Never Mind What We Said. That Was Then. This Is Now.

It is inappropriate when they don't even know who the nominees will be. They would be doing it simply because they were Obama's nominees rather than because they felt the nominees, themselves, would be dangerous.

In fact, isn't that what that line you quoted said?

No, that's not what the line from the NYT says. It says they threatened filibuster "if Mr. Obama’s nominees are not to their liking". It does not specify what "not to their liking" consists of, so you have no real basis on which to conclude it means "because they were Obama's nominees", other than your own bias.

Moreover, it's quite possible that the line doesn't even accurately reflect the content of that letter from Republicans. You misrepresented the Times quote, the Times could just as easily be misrepresenting the Republicans.
 
BPSCG said:
The implication is that it was appropriate to use the filibuster to block Bush's nominees, but it would be inappropriate to use to block any of Obama's prospective nominees.
Which is their opinion and appropriate for an editorial, even thought that is only what you are inferring from what they wrote.
And that is where I come to the conclusion that as far as The New York Times is concerned, the ends justify the means. Filibuster is inappropriate if the end is to block a nominee ("progressive") the Times approves of. Filibuster is appropriate if the end is to block a dangerous conservative nominee the Times disapproves of.

I submit that filibuster is appropriate any time the minority party is strongly opposed to the majority's proposed action. I may agree or disagree with the position, but filibuster is not inappropriate. Shooting up the Senate with machine guns would be inappropriate. Filibuster is an entirely legal tool.

It is inappropriate when they don't even know who the nominees will be. They would be doing it simply because they were Obama's nominees rather than because they felt the nominees, themselves, would be dangerous.
Now wait, that's been fair game all along. Senators - on both sides - always threaten to fight an appointee they don't like, even before a name has been announced. You've heard it many, many times: "If the president sends up the name of someone who's out of the mainstream..."
 
Then that appears to distinguish you from the editorial writers at the Times. Look again at what they have to say:

The implication is that it was appropriate to use the filibuster to block Bush's nominees, but it would be inappropriate to use to block any of Obama's prospective nominees.

Otherwise, the Times would write, "A filibuster can be an appropriate response when it is clear that the minority party strongly opposes a presidential nominee..."

The Times might not agree with Republican opposition to Obama nominees. But why would it be inappropriate for Republicans to threaten filibuster?

Because they are threatening to do so before the nominations have even been introduced. Like the paper said, and you conveniently ignored.
 
Because they are threatening to do so before the nominations have even been introduced.

Well, duh. That's the whole point of a threat. The idea is to influence who Obama picks so that they don't have to fillibuster. If his pick is already announced, a threat is of little use: you pretty much have to accept the nominee or actually fillibuster them.
 
Well, duh. That's the whole point of a threat. The idea is to influence who Obama picks so that they don't have to fillibuster. If his pick is already announced, a threat is of little use: you pretty much have to accept the nominee or actually fillibuster them.

Wow, you managed to say a lot of important things without actually dealing with the argument at hand.
 
Argumentum cum snark. Seems more and more to be your rhetorical weapon of choice.
It seemed to be the appropriate response to an argumentum ad sweet damn-all.

In the first article, the Times argued that filibusters should not be abolished. In the second article, they argue that Obama, when choosing his nominees for judicial appointments, shouldn't cave in to pre-emptive Republican threats to filibuster whoever he nominates. At no point in the second article do they argue that the power to filibuster should be abolished.

There is a difference between saying that senators should be have the power to filibuster and saying that a president should always obey the senate minority whenever they threaten to filibuster. Indeed, if you will remove your head from wherever you currently have it lodged, you may find that you yourself agree with the first but not the second of these propositions.

The views of the Times, therefore, are not inconsistent. They are not remotely inconsistent. If you have an argumentum ad any damn thing at all that will establish that these are inconsistent views, please unveil it.
 
The views of the Times, therefore, are not inconsistent. They are not remotely inconsistent. If you have an argumentum ad any damn thing at all that will establish that these are inconsistent views, please unveil it.

Wait! Wait! I know!

:idea:

He can say that the statement expired!

:D
 
The NY Times editorial board has always elevated convenience to the level of principle; that's hardly news. It will be interesting to see what happens with the so-called "Gang of 14", which is down to 11 I believe, with three Republican members--Warner, DeWine and Chafee-- no longer in the Senate. If McCain, Snowe, Graham and Collins hold to their former position on this issue Obama's candidates will not be filibustered barring extraordinary circumstances.

The Times' current editorial on the matter is indeed as laughable as Beeps suggests:

The nation is now saddled with hard-right Republican judges who are using the courts to push an agenda of hostility to civil rights and civil liberties; reflexive deference to corporations; and shutting the courthouse door to worthy legal claims. Mr. Obama has to repair the damage, which will require technically able judges who can provide a counterbalance to the ideologues who control many appeals courts.

Liberal judges = technically able
Conservative judges: ideologues
 
...In the first article, the Times argued that filibusters should not be abolished. In the second article, they argue that Obama, when choosing his nominees for judicial appointments, shouldn't cave in to pre-emptive Republican threats to filibuster whoever he nominates. At no point in the second article do they argue that the power to filibuster should be abolished.

There is a difference between saying that senators should be have the power to filibuster and saying that a president should always obey the senate minority whenever they threaten to filibuster. Indeed, if you will remove your head from wherever you currently have it lodged, you may find that you yourself agree with the first but not the second of these propositions...


This gets right to the heart of the issue; well said.
 
In the second article, they argue that Obama, when choosing his nominees for judicial appointments, shouldn't cave in to pre-emptive Republican threats to filibuster whoever he nominates.
Speaking of reading comprehension problems: Please show where the article says the Republicans threaten to filibuster "whoever he nominates." They have in fact not filibustered anyone, not even the tax evaders he nominated for cabinet positions.

The views of the Times, therefore, are not inconsistent. They are not remotely inconsistent. If you have an argumentum ad any damn thing at all that will establish that these are inconsistent views, please unveil it.
In the first instance, the Times went farther - much farther - than to argue the filibuster should not be abolished. They hailed the filibuster as a time-honored procedure and argued that the Democrats were justified in using it to block appointments they didn't like.

If it's so "time-honored," then what makes its use inappropriate today?

Sauce. Goose. Gander.
 
Wow, you managed to say a lot of important things without actually dealing with the argument at hand.

BPSCG said, "why would it be inappropriate for Republicans to threaten filibuster? "

You responded, "Because they are threatening to do so before the nominations have even been introduced." In other words, the timing of the threat is what makes it inappropriate.

I responded that threatening before they are introduced is logically the most appropriate time to threaten a fillibuster. So how is that not dealing with the argument at hand? Unless you think your own previous post was off-topic, it seems rather directly relevant. Now, perhaps you disagree with my analysis. But you haven't even indicated if you do, let alone why. So... what gives? Is curt dismissiveness just easier than forming a counterargument?
 
No, that's not what the line from the NYT says. It says they threatened filibuster "if Mr. Obama’s nominees are not to their liking". It does not specify what "not to their liking" consists of, so you have no real basis on which to conclude it means "because they were Obama's nominees", other than your own bias.
True, but that wasn't the line Beeps quoted that I was referring to.
 
And that is where I come to the conclusion that as far as The New York Times is concerned, the ends justify the means.
Then you don't understand what that term means. The line you quoted makes it clear that it is not the means that is in question, but rather the ends. They seem to agree that the means (i.e. filibusters) are appropriate, it is the ends to which they are put that they find inappropriate.


Filibuster is inappropriate if the end is to block a nominee ("progressive") the Times approves of. Filibuster is appropriate if the end is to block a dangerous conservative nominee the Times disapproves of.
Big stretch there.

It is the equivalent of

A: Your mother is a %&$!ing &^*#$%!!!
B: I think that is inappropriate.
A: You think free speech is inappropriate only when you don't like what is said.
 
It seems to me that if people in power don't like the fillibuster, than it's doing what it's supposed to do.


As for the articles, I don't see any contradictions in the opinion.

I think republicans are right to threaten filabusters. They only made themselves look silly for being so vocally against the threat of filabusters during the prior administration.

This is all extremely minor issues. But if there is any egg here, it's on the face of congressional republicans.
 
I think republicans are right to threaten filabusters. They only made themselves look silly for being so vocally against the threat of filabusters during the prior administration.

This is all extremely minor issues. But if there is any egg here, it's on the face of congressional republicans.
Indeed.

eta:

There were more than just vocal against filibusters. They talked about ending filibusters. They even gave it a name: The Nuclear Option. But, as Beeps said: Nevermind what we said. That was then. This is now.
 
Last edited:
BPSCG said, "why would it be inappropriate for Republicans to threaten filibuster? "

You responded, "Because they are threatening to do so before the nominations have even been introduced." In other words, the timing of the threat is what makes it inappropriate.

I responded that threatening before they are introduced is logically the most appropriate time to threaten a fillibuster. So how is that not dealing with the argument at hand? Unless you think your own previous post was off-topic, it seems rather directly relevant. Now, perhaps you disagree with my analysis. But you haven't even indicated if you do, let alone why. So... what gives? Is curt dismissiveness just easier than forming a counterargument?

I don't have short term memory loss, you just weren't dealing with the situation at hand.

In 2005, the Democrats had already blocked a group of judges by filibuster. Some of them were coming back for renomination, and they planned on blocking them again. Then Republicans said they were going to get rid of the filibuster for Judicial appointment reviews.

Now, Republicans are threatening to filibuster Obama if he doesn't give them the people they want, even before Obama has named anyone.

In the first case, Democrats knew who they were going to be blocking. In this case, the Republicans don't.
 
You responded, "Because they are threatening to do so before the nominations have even been introduced." In other words, the timing of the threat is what makes it inappropriate.
Well, possibly. Frankly, I think it is the lack of information about what (or in this case, who) they are filibustering that is probably the least inappropriate thing about the situation.
 
Well, possibly. Frankly, I think it is the lack of information about what (or in this case, who) they are filibustering that is probably the least inappropriate thing about the situation.

They aren't fillibustering anyone yet. They're leveling a threat, with the intent of affecting who Obama picks. For that intent, they do not need to have any information: the whole point is to affect his pick before he picks.

The only way this could be unreasonable is if the specified criteria for fillibustering is unreasonable. But all we really have is a flippant characterization of that criteria from the NYT, which is (to put it charitably) rather vague. Absent a quote from the letter, we can't really tell whether or not their criteria is reasonable or unreasonable. It could be either. But nothing about the timing is unreasonable, and that includes the fact that it came before there is information about who the pick is.
 
Well, possibly. Frankly, I think it is the lack of information about what (or in this case, who) they are filibustering that is probably the least inappropriate thing about the situation.

So you think it is unreasonable for someone to threaten action if a pick violates some criterion you hold dear?
So it would be unreasonable of, say, your spouse, to threaten to cut off your access to the communal checkbook if you bring home another boat/car/rifle/puppy/woman without letting her voice her objections, or even over her objections?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom