Obama Breaks Campaign Pledge on Public Financing

I don't know that he ever "pledged" to stay with public financing either.

Quotes from an earlier article citation:

In November 2007, Obama answered "Yes" to Common Cause when asked "If you are nominated for President in 2008 and your major opponents agree to forgo private funding in the general election campaign, will you participate in the presidential public financing system?"

Obama wrote: "In February 2007, I proposed a novel way to preserve the strength of the public financing system in the 2008 election. My plan requires both major party candidates to agree on a fundraising truce, return excess money from donors, and stay within the public financing system for the general election.

So if you're not going to use private or public financing, what are you to do? Use your own money or the sort of illegal foreign campaign contributions that supported the Clinton and DNC efforts in the 1990s.
 
I can't find where he says this. Can you quote it?

From; https://donate.barackobama.com/page/contribute/splashupsell

CHECK THIS BOX TO CONFIRM THAT THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE AND ACCURATE:
I am a United States citizen or a lawfully-admitted permanent resident.

I am at least 16 years old.

This contribution is not made from the general treasury funds of a corporation, labor organization or national bank.

This contribution is not made from the funds of a political action committee.

This contribution is not made from the treasury of an entity or person who is a federal contractor.

This contribution is not made from the funds of an individual registered as a federal lobbyist or a foreign agent, or an entity that is a federally registered lobbying firm or foreign agent.

The funds I am donating are not being provided to me by another person or entity for the purpose of making this contribution.

and

Your contribution is not tax-deductible for federal income tax purposes. An individual may contribute a maximum of $2,300 per election (the primary and general are separate elections). By submitting your contribution, you agree that the first $2,300 is designated for the primary, and any additional amount up to $2,300 is designated for the general election.

So; Not taking PAC funds. Not taking business funds. Not taking Lobbyist funds. Not taking foreign funds. Not taking more than $2300. And NOT TAKING PUBLIC MONEY.
 
If McCain had done this, the people defending Obama would be the first to attack him.
It never fails to astound me how intelligent people can be so blinded by partisanship.
 
Last edited:
Its McCain's fault Obama won't live up to his finance pledge.

(mind you, i could care less if he does or not, but the excuses are funny)
 
If McCain had done this, the people defending Obama would be the first to attack him.
It never fails to astound me how intelligent people can be so blinded by partisanship.
Really? Why? Oh sure, there will always be people shouting "liar liar", but as we've seen, not all Obama supporters are like that. Probably not all McCain supporters either, it just seems that the ones who are like that are clustering here.
 
From the first NY times link:

In fact, Mr. Obama stopped short of making a flat promise to participate in the public financing system. Asked in a questionnaire whether he would take part if his opponents did the same, Mr. Obama wrote yes. But he added, “If I am the Democratic nominee, I will aggressively pursue an agreement with the Republican nominee to preserve a publicly financed general election.”

So the NYT did mention it, noting that his "yes" was clearly conditional upon the proposals, which is obvious. Meanwhile, the McCain side does everything Obama wanted to agree not to do.


This would be yet another salvo fired by the GOP at its own foot. Going after a candidate because he refuses to take public funds is pretty stupid, moreso when there is no evidence he made an unconditional pledge to do so.

Damn liberals, promising to spend our tax dollars and backing out!!!

It was seven months ago, which is forever in campaign time. A candidate that held to everything he said he planned to do even though the circumstances have greatly changed shouldn't be running a lemonade stand much less the country...
 
Indeed, since taxpayers can deduct their contributions to candidates from their income taxes, it is quite likely (given the amounts that Obama's campaign team is talking about raising) that this will be a net drain on the US Treasury.

My bad on this part; I remembered that there is a line on the income tax form for credit for contributions to candidates for public office, but the amount is capped ($50 IIRC). Thus contributions are not tax deductible beyond that amount.
 
Really? Why? Oh sure, there will always be people shouting "liar liar", but as we've seen, not all Obama supporters are like that. Probably not all McCain supporters either, it just seems that the ones who are like that are clustering here.

Well, honestly, I expected a more universal "pffffft" to this on a skeptic forum with so many people who keep up with current events. Obama has been triangulating and trying to gracefully bail on public financing now for a long time. I think most everyone with a finger on the pulse of the news knew this was coming. The thing I always wondered was, what will the spin be.

The spin is, he has turned this into another fund raising effort. Donate to me and buck the system. And plus, its McCain's fault.

I think an issue like this is one that reveals the blinders some Obama supporters here might have. However, they will probably feel comforted that someone like BeAChooser is dumping on Obama use that as internal consolation that this is yet another partisan attack that they shouldn't fret.

This was a douche move by Obama. More power to him though, he'll get more money this way.
 
Quotes from an earlier article citation:



So if you're not going to use private or public financing, what are you to do? Use your own money or the sort of illegal foreign campaign contributions that supported the Clinton and DNC efforts in the 1990s.


I don't see a pledge in that. He's certainly indicating that he plans to. Plans change. I see him agreeing to it at that point in time. I certainly don't see a "read my lips: no new taxes" type of thing with this. But thanks for trying. Maybe there are some quotes where he pledges (as in promises, guarantees, etc.) to use public financing.
 
Well, honestly, I expected a more universal "pffffft" to this on a skeptic forum with so many people who keep up with current events. Obama has been triangulating and trying to gracefully bail on public financing now for a long time. I think most everyone with a finger on the pulse of the news knew this was coming. The thing I always wondered was, what will the spin be.
Not much that needs spinning. It is the decision to take public money that requires spinning. This is a no-lose situation for Obama.

The spin is, he has turned this into another fund raising effort. Donate to me and buck the system. And plus, its McCain's fault.
Yep. It's an election year all right. I've gotten so damn many phone calls from Michelle Obama, my wife is beginning to suspect something is going on between us. I told her (my wife) that Shelly was just stalking me.

I think an issue like this is one that reveals the blinders some Obama supporters here might have.
I guess I have blinders, even though I'm a lukewarm Obama supporter. I can't see that this is any kind of issue though. What's the big deal? Yeah, he gets to spend unlimited money, but it is all money that individuals have given him to spend. Most of it is not coming from lobbyists or corporations. It's a genuine grass-roots movement. Does anyone honestly think McCain would do any differently if the situation were reversed?

However, they will probably feel comforted that someone like BeAChooser is dumping on Obama use that as internal consolation that this is yet another partisan attack that they shouldn't fret.
Well, it is true that BAC is a bit on the predictable side, but all one needs to do is look at the topics here to see that there are a number of people on the forum here trying to play "gotcha" with Obama. Unsuccessfully. It must be frustrating for them, so I can't be surprised (or offended) if they turn up the attacks. But this is such a lame and potentially backfiring attack.
  • Obama is not taking public money
  • He has very strict rules for donation
  • He has raised a record amount of money, mostly from small donations
The only down side is:
  • He liiiiiieeeeeeeed!!!!
Yeah, he did lie, although some people might call it "changing his mind". If it means he won't be taking public money, then I'm glad he did.
 
Yeah, he did lie, although some people might call it "changing his mind". If it means he won't be taking public money, then I'm glad he did.

Which we have the GOP to blame for that. I can't blame them for the effective tactic of using "i voted for it before I voted against it" to make Kerry look like a flip-flopper. But then to go on and paint everything he ever changed his mind about as being flip-flops showing a person with no core beliefs...... It has changed our political environment. Any change of mind is symptomatic of bad judgment. Skepticism is frowned upon. Changing your mind based on reason and evidence is bad.

If I could, I would declare a "flip flop accusation ceasefire" but nobody cares what I think since I'm writing in a vote for Mickey Mouse.
 
Last edited:
Letter just received from the Obama campaign;

David --

Barack announced an important decision for our campaign today.

I want to add a little context to the video message you received earlier announcing that we will not participate in the public financing system for the general election.

Even though we stood to receive more than $80 million in taxpayer funding for our campaign, the system has been so gamed and exploited by our opponents that it is effectively broken.

John McCain, the Republican National Committee, and their allies in so-called 527 groups that raise and spend unlimited contributions are dedicated to manipulating this broken system to raise as much money as possible -- and they've proven that they're very good at it.

A top McCain adviser told MSNBC earlier this month, "now that we're in the general election, the RNC money counts, the DNC money counts. So the truth is today, John McCain has more cash on hand and more money than Barack Obama does."

In April alone, they raised nearly $45 million. That's more than our campaign and the Democratic National Committee combined. And that doesn't include the plans of 527 groups like the one called "Freedom's Watch," which has said it will spend as much as $250 million under Karl Rove's direction to attack and defeat Barack Obama.

To compete, Barack has put his faith in ordinary people giving only what they can afford. That's been the strategy of this campaign from the beginning, and more than 1,500,000 supporters like you have gotten us this far.

We have a historic opportunity to prove that a movement of ordinary people has the power to change the way political campaigns are funded. And we have a clear goal as we begin this new challenge: 50,000 people declaring their independence by making a donation before July 4th.

You've gotten us this far with your prior giving. But right now you can grow our movement by giving again. If you promise to match the gift of a first time donor, you could be what convinces them to give for the first time. You'll double your impact, and you'll get to see the name and town of the person you match. You can even exchange a personal note about why you've chosen to support Barack.

Declare your independence from our broken system. Make a matching donation now and bring someone new into this campaign:

https://donate.barackobama.com/promise

Opting out of public matching funds was an extremely difficult decision, and frankly we are at a disadvantage when it comes to raising money. Unlike John McCain, this campaign has never accepted donations from Washington lobbyists or special interest PACs.

While McCain has built his fundraising strategy around high-dollar donors giving huge checks to the RNC, you are creating a new model for publicly financed campaigns.

Thank you for your support and for taking on the masters of a broken system,

David

David Plouffe
Campaign Manager
Obama for America
 
What a horrific advert. Obama the traditional values folksy politician isn't the reason I consider him such a terrific candidate, so I hope that isn't what is going to be pushed up to November.

I see that as an introduction to him for people who may have heard quite a lot about him (both trash and otherwise) but now have an opportunity to see him put his best foot forward. It won't be the primary ad campaign but it's a necessary one.
 
Which we have the GOP to blame for that. I can't blame them for the effective tactic of using "i voted for it before I voted against it" to make Kerry look like a flip-flopper. But then to go on and paint everything he ever changed his mind about as being flip-flops showing a person with no core beliefs...... It has changed our political environment. Any change of mind is symptomatic of bad judgment. Skepticism is frowned upon. Changing your mind based on reason and evidence is bad.
I'm actually gonna give the GOP a break here. Accusals of flip-flopping have been around as long as I can remember. They were particularly numerous when Clinton was running, partly because they were true. He really was a master at holding multiple points-of-view. The difference between him and Kerry was that he could talk his way out of trouble smoothly and convincingly, which I actually regard as a useful skill in diplomacy. Kerry always looked like he was being evasive.

Gary Trudeau makes it a tradition of never drawing presidents in Doonesbury. Bush the First was a "point of light". Bush the second was an asterisk. Appropriately, Clinton was a waffle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom