New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

This is nothing more than an argument from incredulity


Nothing in my statemen is an "argument from incredulity". YOU need to read up on the definition of the logical fallacy that you are trying to point out.

So far, the only person to argue from incredulity is you, as demonstrated by your lack of comprehension.
 
links please :)

You are asking this in response to the comment that Steven Jones is a proven fraud and liar.

You really need to ask?

Steven Jones claimed that jets of dust were seen in the top corner of WTC7 when it collapsed, even though these magical jets of dust went down with the building as opposed to hanging in the air.

Steven Jones claimed that fire fighters were able to hover their faces above a river of LIQUID STEEL.

Steven Jones claimed that concrete pulverization is proof of explosives... even though explosives don't pulverize concrete, especially when they aren't drilled into concrete.

Steven Jones claimed that tons of steel columns being thrown hundreds of feet could only have happened via the use of explosives. Tell me what kind of explosive powerful enough to throw tons of steel hundreds of feet and not deafen those within mere yards of the explosion?

Steven Jones dropped a concrete block 12 feet and thought he proved why there should be no pulverization in the collapse of a 110 story building.

Steven Jones claimed that a cut column at ground zero was proof of a controlled demolition even though we know for certain that these columns were cut in the cleanup operation.

I could probably go on for thousands more words, but I think I've made my point perfectly clear and you can not refute a single thing of what I've said.
 
Steven jones didn't even know how to operate a cigarette lighter,think about it, a science professor who didn't know how to flick a lighter!

 
I watched a couple of the segments on YouTube; I loved Janice McKinlay's picture of her "dust", showing it completely uncovered.
 
FANTASTIC video Cyclonic!! Especially when the firefighter picks up the "molten metal light source" (read: Halogen light) and moves it. That alone is PRICELESS!!
 
Steven jones didn't even know how to operate a cigarette lighter,think about it, a science professor who didn't know how to flick a lighter!

I like the "it's probably butane" line. Ya think? Not a Zippo there, Dr.Jones!
 
Jones presents the controversial new article in the peer-reviewed “Bentham Open Chemical Physics Journal” – the result of 18 months of intensive scientific collaboration – exposing “the loaded gun of 9/11”.

When did they switch they catch phrase from "smoking gun" to "loaded gun"?
 
Why on Earth would a quiet Mormon Physics professor want to invent an exotic explosive at the WTC if it were not true ? What possible point could there be to it ? He lost his job and has been castigated by the intelligentia for years now. Don't tell me- he is crazy too ?

That's the argumentum ad vericudinam fallacy, isn't it?

I neither know nor care why Jones tells lies. I only comment that he does. Insanity seems quite likely, though, because nobody with a decent education and basic intelligence could believe his fantasies without a considerable measure of self-delusion.

Dave
 
What claim? "Peer Review"? The publisher has no "peer review" process as it is known fo anyone with first-hand familiarity with the term. Letting the author pick the reviewers is not "peer review".

That's not evidence,that's just another unfounded claim.
 
OH poor twoof...

why would anyone want to waste $800 to debunk a craptacular journal (sham)?

I'd be embarassed to have ANY Bentham publication on my CV. (and I do have 3 peer reviewed journal articles on my CV... and I didn't have to pay for ANY of them...

Sunstealers critique is just as "peer reviewed" and accepted as anything from Bentham...

try again twoof.

When you continue to be this dishonest it's no wonder that JREF has become the laughingstock it is
 
hahahahahahaha

ROFLMAO.

Yes, Bentham KNEW it was a sham and was trying to "catch them."
ROFLMAO.

It was a nice attempt to cover up their SHAM.

Nice try twoof.
lithium bicarbonate is your friend. try again.

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not." "

so sorry there mr. lie, but you are wrong again
 
provide yours... those 1000 NSA agents... I still want to see that link
I could type "I want the link too." in a great big font but I'll refrain from doing that. Your requests for links is laughable SA because you never provided any link to the, supposedly, leaked article about the 1,000 paid shills.

This repeated and repeated dishonesty by every JREF "debunker" just show everyone else that JREF is not a place to come to get the truth.
 
Expecting a "legitimate rebuttal" to the thermite "paper" in the Bentham "journal", is kind of like expecting a "legitimate rebuttal" to your highschool science essay that postulated the same.

you cannot expect an answer when no one is listening.

TAM:)

More excuses for not having a legitemate rebuttal from your sad movement there eh TAM!
 
More excuses for not having a legitemate rebuttal from your sad movement there eh TAM!

Like I said, if no one in the legitimate scientific community even knows the paper exists, where am I to get a "legitimate rebuttal" to provide you? Am I a chemist, or a physicist? Am I a material scientist?

Are you stupid? I ask, because the above is so plain and simple, that for me to have to repeat it twice indicates you are either (A) simple, or (B) purposely ignorant.

Take your pick.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom