliable. But that doesn't mean that DNA should ever be required.

If there is straw at the scene of the crime and a man was accused of committing it, is it a straw-man argument??

I'm sure that prison stoolies that give evidence for shortened sentences always recant. Eyewitness testimony is always accurate. And public defense counsel is never sub-par in capital cases.

Are there times when DNA testing is overkill? Yes. "He stole my circular saw; we found it in his garage with the serial number intact." Are there times when DNA testing should be required? I think so. "That is definitely the stranger that raped me." Any sort of blanket statement that DNA testing should always be required, or is a useless waste of time and money is not reasonable. If a defendant wants to pay for the test himself/herself, what is the concern? Is DNA testing so unreliable that they will win the testing lottery, being one of the few false negatives to be freed to continue a life of crime??
 
Surely any new evidence that might over turn a conviction is the responsibility of a defense lawyer to acquire. It's not the police's job to help support convicted criminals' appeal efforts.

To say that officials are preventing these people having DNA testing is false. They just won't do it on the criminal's behalf. Just like they won't do anything else towards an appeal case on a a criminal's behalf.
 
There's one obvious point to make... DNA testing is only useful if you have something to compare it to. I would presume if the police actually recovered the perpetrator's DNA testing their suspects would be par for the course.

This suggests either

A) Police are recovering DNA at the scene of crimes and not testing it, and neither are the Defense (which indicates unfathomable incompetence on both sides)
B) No DNA has been recovered and officials are refusing DNA testing because it would be entirely pointless since there's nothing to compare it to.
 
There's one obvious point to make... DNA testing is only useful if you have something to compare it to. I would presume if the police actually recovered the perpetrator's DNA testing their suspects would be par for the course.

This suggests either

A) Police are recovering DNA at the scene of crimes and not testing it, and neither are the Defense (which indicates unfathomable incompetence on both sides)
B) No DNA has been recovered and officials are refusing DNA testing because it would be entirely pointless since there's nothing to compare it to.

In the case of District Attorney's Office v. Osborne currently being considered by the Supreme Court, the evidence was collected before accurate DNA testing existed.

What motive would the state of Alaska have to appeal this all the way to the Supreme Court?
 
Surely any new evidence that might over turn a conviction is the responsibility of a defense lawyer to acquire. It's not the police's job to help support convicted criminals' appeal efforts.

To say that officials are preventing these people having DNA testing is false. They just won't do it on the criminal's behalf. Just like they won't do anything else towards an appeal case on a a criminal's behalf.

I supposed you missed Puppycow's post, where he points out that the defense is offering to pay, and the officials are still trying to block it. So calling this a case of the officials preventing people from doing it is quite accurate.

Also:
There's one obvious point to make... DNA testing is only useful if you have something to compare it to. I would presume if the police actually recovered the perpetrator's DNA testing their suspects would be par for the course.

This suggests either

A) Police are recovering DNA at the scene of crimes and not testing it, and neither are the Defense (which indicates unfathomable incompetence on both sides)
B) No DNA has been recovered and officials are refusing DNA testing because it would be entirely pointless since there's nothing to compare it to.

As has been pointed out, you missed "collected material evidence before there was DNA testing of sufficient quality to provide an answer." False dichotomies-- while popular in court arguments-- rarely ever hold water.
 
There's one obvious point to make... DNA testing is only useful if you have something to compare it to. I would presume if the police actually recovered the perpetrator's DNA testing their suspects would be par for the course.

This suggests either

A) Police are recovering DNA at the scene of crimes and not testing it, and neither are the Defense (which indicates unfathomable incompetence on both sides)
B) No DNA has been recovered and officials are refusing DNA testing because it would be entirely pointless since there's nothing to compare it to.

A) Isn't completely implausible and can happen.

B) Is incorrect in that in nearly all of these DNA cases either DNA wasn't in use at all at the time of trial or that advances in DNA technology have made samples untestable at trial now testable.

(Disclaimer: I'm not a neutral observer in this deal as I'm a defense attorney who does a lot of work with DNA in cold cases such as the OP)

In my opinion there are few reasons to deny DNA testing.

The biggest and most common reason is when it is not dispositive. A good example I've run across was in a rape case where the defense wanted to test a sample from a hotel mattress where the rape allegedly occurred. Since the sample's age couldn't be determined with any accuracy, that it was from someone other than the accused would not establish innocence. (In a post-conviction attack the burden of proof shifts to the defendant.)

This factor alone eliminates the vast majority of cases. Most that remain involve rape as your common gunshot murder doesn't usually involve DNA.

The second is that there is staggering evidence. Even tons of eyewitness don't cut it as it isn't that hard to have a mass tainting of eyewitnesses. Same with a confession. I mean something like a clear identification from a video recording, the person caught at the scene next to the body, that sort of thing.

There may be others, but those are the big ones and they eliminate nearly all cases.
 
Suddenly is exactly right; in most cases it's a result of the advancing technology. Tiny samples obtained at a crime scene years ago could not be reliably processed; they can now.
Even if the evidence (say, a bullet with tiny quantities of DNA) has lain in a locker for years, modern testing can recover and analyze it.

DNA is not magic, of course. We only get DNA evidence in a small percentage of crimes.
Interestingly, our university made one of the very first DNA cases in the St. Louis area years ago. A burglar ( a repeat offender ) had broken into a fraternity house through a skylight, cutting himself and leaving blood drops all over.
 
In the case of District Attorney's Office v. Osborne currently being considered by the Supreme Court, the evidence was collected before accurate DNA testing existed.

What motive would the state of Alaska have to appeal this all the way to the Supreme Court?

Motive? The neutral way of saying it is that some state attorneys are zealous in their advancing what they see as an essential state interest in swift and final justice and so forth.

...or you can say they are punishment happy bloodthirsty geeks with no sense of decency.

My favorite example of this sort of thing:

Judge Laura Denvir Stith seemed not to believe what she was hearing.

A prosecutor was trying to block a death row inmate from having his conviction reopened on the basis of new evidence, and Judge Stith, of the Missouri Supreme Court, was getting exasperated. ''Are you suggesting,'' she asked the prosecutor, that ''even if we find Mr. Amrine is actually innocent, he should be executed?''

Frank A. Jung, an assistant state attorney general, replied, ''That's correct, your honor.''

That exchange was, legal experts say, unusual only for its frankness.

I'll comment that the assistant AG's position is not novel in the legal community as some see the purpose of the justice system is to allow a "fair" trial rather than reach the right result.
 
It was assumed in the '80s as all this DNA testing was gaining steam, that there'd be a huge flood of DNA freeings, from death row and otherwise, since common sense* told people that wrongful convictions were rampant. In fact, there were very few defense requests for DNA testing from post-conviction inmates (where DNA was available.) The reason was obvious: Almost all convictions were of actually guilty people, and the inmates knew the DNA test would come back positive.

Most convicts I've come across have figured out the game theory flaw in the assumption that they would only ask for DNA if they are not guilty.

Often these convicts are in a position where there is no harm with a DNA test confirming guilt. They are serving long sentences already with little hope of clemency. So why not roll the dice on the one in a million shot that somehow the lab screws it up?

The reason I don't share the concerns over price and backlogging is threefold. First the criteria I set out in an above post about the usefulness of DNA in a cold case. Second is that the test cost is insignificant against both the cost of incarceration and the common interest in accuracy in criminal matters. Third, I can get a private DNA test with maybe a six week turnaround, even if there was some sort of dramatic upswing private labs will react by increasing capacity.
 
You can't double-check, because we're convinced that we've got the right guy. This is not just stupid, but evil.

The defendant was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If we allow DNA testing simply to "double check" then we are implicitly stating that the standard of reasonable doubt is insufficient. That seems fraught with unintended legal consequences, but I'm not a lawyer.
 
The defendant was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If we allow DNA testing simply to "double check" then we are implicitly stating that the standard of reasonable doubt is insufficient. That seems fraught with unintended legal consequences, but I'm not a lawyer.

Conversely, there have been a number of cases where a person has been "found guilty beyond reasonable doubt" and later DNA evidence has cleared them. Simple justice should preempt concerns about "legal consequences".
 
The defendant was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If we allow DNA testing simply to "double check" then we are implicitly stating that the standard of reasonable doubt is insufficient. That seems fraught with unintended legal consequences, but I'm not a lawyer.

So we shouldn't admit that the standard is lacking? My cynicism tells me that juries are often swayed more by the arguments of lawyers than the evidence, and lawyers know this. It would be a much better system, in my opinion, to have the evidence presented to a jury along with the counsel of experts who can explain its significance. Appeals to emotion have no place in a courtroom, but in our current system they can convict a person who's done nothing wrong.
 
Now that I can agree with.

I think there's a very good chance that in this case, the DNA will exonerate him, enough to justify spending a grand.

What about the waste of money brains and time? He is just as guilty as he was at the top, but you have suddenly reversed yourself about DNA testing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom