MaGZ
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jan 31, 2007
- Messages
- 6,917
From the above-linked article:
As I demonstrated in this post (which you have ignored), Bacque's book is, in the words of Stephen Ambrose, "worse than worthless." No serious historian would use such a thoroughly discredited source as Other Losses; that Weber would do so is prima facie evidence that he is merely attempting to push his (and your) agenda, the truth be damned. Therefore, Weber's entire article is rejected--the burden of proof is now on you to show that any of Weber's claims are accurate using other sources.
Mark Weber on Other Losses.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v10/v10p439_Weber.htmlOne of the most important works of Revisionist history to be published since the last IHR conference is Other Losses, a book published in September 1989 in Canada. In this work, Canadian author James Bacque presents compelling evidence to show that American and French military forces were responsible for the deliberate deaths of about a million German prisoners of war.
The principle figure responsible for this atrocity, Bacque shows, was Allied commander, and later U.S. president, General Dwight Eisenhower. By removing German prisoners of war under American control from the protection of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Eisenhower broke international law and committed an act for which, under the standards of the Nuremberg Tribunal, he could have been hanged. Bacque's book also documents the complicity of the New York Times and the International Committee of the Red Cross in suppressing the truth of this atrocity. Other Losses has prompted a flood of letters and reminiscences by many former German prisoners and American GIs who have provided detailed further confirmation of the essential truthfulness of Bacque's book.
The Plagiarist: Why Stephen Ambrose is a vampire
http://www.slate.com/?id=2060618