New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

are comments on published papers normally peer reviewed themselves? (like steve and bill imply?)
wouldnt this result in never ending peer review process?

No. They're not. The responses to Zdenek Bazant's work and his replies in turn demonstrates this. If I remember correctly, they appeared as letters to the editor of the journal he published in. I don't remember the link to this, so if someone else has it, feel free to post it.
 
I'm still waiting for those links!!

beefhotlinks.jpg


Sorry...couldn't resist :)
 
Oh...so he didn't get his findings published! That's unfortunate. Seems if this is such a big thing he should send his research to a journal to have it peer reviewed and published so other scientists can see his findings and comment on it.

Otherwise it's just a forum posting that has zero relevance in the real world.

Hey if it's so easy to publish in these so-called "sham vanity journals" then sunstealer should have an easy time getting it accepted. Hey with all the JREF cult members here, if you each donated 5 bucks you could easily come up with the $800 to have it published in the same journal, and according to JREF you would not even have to worry about peer review.

OH poor twoof...

why would anyone want to waste $800 to debunk a craptacular journal (sham)?

I'd be embarassed to have ANY Bentham publication on my CV. (and I do have 3 peer reviewed journal articles on my CV... and I didn't have to pay for ANY of them...

Sunstealers critique is just as "peer reviewed" and accepted as anything from Bentham...

try again twoof.
 
You realize that bentham never published that fake article, they contacted the people who wrote that fake article in an attempt to find out exactly who they were. Seems like Bentham did a great job in preventing a fake article from being published.

A forum post is not a legitemate journal/publication of any kind, if the information he has is valid then it will stand up to peer review and get published and then stand up again to peer review from all the scientist that will then see his information.

The only reason to keep it hidden here on JREF is because he knows it will not be accepted, and better to pretend he doesn't have to have it published than to have to face rejection and all that means.

hahahahahahaha

ROFLMAO.

Yes, Bentham KNEW it was a sham and was trying to "catch them."
ROFLMAO.

It was a nice attempt to cover up their SHAM.

Nice try twoof.
lithium bicarbonate is your friend. try again.
 
I could type "I want the link too." in a great big font but I'll refrain from doing that. Your requests for links is laughable SA because you never provided any link to the, supposedly, leaked article about the 1,000 paid shills.
 
ROFL, you obviously missed reading the other thread where 20 or so JREF cult member did the exact same thing over and over and over and over again. LOL so you are making fun of your own cult members here.

Oh and BTW...

Where is that link? :)

The exact same thread where for over 15 pages you DIDN'T PROVIDE a citaiton to your claim.

I'm still waiting for YOU TO PROVIDE ONE.
 
Last edited:
Because there has been no legitemate rebuttal of the peer reviewed journal article that came forward with the findings

There was no legitimate paper published in a peer reviewed journal which shows that thermite was found.

So then there doesn't need to be a "peer reviewed" rebuttal of the crap that you twoofs try to sell.

Once you get into a REAL journal, then we can talk. I'm still waiting.
 
Please do not flood the forum with identical posts. If someone is flooding the forum this way, please don't flood it more by quoting it. Thank you.

Tricky
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
...

Steven E. Jones, Ph.D., Physics Professor Emeritus, Brigham Young University, brilliantly presents his carefully researched new discoveries made as he analyzed the dust from the World Trade Center high-rises on 9/11.

... “the loaded gun of 9/11”. The beauty of the photos and the depth of understanding are breathtaking.

...
You post fraud on sale for 21.65. A DVD of fiction with a delusional conclusion. Where is the Pulitzer Prize for Jone breaking the big "loaded gun"? You posted a joke when you need facts and evidence.

Jones, fired for making up lies about 911! He is not brilliant, he is a fallen physicist who makes up lies about 911 and you fall for his moronic rant.
 
Last edited:
Note the classic disinformation tactics used here. Bill commented on the anthrax as an example of grinding something down to the nanometer size (and also at the same time point out another flaw in the Official Conspiracy Theory with regards to anthrax). So dave takes this as his chance to purposely misrepresent what Bill has said so that dave can then insult/ridicule/smear



:)

Please explain how anthrax, a bacterium, is ground down to nanometer size. Be specific. The fact is that neither you nor Bill has any idea what he's talking about. This is, as we all know, quite typical for "Truthers".
 
Please explain how anthrax, a bacterium, is ground down to nanometer size. Be specific. The fact is that neither you nor Bill has any idea what he's talking about. This is, as we all know, quite typical for "Truthers".

i dont think they quite grasped the idea that anthrax is alive (and still on tour lol)
 
LOL if you could only hear me laugh when I am here reading JREF, but of course that would not fit in with your smear in saying i'm whining.

Maybe next time someone asks me for a link or for evidence I can do exactly what you have done here and say they are whining?? Yes?? No??

Do you laugh when you stop and realize how pathetic your movement is? How in nearly a decade you have been able to convince a few hundred young men, and a few hundred "nutty professors"? Do you laugh then?

Do you laugh when you realize that you could be at this all of the remaining days of your life, and you WILL NEVER get any further, convince no more then a handful of nuts, of your ridiculous theories?

Do you laugh then? No? That's ok, because at those times, I AM LAUGHING AT YOU, FOR YOU!

TAM:)
 
Expecting a "legitimate rebuttal" to the thermite "paper" in the Bentham "journal", is kind of like expecting a "legitimate rebuttal" to your highschool science essay that postulated the same.

you cannot expect an answer when no one is listening.

TAM:)
 
Since the chain of custody argument is often given, does this mean you guys think Jones and Harrit actually spiked the dust? This would be hard to believe; they may be wrong, they may be a bit crazy, but surely they are honest men, no?

In as much as Jones started from the lie that there was molten metal under the rubble pile, after hearing it from a Nazi, and since he allowed himself to be seen and photographed comparing notes with that same Nazi, I must say that their integrity is utterly in the toilet.
 
Please explain how anthrax, a bacterium, is ground down to nanometer size. Be specific. The fact is that neither you nor Bill has any idea what he's talking about. This is, as we all know, quite typical for "Truthers".

I haven't been following the "Anthrax" angle of this thread (I have bill on ignore still), but the above sounds quite silly.

nano particles of Bacillus anthracis would be a great first step in a vaccine, but it would be the exact opposite to what you would do if you wished to give people anthrax.

fact:

Bacillus anthracis are LARGE rods. they average 3-5 micrometers in length, and 1-1.2 micrometers in width. (1 micrometer = 1000 nanometers) so they are hardly nano themselves. once "ground" they are useless except, as I have said before, perhaps as a form of vaccination (though incredibly crude in this context as well).

As for how they would be "ground" into such, I would be very interested in hearing the details.

TAM:)
 
That is correct question.

When a paper is published in a peer-reviewed journal, that same journal often prints responses or comments in a "Letters" section. That section doesn't require peer-review (other than basic editorial review) and is typically provided free of charge by the journal.

What makes the Bentham journals even more of a joke than they are, is that when R.Mackey originally wrote a few comments against one of their papers and inquired about having those published as a rebuttal, they wanted to charge him the same $800 publishing fee as the original authors.

What rubbish.

No. They're not. The responses to Zdenek Bazant's work and his replies in turn demonstrates this. If I remember correctly, they appeared as letters to the editor of the journal he published in. I don't remember the link to this, so if someone else has it, feel free to post it.

ah thanks
thats what i thought
i have often seen truthers say (like someone did before) "why are there no peer reviewed rebuttals published"
it didnt make sense to me (seeing who said it, i wonder why it would :rolleyes) but i wasnt sure


thank you again
 
I haven't been following the "Anthrax" angle of this thread (I have bill on ignore still), but the above sounds quite silly.

nano particles of Bacillus anthracis would be a great first step in a vaccine, but it would be the exact opposite to what you would do if you wished to give people anthrax.

fact:

Bacillus anthracis are LARGE rods. they average 3-5 micrometers in length, and 1-1.2 micrometers in width. (1 micrometer = 1000 nanometers) so they are hardly nano themselves. once "ground" they are useless except, as I have said before, perhaps as a form of vaccination (though incredibly crude in this context as well).

As for how they would be "ground" into such, I would be very interested in hearing the details.

TAM:)
bill is comedy gold
like someone said before its like he just takes a whole mess of words and types them randomly
he might just be that monkey in the room full of a million monkeys
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom