Never Mind What We Said. That Was Then. This Is Now.

BPSCG

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Mar 27, 2002
Messages
17,539
The New York Times then - March 6, 2005:
The White House's insistence on choosing only far-right judicial nominees has already damaged the federal courts. Now it threatens to do grave harm to the Senate. If Republicans fulfill their threat to overturn the historic role of the filibuster in order to ram the Bush administration's nominees through, they will be inviting all-out warfare and perhaps an effective shutdown of Congress. The Republicans are claiming that 51 votes should be enough to win confirmation of the White House's judicial nominees. This flies in the face of Senate history.

(...snip...)

The Senate has confirmed the vast majority of President Bush's choices. But Democrats have rightly balked at a handful.

(...snip...)

To block the nominees, the Democrats' weapon of choice has been the filibuster, a time-honored Senate procedure that prevents a bare majority of senators from running roughshod. Republican leaders now claim that judicial nominees are entitled to an up-or-down vote. This is rank hypocrisy.
Filibusters have a "historic role." Eliminating them would "fly in the face of Senate history." They are "a time-honored Senate procedure."

That was then.

The New York Times now- March 8, 2009
Now that President Obama is preparing to fill vacancies on federal benches, Republican senators have fired off an intemperate letter threatening — you got it — filibusters if Mr. Obama’s nominees are not to their liking. Mr. Obama should not let the Republicans’ saber-rattling interfere with how he chooses judges.
This is now. Now, filibusters are "intemperate." Now, threatening to use them is "saber-rattling."

If you're wondering if The New York Times reads its own editorials, don't worry - they have that covered:
A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that a particular nominee would be a dangerous addition to the bench...Mr. Obama may be tempted to give in to win Republican cooperation for other parts of his legislative agenda. He should resist that temptation, and get to work right away appointing the kind of highly qualified, progressive-minded judges the nation needs.
Ah, now I understand. A filibuster is good if it blocks "a dangerous addition to the bench" i.e., a conservative. It's bad if it blocks "kind of highly qualified, progressive-minded judges the nation needs, i.e., a liberal."

Or, as someone once put it, the end justifies the means.
 
There is a middle ground there - namely, that if Obama appoints moderate (that is "centrist", a term I can't really define to my liking, but seems to have a common understanding), and the Republicans hissyfit, the new editorial isnt' bad.

It changes depending on the judge of course, but there is such a thing as an excluded middle.
 
Yes, you are correct, Beeps: The editorial staff of the NYT has opinions and they write about them. You were right to start a thread to bring this to our attention.

Thank you.



eta: Incidentally, I'm curious if you have investigated the GOP's position on filibusters then and now? I seem to remember them saying that potential nominees deserve an up or down vote to the point of changing the filibuster rules to allow that to happen. Do they still feel the same way?
 
Last edited:
Yes, you are correct, Beeps: The editorial staff of the NYT has opinions and they write about them. You were right to start a thread to bring this to our attention.

Thank you.
You are very welcome! :biggrin:

Since these two opinions seem to contradict each other, do you think one of them is right and the other is wrong?

Or do you think "A" and "Not A" can both be true at the same time?

BPSCG said:
eta: Incidentally, I'm curious if you have investigated the GOP's position on filibusters then and now? I seem to remember them saying that potential nominees deserve an up or down vote to the point of changing the filibuster rules to allow that to happen. Do they still feel the same way?
I think the Repubs are already on record as favoring the filibuster when Bill Clinton was president, opposing them when Bush was president, and favoring them once again today.

But they're Republicans. We all know they're stupid, evil, venal, corrupt, superstitious religious zealots.

What's The New York Times's excuse?
 
Last edited:
I think the Repubs are already on record as favoring the filibuster when Bill Clinton was president, opposing them when Bush was president, and favoring them once again today.
What is the Democrats' position?


eta:
What's The New York Times's excuse?
Who cares? It's an editorial. Does it effect their news reporting?
 
Last edited:
BPSCG said:
What's The New York Times's excuse?
Who cares? It's an editorial.
So:

  • Do you think the Times was right when they were for filibusters in 2005, and wrong to oppose them today?
  • Or do you think the Times was wrong when they were for filibusters in 2005, and right to oppose them today?
  • Or do you think they were right both times?
  • Or do you think they were wrong both times?
Should be an easy choice to make, I would think.
 
I don't have an opinion on the use of the filibuster, in general. It's a tool and, like most tools, what matters is not the tool itself, but how it is used. A gun can be used to gather food to feed a family or murder a grandmother. As with most things, context is everything.

What I do object to was the Republicans' threat to remove the ability to filibuster from the rule book. That was wrong on many levels.

Personally, I think we need a more progressive Supreme Court that will put the kabash on this anti-gay marriage law lunacy and maintain a woman's right to choose for herself whether or not to have an abortion.

Your choices are an exercise in fallacy of the excluded middle, like Rika said. None of your options reflect my opinion of the matter.
 
I don't have an opinion on the use of the filibuster, in general. It's a tool and, like most tools, what matters is not the tool itself, but how it is used. A gun can be used to gather food to feed a family or murder a grandmother. As with most things, context is everything.

What I do object to was the Republicans' threat to remove the ability to filibuster from the rule book. That was wrong on many levels.
So you approve of the filibuster being used, as long as it comports with your views. If it does not, you still approve of principle of the filibuster's continued existence, just not the principle of its being used.

That's a very strange position.

Personally, I think we need a more progressive Supreme Court that will put the kabash on this anti-gay marriage law lunacy and maintain a woman's right to choose for herself whether or not to have an abortion.

Your choices are an exercise in fallacy of the excluded middle, like Rika said. None of your options reflect my opinion of the matter.
That's not correct. It appears you liked the first option - filibusters against Bush = bad, filibusters against Obama = good.

Your position appears to be, "I think the filibuster is an important tool for the Senate to have, but only the Democrats should use it." Or have I mistated your position?
 
So you approve of the filibuster being used, as long as it comports with your views. If it does not, you still approve of principle of the filibuster's continued existence, just not the principle purpose of its being used.
Fixed it for you.

That's a very strange position.
It is a very common position.

I approve of the principle of free speech even if I don't approve of all the ways it is applied. I approve of the principle of gun ownership even if I don't approve of all the ways that guns are used. Likewise, I approve of the principle of the filibuster even if I don't approve of all the ways filibusters are used.

It wouldn't be too hard to find similar views on this board. I bet I could even find some of yours, if I looked.



That's not correct. It appears you liked the first option - filibusters against Bush = bad, filibusters against Obama = good.

Your position appears to be, "I think the filibuster is an important tool for the Senate to have, but only the Democrats should use it." Or have I mistated your position?
Indeed you have. Don't confuse my appreciation of the filibuster as a tool for immediate approval for how it used. Naturally, I approve of it's use against things I don't like and I disapprove of its use for things I do like.

That doesn't meant that I think we should get rid of the minority's (sometimes only) tool to oppose the majority.

As for the NYT's editorial, it would really depend on who Obama puts up for as a judge whether or not I think a filibuster is a good idea. I'm not going to give a blanket "thumbs up" just because it is Obama who nominates them.
 
The New York Times then - March 6, 2005:
Filibusters have a "historic role." Eliminating them would "fly in the face of Senate history." They are "a time-honored Senate procedure."

That was then.

The New York Times now- March 8, 2009This is now. Now, filibusters are "intemperate." Now, threatening to use them is "saber-rattling."

If you're wondering if The New York Times reads its own editorials, don't worry - they have that covered:
Ah, now I understand. A filibuster is good if it blocks "a dangerous addition to the bench" i.e., a conservative. It's bad if it blocks "kind of highly qualified, progressive-minded judges the nation needs, i.e., a liberal."

Or, as someone once put it, the end justifies the means.
Reading comprehension fail.
 
Cherry picking, FTW!

It is clear that they were describing the letter in the first bit, not the filibuster tool itself.

And the part you omitted:

It is particularly strange to see Senate Republicans raising the specter of filibustering nominees. When Mr. Bush was doing the nominating, Senator Orrin Hatch, Republican of Utah and a former Judiciary Committee chairman, warned Democrats that filibusters “mired the judicial-confirmation process in a political and constitutional crisis that undermines democracy, the judiciary, the Senate, and the Constitution.”

A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that a particular nominee would be a dangerous addition to the bench. The Republicans’ rush to threaten filibusters in the absence of actual nominees is not only at odds with their previous views on the subject, but shows a lack of respect for the confirmation process.

I have to laugh at your delicious red herring on the issue. It's not about Republicans going beyond hypocritical about filibusters, it is about the ebil NYTimes!
 
I don't have an opinion on the use of the filibuster, in general. It's a tool and, like most tools, what matters is not the tool itself, but how it is used.

So you support filibuster by people who agree with you, oppose it when it is used by people you disagree with.

When conservatives behave in this way, they're hypocrites and dishonest, and liberals who point out their hypocracy are "brave" and "stand for principles". But when liberals do it -- ah! -- then, I believe it,known as "being able to see both sides of the issue", "not thinking in a simplistic manner", and so on -- and the conservatives who point out their hypocracy are just "not sophisticated" enough and make "simplistic arguments".
 
Last edited:
Indeed you have. Don't confuse my appreciation of the filibuster as a tool for immediate approval for how it used. Naturally, I approve of it's use against things I don't like and I disapprove of its use for things I do like.
Then that appears to distinguish you from the editorial writers at the Times. Look again at what they have to say:

A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that a particular nominee would be a dangerous addition to the bench...
The implication is that it was appropriate to use the filibuster to block Bush's nominees, but it would be inappropriate to use to block any of Obama's prospective nominees.

Otherwise, the Times would write, "A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that the minority party strongly opposes a presidential nominee..."

The Times might not agree with Republican opposition to Obama nominees. But why would it be inappropriate for Republicans to threaten filibuster?
 
So you support filibuster by people who agree with you, oppose it when it is used by people you disagree with.

When conservatives behave in this way, they're hypocrites and dishonest, and liberals who point out their hypocracy are "brave" and "stand for principles". But when liberals do it -- ah! -- then, I believe it,known as "being able to see both sides of the issue", "not thinking in a simplistic manner", and so on -- and the conservatives who point out their hypocracy are just "not sophisticated" enough and make "simplistic arguments".
How dare you impugn the integrity of the brave people standing on principle, you unsophisticated dishonest hypocrit!
 
When conservatives behave in this way, they're hypocrites and dishonest, and liberals who point out their hypocracy are "brave" and "stand for principles". But when liberals do it -- ah! -- then, I believe it,known as "being able to see both sides of the issue", "not thinking in a simplistic manner", and so on -- and the conservatives who point out their hypocracy are just "not sophisticated" enough and make "simplistic arguments".
Wrong. Republicans now want to use the same mechanism that they threatened to remove from the process completely when they were the majority. Their argument was that the use of the filibuster at all was wrong, not that it was wrong for the Democrats to use it in that case.
 
The implication is that it was appropriate to use the filibuster to block Bush's nominees, but it would be inappropriate to use to block any of Obama's prospective nominees.
Which is their opinion and appropriate for an editorial, even thought that is only what you are inferring from what they wrote.

The Times might not agree with Republican opposition to Obama nominees. But why would it be inappropriate for Republicans to threaten filibuster?
It is inappropriate when they don't even know who the nominees will be. They would be doing it simply because they were Obama's nominees rather than because they felt the nominees, themselves, would be dangerous.

In fact, isn't that what that line you quoted said?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom