[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Indeed, and there is little doubt that Speer did know about it....in spite of his denials.

Oh, come on. What possible reason could one of the most senior Nazis have for denying that he knew about exterminating the Jews? Things have come to a pretty pass when we doubt the word of the German Minister for Armaments.

The thousands of survivors of the camps are clearly lying though.
 
As Mel Brooks said:

"Hitler was part of this incredible idea that you could put Jews in concentration camps and kill them. And how do you get even? How do you get even with the man? How do you get even with him? There's only one way to get even," Brooks explained. "You have to bring him down with ridicule. Because if you stand on a soapbox and you match him with rhetoric, you're just as bad as he is. But if you can make people laugh at him, then you're one up on him. And it's been one of my lifelong jobs has been to make the world laugh at Adolf Hitler."

(source)
That's why I voted for Mel as the funniest man in the Community forum.

Who else could show the absurdity that Hitler was?
 
Bumping this link because it provides a better rebuttal to revisionists than any book, video or website I've ever seen.

Nothing like hoping to advance your fraudulent agenda through a legal system that isn't entertained by fraud.

Of course, the revisionists will ignore any court that takes on Irving because it is part of a system manipulated by the jews. They're like ID'ers and Creationsist in that way.

You can pile the documents and proof as high as a mountain...and it can always be "faked" or manipulated.
 
Okay, but it was never used in reference to the death of Jews in WWII until the 1970's.

And that proves what...if true (which, btw, there is no reason to believe your assertion)?

It isn't as if the idea that the Germans set out specifically to target millions of Jews only emerged in th 70s....it was asserted well before that...beginning with the post-war trials...not to mention the founding of the Wannsee minutes in 1947...or the reporting of the 1943 Posnan speech by Himmiler.

So: even If the term holocause was not used as a wrap-around for the actions taken against the Jews till the 70s -- again, an unproven assertion by you -- so what? How does the word change the facts on the ground?
 
Not to mention "Holocaust" (ὁλόκαυστον) is a Greek offering to the Gods in which the entire animal is burnt. The term has been in use for at least three thousand years.

The usage for which it is now associated, meaning "massacre, destruction of large number of persons" dates back to 1833.

-Gumboot

ETA. And the Nazi treatment of the Jews was first referred to as a "holocaust" as early as 1942.

Please provide something to support that last point.
 
Oh, I wholeheartedly concur; I just can't laugh at the actual killings (very often). When I was a kid Hogan's HeroesWP was one of my favorite "grown-up" shows. As you may know (though I suspect a lot of people don't), Werner KlempererWP, John BannerWP, Howard CaineWP, and Leon AskinWP, who played the four main Nazi characters, were all Jews. So is Robert ClaryWP, who played Corporal LeBeau. Askin's parents died at Treblinka; Clary survived three years in Buchenwald and other camps (his parents and four sisters did not), in part because the guards enjoyed his singing.

Will you then agree with me that Hogan's Heros was Jew propaganda?
 
anyone who is suggesting this holocaust did not happen should visit the Anne Frank house in Amsterdam

in fact everyone should try and visit it, very educational as well as emotional
 
I'll grant that characterizing the Final Solution as having developed in stages might be more accurate. There's still a lot of debate among historians about exactly how and when this happened. Although the idea to kill all the Jews encountered in the Soviet Union clearly started with or before the German invasion, there is some evidence that the plan to exterminate all the Jews in Europe didn't take shape until around the end of 1941, after the German Army had failed to capture Moscow.

On the other hand, it's also possible that the deportation plan was merely a smokescreen to conceal Hitler's true plans for the Jews from those Germans who were less than enthusiastic about mass murder.

‘Smokescreen?’
Many Jews were allowed to leave Germany. If there was a planned program of extermination, why were so many Jews allowed to leave?
 
And that proves what...if true (which, btw, there is no reason to believe your assertion)?

It isn't as if the idea that the Germans set out specifically to target millions of Jews only emerged in th 70s....it was asserted well before that...beginning with the post-war trials...not to mention the founding of the Wannsee minutes in 1947...or the reporting of the 1943 Posnan speech by Himmiler.

So: even If the term holocause was not used as a wrap-around for the actions taken against the Jews till the 70s -- again, an unproven assertion by you -- so what? How does the word change the facts on the ground?

It proves ‘The Holocaust’ was devised as a political weapon in the 1970's.
 
Please provide something to support that last point.
Well, there's THIS.

And THIS AS WELL.

The "1970s first use" argument was also brought up and debunked in the David Irving libel case somewhere (linked twice in this thread), but it's such a massive document I'm having trouble finding the exact passage.

But of course those are all part of the disinformation campaign against the Nazis so let's just stick with the numbers Stormfront uses. :rolleyes:
 
We all know the Holocaust happened. Even Holocaust deniers know it happened. How many Jews were killed? I personally compared an old census of European Jews from 1929 and compared that to post WW2 figures..and I came up with around 4 million dead Jews. Does it matter if it was 6 million or 4 million? No. These are not errors of fact..just errors of math and reliable census data.
Wich leads to another question: If a mass murderer who was suspected for 37 killings is only guilty of 29, does that makes him less of a criminal?

Among the deniers there's also an interesting obfuscation of the differece between absolute and relative numbers:

Let's say that a state has a goal of exterminating a people numbering 1 000 000 people. At the height of it's power, it can only "reach" 750 000 of them. And the killing of them is not 100% efficient, but "only" 85%. That leaves us with 637 500 dead, 112 500 survivors and 250 000 potential victims.

And beacuse everyone, member of the targeted people or not, is busy trying to survive and repair the damage after the war - you can't for lack of time and resources get a testimonial from every survivor. But after a few years there's testimonials from 40% of the survivors, numbering 50 pages on average. That leaves us with 45 000 testimonials, totalling 2 250 000 pages.

The number of books on the genocide written during the ten first year after the peace are 2 000, but the ratio books-not murdered are 4:725. And to be frank a lot of the books is crap (how can there be poetry after the genocide?) or are boring sum-ups of the testimonials and only a few of the books has any lasting value.

But the response of the deniers are "look at all those survivors, testimonials and books, how could there be a genocide if there's so many survivors, testimonials and books?"

The sad thing with the real-life deniers are that they aren't applying the same indifference between absolute and relative numbers. If they did, they would swiftly ruin themselves.
 
Last edited:
The Diary of Anne Frank: Is it Genuine?

the house is genuine

the photos and other evidence in the house is genuine

the dutch who hid the jews from the nazis are genuine

have you been to her house?

i have

its fake?, usual slopey shoulder nonsense
 
It proves ‘The Holocaust’ was devised as a political weapon in the 1970's.
:rolleyes:
The Yad Vashem memorial to the victims of the Holocaust was established in 1953.

This hideous claim has been dealt with by historians and by the court:

Nevertheless, Holocaust deniers have been persistent in their claims that the diaries were forged. In 1991, Robert Faurisson and Siegfried Verbeke produced a booklet titled: The Diary of Anne Frank: A Critical Approach. It claimed that Otto Frank wrote the diary, based on assertions that the diary contained several contradictions, that hiding in the Achterhuis would have been impossible, and that the style and handwriting of Anne Frank were not those of a teenager.

In December 1993, the Anne Frank House in Amsterdam and the Anne Frank Funds in Basle instigated a civil law suit in order to prohibit the further distribution of The Diary of Anne Frank: A Critical Approach in the Netherlands. On December 9, 1998, the Amsterdam District Court ruled in favour of the claimants, forbade any further denial of the authenticity of the diary and unsolicited distribution of publications to that effect, and imposed a penalty of 25,000 guilders per infringement.

Wikipedia
For the record, the trial was in the Netherlands where holocaust denial is not outlawed. But of course slander and libel are.

But don't let facts get in the way of your obsession, MaGZ.
 
Last edited:
Please provide something to support that last point.

In the spring of 1942 a historian in Jerusalem, Ben-Zion Dinur, used the
word sho'ah with reference to the extermination of European Jewry, and
called it a "catastrophe" that showed how different and unique the Jewish
people were from the rest of the world.

Source (PDF)

And More.

"Holocaust" is the English translation of the Hebrew "sho'ah". So you could argue that the term "Holocaust" was used to refer to the Nazi extermination of the Jews from the early 1940's, although Ben-Zion Dinur's work appears to be the first one that was translated into English, and thus the first to actually use the term "holocaust" rather than "sho'ah".

-Gumboot
 
Okay, but it was never used in reference to the death of Jews in WWII until the 1970's.


"Sho'ah" was first used to describe the Nazi persecution of the Jews in 1940, and by the 1950's "Holocaust" (the English translation of "Sho'ah") had come be be accepted as the default term to describe it.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom