New DVD – Steven Jones, PhD: “Nano-Thermite”

Please source your evidence for this claim

What claim? "Peer Review"? The publisher has no "peer review" process as it is known fo anyone with first-hand familiarity with the term. Letting the author pick the reviewers is not "peer review".
 
A DVD? Well this shows they really aren't interested in science, but propaganda.

What kind of scientist would prefer selling DVDs over proving their theory to the scientific community? Shameful, but not unexpected from them.

Yes, more of the unfounded and unsubstantiated smear jobs that is all too common here at JREF from the cult.

Tell me pardalis, how is making a DVD not proving their theories to the scientific community? Do the scientific community not have access to these DVD's? Or does the scientific community not have access to the already published findings? You will note that there still has not been any published article in any peer reviewed journal refuting of any of the peer reviewed and published articles from the 9/11 truth community (in this case Jones et al)
 
Yes, more of the unfounded and unsubstantiated smear jobs that is all too common here at JREF from the cult.

Tell me pardalis, how is making a DVD not proving their theories to the scientific community? Do the scientific community not have access to these DVD's? Or does the scientific community not have access to the already published findings? You will note that there still has not been any published article in any peer reviewed journal refuting of any of the peer reviewed and published articles from the 9/11 truth community (in this case Jones et al)
The correct process is to verify with the scientific community FIRST before publishing a DVD. They short circuited correct procedure.
 
You don't have to accept anything. You should, perhaps give him a little time before you outright whine about a "double standard"..he did say that the "proof" so to speak is "offline" rather than via "insta-googling".

TAM:)
Proof? He said it, so it is so!

What is that called? Fetzer, another original failed scholar for truth uses the same proof method. Say it is, and it is so.

The DVD, Another fraud and the failed movement faithful accept lies as their truth.
 
... they may be wrong, they may be a bit crazy, but surely they are honest men, no?

That right there requires a bit of analysis. For starters, you can indeed argue that Jones at least has attempted to argue scientifically and ascribe a modicum of honesty to that (I'll refrain from commenting on Harrit because I know next to nothing about him; Legge and the rest you can look up here on your own). He does work hard to bring a veneer of real empirical observation to his work, something rare in the extreme in conspiracy-favoring arguments. I wish we'd see more of that; what "scientific" work has been done has been beyond laughable. But on the other hand, he's been published in real journals before, and while there's nothing wrong with open source publication per se, there are clear issues with Bentham's rigor specifically. That's even been detailed here in this forum. And I find it hard to believe that he would be able to overlook that. He knows enough about legitimate publishing to understand the difference.

To me, questions about Jones and honesty come down to the details of his work. For starters, he full well realizes that his chosen method of spectroscopy - X-EDS - does not reveal bonding or structure, yet he continues to use that method of spectroscopy to buttress his work. Other methods exist that would provide structural information about the chips he's located, yet he's failed to resort to them. The cynical may infer that this is done in order to allow for obsfucation; the generous may argue that the explanation might be far more mundane, that he may simply have no access to alternate methods. Regardless, he draws conclusions from the spectroscopy that are unwarranted because they're based on information that cannot be drawn from that spectroscopy, but must be inferred from elsewhere; Sunstealer highlighted that in his rebuttals, and demonstrated the erroneous inferences. It wouldn't be so bad if those inferred presumptions were somewhat accurate, but they're not. And therein lies the problem.

Beyond that, there are other parts of the paper where conclusions were drawn that were unsupported by the actual work done. As an example, the elimination of paint as a candidate was conducted by soaking a chip (or several) in a solvent that does not dissolve all classes of paint. Granted, it dissolves a hell of a lot of them, but the point is that it's insufficient to account for all types. That right there is grade-school level lab work, and unworthy of a former professor from a well regarded university. And as other examples, you can do a search for "energetic nano" and "nanothermite" in this forum and see our previous critiques regarding his energy conclusions from his calorimeter experiements. It's questionable for him to classify the chips as thermite when the calorimetric experiments show energy readings completely inconsistent with that compound, but he does it anyway. And his handwave - I assert that it's nothing short of being a handwave - is that nanoprocessed thermite can release more energy in a more explosive manner. That still doesn't account for the fact that it's more energy than thermite is capable of releasing, but he further handwaves that away with the presence of the sol-gel adding extra energy... which means that he cannot separate the energy of the matrix from the reactive substance, and therefore cannot conclusively or even tentatively conclude that the energetics prove his assertion. And that to me smacks of dishonesty. But at the same time, I can't eliminate self-delusion, and a potential for desiring to be right and therefore fooling himself into believing his own arguments. So he might indeed be honest, but that still leaves him as being honestly wrong.

So, the question of honesty ends up being an uncomfortable one for conspiracy advocates. Either he is honestly delusional, and is stretching and misinterpreting his own data to fit his worldview, or he's dishonest, and full well knows that his conclusions are not supported by his evidence. Either way, he's wrong. And the question of his honesty is unfortunately a low bar; it's his claims that are important, whether honestly or deceptively forwarded. Those claims are demonstrably wrong, and in fact contradicted by what is known to be true about the collapses. He cannot argue thermite in the complete absence of any effects of thermite on the steel columns, and it does not matter how much publication and spectroscopic analysis he brings to bear. The veneer of respectability does not change the fact that the presumption is wrong at a fundamental level. And his honesty or lack of it doesn't mitigate the significance of that problem.
 
Ladies and gentlemen... the 2009 9/11 truth movement in all its intellectual glory.

ROFL..do you really want to go there? Ok, let's do it...

Steve, if you can't post a link to the story, could you maybe copy and paste it from your files? Thanks!
SteveAustin, I have cleared half an hour from my schedule this morning to review that article, could you please post the link before noon eastern time? Thanks in advance!
SteveAustin, you have said that the US gov't hired 1000 'disinfo agents' to argue the "Official Conspiracy Theory" on the internet, and that there was a 'leaked' story about it. Could you kindly post a link or source? Thanks!:)
In four pages since Steve claimed htere was a leaked article about 1000 disinfo agents hired by the US govt, I have yet to see a link to where this article is.


Why does it take four pages to do so?
YOU HAVE TOTALLY IGNORED EVERY SINGLE POST ASKING FOR THAT LINK, INCLUDING THE SURPRISINGLY SANE ADVICE FROM BILL SMITH THAT YOU POST IT.
Still no link from Steve Austin re the 1,000 paid shills. Why am I not surprised?
Yes Steve. We know of your derail. :words: But:

What. About. The. Link. For. The. 1000. paid. Shills.
Yes Steve. We know of your derail. :words: But:

What. About. The. Link. For. The. 1000. paid. Shills.

OMG.....:dl:

Thanks Zeus I wasn't drinking anything when I read this post....
Steve, I'm just going to remind you of your 1000 shills LINK, så that you don't forget it.
Which reminds me-

SteveAustin, have you got that link yet? If you don't have it, then just say so, and I will stop asking for it.
Still no link to the 1000 paid debunkers, huh?

Why am I not surprised.
1000 was the original number of internet revisionist (I guess that's the polite term for paid government shill/disinformation agent) that were hired to spout the Official Conspiracy Theory on the internet. I guess you did not see the story that was leaked a week or two ago on this did you?

wheres the story?
liar
you said it existed it dont
there was no "leak"
youve spun 10 pages trying to CYA
quite poorly at that
im tempted to use my ignore function for the 1st time

I could go on, and I skipped many of them, but you get the picture, so thank you for showing JREF in all it's intellectual glory
 
funny how the SA wants us to provide links yet he can't even do that himself. All of his links go to batcrap crazy idiots of the trooth movement,. which of course are filled with lies, ignorance, arguments from idiocy and stupidity

This is nothing more than an argument from incredulity
 
rebuttal to what? Your unfounded and unsourced claims? You need to at least source your claims before I need to have a rebuttal

Uh, the claim that the Jones paper has no public impact whatsoever and has been completely and utterly ignored by everyone oither than die hard truthers and debunkers out for a good laugh.

C'mon, that part of my post.

Now get to it, truther!
 
"Here’s the one we’ve been waiting for. Currently available only from AE911Truth.

Pre-order Now – Ships Aug 12th

...
This would be hard to believe; they may be wrong, they may be a bit crazy, but surely they are honest men, no?

Honest? No.

I came to debunking and JREF several years ago via USENET posts about "molten steel" at WTC. I was intrigued.

I was a witness to some of WTC. I know people that worked on the cleanup of the "pile" in the weeks after 9/11. I also have an engineering background sufficient to read and understand what people that know more than I do say. Literal "molten steel" in the pile was on the edge of plausibility and I was curios.

When I dug into the quotes and citations used to justify claims, I found rampant lying in the form of malicious cherry-picking of quotes of firemen while excising words that contradict Twoofer claims. Dozens of these are on the premier "peer reviewed" Truth Movement, http://www.journalof911studies.com/

I have since collected a long lost of faked images and video by the TM and complaints by people who have been mis-quoted by TM.

So much for intellectual honesty and "Peer Review" of the "Truth Movement".
 
steve you dont seem to understand the difference
you claimed that you read a "leaked" article about 1000 paid shills
we all went looking for it and got nothing
we then asked you to cite that article and again got nada

here people are commenting on an article that exists
people are giving their (well founded) opinions on it
hence youre reading the link (complete with links to similar discussions)
please feel free to post it when you find it fitting

you just got so hammered on something stupid that you typed over the last few days that youre foaming at the mouth to give some back (even when it doesnt apply)

pretty childish (esp to re "link please" to every post over 3 pages adding nothing)

bill if you ground yourself down would you have millions of nano-bills or would you just be dead?
use that gray matter before you type
 
Steve has made abundantly clear that he is only trolling here. Please don't feed the troll.
 
steve you dont seem to understand the difference
you claimed that you read a "leaked" article about 1000 paid shills
we all went looking for it and got nothing
we then asked you to cite that article and again got nada

here people are commenting on an article that exists
people are giving their (well founded) opinions on it
hence youre reading the link (complete with links to similar discussions)
please feel free to post it when you find it fitting

you just got so hammered on something stupid that you typed over the last few days that youre foaming at the mouth to give some back (even when it doesnt apply)

pretty childish (esp to re "link please" to every post over 3 pages adding nothing)

bill if you ground yourself down would you have millions of nano-bills or would you just be dead?
use that gray matter before you type

LOL very few of you even bothered to research it for yourselves, and even after the article that you claim still does not exist was linked you still all continued your rants.

In my case no one has yet linked their sources, unless you can scroll up and show me where they linked them
 
Honest? No.

I came to debunking and JREF several years ago via USENET posts about "molten steel" at WTC. I was intrigued.

I was a witness to some of WTC. I know people that worked on the cleanup of the "pile" in the weeks after 9/11. I also have an engineering background sufficient to read and understand what people that know more than I do say. Literal "molten steel" in the pile was on the edge of plausibility and I was curios.

When I dug into the quotes and citations used to justify claims, I found rampant lying in the form of malicious cherry-picking of quotes of firemen while excising words that contradict Twoofer claims. Dozens of these are on the premier "peer reviewed" Truth Movement, http://www.journalof911studies.com/

I have since collected a long lost of faked images and video by the TM and complaints by people who have been mis-quoted by TM.

So much for intellectual honesty and "Peer Review" of the "Truth Movement".

the misquotes, trick video edits, and faked pics were what really got me angry with the TM and started me down this road a few years ago

one that sticks out was when they took 3 quotes from 3 people and made it seem that one person said all three
when in context the original quotes hurt the TM's argument
 
Because there has been no legitemate rebuttal of the peer reviewed journal article that came forward with the findings

What do you consider legitimate ? and where is this peer reviewed paper ? You can't be talking about Bentham, can you ?
 
Last edited:
are comments on published papers normally peer reviewed themselves? (like steve and bill imply?)
wouldnt this result in never ending peer review process?
 
are comments on published papers normally peer reviewed themselves? (like steve and bill imply?)
wouldnt this result in never ending peer review process?


That is correct question.

When a paper is published in a peer-reviewed journal, that same journal often prints responses or comments in a "Letters" section. That section doesn't require peer-review (other than basic editorial review) and is typically provided free of charge by the journal.

What makes the Bentham journals even more of a joke than they are, is that when R.Mackey originally wrote a few comments against one of their papers and inquired about having those published as a rebuttal, they wanted to charge him the same $800 publishing fee as the original authors.

What rubbish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom