Native American myths/traditions support Bigfoot? A critical look.

Your own mother told your her tribe has no bigfoot.

Correct. My tribe is located in the Alaskan Interior on the Yukon River. Near the Tanana River junction. She stated that when she was a child that the men in her tribe would occasionally battle "Eskimos" while out on a hunt. When I asked her why, she stated "because they're different". Eskimos aren't that different, so I still have some questions, for later.

However, like you said, the native makers of certain artifacts know exactly what creatures they are portraying. Whether it be a wolf, bear, or Bokwus-Wild Man of the Woods.

Here's a bag that my grandmother, a noted Athabascan crafts maker, made and gave to my wife after we married more than 25 years ago. She described the creature as an eagle and I have no reason to doubt her.



 
However, like you said, the native makers of certain artifacts know exactly what creatures they are portraying. Whether it be a wolf, bear, or Bokwus-Wild Man of the Woods.
You know, why don't you tell that to Bob Zenor over at the BFF who can't seem to comprehend an anthropomorphic seal? After that go back and read the OP of this thread again where buk'wus is addressed. Bear and wolf - Not a supernatural ghost figure.
 
However, like you said, the native makers of certain artifacts know exactly what creatures they are portraying. Whether it be a wolf, bear, or Bokwus-Wild Man of the Woods.

Then I don't understand what you recently wrote on BFF, or you didn't clarify your point.

MOTS said:
Here's a Kwakiutl carving that is cataloged as a seal, but is obviously a sea otter. From the book "People of the Totem", photo credit to Museum of Natural History, Chicago.

9a50dd6b.jpg


This is almost a perfect rendition of a fur seal. The shape of the neck, head, and the facial features are all much like a Northern fur seal. I will say the feet do look more like paws than flippers. Yet you declare that the caption is wrong and it is obviously a sea otter. Maybe you are right, but what makes you say this?

007%20Fur%20Seal%20March%208.jpg


26686.jpg
 
BTW, the two Iroquois entries - 'Stonish Giant' and 'Giant Monster'. It's like a classified ad that says "Vehicle for sale. Used." or a personal that says "Person. Single."
 
Yet you declare that the caption is wrong and it is obviously a sea otter. Maybe you are right, but what makes you say this?

I was only using the caption in the book "People of the Totem" as reference.
It says "Although the carved wooden bowl is said to represent a seal, the presence of the tail and paws make it almost certain that a sea-otter is really depicted." Text is by Norman Bancroft-Hunt.
 
Bokwus

Here is the picture of the "Bokwus, the Kwakiutl Wild-Man-of-the-Woods" mask.

 
Last edited:
MOTS, that bag your grandmother made is beautiful. I absolutely love it. It may not matter much to your family, but it probably has considerable monetary value.

The following is no criticism of her, or you. Anyone can see that that is a bald eagle. But it has a problem of sorts. She gave it a black tail with white feather tips. A bald eagle doesn't have that. An adult BE (which she shows) has a tail that is entirely white.

Hundreds of years into the future, a person with cryptozoological inklings could pay close attention to this bag. They could speculate that it really was an accurate piece, but it seems to show an unknown species or subspecies of eagle. Why? Because of the tail.

The point is that translations or interpretations of artifacts can be strongly tied to the personality and opinions of the observer. We will all be dead by then and unable to explain that she simply took artistic license with a genuine bald eagle. This has relation to present day interpretations of artifacts that cause people to think Bigfoot. Most of those artists are dead and so they have no opportunity to tell us that they are not carvings meant to show Bigfoot after they had a sighting. We can't even say with confidence that they saw anything like a Bigfoot prior to making their objects.
 
MOTS, that bag your grandmother made is beautiful. I absolutely love it. It may not matter much to your family, but it probably has considerable monetary value.

The following is no criticism of her, or you. Anyone can see that that is a bald eagle. But it has a problem of sorts. She gave it a black tail with white feather tips. A bald eagle doesn't have that. An adult BE (which she shows) has a tail that is entirely white.

Hundreds of years into the future, a person with cryptozoological inklings could pay close attention to this bag. They could speculate that it really was an accurate piece, but it seems to show an unknown species or subspecies of eagle. Why? Because of the tail.

The point is that translations or interpretations of artifacts can be strongly tied to the personality and opinions of the observer. We will all be dead by then and unable to explain that she simply took artistic license with a genuine bald eagle. This has relation to present day interpretations of artifacts that cause people to think Bigfoot. Most of those artists are dead and so they have no opportunity to tell us that they are not carvings meant to show Bigfoot after they had a sighting. We can't even say with confidence that they saw anything like a Bigfoot prior to making their objects.

That is your interpretation of her work and that is fine. I am sure it was done by design rather than an attempt to fully depict a real bald eagle. Color patterns may be more important than actual depictions in certain crafts. Or she could be representing an actual bird recognizable to her. I didn't ask. I only asked her to make a bag. She crested it herself.
 
I was only using the caption in the book "People of the Totem" as reference. It says "Although the carved wooden bowl is said to represent a seal, the presence of the tail and paws make it almost certain that a sea-otter is really depicted." Text is by Norman Bancroft-Hunt.

Thanks and that helps. But the artist gave the creature a mouth with a large gape (seal) and huge eyes (seal). One could argue that it has characteristics of both animals. How can we know the intent of the artist? Maybe they carved it from memory (not looking closely at either animal at the time of making it) and ended up with what we see. They may have wanted to show a seal but gave it some features that look more like otter. Maybe they really did intend to blend the two animals and long afterwards we are left to argue that it must be one or the other.
 
Here is the picture of the "Bokwus, the Kwakiutl Wild-Man-of-the-Woods" mask.
My god... That forehead... Those eyebrows...



In this performance the part of David Hemmings will be played by a piece of wood...



...David Hemmings appeared by permission of the National Forestry Commission.
 
Here is a mask "cataloged as an ape-like face". It is Tsimshian. The author equates to a skull, but note the ears, lips, and intentional internal nostril divide. Sadly it doesn't have the precise Tsimshian(ian?) description, only "ape-like", which must be by intent.

 
Last edited:
My god... That forehead... Those eyebrows...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_896147f67e5d01c7a.jpg[/qimg]

In this performance the part of David Hemmings will be played by a piece of wood...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1977047f679d0db14d.jpg[/qimg]

...David Hemmings appeared by permission of the National Forestry Commission.

How about, what do Ainu look like? Or, the definition of Skepticism, Redefined.
 
Last edited:
That is your interpretation of her work and that is fine. I am sure it was done by design rather than an attempt to fully depict a real bald eagle. Color patterns may be more important than actual depictions in certain crafts. Or she could be representing an actual bird recognizable to her. I didn't ask. I only asked her to make a bag. She crested it herself.

I don't know what you mean by "my interpretation" of her work. It is what it is. I was pointing out that bald eagles don't have a tail like that. It doesn't detract from the bag in any way that I would explain.

I'm just putting this into a larger context. Crypto folks can and do look at things like this and fantasize that it could show a real bird as it appeared to the artist. Same with the otter/seal carving. They might even speculate that there was (or still is) some species of sea otter that has a head just like a fur seal. It doesn't matter that there are no bodies or fossils of such an imagined creature.

I think that this is going on with people who look at NA artifacts and shout out Bigfoot!
 
For those anthropomorphically inclined, here is a Tlingit owl from the front of a 60' war canoe. Note the brow ridge, nostrils, and hands.

 
Last edited:
The "ape-like face" looks more like a standard gray alien...
AlienL.jpg


So much for cherry-picking characteristics on art...
 
The "ape-like face" looks more like a standard gray alien...

So much for cherry-picking characteristics on art...

I concede it has two eyes, as opposed to the one eyed brazilian bigfuto, but it is cataloged as apelike, not alienlike. Cataloged by an expert, not a toy afficionado.

Remember, this is Thunderduomo.
 
Last edited:
That Tsimshian head carving could be described as ape-like if the person is inclined to think that way. But if another person called it human-like (is a human) it would be hard to argue against that and say it is an (wild) ape instead.

Again we can't know the intent of the artist, nor if they used anything at all as a model. The eye sockets and brow ridges are so strange that it is pure speculation to suggest that this represents any living or extinct hominoid. Alien devotees might be quick to say there is no way that thing is human or ape. This tribe had extraterrestial visitation. No doubt about it.

BTW, I have a question for anyone. We know people are attributing various artifacts to being made in the likeness of Bigfoot. Is anyone suggesting (or implying) that the artist themselves had a sighting and then made the work using their memory of what it looked like. Or, do we have artists creating these things according to what other tribe members may have described? Or what?
 
BTW, I have a question for anyone. We know people are attributing various artifacts to being made in the likeness of Bigfoot. Is anyone suggesting (or implying) that the artist themselves had a sighting and then made the work using their memory of what it looked like. Or, do we have artists creating these things according to what other tribe members may have described? Or what?

That is a baited question. You are the one who recommended Halpin and her series, which deals with masks, myths, manlike monsters...but you didn't mention if any of her work dealt with any of the various Thunderbird myths, you know, for any ufo buffs.
 
Written communication is not your forte. Now, as often in the past, I have no idea what you are trying to say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom