Obama Breaks Campaign Pledge on Public Financing

Oh wow, thats the kinda stuff they send to their email lists?

PACs can only contribute 5000 dollars directly to a candidate. However, there are a number of other ways they can use their money.

For instance, one of the top 20 PACS by receipts is:
Moveon.org $14,080,682

This money will go into attack ads against John McCain.

The idea that somehow the 5k McCain will get directly from a PAC needs to be counter-balanced by bucking public financing is laughable and at worst, very deceptive. I expect this sort of thing though from a private political mailing list. The one time I was on one, it was almost as bad as the faith healer mailing lists Randi described in his book.

Edited to add:
http://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/toppacs.php?cycle=2008&Type=R&filter=P

There are our top 20 PACs by receipts, does the dire situation spelled out by the private letter Burch got match reality?

Edited to add yet more:
http://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/expenddetail.php?cycle=2008&cmte=C00401224&name=OBAMA+FOR+AMERICA

One of the top 20 is ActBlue which just gives money to other orgs, including one called "OBAMA FOR AMERICA". However, Obama himself doesn't take money. It must be nice having your cake, eating it too, and fooling everyone in the room.
 
Last edited:
Oh wow, thats the kinda stuff they send to their email lists?

PACs can only contribute 5000 dollars directly to a candidate. However, there are a number of other ways they can use their money.

For instance, one of the top 20 PACS by receipts is:
Moveon.org $14,080,682

This money will go into attack ads against John McCain.

The idea that somehow the 5k McCain will get directly from a PAC needs to be counter-balanced by bucking public financing is laughable and at worst, very deceptive. I expect this sort of thing though from a private political mailing list. The one time I was on one, it was almost as bad as the faith healer mailing lists Randi described in his book.

Edited to add:
http://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/toppacs.php?cycle=2008&Type=R&filter=P

There are our top 20 PACs by receipts, does the dire situation spelled out by the private letter Burch got match reality?

Edited to add yet more:
http://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/expenddetail.php?cycle=2008&cmte=C00401224&name=OBAMA+FOR+AMERICA

One of the top 20 is ActBlue which just gives money to other orgs, including one called "OBAMA FOR AMERICA". However, Obama himself doesn't take money. It must be nice having your cake, eating it too, and fooling everyone in the room.
Yes, American politics is very dirty. One of the things I respect McCain for is that, once, he tried to clean them up a bit. Of course, they immediately found ways around it. Now he doesn't even try. Can't blame him really.

The thing is, no politician is going to do anything that seriously hamstrings the ability of politicians to collect money, for the same reason you don't see importers supporting tariffs. I wish it were different. I've written letters, but these things have a lot of inertia.

But in the past, the GOP has been much better at raising funds and circumventing roadblocks. Yeah, MoveOn is up there, but so is the NRA. Unless the Dems are doing something that the Reps are forbidden to do, then I cannot see where they have a case for complaining.
 
Back when he made that pledge, he didn't expect to actually win. You can't hold him to that now.


That does remind one of the wonderful George Stephanopoulos quote about Bill Clinton - "He kept all the promises he intended to keep". Chuckles.

Change you'd better believe - it's even different than last November.
 
Yes, American politics is very dirty. One of the things I respect McCain for is that, once, he tried to clean them up a bit. Of course, they immediately found ways around it. Now he doesn't even try. Can't blame him really.

Well, at least the PACs can't run ads the last month before election day.

we have the 527s for that.....
 
Like it or not, he has over 30,000 of that 50,000 donors he wanted to recruit already. I expect he will be done with his July 4th challenge by midnight.

Oral Roberts was pretty successful with his mailings too. Complete with challenges and dates (and deception).

We need someone on a McCain mailing list to show the kind of crap they're getting.
 
I keep hearing "pledge." Where is this pledge?

Langauge like "I pledge" "I promise" "I guarantee" would be helpful.

Language like "I intend to aggressively pursue the possibility provided McCain agrees to terms" is not helpful.
 
Here's the money quote:
Ben Burch quoting a letter from the Obama campaign sent to someone named "Dave" said:
Even though we stood to receive more than $80 million in taxpayer funding for our campaign, the system has been so gamed and exploited by our opponents that it is effectively broken.

John McCain, the Republican National Committee, and their allies in so-called 527 groups that raise and spend unlimited contributions are dedicated to manipulating this broken system to raise as much money as possible -- and they've proven that they're very good at it.
Translation: "Waaahhh!!! The mean old Republicans made us do it!"

Come on, just man up and admit that you've been able to raise $250 million in private donations, and expect to get another $250 million before the election, that you hope to blow McCain out of the water by spending half a billion dollars out-advertising him, and you're going to use whatever strategy gets you the most bucks.

Wasn't the purpose of the McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform to get the corrupting influence of money out of our campaigns? So glad to see it's working.
 
Ah ... it's the old definition of "is" argument, so dear to democrats.

Not really. A pledge is a solumn binding promise. A guarantee. The question was ...

"If you are nominated for President in 2008 and your major opponents agree to forgo private funding in the general election campaign, will you participate in the presidential public financing system?"

He replied, "yes".

So, lets look at it this way. If I ask you the following ...

"If you decide to go to the movies this weekend and your best friends agree to go see "The Love Guru", will you go see it with them?"

If you say, "yes", have you made a pledge? If you hear that 'The Love Guru" has gotten sucky reviews and change your mind tomorrow and instead go see "The Hulk", have you broken a pledge?
 
Here's the money quote:
Translation: "Waaahhh!!! The mean old Republicans made us do it!"
I think you're misreading that translation book. Apparently you were trying to say, "My hovercraft is full of eels."

This issue is a land mine for McCain. If he tries to criticize Obama, it will look like he wants the Government to finance elections. Given the average political savvy of Americans, that just ain't gonna fly with either party. He will be so smacked down. They're not going to understand "Taking government funds puts restrictions own how you can use the money", they're just going to understand "You want a government handout?" A clever politician, like Obama is, will make sure that impression is emphasized.

Come on, just man up and admit that you've been able to raise $250 million in private donations, and expect to get another $250 million before the election, that you hope to blow McCain out of the water by spending half a billion dollars out-advertising him, and you're going to use whatever strategy gets you the most bucks.

And how would the Republicans behave differently if they had the same situation? The only difference would be that the bigbux would be from a few ultra-rich donors, not from many thousands of "ordinary people".

Why don't you woman up and admit that?

Wasn't the purpose of the McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform to get the corrupting influence of money out of our campaigns? So glad to see it's working.
It didn't work. Special interests quickly found loopholes and workarounds. But Obama's fundraising isn't even the sort of money-leak McCain-Feingold was trying to plug. Indeed, it was written to encourage individual participation over PACs, lobbyists and corporations. This sort of grass-roots fundraising was probably McCain's dream when he co-sponsored the legislation. Ironic, isn't it?

Of course, Obama can't take all the credit for this incredible feat of reaching out to individual Americans and convincing them that they need to participate in the political process. For that, he should give a word of thanks to his number one fundraiser. George W. Bush.
 
Last edited:
The original "pledge" had a necessary condition added by the organization asking the question. McCain's recent release of the 527s (way to keep the corrupting influence of money out of the campaigns, Senator), his own reversal on public financing in the primary when he saw he could raise more cash outside the system (something that may yet land him in jail), and the current amount of money he has working for him by gaming the system shows that he has no intention of honoring the spirit of this condition.

So Barack is out. This is not the "mean old Republicans making him do it." The pledge had a necessary condition. McCain is not honoring it.

Tough.
 
And how would the Republicans behave differently if they had the same situation?
Did I say they would behave any differently? Any politician who wouldn't follow the path that leads to the most money would be a fool.

It didn't work. Special interests quickly found loopholes and workarounds. But Obama's fundraising isn't even the sort of money-leak McCain-Feingold was trying to plug. Indeed, it was written to encourage individual participation over PACs, lobbyists and corporations.
So Moveon.org isn't a PAC, lobbyist, or corporation? What is it, then? Is it some kind of non-partisan group dedicated to getting the facts about the issues, the candidates, and their positions, without spin?

Or is it $14 million worth of McCain-bashing?

Organized Republicans = PAC/lobby.
Organized Democrats = grass-roots fundraising.

For the record, I think campaign finance laws are ridiculous. They should all be abolished. Let the candidates get money from wherever they want, and if they want to have a pissing match over whose money is dirtier instead of discussing issues, let them have at it.

The two biggest issues in this campaign should be, not necessarily in order, who's going to actually do something about our need to buy oil from people who hate us and want to kill us and are using that money to build the weapons to kill us with, and how to save Social Security.

How the candidates got their money should be somewhere around #388 down the list, right after how we'll deal with the Martian invasion and ahead of stopping those invisible black helicopters from buzzing your house at 3:00 in the morning.
 
Did I say they would behave any differently? Any politician who wouldn't follow the path that leads to the most money would be a fool.
You seem to be not-so-subtly implying that Obama is somehow tainted for doing so.

So Moveon.org isn't a PAC, lobbyist, or corporation? What is it, then? Is it some kind of non-partisan group dedicated to getting the facts about the issues, the candidates, and their positions, without spin?
It is not a group with a vested interest or a specific agenda (other than getting Democrats elected). If the Dems win, Moveon will not stand to benefit by receiving government contracts. It is a pro-Democratic fund-raising organization, but as far as I know, it is not a lobby. But Obama is not getting all his money from Moveon.org. He is getting it from lots of people and lots of places. Yes, I've donated (just to keep Michelle from nagging me) by sending a check for twenty dollars. Hell yeah, I'm partisan. So are you. Most people here are. Being partisan doesn't mean you agree with everything one party does, it just means you think they are overall better than the other party.

Or is it $14 million worth of McCain-bashing?
It is $14 worth of campaigning, which will almost certainly include some McCain-bashing.

Organized Republicans = PAC/lobby.
Organized Democrats = grass-roots fundraising.
LOL. Yeah, if the Democrats were organized, that'd be an apt comparison. From what I can tell, they're all over the map. And this is sort of the fundamental difference that is perceived about the two parties. Democrats are perceived as well-meaning bumblers who can't organize their sock drawer. Republicans are perceived as incredibly organized and efficient, evil Mofo's. (Remember, these are just generalizations.:D)

For me, I'll take the bumblers. They're less effective, but less dangerous.

For the record, I think campaign finance laws are ridiculous. They should all be abolished. Let the candidates get money from wherever they want, and if they want to have a pissing match over whose money is dirtier instead of discussing issues, let them have at it.
Well, I go just the opposite way. I would like candidates to have very strict limits on what they can spend even stricter limits on the "campaign season". Any money they raise over those "strict limits" goes directly into the US Treasury. Of course, this is unworkable, but you know, in Europe, especially England, the campaigns don't go on endlessly. Why can't we do something similar here?

The two biggest issues in this campaign should be, not necessarily in order, who's going to actually do something about our need to buy oil from people who hate us and want to kill us and are using that money to build the weapons to kill us with, and how to save Social Security.
I'm not sure what a President can do about your main issue. We tried invading an oil-rich country, and you saw how that worked. I think most knowledgeable people agree that increasing domestic production will not cover the gap. Some (like myself) think it will hurt us in the long run. Pretty much everyone agrees that we ought to develop alternate energy sources, with the exception that some don't agree that nuclear should be one of them.

As for Social Security, it is going to be a rocky thirty years or so until we get over the baby-boomer hump. We'll probably go deeply into debt, but at least that debt will be for something useful, not a pointless war.

How the candidates got their money should be somewhere around #388 down the list, right after how we'll deal with the Martian invasion and ahead of stopping those invisible black helicopters from buzzing your house at 3:00 in the morning.
I have to disagree. I'm not in favor of a Corporate Government, which is what I see unrestricted fundraising leading to. This isn't Martian Invasion stuff either. Look at Bush and Cheney's ties to corporations and how they've manipulated things to the advantage of their "friends". Sure, a few blow up (like Enron) but overall, they benefit greatly, and the gap between rich and poor grows ever wider. I think that's a bad thing for our country. YMMV.
 
David Brooks says Obama's two politicians in one:

And Fast Eddie Obama didn’t just sell out the primary cause of his life. He did it with style. He did it with a video so risibly insincere that somewhere down in the shadow world, Lee Atwater is gaping and applauding. Obama blamed the (so far marginal) Republican 527s. He claimed that private donations are really public financing. He made a cut-throat political calculation seem like Mother Teresa’s final steps to sainthood.
 
I have to admit, it was shrewd of him....very. Ok, I admit, he is no longer the messiah....lol

TAM:)
 
When it comes to flip flopping Obama is no worse...but no better...them most politicians.
You can convince me that Obama is a better choice then McCain, but don't try to convince me he has some kind of poltical Immaculate Conception and is with out sin.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom