New Book on Pearl Harbor Puts Blame on Washington and Exonerates Kimmel

In addition if the Japanese hadn't attack PH the war would still have begun as they attack Guam, US forces in China and Philippines

This is a point that Mr. Taftfan has ignored in favour of excoriating FDR. Unless of course he actually believes that the US should not have responded to attacks on its territories.
 
Perhaps a bit off-topic, but it's always seemed a bit odd to me that Kimmel and Short were fired after being hit by a surprise attack while MacArthur was caught with his pants down in the Philippines when he already knew about the Pearl Harbor raid.

MacArthur had a better PR team...
 
You might read the book first, before you comment on it. I find that's the best way to comment intelligently and credibly about a book--read it first.
FYI, Summers and Swan thoroughly document that FDR was scheming and lying all over the place to get us into the war.

I will rely on the other posters here to response to your views on the actual facts- they are far more expert than am I. But I could not help but notice that you never claim to have read the book yourself. Your OP in fact refers to statements by reviewers. Did you follow your own advice before starting or continuing this thread?
 
Last edited:
This is a point that Mr. Taftfan has ignored in favour of excoriating FDR. Unless of course he actually believes that the US should not have responded to attacks on its territories.

My father who was in the Army at the time of the Pearl Harbour attack (he got married on Sunday December 7th) thought an attack on US forces in the Philippines would be the starting point of the war. Although he also thought the Japanese would be 'smart' and attack only the Brits and Dutch and by-pass the Americans.
 
Oh, so quoting a review is not good for you huh? He read it didn't he?

Okay straight question since you have read it - does it support your conspiracy theory - yes or no? Ie he deliberately allowed the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor and he knew they would do it but he did not inform the commander?

Please quote to us the page and paragraph where Summers and Swan state that.

Can you do that?

Additionally tell us why the guy who did the review said this:

I mean this guy read it why don't you believe what he wrote?.......lol

Is the book out of your price range or something? Or do you just not care enough to read it yourself?

If you ever do get around to reading the book, you'll see that the book seems to be of two minds on the subject of conspiracy. On the one hand, Summers and Swan allow that there might have been a conspiracy, and they present evidence that vital intel was purposely withheld from Hawaii. On the other hand, they state that they favor the non-conspiracy position and that no evidence has surfaced of conspiracy, even though they quote such evidence. The text and the endnotes almost seem to have been written by different authors.

Here is my Amazon.com review of the book:

This book powerfully and persuasively exonerates Admiral Kimmel. It exposes the shameful efforts of FDR and senior military brass in Washington to falsely and unjustly place all the blame on Admiral Kimmel and General Short. It also exposes the massive cover-up that kicked into gear to keep the American people from knowing just how much advance knowledge arrived in Washington before the attack. Summers and Swan refute every traditionalist attack on Kimmel and Short.

Surprisingly, however, Summers and Swan opine that no one in Washington purposely withheld vital intelligence from Kimmel and Short, although they allow that this might have occurred, and even though they cite evidence that this occurred.
...​


https://www.amazon.com/Matter-Honor-Betrayal-Familys-Justice/dp/0062405519


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rule 4. Do not quote large tracts of text available elsewhere on the web, even if you're the author.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
deleted a lot of 'stuff'

Back to my questions:

I wrote: Okay straight question since you have read it - does it support your conspiracy theory - yes or no? Ie he deliberately allowed the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor and he knew they would do it but he did not inform the commander?

Your answer hidden under a great deal of waffling and evasion: NO it does not

Please quote to us the page and paragraph where Summers and Swan state that.

Can you do that?

Nope you cannot.

Yawn

Just to give you another chance: Can you quote the authors stating that the President deliberately did not inform PH that an attack was coming as part of conspiracy to get the US into the war?
 
Last edited:
Back to my questions:

Your answer hidden under a great deal of waffling and evasion: NO it does not

Nope you cannot.

Yawn

Just to give you another chance: Can you quote the authors stating that the President deliberately did not inform PH that an attack was coming as part of conspiracy to get the US into the war?

That's all you have to say in answer to my response and review? More of your simplistic all-or-nothing posturing?

There is a reason that so many traditionalists are railing against the book as "revisionist nonsense." Perhaps because Summers and Swan do not rule out conspiracy, even though they say they see the non-conspiracy position as more likely? Perhaps because they present considerable evidence of conspiracy, seemingly approvingly, in spite of their stated position on the issue?

Finally, would you care to take a stab at dealing with the evidence of conspiracy that I discuss in my review?
 
So, still no the President didn't deliberately withhold information to get the US in to the war.

It's a stupid idea anyway. Even if the attacking force had been detected it would still have led to a war.
 
That's all you have to say in answer to my response and review? More of your simplistic all-or-nothing posturing?

There is a reason that so many traditionalists are railing against the book as "revisionist nonsense." Perhaps because Summers and Swan do not rule out conspiracy, even though they say they see the non-conspiracy position as more likely? Perhaps because they present considerable evidence of conspiracy, seemingly approvingly, in spite of their stated position on the issue?

Finally, would you care to take a stab at dealing with the evidence of conspiracy that I discuss in my review?

So again your answer is again, 'No I am wrong but I won't admit it'. Yes Bob but we already knew that.

This has to be one of your more amusing stances - like your laugh at loud moment when you declare it was impossible for ships to keep station without radio communications - yeah all those 16-19th century fleets were just faking it.....I digress.

I've asked you twice to quote the part where those fine authors agreed with your conspiracy, you know 'Bobtaftan is right about the Pres forcing us into a war' or something like that? They didn't now did they? lol
 
Last edited:
So, still no the President didn't deliberately withhold information to get the US in to the war.

It's a stupid idea anyway. Even if the attacking force had been detected it would still have led to a war.

Not in Bobworld. In Bob's view the war wouldn't have happened if the Americans had been ready....or something equally silly.
 
So, still no the President didn't deliberately withhold information to get the US in to the war.

It's a stupid idea anyway. Even if the attacking force had been detected it would still have led to a war.

We have several anecdotal accounts that FDR believed that only an attack on American soil/territory, an attack with more than just a few casualties, would spur the people to support entering the war. After all, there had been incidents where the Japanese had fired on American ships in China, and the pro-FDR press had concocted a story about a German naval vessel firing on an American ship--but none of these had prompted any substantive change in the people's anti-interventionist sentiment.

But did you just say it's a stupid idea that a president would lie and withhold information to get us into a war? Did you really just say that? I take it you've read nothing about how the Bush administration lied and withheld information from the American people to drag us into the Iraq War? Let's see: How many books have documented how the Bush people suppressed intelligence analyses that debunked the claim that Saddam had nukes? How many books have documented how the Bush people grossly exaggerated what little evidence they had? How many documentaries and book have been done on how much myth and half-truths were fed to Colin Powell for his now infamous UN speech that laid out the case for WMDs in Iraq? Did you somehow miss all this?

Or, can you say "Gulf of Tonkin"?

I guess it's comforting for you folks to live in this fantasy world where government leaders never tell big lies and never falsely drag the country into terribly misguided actions. I wish it were true too.

One of the reasons that traditionalists are not happy about Summers and Swan's book is that it documents that FDR and other senior officials lied through their teeth to scapegoat Kimmel and Short and to conceal from the American people just how much advance knowledge arrived in Washington before the attack and how much of that information was never relayed to Kimmel and Short.
 
Last edited:
I said allowing the attack on Pearl Harbour was a stupid idea.
Do you think that having the defences ready and meeting the attack as it flew in wouldn't have resulted in a declaration of war?

Many hundreds of Japanese aircraft attacking and being met by alerted defences would have had the same result.
As would the invasion of US territories in the Pacific.

To be honest I think you are as deluded as the 9/11 Truthers.
 
Firstly, if FDR wanted an excuse to enter the European War on the side of England against Germany, he already had ample justification for doing so long before December 7, 1941 (see the extensive list of German attacks on US shipping and personnel listed by PhantomWolf in post #18). I note that bobtaftfan has still failed to address these issues in any meaningful way.

Secondly, how does "encouraging" Japan to attack Pearl Harbour help his cause? There was no guarantee that Hitler would declare war on the USA. In fact there was a very real fear in England that he might not do so, instead preferring leave England in the problematic position to have to fight two parallel and disconnected wars, one in Europe and another in Asia-Pacific. Its a common misconception that Hitler was bound under the terms of the Tri-Partite pact to declare war after Pearl Harbour - this simply is not true. The terms of that pact specifically required Germany to come to the aid of Japan only if they were attacked by a third country, not if Japan attacked a third country. Von Ribbentrop tried to remind Hitler of this fact but his counsel was spurned and Hitler, without further consultation, declared war against the US.

That Hitler did actually declare war on the USA shows just how bat-crap crazy he was.
 
Last edited:
Is the book out of your price range or something? Or do you just not care enough to read it yourself?

Given that all you've done is quote the Amazon reviews we might ask the same of you.

Given that in addition to attacking Pearl Harbour japan ALSO attacked the Phillipines (a US territory/protectorate/colony) and Guam (a US territory) how would the US have NOT ended up in a war with Japan?
 
New Book on Pearl Harbor Puts Blame on Washington and Exonerates Kimmel !!!!


About time too (well, actually way past it!!!)!!!
 
Given that all you've done is quote the Amazon reviews we might ask the same of you.

Given that in addition to attacking Pearl Harbour japan ALSO attacked the Phillipines (a US territory/protectorate/colony) and Guam (a US territory) how would the US have NOT ended up in a war with Japan?

His own Amazon review was the bestus though!
 
Regarding Hitler and Pearl Harbour. Hitler had been telling the Japanese for months before Pearl Harbour, (Since early Spring in fact, 1941), that if Japan attacked the US he would declare war on the United States.

Hitler appears to have seriously over estimated the economic etc., strength of Japan and to have underestimated the strength of the USA. In 1941 the USA's economic strength was about 10 times that of Japan.

Hitler wanted the Japanese Navy involved in his war and felt that war with the USA was a price worth paying. Why? Hitler felt by early 1941 that the lack of a big surface Navy was hampering his plans, and further that creating one would take years if not decades and take huge resources from prosecuting the war in the air and on land, while he was still fighting the Soviet Union. So if Hitler could not get his own large surface Navy the Japanese Navy would have to do.

So Hitler was encouraging the Japanese to attack the British and Dutch etc., along with the Americans by the spring of 1941.

The Japanese had apparently decided to "move south" in the spring of 1941. Apparently there was a dispute in the Japanese leadership about whether or not this would involve an attack on the USA. Many in Japan arguing that it would be insane to leave American bases in Guam and the Philippines alone when the Americans could attack them in the flank of their attacks on the British and Dutch colonies. Further many in Japan doubted that even if they did not attack the Americans, that the Americans would simply stand by while they invaded the Dutch and British colonies.

A step towards this southern advance was the Japanese occupation of French Indochina, which the Americans responded to by imposing a oil and scrap metal embargo. Joined in by the British and Dutch. This convinced the Japanese leadership that America would definitely not sit by while the Japanese invaded British and Dutch colonies. Only a few in the Japanese government thought that the whole southern advance idea should be abandoned. Far too many in Japanese government underestimated the Americans and thought they didn't have the stamina for "real" war.

Japanese officials told the Hitler zero about the forthcoming attack but at the time Hitler was apparently ecstatic and had no problems with declaring war on the USA.

We all know how this all turned out. Pearl Harbour decided the war by bringing in on the Allied side the greatest industrial power on the planet. It turned out to be a catastrophic mistake for Nazi Germany and Japan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom