More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

What wishful thinking? What dangerous ground? aka "Conspiracy Theory"
The official position of homeopathy in India is clearly stated - At present homeopaths will only carry out counselling for HIV / AIDS prevention as part of their public health duties.

All HIV / AIDS cases are notifiable by law and are to be dealt with strictly by conventional medicine.

Well, that is very good news. I'm glad to see someone in India has some kind of sense. Even here Ullman would get into very bad trouble if he tried to actually treat HIV positive person with just homeopathy. There is a reason it is technically only allowed for self-limiting diseases.

Of course, neither of you have shown homeopathy does anything for either syphilis or HIV.
 
Third hand report of inadequately described clinical cases. There are many reasons why 6 out of 6 cases might be reported through hat same unreliable chain as being "cured".

I'm afraid that by your repeated use of such anecdotes, I'm afraid that yu reveal that deep dow you simply do not understand the need for pairing clinical cases with placebo-treated controls. Like every homeopath I have ever met, you regard proper trials as window dressing for something you think you already know. Your great mistake is in failing to accept that the evidence base on which you rely to "know" what you think you know is utterly flawed and is simply logically incapable of supporting the conclusions you draw from it.

Which is wht I have asked you, several times, the same question, which you have steadfastly failed to answer;

Which do you want to admit, either homeopathy is scientifically testable or your entire clincal case record must be ignored? There is no third option. Which do you want to choose?
Out of context - not presenting standard proof here - only answering your query as to how I personally can be so sure. Do not think that I want you to either believe or accept this as proof that homeopathy works - Not at all - we are working towards a proper modality for proof separately.
 
Why would you want to use DEXA when you are looking at cartilage damage?...
For RA an important early indicator is BMD and see:

"Rheumatology International 2006, vol. 26, no12, pp. 1084-1090
Multi- site quantitative ultrasound compared to dual energy X-ray absorptiometry in rheumatoid arthritis : effects of body mass index and inflamed soft tissue on reproducibility
PFEIL A. (1) ; BÖTTCHER J. (1) ; MENTZEL H. J. (1) ; LEHMANN G. (2) ; SCHÄFER M. L. (1) ; KRAMER A. (1) ; PETROVITCH A. (1) ; SEIDL B. E. (1) ; MALICH A. (3) ; HEIN G. (2) ; WOLF G. (2) ; KAISER W. A. (1) ;
(1) Institute of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Erlanger Allee 101, Jena 07747, ALLEMAGNE
(2) Department of Rheumatology and Osteology, Clinic of Internal Medicine III, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Erlanger Allee 101, Jena 07747, ALLEMAGNE
(3) Department of Radiology, Sued-Harz Klinikum, Nordhausen, ALLEMAGNE

Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases 2002;61:325-329
Bone quality and bone mass as assessed by quantitative ultrasound and dual energy x ray absorptiometry in women with rheumatoid arthritis: relationship with quadriceps strength
O R Madsen1,2, O H Sørensen1 and C Egsmose3
1 Osteoporosis Research Clinic, Hvidovre University Hospital, Denmark
2 Department of Rheumatology, Amager and Herlev University Hospitals, Denmark
3 Department of Rheumatology, Bispebjerg and Gentofte University Hospitals, Denmark

Rheumatology Volume 35, Number 12 Pp. 1256-1262
CLINICAL ASSOCIATIONS OF DUAL-ENERGY X-RAY ABSORPTIOMETRY MEASUREMENT OF HAND BONE MASS IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
J. DEVLIN, J. LILLEY, A. GOUGH, A. HUISSOON, R. HOLDER, R. REECE, P. PERKINS and P. EMERY
Department of Rheumatology, University of Birmingham
*School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Birmingham
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham"
 
Great,
Now you need to have a definitive diagnosis and set up clear inclusion criteria. This means you would have to work trough the differential diagnosis of arthritis. I recommend you let conventional medicine take care of that. It would mean that you would also have to do the other tests to make sure you are only looking at osteoarthritis... since conventional medicine has an entire sub-specialty that deals with rheumatology I think you would do better to let them handle this part of making the diagnosis (it is safer in the way that you don't run the risk to misdiagnose and postpone treatment, but also in the way that it protects your research from possible unforeseen errors: the object of the research is to evaluate the drug, not the homeopath making the diagnosis) .
Agree that the suggestion makes sense to me.
 
Out of context - not presenting standard proof here - only answering your query as to how I personally can be so sure. Do not think that I want you to either believe or accept this as proof that homeopathy works - Not at all - we are working towards a proper modality for proof separately.

Sorry, manioberoi, your English has wandered a long way from comprehensible there.

I think you have, yet again, failed to answer the question I posed. This time I'll pose it without reference to the other issues. Please quote this post in your reply and just answer this single question. It is futile going any further with you unless you answer this question;

Which do you want to admit, either homeopathy is scientifically testable or your entire clincal case record must be ignored? There is no third option. Which do you want to choose?
 
Out of context - not presenting standard proof here - only answering your query as to how I personally can be so sure. Do not think that I want you to either believe or accept this as proof that homeopathy works - Not at all - we are working towards a proper modality for proof separately.


I see your point here; I did after all ask you how you could be so certain. Personal experience can contribute significantly to one's confidence in something. The six case studies that you listed, apparently contributed to your own confidence in homeopathy. That they do not provide scientific evidence or validity for homeopathy, well, that's an additional topic for discussion.
 
Some quotes in this thread to make you think about why you are deciding to do research. It's probably the most important part of the start of your research, so look at it carefully:

















:idea: As you can see several of us have raised the question why you would want to do a study. As long as homeopathy does not recognize that science progresses and that a new paper can completely destroy what you tried to prove, there will be no progression. The latching on to papers once published 100 years ago, that have long been refuted is an example of that. So is the persistent referral to anecdotal "evidence".

:idea: Can you subscribe to BSM and Rolfe's comments and decide to take notice of the results, including when they turn out negative? I mean you are asking us to look at evidence when it turns out positive, this would also mean that you would have to look at it when it turns out negative...

I think a negative result would have to be weighed against the positive ones. The fact that a paper is refuted actually shows it does not work and means your evidence ends up in the bin.

:idea: It would also mean that the collected works and corresponding conclusions about the anecdotal evidence gathered in the last 150 years is useless and belongs in the bin. You would start over in a scientific manner and work through a way to build a discipline that could improve itself. Conventional medicine has taken that step long ago. Can you subscribe to these things?

Please read it carefully and think it over. It is an important premise to start of on your research. You do the best research you can, compare it with others and accept the outcome to improve your discipline. If you can not do that, then there is no point in doing research, because you don't use it anyway...

SYL :)
Some of these points need serious consideration in the best interests of the future course of homeopathy.
 
Not quite... I think that you misunderstand. Those are actually 6 remission cases out of an unknown number of patients. You can't remove cases out of statistics simply because they do not work to your satisfaction. It does not work that way. It is the main reason anecdotes are not data. You have to follow-up every one of them.

Now if you really want to do actual testing, some people here have suggested very good protocols. What I would add is to get your hands on a Good Laboratory Practices (GLP) guide from FDA or equivalent from another drug testing agency and follow it to the letter. That way, when comes time to submit your paper, you will be able to defend its quality to good journals.

Another thing is to follow the process of peer review in the right order, meaning, publish first in a specialized journal that is known for its rigor, rather than a wide spectrum or public-oriented one where review might be too whooly or done by non-specialists.

the Kemist
The ICMR Research Guidelines are based on international practice. The CCRH is co-operating with the ICMR to adopt ICMR Research Guidelines.

I would not like homeopathic remedies to be tested by purely conventional oriented practice. Certain modifications in the protocols as is emerging out of this discussion would help to include the peculiarities of homeopathic action as well as meet the stricter standards desirable in todays more scientific and critical environment.

Certainly your suggestions are very positive and should be incorporated in any sound and acceptable homeopathic trial.
 
Not quite... I think that you misunderstand. Those are actually 6 remission cases out of an unknown number of patients. You can't remove cases out of statistics simply because they do not work to your satisfaction. It does not work that way. It is the main reason anecdotes are not data. You have to follow-up every one of them.

Now if you really want to do actual testing, some people here have suggested very good protocols. What I would add is to get your hands on a Good Laboratory Practices (GLP) guide from FDA or equivalent from another drug testing agency and follow it to the letter. That way, when comes time to submit your paper, you will be able to defend its quality to good journals.

Another thing is to follow the process of peer review in the right order, meaning, publish first in a specialized journal that is known for its rigor, rather than a wide spectrum or public-oriented one where review might be too whooly or done by non-specialists.

the Kemist
And how might a homeopath publish at the inital stage in any other than the homeopathic or alternative journals which do not pass muster of members of this forum?
 
I see we have more replies, but no answers from manioberoi to this question;

Which do you want to admit, either homeopathy is scientifically testable or your entire clincal case record must be ignored? There is no third option. Which do you want to choose?
 
And how might a homeopath publish at the inital stage in any other than the homeopathic or alternative journals which do not pass muster of members of this forum?


By producing work that is of good enough quality to get into reputable journals. Are you invoking some sort of conspiracy again?
 
You have not considered the fact that in conventional medicine, the drug companies research the new drug and independent doctors at research facilities carry out the trials (in the ideal world the drug companies carry no influence on the trial even if they pay for them) with proper double blind controls & c.

Who pays for the trials - the drug companies - who then recover the cost (and more) from the sale of the drug.
I think you were foolish to try to defend your little "big pharma conspiracy" at all, but the approach you took implies you didn't actually think about what I said ...

No-one of the trials we have talked about require a great deal of money. But proper trials do require thought and integrity - which is why I think they don't ever get carried out by homoeopaths. (I do hope that get quoted ... :) )

Again ... what is stopping homoeopathic practioners doing these kind of trials for themselves? They can start out by coming up with small scale tests that can be conducted in their day to day work - just to get used to the idea. They can discuss the structure of their tests and results with others to see if they can improve upon their tests. Keep it among themselves until they are happy to face the world with their "proof"(*) The cost of this is virtually negligible. You only have to pay the big bucks if you want to sell this stuff as conventional medicine when you have to prove that you have proven its safety and efficacy to the best of your ability. If a homoeopath can show that it works under reasonable controls then, what is stopping them publishing it in their own journals - as opposed to just rolling out a pile of anecdotes? Why has no-one even vaguely attempted this in the homoeopathic literature? Come on ... don't pretend to be dim ... you know the answer ....

(*) Of course - homoeopaths may have already gone down this route, and not liked the results, and so they have to invent reasons why homoeopathy is a special case and shouldn't be tested in this way. Who'd know eh?? ;)

I think you have added this economic element as another excuse. But it is just a smokescreen and is really just pointless crap.

As for homeopathic remedies the proving is done by any homeopath or homeopathic organisation.

Manufacture of homeopathic remedies is a relatively routine process requiring no excessive costs of safety trials & c. Once the proving is done no homeopath feels the necessity to carry out trials of effectiveness of the remedy.

Let's just re-read that last sentence and pause for thought shall we? .... "Once the proving is done no homeopath feels the necessity to carry out trials of effectiveness of the remedy." :eye-poppi

Do you mean that homoeopaths - without any proof that they made any difference at all - are happy to plod on in ignorance? :covereyes

Even if he were to feel like carrying out a trial, such as has been suggested here the costs(in the region of 5 to 10 million dollars) would dissuade the richest homeopath from attempting this.

No homeopathic remedy manufacturer would agree to bear the cost since all single homeopathic remedies are FREE to manufacture and there are over 1000 manufacturers of homeopathic remedies worldwide.

So if this forum were to be serious about a long series of homeopathic trials, a little thought needs to be given on how to share out the costs among all the homeopaths and all the homeopathic remedy manufacturers worldwide - and set up an organisation to carry out such a series of trials.

Right - we've dis-spelled your invented economic obstacle above - what is stopping you?

Don't you ever feel like you are running out of places to hide while trying to defend homoeopathy? :boxedin:
 
And how might a homeopath publish at the inital stage in any other than the homeopathic or alternative journals which do not pass muster of members of this forum?

As Mojo said, if the work is of sufficient quality, then it will get into a reputable journal.

But before you return to your "conspiracy theory" style of defence on that ... I'd like to add - even the poorly-formed first attempts at this kind of study should be available in the homoeopathic literature ... but instead the papers you quote from such journals are filled with anecdotes, uncontrolled studies, and excuses for why blinded trials don't "work" for homoeopathy. This stuff has been around for hundreds of years yet the best you've got is anecdotes :confused: Why does no-one inside homoeopathy care if it really works or not? :rolleyes:

As I pointed out to you before ... (remember the big red writing!) ... the references you have given from the homoeopathic literature have been dismissed here because of the poor quality of the work, not just because of the location they were published.

By publishing crap in these journals, homoeopaths under-mine the integrity of all the work presented - but a strong piece of work, even from such a dubious source, will stand up to criticism and will be considered evidence.

Frankly, I find it pathetic that you try to blame every one else apart from homoeopaths themselves for the p!ss poor state of the homoeopathic literature. :rolleyes:

Doesn't this embarass you? Do you understand why we are so skeptical of the claims made by homoeopathy? Don't you think that you should start a skeptical campaign from the inside to remove the hear-say and smoke-screens, and look for real evidence of this thing you are so convinced by? What are you afraid of? :confused:
 
I have not read the posts after this one yet, but:

The conventional medicines are tagged with severe side effects and each causes some new disease, cancer, genetic damage, liver dysfunction, blood disorders, immue suppression and the like. EVERY prescription has a high cost of cure - one that the patient bears for the rest of her life.

This is not correct. The vast majority of patients experience little or no side effects. Most side effects that exist are beneign and of transient nature. Conventional medicines are under strict regulation, and are not released if they cannot be shown to have an acceptable "cost-benefit" ratio. That is, the side effects must be less harmful than the disease the medicine is addressing.

You statement above is a pure anti medicine propaganda lie.

In homeopathy, provided a lower 'balancing' potency in the range of 6X to 6C (water) is used the effects are slow in coming up (for the first month) but the cure thereafter is increasingly perceptible and entirely without the kind of side effects stated above.

That is not correct. Your claim that the cure is perceptible is unfounded. You do not have evidence for it.

(But I agree that there are no side effects. Water is largely considered harmless).

So even if the homeopath throws the dice successfully the seventh time (most good homeopaths manage it on the first or second throw) the patient will still be benefited more by homeopathy than by conventional medicne in a chronic disease.

However, you cannot show any evidence that the homeopath throws the dice successfully ever.
 
The remedy at 12C is diluted to 100 to the power 12 ie 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 (is also equal to 24X which is 10 to the power 24). This scale of dilution (Avogadro's Number) is such that the probability of even a single molecule of the original substance being present in the remedy is for all practical purposes ZERO.

Ehr, yes, we know that. Thank you for confirming one of our main points.

So the only trials that can be done are trials to verify the effectiveness of remedies against placebo(?). You cannot ask to chemically test the remedy as it would only show placebo(?)

Yes, we know that.

Incidentally even Sac lac (the homeopathic equivalent of placebo has been known to cure - and I personally know a lady who gets the most terrible aggravation from Sac lac.

So you admit that the things you claim to observe for homeopathic remedies can be a placebo reaction? Why, thanks!

Hans
 
You have not considered the fact that in conventional medicine, the drug companies research the new drug and independent doctors at research facilities carry out the trials (in the ideal world the drug companies carry no influence on the trial even if they pay for them) with proper double blind controls & c.

Who pays for the trials - the drug companies - who then recover the cost (and more) from the sale of the drug.

All this is correct.

As for homeopathic remedies the proving is done by any homeopath or homeopathic organisation.

Manufacture of homeopathic remedies is a relatively routine process requiring no excessive costs of safety trials & c. Once the proving is done no homeopath feels the necessity to carry out trials of effectiveness of the remedy. Even if he were to feel like carrying out a trial, such as has been suggested here the costs(in the region of 5 to 10 million dollars) would dissuade the richest homeopath from attempting this.

No homeopathic remedy manufacturer would agree to bear the cost since all single homeopathic remedies are FREE to manufacture and there are over 1000 manufacturers of homeopathic remedies worldwide.

Financing is a point. The motivation for the homeoapthic manufacturer, under the present system, is that if one proved the efficacy of their remedies, and aquired medical registration, they would have the possibility to increase the whole market greatly, and at the same time make life extremely difficult for their competitors. How easy do you think it would be to sell a non-registered remedy, if a registered was on the market? In many countries, regulations would make it downright impossible.

So if this forum were to be serious about a long series of homeopathic trials, a little thought needs to be given on how to share out the costs among all the homeopaths and all the homeopathic remedy manufacturers worldwide - and set up an organisation to carry out such a series of trials.

My personal idea is that we should influence authorities to outlaw homeopathic remedies till they ar properly tested and registered. If homeoapthy claims to be real medicine, then it should be treated as such.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom