[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

From the above-linked article:




As I demonstrated in this post (which you have ignored), Bacque's book is, in the words of Stephen Ambrose, "worse than worthless." No serious historian would use such a thoroughly discredited source as Other Losses; that Weber would do so is prima facie evidence that he is merely attempting to push his (and your) agenda, the truth be damned. Therefore, Weber's entire article is rejected--the burden of proof is now on you to show that any of Weber's claims are accurate using other sources.

Mark Weber on Other Losses.
One of the most important works of Revisionist history to be published since the last IHR conference is Other Losses, a book published in September 1989 in Canada. In this work, Canadian author James Bacque presents compelling evidence to show that American and French military forces were responsible for the deliberate deaths of about a million German prisoners of war.

The principle figure responsible for this atrocity, Bacque shows, was Allied commander, and later U.S. president, General Dwight Eisenhower. By removing German prisoners of war under American control from the protection of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Eisenhower broke international law and committed an act for which, under the standards of the Nuremberg Tribunal, he could have been hanged. Bacque's book also documents the complicity of the New York Times and the International Committee of the Red Cross in suppressing the truth of this atrocity. Other Losses has prompted a flood of letters and reminiscences by many former German prisoners and American GIs who have provided detailed further confirmation of the essential truthfulness of Bacque's book.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v10/v10p439_Weber.html

The Plagiarist: Why Stephen Ambrose is a vampire

http://www.slate.com/?id=2060618
 
The Allies did nothing about bombing the camps because they knew it was propaganda.

An interesting point: The ‘Holocaust’ was invented in the early 1970's. Look at a dictionary or encyclopedia printed before 1970 and you will not find the ‘Holocaust’ mentioned.

Not true.

The word "Holocaust" was first used in its Old English form in the 13th century.
 
Not true.

The word "Holocaust" was first used in its Old English form in the 13th century.


Not to mention "Holocaust" (ὁλόκαυστον) is a Greek offering to the Gods in which the entire animal is burnt. The term has been in use for at least three thousand years.

The usage for which it is now associated, meaning "massacre, destruction of large number of persons" dates back to 1833.

-Gumboot

ETA. And the Nazi treatment of the Jews was first referred to as a "holocaust" as early as 1942.
 
Not to mention "Holocaust" (ὁλόκαυστον) is a Greek offering to the Gods in which the entire animal is burnt. The term has been in use for at least three thousand years.

The usage for which it is now associated, meaning "massacre, destruction of large number of persons" dates back to 1833.

-Gumboot

ETA. And the Nazi treatment of the Jews was first referred to as a "holocaust" as early as 1942.

Really? I had no idea it was that old, but i disagree about the 1833 date, as, according to The History Of Britain (BBC), King Edward I used it to refer to a massacre of English Jews (Originally from a written source, the name of which currently escapes me)
 


Irrelevant. Weber claims his source is highly credible. Where is the independent confirmation of that?

The Plagiarist: Why Stephen Ambrose is a vampire

http://www.slate.com/?id=2060618


Argumentum ad hominem abusive. You can't refute any of the criticism of Bacque by Ambrose or any other serious historian, so you're reduced to calling attention to the Ambrose plagiarism scandal.

I'll have a much more detailed response to this tomorrow, when I don't have to work.
 
--when the war started going badly, and there was no place to expel the Jews, then the Nazis decided on extermination. See the Wannsee ConferenceWP.



.

Disagree...the Commisar Order and the formation of the various action groups that followed the German Army East at the outset of the war show that extermination was on the front burner...not something that was decided after the war went bad. After the war started going bad...exterminating as many as possible as quickly as possible became a priority.. often at the expense of the military...but it was merely to further a basic policy that was in place at the outset.
 
Not to mention "Holocaust" (ὁλόκαυστον) is a Greek offering to the Gods in which the entire animal is burnt. The term has been in use for at least three thousand years.

The usage for which it is now associated, meaning "massacre, destruction of large number of persons" dates back to 1833.

Indeed, kinda like "Hécatombe" (εκατόμϐη), which comes from the sacrifice of a hundred animals, and is now used in French, amongst other meanings, to describe any massacre.
 
As Mel Brooks said:

"Hitler was part of this incredible idea that you could put Jews in concentration camps and kill them. And how do you get even? How do you get even with the man? How do you get even with him? There's only one way to get even," Brooks explained. "You have to bring him down with ridicule. Because if you stand on a soapbox and you match him with rhetoric, you're just as bad as he is. But if you can make people laugh at him, then you're one up on him. And it's been one of my lifelong jobs has been to make the world laugh at Adolf Hitler."

(source)


Oh, I wholeheartedly concur; I just can't laugh at the actual killings (very often). When I was a kid Hogan's HeroesWP was one of my favorite "grown-up" shows. As you may know (though I suspect a lot of people don't), Werner KlempererWP, John BannerWP, Howard CaineWP, and Leon AskinWP, who played the four main Nazi characters, were all Jews. So is Robert ClaryWP, who played Corporal LeBeau. Askin's parents died at Treblinka; Clary survived three years in Buchenwald and other camps (his parents and four sisters did not), in part because the guards enjoyed his singing.
 
Oh, I wholeheartedly concur; I just can't laugh at the actual killings (very often). When I was a kid Hogan's HeroesWP was one of my favorite "grown-up" shows. As you may know (though I suspect a lot of people don't), Werner KlempererWP, John BannerWP, Howard CaineWP, and Leon AskinWP, who played the four main Nazi characters, were all Jews. So is Robert ClaryWP, who played Corporal LeBeau. Askin's parents died at Treblinka; Clary survived three years in Buchenwald and other camps (his parents and four sisters did not), in part because the guards enjoyed his singing.

I've heard that "Hogan's Heroes" remains popular in Germany.
 
I've heard that "Hogan's Heroes" remains popular in Germany.


Yes, but--the "but," being that the dubbed dialog completely changes the show's original storyline. From "Hogan's Heroes and the Holocaust: The Association That Just Won't Go Away," a paper by Leslie Campbell Rampey:

The last place, however, that anyone ever expected the show to find an audience was Germany. Indeed, it wasn’t even tried there until 1992, and then it was "a ratings flop" (Cowell, 4:3). It was determined that radical surgery was what was needed, and Hogan’s Heroes now flourishes in Germany under the title Ein Kafig Voller Helden ("A Cageful of Heroes"). But what a different Hogan’s Heroes it is. It is: (a) nothing its U.S. audience would recognize; and (b) everything that its original 1960s critics feared it would be.

"Creative dubbing" is the term most often used to describe the German-altered text of Ein Kafig Voller Helden. Creative, indeed. While no translation from one language to another reproduces the original one hundred percent accurately, "bombs" usually are not translated as "condoms." Yet, that’s what the Germans of the German version of Hogan’s Heroes drop on London. In keeping with post-war Germany’s preference for avoiding "Heil Hitler" salutes and other Nazi Party practices, German characters accompany their stiff-armed gestures with such exclamations as "This is how high the cornflowers grow!" The Germans even have invented a new character: "In Germany Now, Col. Klink’s Maid Cleans in the Nude" proclaims a headline in the Wall Street Journal (Steinmetz, A1). In the original 1960s U.S. version of the show, Col. Klink did not have a maid, and no one ever was said to be in the nude. And more is going on here than textual alterations and additions. The voices of Klink and Shultz and other Germans are rendered in regional accents that are said to be inherently comic to the German ear – possibly something like the characters Jed ClampettWP and Gomer PyleWP sound to us. The effect of this, says a Munich newspaper commentator, is to make the German characters ‘"absolutely non-threatening’" (Cowell, 4:3). [Wikipedia references added]
 
Last edited:
Disagree...the Commisar Order and the formation of the various action groups that followed the German Army East at the outset of the war show that extermination was on the front burner...not something that was decided after the war went bad. After the war started going bad...exterminating as many as possible as quickly as possible became a priority.. often at the expense of the military...but it was merely to further a basic policy that was in place at the outset.


I'll grant that characterizing the Final Solution as having developed in stages might be more accurate. There's still a lot of debate among historians about exactly how and when this happened. Although the idea to kill all the Jews encountered in the Soviet Union clearly started with or before the German invasion, there is some evidence that the plan to exterminate all the Jews in Europe didn't take shape until around the end of 1941, after the German Army had failed to capture Moscow.

On the other hand, it's also possible that the deportation plan was merely a smokescreen to conceal Hitler's true plans for the Jews from those Germans who were less than enthusiastic about mass murder.
 
Indeed...Wansse was, it would seem, about formalizing not only Goreing's command to find a final solution to the Jewish "question"...and that was post invasion. I would agree that the formal intention to kill all the Jews...made manifest in the creation of death factories...was evolutionary. But it was also the inevitable result not only of ideology but Nazi practice both in Germany, the Reich and in occupied territories. In any event, the point was that the Commisar Order showed that murder of the Jews was an extrememly high priority in the Russian campaign.
 
In 1939 Hitler said in a speech at the Reichstag that a war would result in the destruction of Jewry in Europe.

That's pretty clear if you ask me.

-Gumboot
 
Really? I had no idea it was that old, but i disagree about the 1833 date, as, according to The History Of Britain (BBC), King Edward I used it to refer to a massacre of English Jews (Originally from a written source, the name of which currently escapes me)

The word "holocaust" in its English manifestation only dates back to about 1250, and is specifically in reference to Jewish religious practices. (Jews, like Greeks and Romans, burned whole animals as a sacrifice). It's quite possible that Edward I made reference to their expulsion in relation to their religious rites. However the term "holocaust" did not begin to commonly appear as a generic word for any massacre until the mid 19th Century.

-Gumboot
 
In 1939 Hitler said in a speech at the Reichstag that a war would result in the destruction of Jewry in Europe.

That's pretty clear if you ask me.

-Gumboot


Yes, but--this time, the "but" is, even if you're an evil absolute dictator, you can't just issue orders to murder millions of people through normal channels--you have to determine who's reliable, convince or coerce people who may be reluctant to go along with the plan, etc.

Also, the fact that Hitler said this doesn't necessarily mean he was announcing that that destruction would come at the hands of the Nazis, or that most people took it as anything other than overblown rhetoric at the time. Though it may seem so in hindsight, we can't be certain that Hitler was stating his intention to exterminate the Jews, but that's obviously a strong possibility.
 
Yes, but--this time, the "but" is, even if you're an evil absolute dictator, you can't just issue orders to murder millions of people through normal channels--you have to determine who's reliable, convince or coerce people who may be reluctant to go along with the plan, etc.

Also, the fact that Hitler said this doesn't necessarily mean he was announcing that that destruction would come at the hands of the Nazis, or that most people took it as anything other than overblown rhetoric at the time. Though it may seem so in hindsight, we can't be certain that Hitler was stating his intention to exterminate the Jews, but that's obviously a strong possibility.


Taken in context with what the Nazis were doing at the time, what he had said previously, what he had written in his book, what laws were being passed, what Jewish intellectuals who had fled Germany were saying, and Kristallnacht, it was pretty obvious what was to come.

The Holocaust was as obvious as WW2 was, it's just no one was willing to connect the dots, and no one was willing to accept that the unthinkable was about to happen. There's a good reason for this. Once you accepted what was happening, you had no choice but to act.

The denialism of Pre-WW2 nations is only the most identifiable example of one of the least admirable aspects of humanity.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom