[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Where does this hate come from sarge? Are you a decedent from a Holocaust Jew or committed Stalinist?
Ayn Rand said that racism is the worst kind of collectivism. And she escaped from the Soviet Union, mind you.

I leave the connection of the dots to you...
 
Isn't this the same in the US? Many people say the Nazis could not have been possible without the backing of influential people abroad.

Hitler was also Time's Man of the Year.


Oooh, do I hear the pitter patter of little "Prescott Bush" feet?

(And someone's already covered the actual content of the Time piece.)

Kageki,
You've rapidly progressed from "just want to balance" to "Hey, prove that people died in gas chambers!" Whomever called it way back at your first posts would seem to be correct. The opening gambits of a true Denier.
 
Civil rights and liberties have disappeared. Opposition to the Nazi regime has become tantamount to suicide or worse. Free speech and free assembly are anachronisms. The reputations of the once-vaunted German centres of learning have vanished. Education has been reduced to a National Socialist catechism.

I wonder if the Nazi state had video recording cameras if they would place them in the schools and send a feed to the police.
 
Grow up - that award is for the most influential figure of that year - For better or worse - there is no criteria for that influence

Grow up?

Someone mentioned that he was TIME man of the year and I presented the cover of the magazine thinking it would be of interest. I doubt most have seen the cover.

What exactly is your problem?
 
What I am concerned with is that there are lower life forms who would like to try it again. Have you read The Turner Diaries? That was not written for entertainment purposes. There are quasi-human beings who wouild like to act out that scenario, and have even made concrete efforts to do so (e.g., McVeigh, Richard Wayne Snell and Robert Matthews, may they burn in the most vile pit of hell.)

Should they rise up in force, I would feel it my duty to feed them a few Czech silvertips.

I will certainly not, in the mean time, remain silent when someone apologizes for or in any way tries to put a less malignant face on the Third Reich.

The author of The Turner Diaries, Dr. William Pierce was a very great man.

So was Bob Mathews.

I know.
 
I wonder if the Nazi state had video recording cameras if they would place them in the schools and send a feed to the police.

They might. I wonder how many they would have then killed when it was discovered members of the White Rose types.
 
The author of The Turner Diaries, Dr. William Pierce was a very great man.
You think so, huh? Well, recent scholarship has revealed that Pierce didn't even write the sequel, Turner and Hooch.
 
I admit a special motivation to keep those fools down. There's a rope in it for me if they try to pull it off. There are three different racial components of my immediate family in my wife and son, my brother's wife and daughter, and my sister's husband.

Organization types don't take kindly to mixed families.

What was it about your parental upbringing that led you and your siblings to betray your race?
 
First this illustrates that the Jews were not entirely exclusive to the Holocaust. The Nazis got rid of anyone they deemed undesirable. Not just because you were a Jew.

But did they really want to work and starve them to death? Your comments also slightly disprove the official story that it was a death camp. It was primarily a labor camp to produce goods necessary during war.

How do you know exactly those corpses were all Jews to begin with? The camps were ravaged with disease like Typhus and there was massive food shortages and resources due to the Allied bombing campaign. It does seem to make sense the Germans would rather save themselves first before anyone else when there were not enough food to go around to everyone.

Oh but they also saved the Allied POWs??


I am not allowed yet to post links, but this testimony comes from the Nuremburg trial (Nuremberg document NO-1523.)


Funny document, the only people I could find who used it in an argument were Stormfront and Mark Weber, can I have a "Sieg Heil"?

Now, it is incredibly easy to find a few lines in a document that seems to support your argument, the trick is does your argument survive when the few lines is placed in context? This is a case where it does not.

First the testimony is not from Himmler but rather one of his lackeys, Himmler gave no testimony at Nuremberg. Being stiff as a board due to a case of death. I wonder why they never ask why he committed suicide if he did nothing wrong?

Now, what was he testifying about? A passionate argument that the holocaust was a myth? No, rather he was arguing that the death rate was a result oif a few exuberant commandants and the crack SS legal team was on the job.

http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/imt/tgmwc/tgmwc-20/tgmwc-20-197-01.shtml

Moreover, this witness makes a point that his evidence is only relevant beginning in the latter half of 1943. What evidence is provided that the order was actually carried out? None. Evidence from camp records cited in the 1946 investigation of Auschwitz do not indicate any increase in rations. There is also the nasty problem of Himmler's Posen speech. Even if we accept the revisonist semantics argument, the tone of the speech is undeniable.

http://www.cwporter.com/posen.htm

Now let's take it a step further, what was happening around Himmler at that time that might have precipitated the order? We could, I suppose, accept that Himmler had a flash of humanity, but there is something that stands out in the documentation. By the end of 1941 Germany was suffering a significant manpower shortage. They did not use women in factories, instead relying on the slave labour of POWs and the "undesirables" of the captured populaces. Speer was screaming for more labour, and the SS was making a huge profit off of the slave labour. This meant that those who could work gained a longer existence.

http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/imt/tgmwc/tgmwc-03/tgmwc-03-24-04.html

Now that existence would be largely based on the kind of work performed. The harder the work, the less likely it can be performed indefinitely, especially if it was not rewarded in a corresponding manner (rations, rest). What was the pecking order in a camp? Who was relegated to the worst conditions, and hence the greatest danger of death. This political prisoner's account sheds some light.

http://www.germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org/sub_document.cfm?document_id=1512

Basically, I would more readily rely on the 1946 investigation of Auschwitz, supported by eyewitness testimony from both sides, supported by the documentation of German government officials. It has errors to be sure (I think most historians would agree that anything less that 50 years old is journalism) but that is recorded in the historiography. Still, there has been no major revision of their findings.

http://www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/genocide/gcpol9.htm

A word about gassing. Because of the destruction of camps like Aushwitz, there is no way to know the extent of this story. Regardless, I know of no historian who is interested in quibbling between gassing, hanging, shooting, working to death, starving to death or confining someone in conditions that lead to an inevitable death. The method only comes up when dealing with specific elements, for example the Einsatzgruppen.

A final word about the inevitable (and strictly neo-nazi) argument about ignoring the other victims of the holocaust. The Slavs, the homosexuals, the intellectuals, the handicapped, the Jehovah Witnesses, the gypsies, and so on. Only the Slavs can really be put in the same category of sheer persecution by the Nazis, but even then the Jewish persecution was much more enduring. All of the victims are remembered by history, as anyone who has read any real works on the Nazis well knows. Do the Jews as a political body use the Holocaust to further their cause? Maybe, but does it affect the real history (as opposed to pop culture. The odd legend of a heroic Custer was kept alive for decades after it had been exposed by historians. The same holds true of Nazi Germany, a good example being "they made the trains run on time" inferring the Nazis were an efficient bunch, they weren't).


Ok, I'll stand by now for more references from psychologists (Faurisson), electrical engineers (Butz), neo-nazis (IHR, experts my ass) in hopes that they might actually get around to consulting a historian or two (Kershaw and Bullock would be a good start).
 
The only country National Socialist Germany wanted to destroy was the Soviet Union. To get there you have to go through Poland.

Can you spell "Czechoslovakia"? (Well, probably you cannot.) OK, how about "Austria"?

Heck, how about "Germany." That was the country the Nazis most successfully destroyed.
 
What was it about your parental upbringing that led you and your siblings to betray your race?

Does it sting that I'm Black and my fiancee is not only White, but related to Adolph Eichmann? :D
 
I wonder if the Nazi state had video recording cameras if they would place them in the schools and send a feed to the police.

Close, they had to work with the technology of the time. It involved radio and a sort of blockwatch created to feed information back to authorities.
 
Belz don't you have anything to add to the discussion then ad hominen attacks?

You're frankly just wasting space.

Funny how a majority of posts by people like you consist mainly of insults with little to no substance.

Is this what they teach you in America?

Oops, I'm Canadian. Maybe you should answer my question. Did you skip history class, or do they not teach that in Japan ? I'm actually expecting you to have had history class, and to have decided to ignore it.

And it would do some good if you knew what an ad hominem attack was.
 
Last edited:
Hello. Very interesting thread here.

These are great questions that have crossed my mind as well as I started looking more into our history. In many ways though it is a strange question that shows the incredible force of social conformity. You ask these questions simply because it is unfashionable to even hint that the Nazi regime could possibly have not been evil incarnate.

The point is that you shouldn't be asking these questions just to see what opinion or answer is acceptable. If you are truly interested in finding out the answer then the only recourse is to do research yourself, but since they are good questions in the context of this discussion I can add a little to it.


I can't post any links yet so a quick summary regarding pre-WWII conditions:

- Germany suffered a crushing defeat in WWI. Hitler blamed the Jews for the loss (there is some truth in this)

- Hitler felt the Treaty of Versaille was unfair. Most of Europe felt the same. Germany also lost some territory as a consequence.

- Hitler wanted revenge from WWI. Hitler wanted to rebuild and rearm Germany and to regain the lost territory.

- Hitler hated Communism. His plans for the east were to mainly stop the Soviet Communists.

Invasion of Poland

- Poles were killing Germans living in Poland. Hitler wanted to defend them.

- Hitler wanted to regain the lost territory to Poland.

- Hitler only invaded Poland after making a non-aggression pact with the Soviets. They made a deal to split up Poland between them. The Soviets also invaded Poland from the east.

- Hitler did not think the British and also the French were going to attack Germany when he invaded Poland. The British were appeasing Hitler up to that point. The British made a secret pact to defend Poland if Germany were to attack Poland. This is what made Poles cocky and were openly taunting Germany prior to the invasion.


While this is not meant to justify the Nazis, it is a good start in illustrating that we have not been told the whole story. I can discuss this further, but I'll leave it at that for now since this thread is about the Holocaust.

Welcome to the forum kageki.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom