New Book on Pearl Harbor Puts Blame on Washington and Exonerates Kimmel

Given that all you've done is quote the Amazon reviews we might ask the same of you.

Given that in addition to attacking Pearl Harbour japan ALSO attacked the Phillipines (a US territory/protectorate/colony) and Guam (a US territory) how would the US have NOT ended up in a war with Japan?

A major reason for the success of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor was that almost everybody in the US Government expected that if Japan attacked, it would be in the Phillippines and Guam. No one though that Pearl Harbor would be the target of a large scale air attack. The most they expected at Pearl were Submarine attacks and possibly sabotage.
In the words of one US official at the time. "No One thought the Bastards would have the nerve to attack that far to the East".
 
A major reason for the success of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor was that almost everybody in the US Government expected that if Japan attacked, it would be in the Phillippines and Guam. No one though that Pearl Harbor would be the target of a large scale air attack. The most they expected at Pearl were Submarine attacks and possibly sabotage.
In the words of one US official at the time. "No One thought the Bastards would have the nerve to attack that far to the East".

Oh, really? This is another debunked myth.

In February of that year, Admiral Stark, the Chief of Naval Operations, endorsed a memo written by Admiral Richmond Kelly Turner that stated that if America and Japan became enemies "it is believed entirely possible that hostilities would be initiated by a surprise attack upon the Fleet or the Naval Base at Pearl Harbor." This was no low-level memo. Admiral Turner was the director of the Navy's War Plans Division, and he wrote the memo to the Secretary of War.i Admiral Turner's memo and Admiral Stark's endorsement of it refute the claim that no senior officials in Washington believed that the Japanese would attack Pearl Harbor.

By early October, FDR and other senior officials knew that the Japanese government had asked the Japanese consulate in Hawaii for the locations of all ships in Pearl Harbor and that the positions be plotted on a specific grid map. These were the famous "bomb plot messages." The Japanese did not ask for such information about any other American port. Military intelligence analysts in the Philippines recognized the bomb plot messages as an indication of an air attack on Pearl Harbor. However, senior Navy brass intervened to prevent Kimmel from being informed about the bomb plot messages.
 
Oh, really? This is another debunked myth.

In February of that year, Admiral Stark, the Chief of Naval Operations, endorsed a memo written by Admiral Richmond Kelly Turner that stated that if America and Japan became enemies "it is believed entirely possible that hostilities would be initiated by a surprise attack upon the Fleet or the Naval Base at Pearl Harbor." This was no low-level memo. Admiral Turner was the director of the Navy's War Plans Division, and he wrote the memo to the Secretary of War.i Admiral Turner's memo and Admiral Stark's endorsement of it refute the claim that no senior officials in Washington believed that the Japanese would attack Pearl Harbor.

By early October, FDR and other senior officials knew that the Japanese government had asked the Japanese consulate in Hawaii for the locations of all ships in Pearl Harbor and that the positions be plotted on a specific grid map. These were the famous "bomb plot messages." The Japanese did not ask for such information about any other American port. Military intelligence analysts in the Philippines recognized the bomb plot messages as an indication of an air attack on Pearl Harbor. However, senior Navy brass intervened to prevent Kimmel from being informed about the bomb plot messages.

"Possible that hostilities would be initiated" =\= "we think this is the most probable way that hostilities will be initiated"

In addition, we've been over the "bomb plot messages" before. They most certainly were NOT for determining the locations of the ships for the attack. At best the information would be a couple of days old - the windows of the attacking aircraft were a far more accurate method of target location. Any knowledge that the Japanese where figuring out what ships were in Pearl, would be an "and?" Collecting information on enemy, potential enemy or even friendly dispositions is what intelligence services do. What the Japanese found was that Kimmel was keeping regular hours for the fleet for the months leading up to the war, allowing them to plan their attack for a day when the largest number of capital ships would be in port.
 
Bobtaftfan,

The question has been asked several times: Did you youself read the book? From cover to cover? At first I was just curious and reasonably certain that you would quickly respond, "Of course." But your continued lack of a response really has me wondering. Have you read the book?
 
Last edited:
I thought I'd throw this into the mix and see what others think.

I was reading through some old books yesterday and found a book called "Secrets and Stories of the War" (actually, I think I might have posted about this once before, sorry if I have - I'll use advancing age as an excuse)

In this book I found a story called "Blueprint for Pearl Harbour" by Edwin Muller. As near as I can find out, Muller was a writer of WW2 history, and US Navy veteran of the Korean War.

I scanned the book and used an OCR to turn it into a PDF. Its worth a read; only three A4 pages so its well within the grasp of even those with the shortest of attention spans.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/9umr84slx9gu0uf/Blueprint for Pearl Harbour.pdf?dl=1
 
Bobtaftfan,

The question has been asked several times: Did you youself read the book? From cover to cover? At first I was just curious and reasonably certain that you would quickly respond, "Of course." But your continued lack of a response really has me wondering. Have you read the book?

I already said I read the book. You should have been able to deduce from my review that I read the book, including all the endnotes.

Tell me, do you think William Casey, a former CIA director and OSS veteran, was lying when he said the British warned us that Pearl Harbor would be attacked?

Do you think Victor Cavendish-Bentick, head of the British JIC, was lying when he said British Intelligence warned us that a Japanese fleet was heading toward Hawaii?

Do you think all the former British intelligence analysts and technicians, such as Burnett and Mortimer, who said they knew from Japanese intercepts that the Japanese were going to attack Pearl Harbor were all lying too?

Do you think the American intelligence officers and technicians who said we knew from Japanese intercepts that Pearl Harbor was a target were all lying too?

Do you think James Stahlman, Congressman Martin Dies, Joseph Leib, Helen Hamman, Colonel John Bissell, Deputy FBI Director D. M. Ladd, FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, Governor John Burns, William Kaina, Colonel Carlton Ketchum, General Wedemeyer, etc., etc., were all lying when they said that they and/or the government knew from various intelligence sources that Pearl Harbor would be attacked? ALL of them? If just *one* of these people was telling the truth, the traditional version is a myth.

You realize that some of these people, such as Ladd and Hoover, put this information in writing in secret memos that were never intended for public release, right? Were Ladd and Hoover playing some kind of weird practical joke on the White House? Was Bissell?
 
Last edited:
Do you think that forward bases that are accessible are potential targets?

Do you think that a senior commander needs to be told that keeping to regular timings makes your military assets vulnerable?
 
I already said I read the book. You should have been able to deduce from my review that I read the book, including all the endnotes.
...[snipped all the portions that had nothing to do with my post- I refer you to the other posters here who have addressed those points better than I can]

How amusing! Do you really think that everyone who writes a review of a book actually read it? Your own review could easily have represented a compilation of what you read in other reviews and summaries.

And no- I've carefully checked this thread three times now: you never stated that you read the book. Not once. I guess you imagined that you had. If anything you appeared to go out of your way to not address the question of whether you read the book or not. And other posters here were left with the same impression. But okay- you at last answered my question. You say you read it. Good.
 
Last edited:
...deleted....

So, Bob tsk tsk, you really don't want to discuss the new book you 're just trying to use it to start yet another exceedingly boring session going thru your failed ideas once again.

Why would you think anyone would want to do that - again? How many times do you feel people would be interested enough in what you think to go over it all again?

Yawn

Edited to add:

Here is a bright fellow who thinks the British planned and directed the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour - now that is a guy you could have an enlightened conversation with!

http://www.reformation.org/british-attack-on-pearl-harbor.html
 
Last edited:
Of course Pearl Harbour was a target. That was obvious.
Knowing it was a target why didn't the local commanders take more precautions?

Do you think that if Pearl had been warned and was able to mount a proper defence and maybe even a counter attack against the Japanese fleet that war couldn't be declared?

Why does it need all the secret conspiracy crap around it?
 
...deleted rational and logical comments....

Why does it need all the secret conspiracy crap around it?

..because Bob has devoted his life to this subject and without that conspiracy idea what else would he do with his time?

I mean the Japanese had sent a declaration of war to the US so even if whales had eaten the Japanese fleet they would have still been at war!

Bob lives in a confused and oddly colored world.
 
further to posts #46 and #47

Do you think it was wise for local commanders to park their aircraft wingtip to wingtip on the flight lines at Hickam making them easy to strafe given that Pearl Harbour was a likely target at a time when belligerency with Japan was ramping up.

Kimmel and others acted stupidly. Even if they didn't know of any specific threat, doing what they did made their charges dangerously exposed and vulnerable.
 
further to posts #46 and #47

Do you think it was wise for local commanders to park their aircraft wingtip to wingtip on the flight lines at Hickam making them easy to strafe given that Pearl Harbour was a likely target at a time when belligerency with Japan was ramping up.

Kimmel and others acted stupidly. Even if they didn't know of any specific threat, doing what they did made their charges dangerously exposed and vulnerable.

They were worried about saboteurs getting at the aircraft if they were dispersed so had them all grouped in lines in the centre of the field where they could be guarded at night.
 
..because Bob has devoted his life to this subject and without that conspiracy idea what else would he do with his time?

I mean the Japanese had sent a declaration of war to the US so even if whales had eaten the Japanese fleet they would have still been at war!

Bob lives in a confused and oddly colored world.

That's the thing that has always confounded me about this conspiracy theory. Had we been well prepared for the attack on Pearl Harbor... we still would've been attacked. War would still have happened only we'd have been in a much better position. No one *knew* that carrier air power was going to be so dominant at that point. Letting the bulk of the Pacific Fleet be destroyed before the war even started would be a terrible strategy.
 
Last edited:
They were worried about saboteurs getting at the aircraft if they were dispersed so had them all grouped in lines in the centre of the field where they could be guarded at night.

Yes, I am aware of that (flawed) strategy. However, when the threat level is high, you spread your assets out, and you put more of your airmen/soldiers/sailors on guard duty to guard those assets.
 
That's the thing that has always confounded me about this conspiracy theory. Had we been well prepared for the attack on Pearl Harbor... we still would've been attacked. War would still have happened only we'd have been in a much better position. No one *knew* that carrier air power was going to be so dominant at that point. Letting the bulk of the Pacific Fleet be destroyed before the war even started would be a terrible strategy.

I'd say we'd only have been in a somewhat better position. We'd probably have two or three more obsolete battleships available. And a couple of cruisers. And some more aircraft on Oahu, where they weren't going to be doing any more fighting anyhow. The Japanese would have a few less naval aircraft, but it's unlikely we'd have found their carriers. And it wouldn't have gone well if we had.
 
I have not nor will I read this book, as the author has his wallet in mind more than finding the real causes of the incident. From all the programs I have watched there is plenty of blame to spread to all parties including Washington DC and the commanders in Hawaii. The military up to the Korean conflict were always fighting the "last war" and perhaps this is still the mantra that the military still lives, although it would be nice if they were far sighted enough to fight the next war.
That being said, the Navy did not believe that a torpedo attack was possible in the shallow waters so torpedo nets were not employed by the fleet while in port, who made the decision? The commanders.
As smartcooky has noted the air corps had the flight line lined up wingtip to wingtip, just as the French and British in the begging of the European part of the war. Did they learn a lesson or were they protecting just from saboteurs?

Did the commanders in Washington share all the knowledge with those local commanders, NO.
Seems like a perfect storm against the US military versus the Japanese without a change of outcome other than the fleet may have been destroyed and unusable in deeper waters

So I err on the side that the local commanders were rightfully punished, but really overly punished.
 
That's the thing that has always confounded me about this conspiracy theory. Had we been well prepared for the attack on Pearl Harbor... we still would've been attacked. War would still have happened only we'd have been in a much better position. No one *knew* that carrier air power was going to be so dominant at that point. Letting the bulk of the Pacific Fleet be destroyed before the war even started would be a terrible strategy.

You are correct. Even if Pearl Harbour had been utterly foiled, the Japanese had delivered a formal Declaration of War. It beggars belief what more was needed.
 
I'd say we'd only have been in a somewhat better position. We'd probably have two or three more obsolete battleships available. And a couple of cruisers. And some more aircraft on Oahu, where they weren't going to be doing any more fighting anyhow. The Japanese would have a few less naval aircraft, but it's unlikely we'd have found their carriers. And it wouldn't have gone well if we had.

The Japanese might have been motivated to risk the second attack which they decided not to use.
 
The Japanese might have been motivated to risk the second attack which they decided not to use.

Err, I'm sure you didn't mean that. The Japanese attacked in two waves,

1st Wave TOT 7:53 am: 88 Kate Bombers, 48 Val dive bombers, 41 Zeros

2nd wave TOT 8:06am: 54 Kate Bombers, 75 dive bombers, 35 Zeros

It was the third wave that they abandoned.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom