Obstruction of Justice

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,628
Location
Yokohama, Japan
Prosecutors Block Access to DNA Testing for Inmates

Mr. Reed has been seeking a DNA test for three years, saying it will prove his innocence. But prosecutors have refused, saying he was identified by witnesses, making his identification by DNA unnecessary.
. . .
In Illinois, prosecutors have opposed a DNA test for Johnnie Lee Savory, convicted of committing a double murder when he was 14, on the grounds that a jury was convinced of his guilt without DNA and that the 175 convicts already exonerated by DNA were “statistically insignificant.”

Eyewitness identification
Eyewitness identification evidence is the leading cause of wrongful conviction in the United States. Of the more than 200 people exonerated by way of DNA evidence in the US, over 75% were wrongfully convicted on the basis of erroneous eyewitness identification evidence.[1] In England, the Criminal Law Review Committee, writing in 1971, stated that cases of mistaken identification "constitute by far the greatest cause of actual or possible wrong convictions".[2] Yet despite substantial anecdotal and scientific support for the proposition that eyewitness testimony is often unreliable, it is held in high regard by jurors in criminal trials, even when "far outweighed by evidence of innocence."[3] In the words of former US Supreme Court Justice William J. Brennan, there is "nothing more convincing [to a jury] than a live human being who takes the stand, points a finger at the defendant, and says 'That's the one!'"[4]
You can't double-check, because we're convinced that we've got the right guy. This is not just stupid, but evil.
:bwall
 
I don't get it. If they're so sure the guy's guilty, why not just pay for the stupid test.

If he's guilty the test will conclude he did it and it will be case closed, unless they're afraid they actually convicted an innocent person and don't want to deal with the "embarrassment"
 
I don't get it. If they're so sure the guy's guilty, why not just pay for the stupid test.

Because if he actually is guilty, the test is a WOMBAT (Waste Of Money, Brains, And Time).
 
They should always do a DNA test.

Because in your universe, neither money nor lab time are in limited supply?

I wish I lived in your universe.


When Aldo Penaflor raped a 9-year-old girl in Houston's East End nearly four years ago, he left behind a telltale piece of evidence: his DNA.

Soon afterward, an unrelated case landed Penaflor's name and genetic code on file in the FBI's database of 1.6 million criminal profiles, the place police can go to match known criminals with unsolved crimes.

Yet Penaflor remained free for a year and a half because of delays in getting the evidence in his case tested and checked against the massive national database. During that time, prosecutors alleged during his trial last month, he abducted and raped a woman, an 18-year-old who was walking home from school.
 
Because in your universe, neither money nor lab time are in limited supply?

I wish I lived in your universe.

I honestly don't see why two wrongs equal a right.

I suppose there are DNA tests and DNA tests but a quick Google shows tests at accredited labs from $80 US up. Since there is a chance that this person may be innocent, does anyone think that it is too much to pay. Let him or his family or anyone pay for it. If it turns out that it proves he is innocent, is this not justice done? :boggled:
 
You can't double-check, because we're convinced that we've got the right guy. This is not just stupid, but evil.
:bwall


Correct, unfortunately. :(



The Supreme Court has pointed out that a "normal" conviction that doesn't use DNA testing is sufficient for everything up to and including capital cases*, but that's a far cry from actively opposing DNA testing to prevent overturning a conviction.






* Which, by the way, is the correct answer, since the validity is based on whether a jury convicts or not. Note this says nothing about a judge allowing appeals, or a DNA test at the request of the defense after the trial, or similar issues. In any case, we dare not let the government overrule jury declarations of innocence, though overruling jury declarations of guilt are fine.
 
I don't get it. If they're so sure the guy's guilty, why not just pay for the stupid test.

If he's guilty the test will conclude he did it and it will be case closed, unless they're afraid they actually convicted an innocent person and don't want to deal with the "embarrassment"



It was assumed in the '80s as all this DNA testing was gaining steam, that there'd be a huge flood of DNA freeings, from death row and otherwise, since common sense* told people that wrongful convictions were rampant. In fact, there were very few defense requests for DNA testing from post-conviction inmates (where DNA was available.) The reason was obvious: Almost all convictions were of actually guilty people, and the inmates knew the DNA test would come back positive.




* Where we define common sense as the disasterbating fantasies of people who find a little rush of purpose and feelings of goodness in their lives by believing themselves defenders against such monstrous and pervasive things.

In any case, 175 may very well be statistically vanishing when compared to hundreds of thousands or millions of cases. Still, to oppose this, feigning you're saving dollars for the constituency (what a swell guy!) and, oh, coincidentally, you're trying to prevent embarrassment for a wrongful conviction. No, that's not really why. I"m really about saving a tiny sum of money. By the way, 175 is statistically insignificant vs. the prison population as a whole, but not vs. prisoners who actually want DNA testing. Remember nobody, especially capital cases, want to be tested if they actually did it. So the correct statistics to use are not 175 vs. the prison population as a whole, but 175 vs. the number who requested as a whole, and the number who requested, got tested, and failed.

I'm willing to bet 175 is pretty damned close to the number who requested DNA testing, if not identical to it.

Hence it's statistically almost a certitude it will come back to exonerate him.




So the long and short of it is, either way, the officials are being disingenuous at best, and deserve to replace him in jail at worst. And in either case, deserve to lose their jobs. The population should see to it at the next election.
 
Because if he actually is guilty, the test is a WOMBAT (Waste Of Money, Brains, And Time).

This is absolutely false. If he's guilty, then it means they've done due diligence in maintaining that he is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. That is the onus of criminal convictions in the first place.
 
This is absolutely false. If he's guilty, then it means they've done due diligence in maintaining that he is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. That is the onus of criminal convictions in the first place.

This is word salad.

If the convicted defendant is guilty -- i.e., he actually committed the crime for which he has been convicted and sentenced -- then the only way for the DNA test to have any effect at all is for it to erroneously clear him, a clear miscarriage of justice. Since the whole advantage of DNA testing is its extremely low error rate, the chances of this happening are remote, and DNA testing is a WOMBAT.

If the convicted defendant did not actually commit the crime for which he has been convicted and sentence, he is not guilty. (And, in fact, "actual innocence" is the term used for this particular grounds for appeal.) Just because a court has pronounced you guilty doesn't mean that you are. And, of course if this is the case, then a DNA test is appropriate to clear the convicted defendant.

And it makes sense that in cases where the evidence is questionable, DNA testing should be made available. But that's not what INRM said. He said that the cops should offer [and pay for] DNA testing specifically in cases where "they're so sure the guy's guilty." Those are, at least in theory, the cases where new DNA testing is least appropriate.
 
I honestly don't see why two wrongs equal a right.

They don't. But refusing a DNA test absent compelling grounds to demand it is hardly a wrong.

I suppose there are DNA tests and DNA tests but a quick Google shows tests at accredited labs from $80 US up.

I'm not sure what "accredited" means in this instance,.... but I'm willing to bet large sums of money that it's not good enough for courts. The forensic standards for admissible evidence is quite high, and therefore quite costly. It's like the difference between the $5 home pregnancy tests with an 80% accuracy rate and the one your ob/gyn will give you to confirm that has a 99.9% accuracy rate, but costs several hundred dollars.

Since there is a chance that this person may be innocent, does anyone think that it is too much to pay.

Who's going to do the test? Are you going to let other criminals walk free while you deal with the backlog of spurious cases? Re-read the example I posted. It took a year and a half to get the test done. How much are you willing to contribute to that problem?
 
This is word salad.

If the convicted defendant is guilty -- i.e., he actually committed the crime for which he has been convicted and sentenced -- then the only way for the DNA test to have any effect at all is for it to erroneously clear him, a clear miscarriage of justice. Since the whole advantage of DNA testing is its extremely low error rate, the chances of this happening are remote, and DNA testing is a WOMBAT.

If the convicted defendant did not actually commit the crime for which he has been convicted and sentence, he is not guilty. (And, in fact, "actual innocence" is the term used for this particular grounds for appeal.) Just because a court has pronounced you guilty doesn't mean that you are. And, of course if this is the case, then a DNA test is appropriate to clear the convicted defendant.

And it makes sense that in cases where the evidence is questionable, DNA testing should be made available. But that's not what INRM said. He said that the cops should offer [and pay for] DNA testing specifically in cases where "they're so sure the guy's guilty." Those are, at least in theory, the cases where new DNA testing is least appropriate.

I don't care what INRM said. In cases where the only evidence is circumstantial and based on eyewitness testimony, DNA evidence should be mandatory. The number of cases being turned around here in Texas alone should be enough to show just how flimsy testimony is compared to actual evidence. There's no word salad about it: if there's a chance the guy is not guilty, then it should be pursued to avoid a false conviction.
 
In cases where the only evidence is circumstantial and based on eyewitness testimony, DNA evidence should be mandatory.

Well, I'll be happy to let you pay for it, then.

The number of cases being turned around here in Texas alone should be enough to show just how flimsy testimony is compared to actual evidence.

How many "cases" are being turned around in Texas? (The numbers I see are about 25, over the past ten years; feel free to correct me if I'm grossly inaccurate.)

Bear in mind that that is out of a total prison population per year of about 160,000. This suggest that fewer than 0.0156% the total population of prisoners in the past year have been overturned on DNA evidence, since many prisoners will have served out their sentences and been released.

Since forensic DNA tests cost about a grand each, you want to spend something like $160 million to release 25 prisoners. That works out to, what, fifty million dollars per false conviction?
 
I'll amend my statement. If there's a chance DNA evidence could exonerate a defendant, and the plea is "not guilty," a DNA test should be performed. Wouldn't you want that if you were accused of a crime?

I'll not amend mine. Apparently in your world neither time nor money are in limited supply.
 
I'll not amend mine. Apparently in your world neither time nor money are in limited supply.

Well, if DNA testing shouldn't be used to clear someone falsely accused of a crime, am I understanding correctly that you only support such testing as a means to seal a conviction?
 
In cases like this where DNA evidence from the original case is available, and the culpatory evidence is essentially that of eyewitnesses, the test should be done.

NPR's Talk Of The Nation recently profiled a similar case, the convicted individual had been identified as the rapist by the victim herself, who not only assisted in preparing a composite drawing, but picked the suspect out of a lineup.
She was wrong.
The actual rapist, imprisoned in the same facility as the wrongly-convicted suspect, did in fact look quite a bit like him. It took several years working through the Project Innocence folks to not only prove the fellow innocent but to convict the actual rapist.

Now, the freed suspect has established a project with the victim in the case to explore these sorts of cases.

As one working in law enforcement for many years, it's painfully clear that the once gold-standard of eyewitness testimony is often unreliable.

Alas, prosecutors are often unwilling to re-visit cases. Money is a concern, of course, but often the actual expense is minimal. More often it's that these overturned cases make the prosecutors look bad. In most venues, prosecutors are in an elected-to-office scenario, and having a good conviction ratio can be used when angling for a more prestigious elected position.
 
Last edited:
Well, if DNA testing shouldn't be used to clear someone falsely accused of a crime, am I understanding correctly that you only support such testing as a means to seal a conviction?

Not at all. DNA testing should be available if it's likely to be useful. But to claim that "If there's a chance DNA evidence could exonerate a defendant, and the plea is "not guilty," a DNA test should be performed" is tantamount to saying that DNA testing should always be performed, regardless of the amount of other evidence available, and (equivalently) that conviction should be impossible without DNA evidence.

That's a preposterous bar to set.

If I find your tire tracks outside the motel room where I find the body of your estranged spouse, with your footprints in her blood and your fingerprints on the murder weapon, and I have three eyewitnesses who saw you enter the room with the crowbar and heard her scream, I shouldn't need to spend another $1000 and year and a half to convict you of her murder.

And you shouldn't be able to have your lawyer tie the appeals court in knots about how justice has been denied to you.

It's a little different, of course, if I didn't have the physical evidence, or if all three witnesses later recanted and said I had bribed them into testifying against you. Eyewitness testimony is unreliable. But that doesn't mean that DNA should ever be required.
 
In cases like this where DNA evidence from the original case is available, and the culpatory evidence is essentially that of eyewitnesses, the test should be done.

Now that I can agree with.

I think there's a very good chance that in this case, the DNA will exonerate him, enough to justify spending a grand.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom