ElMondoHummus
0.25 short of being half-witted
are comments on published papers normally peer reviewed themselves? (like steve and bill imply?)
wouldnt this result in never ending peer review process?
No. They're not. The responses to Zdenek Bazant's work and his replies in turn demonstrates this. If I remember correctly, they appeared as letters to the editor of the journal he published in. I don't remember the link to this, so if someone else has it, feel free to post it.