Obama Breaks Campaign Pledge on Public Financing

I think that is part of the point. Obama always talked about using public financing but always triangulated on the issue. He always hinged it on conditions and on what McCain did.

Like I said, for political observers, this announcement wasn't a big shock. He always made it sound like he was just waiting for McCain to do X before he would accept financing and such. It always sounded like he was all for doing it (as long X, Y, Z happen).

It was a douche move at the end of a long and weaselesque journey of the kind of triangulation he dumped on Hillary for during their early debates.

Again, he didn't betray me in any way. I doubt his followers will feel betrayed since he put a positive spin on it.

The bold pretty much says it all. Everything else is just disappointed kvetching because he didn't say something you could hang him with later.
 
I can't help but note the irony of people ridiculing this as nothing more than people screaming "he liiiiieeeed!!!".. the very people who are quick to call every single word out of Bush's mouth a lie and treason. Even when it's clearly cases of mistakes, bad intelligence, etc.
.

It's funny you should pick this thread, one where the anti-Obama people are trying to spin a conditional statement of intent into a solemn pledge, to make your comments about dishonesty.

If this is the worst "lie" of Obama's you can match up against Bush's ********, I'd say you've got your work cut out for you.
 
The bold pretty much says it all. Everything else is just disappointed kvetching because he didn't say something you could hang him with later.

No, it doesn't say it all.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/02/u...ce/Times Topics/People/K/Kirkpatrick, David D.
WASHINGTON, March 1 — Senator John McCain joined Senator Barack Obama on Thursday in promising to accept a novel fund-raising truce if each man wins his party’s presidential nomination.

The funny note here is that in March 2007 when this happened, each man was seen as a long shot for his parties' nomination so they could afford to take this symbolic high road gestures. In Obama's case, gesture was all it was.
 
I can't help but note the irony of people ridiculing this as nothing more than people screaming "he liiiiieeeed!!!".. the very people who are quick to call every single word out of Bush's mouth a lie and treason. Even when it's clearly cases of mistakes, bad intelligence, etc.

dudalb is correct. I find myself constantly at odds with how some of you think. You say things that demonstrate high intelligence and logical thinking / critical thinking when it comes ot things like CT's and Woo nonsense. But you throw it all out the window and blindly support your party, whatever the cost, no matter how irrational it is to do so, no matter how wrong they are. Ever.

It's pure "fanboism". They can do no wrong in your eyes. If worst comes to worst, and you are painted into a corner, you will always go to the old "we may do X but it's nowhere near as bad as Republicans who do X, Y and Z". So, it's all fine and dandy because "the other guy does worse!" or "the other guy is EVIL!". Forget old axioms like "Don't stoop to their level" and "two wrongs do not make a right".. "be the bigger man<sic>".

Hell, one of you even goes so far as to admit that winning is "the only thing" (isn't that quote attribution to Lombardi an old myth?). Therefore more important than honesty, integrity, honor? Anything?

It's shocking at times. And it causes me to constantly re-evaulate my level of respect for a great many people here. I see alot of intellectual dishonesty. Way too much to ignore.

My simple answer is this. Do not expect a lot of rationalism in "Politics" or "Faith".

TAM:)
 
I can't help but note the irony of people ridiculing this as nothing more than people screaming "he liiiiieeeed!!!"..
That would be me. That is my phrase exactly.

The very people who are quick to call every single word out of Bush's mouth a lie and treason. Even when it's clearly cases of mistakes, bad intelligence, etc.
That would not be me. I have stated many times that I don't believe Bush does nothing but lie, although some of his statements have been shown to be discernable as deliberately incorrect. He's a politician. Go figure. However, I have not only given numerous instances where I agree with Bush's decisions (like the UAE control of ports an his stance on illegal immigration) as well as the times I disagree with him. I have also stated that everybody lies, including myself, and that lying is not so as important as the consequences of what they do. Clinton lied (under oath) about a blow job. The consequences for the nation should have been practically nothing. Bush cherry-picked CIA information to justify a decision he had already reached. Less of a lie, perhaps, but the consequences for the nation were much greater.

So you see, these are not the same people. I know there are a lot of posters here and they tend to blend together, but it is a mistake to try to divide them into "right" and "left". We are complex people with a wide range of beliefs that cannot be pigeonholed. Making general statements like "These are the very people who..." is usually going to be a mistake. I do not say that you are the very same as Painter or BeAChooser or Brainster, even though you may agree on some issues.

I do feel that this issue is an attempt by McCain supporters to sceam at the top of their voices "Barak is a liar" and I also think it is a wrong and misleading way to deal with issues. But I am consistant. I also feel that demonizing Bush simply because he lied (or shaded the truth or dissembled etc.) is wrong. Talk about the consequences. That's what's important.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom