Never Mind What We Said. That Was Then. This Is Now.

Absent a quote from the letter, we can't really tell whether or not their criteria is reasonable or unreasonable.
Well, then. Let's look.

Dear Mr. President:

We look forward to working with you as you consider nominees for the federal judiciary. Unfortunately, the judicial appointments process has become needlessly acrimonious. We would very much like to improve this process, and we know you would as well. It is in that spirit that we write early on to suggest two steps your Administration can take to achieve that shared goal.

First, in the beginning of his Administration, your predecessor demonstrated his desire to improve the judicial confirmation process by nominating to the circuit courts two of President Clinton’s previous judicial nominees, Judge Barrington Parker to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, and Judge Roger Gregory to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. It would help change the tone in Washington if your Administration would take the same bipartisan step. Because the last Congress sadly set the modern record for the fewest circuit court confirmations in a President’s final Congress, there are plenty of well-qualified nominees with bipartisan support from whom to choose. For example, Peter Keisler has been praised repeatedly by colleagues in both the public and private sector, Democrats and Republicans, and has earned accolades from major media observers, like The Washington Post. And Judges Glen Conrad and Paul Diamond both enjoyed bipartisan support and have outstanding records on the federal trial bench.

Second, as our Democratic colleagues have emphasized for the last several years, the process of federal appointments is a shared constitutional responsibility. We respect your responsibility to nominate suitable candidates for the federal bench. And as a former colleague, we know you appreciate the Senate’s unique constitutional responsibility to provide or withhold its Advice and Consent on nominations. The principle of senatorial consultation (or senatorial courtesy) is rooted in this special responsibility, and its application dates to the Administration of George Washington. Democrats and Republicans have acknowledged the importance of maintaining this principle, which allows individual senators to provide valuable insights into their constituents’ qualifications for federal service.

We hope your Administration will consult with us as it considers possible nominations to the federal courts from our states. Regretfully, if we are not consulted on, and approve of, a nominee from our states, the Republican Conference will be unable to support moving forward on that nominee. Despite press reports that the Chairman of the Judiciary Committee now may be considering changing the Committee’s practice of observing senatorial courtesy, we, as a Conference, expect it to be observed, even-handedly and regardless of party affiliation. And we will act to preserve this principle and the rights of our colleagues if it is not.

Because of the profound impact that life-tenured federal judges can have in our society, the Founders made their appointment a shared constitutional responsibility. We look forward to working with you to discharge this important duty in the best interest of our country.


Sincerely,
All Republican Senators

eta: I see that the Republicans not only have a renewed appreciation of the filibuster, but also of balance of powers. Never mind what they said. That was then. This is now.
 
Last edited:
Well, between Bush and Bush, with some help from Clinton, the court has been moved so far into a pro-big-business, anti-civil-rights direction that I hope Obama takes major steps to deal with it.

Maybe banks ought to be nonprofit public service institutions.
 
There were more than just vocal against filibusters. They talked about ending filibusters. They even gave it a name: The Nuclear Option. But, as Beeps said: Nevermind what we said. That was then. This is now.

As long as Democrats don't resurrect the "Nuclear Option" threat, republicans will be the ones to have lost face.
 
March 13, 2009:
I submit that filibuster is appropriate any time the minority party is strongly opposed to the majority's proposed action. I may agree or disagree with the position, but filibuster is not inappropriate. Shooting up the Senate with machine guns would be inappropriate. Filibuster is an entirely legal tool.

May 17, 2005:
Kill the filibuster.

If your party is so out of touch nationwide with the electorate that it has lost both the presidency and both houses of congress, then it's the height of arrogance to claim that the majority party is somehow "out of the mainstream." If you were in the mainstream, you would control congress and the presidency.

And this will still be true twenty years from now, when the Democrats hold the presidency and both houses of congress.

Are you conservatives calling for the end of fillibusters entirely, or for just judicial nominations?
I generally hold to the principle that a bad idea is a bad idea, period, and a good idea is a good idea, period (note, I said generally). If term limits is a good idea for the president, why is it a bad idea for congress?

My inclination would be to abolish it altogether, and I wonder if this country would be significantly different if there had never been any such thing.

By the same token, I note that the Dems are using it strictly against federal judges, from which pool future Supreme Court justices will someday emerge. This strikes me as a transparent attempt, having lost every other branch of the government, to control that one part that they haven't lost. "Even if we can't win the presidency, we can make sure the future Supreme Court is to our liking." They started this strategy of demonizing nominations they don't like with the Supreme Court nominations of Robert Bork and Clarence Thomas (50% success rate), and are now trying to move it lower down the hierarchy.

Here's a strategy the Dems might try: Win back the presidency and/or congress. Then you can get whatever judges you want.

BTW: I thought a filibuster amounted to a senator (or group of senators) holding the debate floor and stopping all other Senate business. But that doesn't seem to be going on here; the Dems are simply threatening a filibuster. I don't understand why Frist doesn't call their bluff and treat the nation to the spectacle of watching the Democrats spending 57 days holding up the nation's business while trying to make their case.

So, rhoadp, the answer to your question is a firm, resounding, "I'm not sure..."

Never mind what he said. That was then. This is now.

(Or did your statements have expiration dates that were ironically less than the 20 years you said it would be true?)
 
Last edited:
Speaking of reading comprehension problems: Please show where the article says the Republicans threaten to filibuster "whoever he nominates."
According to the article:

Senate Republicans are not waiting to evaluate Mr. Obama’s nominations on their merits ... A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that a particular nominee would be a dangerous addition to the bench. The Republicans’ rush to threaten filibusters in the absence of actual nominees is not only at odds with their previous views on the subject, but shows a lack of respect for the confirmation process.​

Hence, according to the article, they are not presently threatening to oppose any nominee in particular; they are threatening to oppose nominees in general.

In the first instance, the Times went farther - much farther - than to argue the filibuster should not be abolished. They hailed the filibuster as a time-honored procedure and argued that the Democrats were justified in using it to block appointments they didn't like.

If it's so "time-honored," then what makes its use inappropriate today?
They explicitly say that it isn't inappropriate today. They actually use the frickin' word "appropriate" to describe it:

A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that a particular nominee would be a dangerous addition to the bench.​

What they seem to object to is that the threat to filibuster is coming before there are "particular nominees". And, please note, the remedy that they suggest is not that the filibuster should be abolished, which was what they criticized in the first article you pointed to.

I don't see that either article, or both taken together, can justify the apparent torsion of your undergarments.
 
I see that the Republicans not only have a renewed appreciation of the filibuster, but also of balance of powers. Never mind what they said. That was then. This is now.

Indeed there is irony here. You can readily see it when republicans flip-flop (and yes, they did), but you seemed strangely resistant to acknowledging that the NYT flip-flopped too. But aside from the irony of the republicans' change in positions, I'm not seeing much to really object to within the letter itself. I don't see anything in the content to support your earlier charges of inappropriateness.
 
Indeed there is irony here. You can readily see it when republicans flip-flop (and yes, they did), but you seemed strangely resistant to acknowledging that the NYT flip-flopped too.
Well, where did they?

But aside from the irony of the republicans' change in positions, I'm not seeing much to really object to within the letter itself. I don't see anything in the content to support your earlier charges of inappropriateness.
If that's all the Times is going on, then they have indeed exaggerated the situation. That is an "intemperate letter"? Good grief. Are the Republicans using some sort of intemperate code whereof I wot not?
 
Well, then. Let's look.



eta: I see that the Republicans not only have a renewed appreciation of the filibuster, but also of balance of powers. Never mind what they said. That was then. This is now.

I think this letter throws considerable insight on the controversy. If I understand their objection, it is that there has evolved the tradition to consult with the senators from the nominee's home state when someone is chosen for the federal bench. IF Bush and prior presidents honored this precedent and IF Obama was planning on changing it, I think the Republican Senators have a legitimate beef, one worthy of threatening to place a hold on any nominee that is chosen through a new system imposed on the Republicans without their agreement. Obama should not unilaterally try to change the way the nomination process works, or if he does he should be prepared to suffer the consequences.

If, on the other hand, Obama nominates judges as his predecessors did, then I think he deserves to have them judged by the same rules that the Democrats used. That is, reasonable judges should be approved even it their judicial philosophy does not conform 100% to that of the Republican party, and extreme candidates should be filibustered or blocked from coming to a vote.
 
Last edited:
The Republicans use filibusters to block good legislation. Democrats use them to block bad legislation. That's the difference.
 
Discussion on Senate representation split to new thread.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom